The Complete Theoretical Works of Johannes Tinctoris: A New Digital Edition

Lead Research Organisation: Birmingham City University
Department Name: ADM Birmingham Conservatoire

Abstract

The corpus of twelve Latin theoretical treatises by the fifteenth-century Brabantine musician and lawyer Johannes Tinctoris (c.1435-1511) is acknowledged as one of the most significant and comprehensive sources for late medieval musical notation and compositional process, as well as a central focus for important recent research on musical aesthetics and reception at this crucial point in western European culture. Their content demonstrates not only an exceptional technical command of musical notation and theory, but also an intimate acquaintance with contemporary polyphonic practice, derived from a wide knowledge of the composers of his day and their music, both in northern Europe, where he began his career, and in Italy. This project will complete a new online edition of the whole corpus (also to be made available as a more permanent resource in DVD format), supplanting the existing edition (ed. Albert Seay, American Institute of Musicology, 1975-8) which has long been regarded by musicologists as highly unsatisfactory. The completed resource will greatly enlarge both the scope and accessibility of Tinctoris's work. Full English translations will be provided in addition to the Latin texts; in many cases these translations will be the first ever made, which will further enable the detailed significance of the treatises to be appreciated and explored by both scholarly and performance-based readers outside academia who are unable to handle the original Latin. Multiple layers of hyperlinked commentary material will also be provided, covering a wide range of technical and historical issues arising from both the texts themselves and the wider context of Tinctoris's life and musical environment in Renaissance Europe. Combining the highest levels of historical, textual and critical scholarship with innovative technological presentation, this open-access edition explores new methods of relating text-based materials to the numerous, often complex, music examples (both monophonic and polyphonic, mensural and non-mensural) that punctuate the treatises. An additional outcome will be the production of a new notation software package which will make available a wide spectrum of medieval and Renaissance musical notations for the first time to scholars, students, editors, publishers and performing musicians in a flexible and user-friendly application to a high professional level of historical and typographical accuracy. As the project progresses, the edition will have additional layers added which will use Tinctoris's primary texts as a pedagogical resource to enable users (e.g. undergraduate and postgraduate students, and early-stage scholars of pre-modern music repertories) to learn and practise the detail of late medieval notation through interactive engagement, independent virtual learning and self-testing.

Planned Impact

Although the project essentially sits squarely within the disciplines of historical and theoretical musicology, its particular slant towards (a) early music performance implications, and (b) the technology of early music notation and editing, brings to the fore a number of strong and valuable linkages with creative and publishing industries beyond academia. It is planned that these will be explored and exploited in order to maximize the cultural and economic impact, within realistic limitations, that the project will have, both in the UK and in other countries for which these areas of knowledge are significant.

Early music performance, in the UK as well as continental Europe, the USA and increasingly the Far East, is in a remarkable healthy state in the present economic climate, and this is true not only of the later, baroque and classical, eras, but also of the medieval and Renaissance vocal and instrumental repertories with which the project is concerned. Small, specialist ensembles are burgeoning in France, Italy, Germany and the Netherlands, to some extent following the lead given in the 1980s and 90s by high-ranking vocal groups in the UK. There already exists, therefore, a powerful infrastructure for the creative interaction of academic work and high-level performance, both in a live context and through the commercial recording world, in late medieval and early Renaissance music. The significance of Tinctoris as composer of high standing as well as theoretical writer of the greatest importance is already well recognized, as witnessed by several CDs produced over the past decade or so. There is still, however, much scope for the project to spearhead a concerted effort to raise Tinctoris's profile as composer, not only in the project's home territory of the UK, but especially in his own homeland of Belgium, with the collaboration of the Alamire Foundation, which is the recognized International Centre for the Study of Music in the Low Countries, and with which Professor Woodley already has close links.

The year 2011 is the 500th anniversary of Tinctoris's death, providing a wonderful opportunity to capitalize on the personal links between the project team and the professional performing world, in order to explore some of the practical, performative implications of his writings. Such an interaction between scholarship and performance will be able to be exploited through outlets such as BBC Radio 3 broadcasts and talks, performance workshops, public lectures and ensemble tours. The outcomes of these experimental interactions could well feed directly into subsequent commercial recordings, becoming part of a wider cultural knowledge base in musical practice beyond the duration of the project itself. In so doing, the project hopes to use the engaged and outward-facing elements of the research to maximize public awareness of Tinctoris's contribution to early modern musical practice, and of his writings and compositions as a significant part of Western Europe's cultural and intellectual capital.

The technological component of the project, which involves the development of an innovative software application to enable high-quality notation of various medieval and early Renaissance musical repertories, will also have clear benefits and impacts beyond the project itself, and beyond the strictly academic sphere. Such impacts and benefits will include editors, typesetters and publishers of early music repertories, giving a high degree of flexibility for the reproduction of early historical notations, and the ability to incorporate diplomatic facsimile material into their music publications with much more ease and professional quality than has been generally possible hitherto. Individual performing musicians will be able to make use of it, and the project texts, when preparing material for performance from original notation. A mo
 
Title Vocal Concert (free, public) as part of international conference 'Johannes Tinctoris and Music Theory in the Late Middle Ages and Early Renaissance' (Senate House, University of London, 9-10 October 2014) 
Description Free public concert of rarely heard vocal polyphony by the 15th-century musical theorist and composer Johannes Tinctoris, given by the ensemble Il Suono (director: Christian Goursaud [PhD student attached to Award]). Embedded as part of the international conference 'Johannes Tinctoris and Music Theory in the Late Middle Ages and Early Renaissance' (Senate House, University of London, 9-10 October 2014), supported by the Award. 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2014 
Impact The concert was a very rare opportunity for the public (as well as conference delegates) to experience the vocal polyphony of Tinctoris, a figure well known by musicologists for his theoretical writings, but much less well known as a composer to the listening public interested in the music of the late Middle Ages and Renaissance periods. It is expected that some of the music brought to life here will form an adjunct (in the form of CD or download) to the volume of essays to be published as a result of the conference, listed elsewhere here under Publications and Other Outputs. 
 
Description [Note that the project is still ongoing at time of writing.]

The key findings from this award concern the eminent fifteenth-century musician, writer, composer and lawyer, Johannes Tinctoris (c. 1435-1511). The primary resource developed through this award has been the open-access website 'Johannes Tinctoris: The Complete Theoretical Works' (http://www.earlymusictheory.org/Tinctoris), itself embedded in a new more broadly based Early Music Theory website (http://www.earlymusictheory.org), which has been set up as a long-term sustainable resource for other scholarly materials relating to the theoretical and intellectual underpinnings of music from the medieval and early modern period, beyond the current project.

The Tinctoris project itself has so far produced something in excess of 200,000 words of material, comprising newly edited Latin texts of Tinctoris's treatises, English translations (in most cases the first available), and detailed source transcriptions and facsimile images from the major fifteenth-century manuscript and early printed sources. Texts completed, which also include some initial (and ongoing) commentary material in article format, are listed separately here under Publications. Considerable time and care has been taken to develop custom-built software of a much more sophisticated nature than originally envisaged in the grant application. This embeds into the web-based representation system a software parser which can display on screen both normal text and fifteenth-century music notation from alphanumeric input, enabling Tinctoris's numerous music examples, which are an essential component of his treatise texts, to be both generated and searched in ways that would be impossible with purely graphics-based presentation. We believe that the time taken in developing this software, along with other technical aspects such as its exportability in TEI-compatible form, will be well repaid in its wider usefulness and transferability beyond the current project. All software materials are open-source and publicly available: for details, see under Software and Technical Products. The project is intended to be continued beyond the lifetime of the present funding, and new sources of support are currently being explored, in both the UK and the US.

Aside from the project website, a successful international conference was organised and part-funded by the project, held in collaboration with the Institute of Musical Research, School of Advanced Study, University of London, at Senate House, University of London 9-10 October 2014. Contributing delegates, beyond the immediate project team, included both senior established and younger-generation scholars from the United States, Australia and Europe as well as the UK, and the proceedings included particularly valuable practice-based presentations from the Schola Cantorum Basiliensis (Switzerland), and a vocal concert of Tinctoris's polyphonic compositions, freely open to the public, given by the ensemble Il Suono and directed by the PhD student on the project. A volume of essays, based on (but not exclusively) extended versions of the conference papers, has been agreed in principle for the prestigious series Épitome musical (general editor: Philippe Vendrix, Director of the Centre d'Études Supérieures de la Renaissance, University of Tours), to be published around 2016 by Brepols (Turnhout, Belgium). A further concrete outcome of the project has been the publication of a special issue of the Journal of the Alamire Foundation (April 2013), also published by Brepols, devoted to Tinctoris, with contributions by each of the three members of the project team (Woodley, Dean, Lewis), with Woodley also acting as invited Guest Editor.
Exploitation Route The principal website of the project is openly available to the public, which will include not only other academic scholars and research students across the world, but also others involved in the understanding, performance and dissemination of late medieval and early Renaissance music, such as professional musicians, editors, publishers, broadcasters and record companies. From a musicological perspective, the research, especially the technical components of the online presentation of materials, suggests several next steps. The most immediately apparent of these is the perceived need to develop software that can take the precepts of Tinctoris's primary theoretical texts and use these to translate directly between fifteenth-century mensural notation and more modern 'common-practice' notation, both for editorial purposes and as a testing-ground for the comprehensiveness, or otherwise, of the theoretical precepts themselves. The project team are currently investigating possible funding sources for this next stage of the research.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.earlymusictheory.org/Tinctoris
 
Description Since the project is still ongoing at time of writing, and has been focusing primarily on the academic development of the resource, it is a little early to give concrete evidence for non-academic impacts. Eventually (say, within the few years following the completion of the project) it is highly likely that that contents of the site -- especially the texts and new translations of the Tinctoris treatises, but also the evolving commentary material -- will have significant, if slow-burn, impact on other non-academic areas of the early music world, involving performers' increased understanding of the historical, cultural and technical aspects of the music being performed, as well as related activities in editing, publishing, sound recording and broadcasting. An embryonic instance of this has been the feed of academic content from the project research into a public concert exemplifying Tinctoris's output as composer, given as part of the essentially academic conference 'Johannes Tinctoris and Music Theory in the Late Middle Ages and Early Renaissance', which took place at Senate House, London in October 2014, in collaboration with the Institute of Musical Research. However, beyond the strictly musical and musicological frameworks, it has already become apparent that from a broader cultural point of view this project, in raising the profile of Tinctoris within the context of francophone Belgian patrimony, has impacted substantively at a local level in that country. As a result, articles by the project's PI (Woodley) and another colleague in Liège (Marlène Britta) have been published in the journal of the local historical and genealogical society in Tinctoris's home town of Braine-l'Alleud (Brania 2012: listed under Publications). Indeed the newly forged contacts at this local level have themselves enabled access to primary archival material, not hitherto investigated, resulting in clear transfer of impact between academic and non-academic domains, and between the UK and Belgium. Initial discussions have been initiated (February 2016) regarding possible avenues of collaboration with a similar project, the Thesaurus Musicarum Germanicarum, run jointly by the Institut de Recherche en Musicologie (CNRS, Paris-Sorbonne) and Humboldt-Universität, Berlin. This may result in shared resources and expertise across the two projects. Discussions are also in train (March 2016) regarding a new international collaborative project, extending our existing work more broadly within 15th-century musicology, with a senior colleague at the University of Michigan. It is intended that a new US-based funding bid will be put together in order to facilitate this collaboration with the UK-based research team. Update 2017: Since the completion of the funding for the present project, our team has been successful in securing substantial further funding from the AHRC for a closely related follow-on project 'Interpreting the Mensural Notation of Music: An Expert System Based on the Theory of Johannes Tinctoris', to run from October 2017 to September 2021 (project value with indexation £854,641.
Sector Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description AHRC Research Grant (Standard)
Amount £854,641 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/P013910/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2017 
End 09/2021
 
Description Birmingham City University, Faculty of Arts, Design and Media, Faculty Research Investment Scheme
Amount £6,817 (GBP)
Organisation Birmingham City University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2017 
End 07/2017
 
Description Birmingham City University, Faculty of Arts, Design and Media, Faculty Research Investment Scheme
Amount £18,844 (GBP)
Organisation Birmingham City University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2015 
End 10/2016
 
Description Birmingham City University, Internal university (Faculty of Arts, Design and Media) funding
Amount £85,280 (GBP)
Organisation Birmingham City University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2014 
End 04/2016
 
Description British Academy/Leverhulme Trust Small Grant
Amount £2,775 (GBP)
Funding ID SG162646 
Organisation The British Academy 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2017 
End 09/2017
 
Description Interpreting the Mensural Notation of Music: An Expert System Based on the Theory of Johannes Tinctoris
Amount £683,713 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/P013910/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2017 
End 09/2022
 
Description Research Investment Fund
Amount £16,000 (GBP)
Organisation Birmingham City University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2015 
End 10/2015
 
Description Cantare super librum recording session 
Organisation The Clerks Group
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Musical collaboration to provide score material for recording session, to record examples of fifteenth-century super librum singing practice related to wider research on the theoretical writings of Johannes Tinctoris.
Collaborator Contribution Musical collaboration to provide artistic input for recording session, to record examples of fifteenth-century super librum singing practice related to wider research on the theoretical writings of Johannes Tinctoris.
Impact Digital recordings of the musical examples and short polyphonic works will be used to support a book chapter in our forthcoming volume of essays on Johannes Tinctoris, to be published by Brepols in c.2019. Sound files of examples will be made available for download on our project website, as notified elsewhere on Researchfish. The research was funded by an award from the British Academy/Leverhulme Trust Small Grant Scheme (2017), reported elsewhere on Researchfish.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Partnership with the Institute of Musical Research, School of Advanced Study, University of London: international conference 'Johannes Tinctoris and Music Theory in the Late Middle Ages and Early Renaissance'. 
Organisation Royal Holloway, University of London
Department Institute of Musical Research
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Planning, organisation and running of conference, held in Chancellor's Hall, Senate House, University of London, 9-10 October 2014
Collaborator Contribution Booking and shared costs of space in Chancellor's Hall, Senate House, University of London; adminstrative support with online delegate booking and paperwork; on the ground administrative support and provision of meals/refreshments during conference.
Impact The conference will result in the publication of an academic volume of essays, reported elsewhere here under 'Other', and individual papers as unpublished Publications.
Start Year 2014
 
Title Software representation system and user interface for The Complete Theoretical Works of Johannes Tinctoris 
Description Software representation system and user interface for The Complete Theoretical Works of Johannes Tinctoris, incorporating (a) a custom-built, web-based editing and display tool for mixed text and late medieval music notation; (b) a live incremental parser for on-screen representation of text and music input; (c) SVG drawing routines for fifeenth- and sixteenth-century mensural and non-mensural music notations; (d) co-ordinated navigation of multiple on-screen texts and facsimiles of original manuscript and early printed sources; (e) innovative display of source variants and editorial commentary through custom pop-up windows; (f) exportability in TEI-compatible form, for third-party access and analysis. Javascript code available through the project website: http://earlymusictheory.org/Tinctoris; also full code repository published on GitHub at https://github.com/BirminghamConservatoire/JohannesTinctoris. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2013 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact Provides essential technical infrastructure for musicological project 'The Complete Theoretical Works of Johannes Tinctoris'. 
URL http://earlymusictheory.org/Tinctoris
 
Description Announcement (Twitter, Facebook) of updated EMT website with De arte contrapuncti, JTMTL15C:E&S 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The updating of the project website in December 2020 was announced on Twitter and in several interest groups on Facebook. It was enthusiastically received in comments, and the announcement generated traffic to the website.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://earlymusictheory.org/#
 
Description Expert workshop for US-based 'Measuring Polyphony' project 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Part of a panel of experts invited to participate in a workshop as part of the Measuring Polyphony project, which developed tools to support transcribing and editing medieval and renaissance musical sources.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://measuringpolyphony.org/
 
Description Hosting of and participation in Music Encoding Initiative (MEI) Special Interest Group meeting on tablatures 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Co-hosted the Special Interest Group on tablatures (including guitar tab) in a working meeting for guideline and encoding development between 18/12/2019 and 19/12/2019
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Learning to Interpret Mensural Rhythm: Rules or experience (conference paper) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Presentation (unpublished) at the 47th Medieval and Renaissance Music conference, Basel, July 2019
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Member and co-chair of Special Interest Group on tablature notation for the Music Encoding Initiative 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Membership of a SIG for the standards body the Music Encoding Initiative aiming to develop and extend support for tablature notations (including guitar tabs and historical lute tablature). This includes adding this notation to music typesetting tools.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021,2022
URL https://music-encoding.org/community/interest-groups.html
 
Description Member of Special Interest Group on mensural notation for the Music Encoding Initiative 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Membership of (and at times co-chairing) a SIG for the standards body the Music Encoding Initiative on pre-1600 music notation.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020,2021,2022
URL https://music-encoding.org/
 
Description Participation in research network 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Regular 'seminars' for a UKRI-funded network (AH/V015095/1), gathering scholars and music editors to consider the future of collected music editions
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022