Smart Tooling for Ceramic Profile Extrusion: New Approaches to Industrially focused Interdisciplinary Practice Based Research

Lead Research Organisation: University of the West of England
Department Name: Fac of Arts Creative Ind and Education

Abstract

Ceramics have been used for millennia for architectural construction, utilitarian items and cultural artefacts. The ceramic medium has unique qualities in terms of durability, sustainability, longevity and aesthetics and has been an integral part of our creative and commercial output. However, many of the sectors involved with ceramic production have faced extremely difficult conditions with a very significant decline over the last many decades. Such a decline is likely to be a combination of many factors, including overseas competition and cultural changes, but a lack of innovation is also likely to have contributed. In order for the UK to maintain or regrow its long heritage with this medium, new approaches and innovation are required.

Innovation within digital fabrication in the field of ceramics has, to date, been predominantly focused on 3D printing, with both powder and plastic clay printing methods being established. While these methods have extended manufacturing possibilities with new geometric possibilities, 3D printing remains a very slow and size limited production method, which limits the process' commercial potential with the ceramic medium. In contrast, profile ceramic profile extrusion is an extremely quick and efficient production method. This method dates back to the 17th century and remains a highly utilised manufacturing process in the production of bricks and clay pipes. However, ceramic profile extrusion is generally limited to the productions of straight linear sections and remain significantly under-utilised in many other aspects of ceramic production. This research project will seek to explore how digital fabrication technologies can be used to establish new approaches with the ceramic profile extrusion technique that extends conventional capabilities to provide new creative and commercial opportunities. The research will investigate how customised, curved and bespoke shapes can be generated through the application of robotics, and how rapid workflows from computer aided designs to creation of extrusion dies be developed through the used of parametric scripting and digital fabrication approaches which collectively are termed: Smart Tooling.

The research will include an in-depth survey of existing practices through interaction with industry specialists, visits to companies and leading international research centres. The core of the research will focus on interdisciplinary practice based investigations structured as a series of experimental feasibility studies. Technologies and approaches developed through the research are aimed to impact on a number of sectors including architecture, design and craft. Applications and exploitation opportunities will be identified through collaborative dialogue with key sector organisations, research partners and commercial companies.

The fellowship will be hosted at the Centre for Fine Print Research and draw support from the centre's extensive experience in practice based research and technology driven innovation. Furthermore, the project draws together a group of world leading companies and organisation as collaborating partners in the research; Wienerberger, Sibelco, Arup and Centre for Window and Cladding Technology.

The vision for this research project is to provide an exemplar of how material knowledge, new technologies and interdisciplinary approaches can be complied to deliver sustainable innovation with a traditional material.

Planned Impact

The fellow will develop entirely new ceramic production approaches and technologies to provide new creative and commercial opportunities. Whilst centred on the use of the ceramic medium the interdisciplinary nature of this research provides the potential for both focused and wide ranging impacts.

Among the core target beneficiaries are companies that engage in the production of ceramics. SME's that produce bespoke ceramic parts for architecture or design lead artefacts will particularly benefit, as the tooling concepts developed will present opportunities for producers to rapidly respond to market demands and the development of new designs and products. Larger manufacturers (ie project partner, Weinerberger) will benefit from the research in enabling the creation of more flexible productions methods which enable the capacity to respond to changing market conditions and specialist customer requests. Short to medium term impact goals for all scales of ceramic manufacturers are the real-life implementation of Smart Tooling concepts. Longer term goals are to increased productivity and profitability.

The research will develop digitally driven flexible manufacturing concepts that offer designers, and architects with new creative opportunities that can be explored with low tooling cost and short development time. Smart tooling concepts on smaller scales will present individual designer-makers and art practitioners with new creative opportunities, and the potential for low cost and efficient fabrication methods that could enable individual creative practices to be more economically viable. The research presents increase opportunities for the creation of bespoke constructions parts which is evidenced by Arup and CWCT as collaborative research partners. Material suppliers for ceramic production, ie project partner Sibelco, will benefit from the potential of new markets and business opportunities.

The ceramic medium presents unique characteristics in term of durability, longevity and low embodied energy. Smart tooling approaches for ceramics will enable architects, designers and engineers to create parts and artefacts that respond to environmental and sustainability issues facing construction and production. Working in collaboration with ECAlab will ensure that these issues will be embedded within the research.

This fellow seeks to provide an exemplar of how conventional fabrication methods and traditional materials can be utilised in new fabrication concepts in combination with digital technologies and robotics. Technologically focused practitioners and companies will benefit from diversifying technology applications and increased user-base resulting in enhanced commercial opportunities.

Students from school to HEI will benefit through learning new skills and potential applications, which will allow them to understand and utilise this technology in the future. It will also demonstrate the impact of interdisciplinary solutions, utilising digital fabrication and robotics to innovate and strengthen traditional manufacturing in the UK to the next generation of the workforce.

The interdisciplinary approach of the project will offer case studies for wider industry, policy makers and third sector organisations, demonstrating the practical aspects of applying digital technology and robotics to traditional manufacturing techniques. The research will engage with third sector organisations to ensure that practices and policy are developed to facilitate similar project and initiatives.

It is anticipated that the proposed research will contribute to improving the UK's economic competitiveness by creating innovative new manufacturing methods that have wide application in domestic and commercial arenas. The new creative opportunities presented by the smart tooling systems have the potential for growing the cultural output of the UK both in terms of our built environment and domestic life.
 
Title 3D Toolprinting for Clay Extrusion 
Description This exhibition showcases the use of 3D printing to create tools for research explorations into clay extrusion. The tools exhibited are the extrusion profiles - also know as dies, which are most central part of the process. The exhibition also includes examples of the creative outputs of the research. 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact Transfer of knowledge of research process and methodology to new audiences in the printmaking community 
URL https://cfpr.uwe.ac.uk/impactconference12/home/exhibitions/
 
Title Artful Craft 
Description An exhibition of extruded porcelain pieces part of group exhibition 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact Exposure of research outcome to the public. The group exhibition curated by Peter Randell-Page RA featured some of the UK leading Makers including Alice Dudgeon, Amanda Cobbett, Amy Shelton, Andrea Liu, David Mach RA, David Nash RA OBE, Halima Cassell MBE, Jonathan Keep, Marcus Vergette, Peter Randall-Page RA, Sarah Gillespie, Susan Derges, Tavs Jørgensen 
URL https://makesouthwest.org.uk/all-exhibitions/artful-craft
 
Title Extruded Porcelain Twisted vases 
Description A series of twisted porcelain vases produced via 3D printed dies developed during this research. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2022 
Impact Vases exhibited at the launch event of Make South West Gallery, Bovey Tracy, UK. 
 
Title Set of extruded ceramic pieces for tissue transfer printing 
Description This is early stage creative exploration of the novel extrusion approaches developed during this research. These exploration is carried out in collaboration with Lisa Sheppy who is undertaking doctoral research into new uses of the ceramic tissue printing process. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact No notable impacts as yet 
URL https://www.instagram.com/p/CLWhDjcFwbh/
 
Description While this grant period has formally ended, development of knowledge from the research still continues, particularly as follow-on funding for a second phase of the fellowship has been granted and this phase is now underway. The new phase is structured with new objectives but there is degree of overlap in the core research aim, and outputs and impact from the initial phase of research will be delivered along-side outcomes from objectives of the new phase of the fellowship.

The research consists of both contextual and practice-based enquiries, with the main aim of the enquiry to explore research challenges and innovation opportunities through a practitioner investigation in the combined research space of design, architecture and robotics focusing on the process of ceramic profile extrusion.

The project's core objectives in this overarching aim:

• To provide an exemplar for how interdisciplinary practitioner lead research can foster cross-sector innovation in this particular combined research space.
• To undertake practical research to explore how advances in digital fabrication can be utilized to deliver innovation with the clay profile extrusion process.
• To explore new creative design opportunities that digitally assisted extruded ceramic forms presents.
• To undertake a survey of current practices with the clay extrusion processes in the fields of design, craft, architectural and technical ceramics. The purpose of the review is to provide a solid foundation to inform the practical research from a number of interdisciplinary perspectives.
• To track the interdisciplinary interaction in the practical research in order to map ways of engagement leading to insights and innovation in this particular combined research space.

The contextual aspects of the research have been successfully undertaken and has confirmed a key rationale for the research through the hypothesis that there is significant unexplored innovation potentiation with the ceramic profile extrusion process.

Despite significant challenges (faulty equipment and covid) the practical aspects of the research have also progressed well and delivered and significant technical development and findings. These include the development of a low-cost hydraulic extruding machine. This represents one of the most significant findings of the early stages of the practical research. The concept of this machine has very significant impact potential for individual ceramic practitioners as well as SME's. Other significant finding includes the development of novel concept for an extrusion die with integrated coating capabilities. Patent is now in the process of being filed for this invention.

In terms of the objectives regarding interdisciplinarity the project has been extremely successful in delivering new research partnerships. Examples of this is collaboration with the National Composite Centre (NCC) to develop the methods for extruding Ceramic Matrix Composite for the use in high performance applications in aerospace and energy. Collaboration with University of Plymouth is also underway to explore extrusion of non-fired clay fibre composites for low carbon construction.
Exploitation Route The outcomes of this research are highly likely to provide impact on manufacturers of architectural ceramic components through the innovation opportunities that are being presented by new production capabilities facilitated by the technical findings from the practice-based enquiries. Evidence of this is a new partnership with National Composite Centre (NCC) to explore how the findings of the research can be utilised for commercial exploitation. Development of the extrusion of Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMC) has been identified as of particular significant commercial interest.

The findings are also likely to presents new creative opportunities to architects and designers through these new production approaches, and thus the potential to enhance the cultural output of the UK with positive societal impact.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction,Creative Economy,Education,Energy,Environment,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description Smart Tooling for Ceramic Profile Extrusion: Interdisciplinary exploration of innovation opportunities
Amount £202,266 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/W000555/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2021 
End 10/2024
 
Title Development of clay hardness tester 
Description This tool has been developed to establish and reliable and cheap testing apparatus for testing clay hardness 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Test method being implemented at the Royal Danish Academy - Architecture, Design, Conservation 
URL https://wikifactory.com/+cfprceramics/clay-hardness-tool
 
Title Rich Media Smart Tooling Research Journal. 
Description A number of bespoke research templates has been created in the Filemaker Pro software platform to record the development of the practical aspects of the project. The templates are enabled for media entries to record observations in number of ways, including with images, textual, video and still images. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2019 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The tool has enable the research team to record tests via a single collaborative research journal. Still in development, but use expanded to other research projects. 
 
Description Ceramic Extrusion Collaboration with Arup 
Organisation Arup Group
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Development input to infrom Arup's building facade team.
Collaborator Contribution Consultation to guide and inform research from an industry perspective and to insure commercially relevant impact of the research.
Impact Specific outputs and impact outcomes are still in development.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Ceramic Extrusion Collaboration with Sibelco 
Organisation Sibelco
Country Belgium 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Development and research into new production approaches within key commercial interests to research partner.
Collaborator Contribution Contribution in the shape of consultation , industry insights and material sponsorship (clay)
Impact Specific outputs and impact outcomes are still in development.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Ceramic Extrusion Collaboration with Wienerberger 
Organisation Wienerberger
Country Austria 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Research and development into new production approaches with the clay extrusion process commercially relevant to research partner.
Collaborator Contribution Contribution with consultation and industry insights, also hosted visits to several production sites to inform research.
Impact Outputs and impact outcomes still in development
Start Year 2019
 
Description Ceramic Extrusion Research in Consultation with CWCT 
Organisation Centre for Window and Cladding Technology
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Involvement in sector relevant research and development.
Collaborator Contribution Consultation and industry insights, access to organisation members.
Impact Outputs and impact outcomes are still in development
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration with Ibstock Plc 
Organisation Ibstock Brick Limited
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Exploration commercial exploration have begun with this company. Early scale trails have been undertaken which utilise knowledge from this research in Ibstock production of specialist brick at the Cattybrook site in Bristol. KTP opportunities are being explored.
Collaborator Contribution Hosting visit to the Cattybrook, contribution of industrial know-how and commercial problem posing
Impact Early practical tests results
Start Year 2022
 
Description Collaboration with National Composite Centre 
Organisation National Composites Centre (NCC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The initial phase has developed a promising collaboration with the NCC, with exchange of knowledge for the potential commercial exploitation.
Collaborator Contribution In kind time for advise and facilitating link with commercial companies
Impact Specific output and outcome still in process. The collaboration is multidisciplinary, with disciplines including: engineering, design, science,
Start Year 2020
 
Description Material Sponsorship by Rolls Royce 
Organisation Rolls Royce Group Plc
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Undertaking test with supplied Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMC)
Collaborator Contribution Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMC) Material
Impact The collaboration facilitated success tests of extrusion with Ceramic Matrix Composites (CMC). This collaboration is multidisciplinary (design, craft , ceramics, aerospace engineering)
Start Year 2022
 
Title Ceramic Tube Extrusion Die Definition 
Description An advanced software tool to assist the development of extrusion die designs has been created as an outcome of this research. This tool has been created using visual scripting in the Grasshopper module within the Rhino 3D CAD program. The parametric scrip enables rapid iterations of extrusion die designs - particular for tube and pipe geometries. The tool presents the user with easy adjustment of a high number of variables and facilitates automated descriptions of the details of the tool design to be imprinted on the dies that are realised via 3D printing 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Still in development, so not employed beyond the research project. 
 
Title Clay Hardness Tester 
Description This technical product is a design for an open source clay hardness tester. The design is a penetrometer type based on the fall cone principle. The design is intended to be a low cost option for accurately establishing clay harnesses in the context of creative ceramic practices in particular. The design is predominately based on manufacturing via Fused Deposition Modelling (FDM) to enable easy distribution among practitioners with the ultimate aim of establishing a common clay hardness standard. 
Type Of Technology Systems, Materials & Instrumental Engineering 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The impact pf the development is still to assess 
URL https://wikifactory.com/+cfprceramics/clay-hardness-tool
 
Title Clay extrusion control through the use of angled nozzles 
Description This technique represent a novel way of addressing the issue of uneven material low in clay profile extrusion. The novel concept developed is a method of using 3D printed nozzles to counteract the effects of an 'unbalanced die' to secure an even and straight extrusion. The concept can also be applied to affect a controlled curving of the extrusion output. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The development is too recent to have notable impacts. 
 
Title Clay loading approach for piston extruder 
Description This is a new approach to load clay into a piston base extrusion devise. The method consists of a workflow were clay can be prepared by hand wedging or via a pug mill. A steel cartridge is used to load in sequential operations into the extrusion cylinder. A nesting devise is used to ensure the cartridge is in line with the extrusion cylinder and with the extrusion system piston used to push the clay to the cylinder. The piston is fitted with concave plunger which prevents air from being introduced into the clay stock. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The method is too recent to have notable impacts. 
 
Title Extrusion die with integrated coating Facility 
Description This invention is a further development of the profile extrusion manufacturing method. The extrusion profile tools used in this process are commonly known as dies. This invention facilitates extrusion dies to be integrated with coating capabilities for both the external surfaces as well as internal cavities of extruded profiles. This invention enables the facility of applying a coating as an integrated part of extrusion process - particular in with the use of ceramic pastes. The invention has the capacity to use coatings to improve the functional performance of the products such as enhanced capacities of extruded pipes to carry liquids, improved structural integrity - or facilitate weather resistance of products intended for external use. This facility also enables aesthetic transformations of products produced in a single standard body through the application of coloured coatings, which has significant commercial potential. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The impact of this innovation is still to be realised but it is likely to have commercial impact through innovation in industries that already utilize profile extrusion by extending the existing capacities manufacturing capabilities of these industries. The invention also has the potential to enable entirely new and novel uses of ceramics in sectors not currently utilising ceramic profile extrusion. Sectors identified where this invention has relevance include aerospace, energy and low carbon construction. Our team is particular motivated by the potential of actively contributing to UK's sustainability agenda and the 2050 net zero carbon target. A spin-out enterprise is also an ambition, with the commercial foundation on the basis of this invention and other IP of the associated research. 
 
Title Low Cost Hydraulic Ram Extruder Concept for Ceramics 
Description A new low cost ceramic ram extruding system has been developed as a part of this research. The system utilises of-the-shelf components in combination with 3D printed dies. 
Type Of Technology Physical Model/Kit 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact This technological product has just been established so to early to have notable impacts beyond the research project. 
 
Description Bristol print innovators make a strong impression 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Journal article featuring research and research methodologies
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://physicsworld.co...ke-a-strong-impression/
 
Description CFPR Industry Open Day 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact This event was a 3 day industry open day(s) at the CFPR research labs. Leading industry contacts attended the event over the three days. The event lead to numerous new contacts and expression of interest for further collaboration on the basis of the findings of the research. A booklet outlining the research was launched at this event.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Exhibition at Future Textiles 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Research exhibition at the Future Textile conference.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://cfpr.uwe.ac.uk/future-textiles-conference/
 
Description Materials Research Exchange (MRE) 2022 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Exhibition stand at the Materials Research Exchange (MRE) 2022. Participation resulted in a number of industry connections and collaborations opportunities.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://iuk.ktn-uk.org/events/materials-research-exchange-mre-2022/
 
Description On Line panel discussion for ArtFul Craft Exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Live online panel discussion with key participants in the ArtFul Craft Exhibition to mark the launch of the Artful Craft exhibition at MAKE Southwest, Peter Randall-Page RA, artist, MAKE Southwest president, and curator of the exhibition, chaired a Q&A with a handful of the exhibitors. The panel is Halima Cassell MBE, Jonathan Keep, Tavs Jørgensen, Alice Dudgeon and Andrea Liu. Presented by Exhibitions Manager Flora Pearson.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=taJ-050j7JQ