📣 Try out the NEW Gateway to Research and let us know what you think.

We're looking for users to test the new service during August and September and share their feedback. Express your interest by completing this short form.

Catastrophic shifts in tree-microbial symbioses: the causes, consequences, and warning signs of environmental collapse in the global forest system

Lead Research Organisation: UNIVERSITY OF EDINBURGH
Department Name: School of Biological Sciences

Abstract

The distribution of life on earth is shaped by climate. Moving north or south from the earth's equator to its polar caps, the sequence of ecosystems spans moist rainforests, dry deserts, seasonally green temperate forests and the vast evergreen forests and frozen tundra. Life in each of these ecosystems is adapted to the challenges that climate imposes, from the extremes of heat and cold that must be survived to the regular cycles of resources that must be exploited. As the earth's climate is changing at unprecedented speed, this regular sequence of ecosystems is being massively reorganised. As a NERC Independent Research Fellow, I propose to study how climate warming is driving transformative changes in the world's largest forested region over decades and centuries, fast enough to witness over the scale of individual human lifetimes.
My research indicates that hundreds of billions of trees that span the earth's great northern forests are living on the edge of a climatic tipping point. Tipping points occur when alternative ecosystem types engage in a tug-of-war with their environments, with each ecosystem altering local conditions in a way that allows it to survive. This tug-of-war can create an unstable frontier between warring ecosystems, where small climate changes can rapidly and irreversibly determine the winner. The technical term for these changes in ecosystem state is catastrophic ecosystem shifts; collectively, they represent the most dramatic planetary response to climate change.
The tipping point my research has unmasked is massive, stretching from North America clear across Eurasia, encompassing an area roughly twice the size of Europe. It separates forests that are dominated by trees that form symbiotic partnership with different groups of fungi (called mycorrhizas). Over 99% of trees associate exclusively with one of two primary groups of mycorrhiza to acquire the soil nutrients they require to grow and reproduce. Ectomycorrhizas dominate on the colder side of the tipping point where nutrient cycling is slow, in the vast boreal forests of Canada and Eurasia, whereas arbuscular mycorrhizas dominate on the warmer side where nutrient cycling is fast, in temperate and tropical forests. Moreover, these two groups appear locked in a tug of war on the process of nutrient cycling, with ecto- and arbuscular mycorrhizas slowing down and speeding it up, respectively, in an effort to transform their environments to their liking. Climate change is tipping the balance in this global tug-of-war, warming climates, speeding up nutrient cycling, and sending ectomycorrhizal trees and and their fungal partners beyond the tipping point where they can no longer thrive. If global forests follow the model set by other ecosystems engaged in such a tug of war, the transformations could occur much more rapidly than previously thought, occurring over the course of decades and centuries rather than thousands of years.
My objective is predict exactly how fast global forests will change as a result of climate change acting on this massive, ecological tug of war. Specifically, I will use global datasets comprising over 31 million forest census plots to build a mathematical model that can be used to determine the speed and consequences of catastrophic shifts in forest tree symbioses. These models will be used to predict catastrophic symbiotic shifts before they happen, identify warning signs of imminent ecosystem collapse, and forecast the resulting losses (and potential gains) in resulting ecosystem function. The resulting research will also help identify whether these ecosystem catastrophe's can be averted by reducing greenhouse gas emissions. The goal is to gain advance knowledge about the changing fates of our forests so that we can learn how to live them with them.

People

ORCID iD

 
Description Forests depend on partnerships between trees and microscopic fungi in the soil, known as mycorrhizal symbioses. These fungi help trees obtain nutrients and water, while trees provide the fungi with carbon. Different forests are dominated by different types of these partnerships, but until recently it has been difficult to measure where these symbioses occur across large areas.

This research has shown that the dominant type of tree-fungus partnership in a forest can be detected using satellite observations of the forest canopy. This means that shifts in these underground symbioses can potentially be monitored over large regions and updated frequently, without relying entirely on time-consuming ground surveys.

The research has also revealed that changes in these fungal partnerships are linked to changes in forest biodiversity. When forests shift from one symbiotic system to another-for example from forests dominated by arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi to those dominated by ectomycorrhizal fungi-the number of tree species often changes as well. Our analyses suggest that these symbiotic shifts may explain around 10-30% of the global decline in tree species richness from tropical to temperate regions, helping to explain one of ecology's long-standing puzzles: why biodiversity is highest in the tropics.

Together, these findings provide new tools for monitoring forest ecosystems and improve our understanding of how below-ground symbioses influence global patterns of biodiversity.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of this research can be used in several ways by researchers, conservation organisations, and land managers.

First, the demonstration that forest symbiotic state can be detected using satellite observations opens the possibility of monitoring below-ground ecological processes using remote sensing. This approach could be used by researchers and environmental agencies to track large-scale changes in forest composition and ecosystem function over time, including responses to climate change, land use change, or restoration activities.

Second, the findings linking shifts in mycorrhizal partnerships to changes in tree species diversity provide a new framework for understanding and predicting patterns of forest biodiversity. Ecologists can incorporate these relationships into models that forecast how forests will respond to environmental change.

Finally, this work highlights the importance of soil microbial partnerships in shaping forest ecosystems. This insight may inform forest management and restoration strategies by encouraging practitioners to consider below-ground symbioses when planning reforestation or biodiversity conservation efforts.
Sectors Environment

URL https://youtu.be/9yIjLAjxCPQ
 
Title Data from: Complementary effects of beneficial and non-beneficial mycorrhizal fungi on root phosphatase activity: A mycorrhizal "White Album" effect 
Description Mycorrhizal fungi are diverse, with strains differing in the magnitude and types of benefits provided to their hosts. In mixture, mycorrhizal strains that have complementary functions could provide their hosts with greater benefits than any constituent strain in isolation. Conversely, mycorrhizal strains could also interfere with one another, competing for host resources, providing less benefits than the most beneficial strain. The actual, realized effects are likely a composite of these complementary and competitive effects. Spatial structure in the root system may allow plants to benefit from complementary benefits while reducing competition among mycorrhizal strains. I tested the role of spatial structure using a species of plant from the family Podocarpaceae, which host arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi inside both finely separated nodules and longer, contiguous sections of fine root. In root nodules, co-inoculation with both growth-promoting and non-growth-promoting arbuscular mycorrhizal fungi resulted in complementary increases in aggregate root / fungal phosphatase activity. This complementary effect was not present in longer, contiguous sections of fine root or in either root type with P-fertilization. I dub this interaction a "White Album effect", a reference to the Beatles' best-selling album, where complementary effects of single artists were only revealed when individual conflicts were avoided by separating band members and synthesizing their contributions in post-production. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2025 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://datadryad.org/dataset/doi:10.5061/dryad.jm63xsjm6
 
Description Botanical Society Seminar Series (Non-Academic, for General Public) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I presented some of my work and ideas about large scale ecological patterns to a general audience. I then took questions and went out to dinner with some participants. The discussion ranged widely and included perspectives on natural history and even philosophy of science that I had not encountered before. The Botanic Society lectures are quite a bit less academic then a University or conference seminar series, and so the presentation and discussion was shaped by a more diverse audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://youtu.be/9yIjLAjxCPQ?feature=shared