Bradford's National Museum: Methods for re-founding 'inter/national' museums translocally

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: Sch of Fine Art History of Art&Cult Stud

Abstract

The designation of a museum as 'national' implies a number of things: status and significance; a settled view of how collections fall within disciplinary boundaries (art, history, science); certain types of relations with visitors as citizens; specific forms of governance and funding structures; and a conceptual affiliation to the civic and the state. Yet the political and epistemic settlement that has underpinned the 'national museum' is under pressure on all of these fronts, with significant funding cuts, trans-disciplinary innovations and global flows of people, goods, capital and ideas that transcend national borders. Based in a city that has come to exemplify so many of these processes, 'Bradford's National Museum' project will deploy ideas of 'translocality' - a concept which foregrounds the connections between people in specific local areas rather than between national states and capital cities - as a way of re-framing the political geographies of museums.

The 'Bradford's National Museum' project - conceived with the National Media Museum (NMeM), part of the Science Museum Group (SMG) - will deploy 'translocality' in three ways, as a research method (with strands of work which are multi-sited and link Bradford with other local places), as an approach (of community network building in Bradford and through the connections Bradford has to other local places in other countries specifically Pakistan, Indian, Bangladesh, Commonwealth of Dominica and Poland) and as a concept (to support the development of new readings of inter/national in the context of museums).

The NMeM was founded as the National Museum for Photography, Film and Television in 1983, at a moment of optimism for Bradford. However, in the 1990s and 2000s different characterizations of the city hardened, the effect of three decades of national media and policy rhetoric which had sought to represent and account for 'what's wrong with Bradford'. The NMeM has been both affected by, and a player in, these national narratives of Bradford. Since its establishment, the museum has often been cited as a reason to come to Bradford in tourism and business relocation campaigns. Yet the NMeM has found a tension in its mission between being locally-engaged and maintaining a high-status role in international photography, film and television peer networks. Recent public debates concerning the sustainability of the NMeM have made visible a tension between the desire for the status that comes from Bradford having a national museum and an equally strong desire for local accountability.

The Bradford's National Museum project will explore the political geographies of the NMeM and wider SMG and of the different communities who live in Bradford as a means of addressing the tensions facing inter/national museums in engaging their local audiences. The project will work with the idea of Bradford not as a 'global city', but as provincial and connected translocally and place this in dialogue with the NMeM's focus on the 'science and culture of sound and vision technologies'. The research questions will be addressed through systemic action research allowing us to build a 'working picture' of the role the NMeM currently plays and use this to identify blocks as well as pathways for productive change. In Phase 1 it will use co-producing translocal stories with people who live locally to 'Write Bradford into the NMeM'. In Phase 2, the project will identify targeted interventions that will 'Write the NMeM into Bradford', refounding the 'national' in the NMeM translocally. In Phase 3, the project will ensure wider applicability through working with the NMeM SMG sister museums NRM and MOSI, by building exchanges with other museums internationally - the Smithsonian Institution (US) and via Beaconhouse National University (Pakistan) - and through identifying the implications of the research in a UK context through practitioner and policy-maker workshops.

Planned Impact

The Bradford's National Museum (NMeM) project will benefit a wide range of practitioners, policy makers and communities.

To describe benefit from the centre of the project outwards, the most immediate beneficiaries of the research will be the NMeM and the wider Science Museum Group (SMG). Through the project new ways of working will be identified. This will be done through drawing translocal research approaches into museum practice - multi-sited ethnography, trans-national history and science and technology studies - in order to articulate new curatorial and community engagement methods. The research will map, track and build new networks with, and for, the museum as a way of identifying new roles for the NMeM in Bradford. Exhibitions and programmes will be developed to consolidate the learning and relationships and, as the Phase 1 research design has it, 'Write Bradford into the NMeM'. The museum will then identify the structures that will sustain and embed these ways of working, both through trans-local methods into permanent display, Treasures (working title) and through organizational structures and roles with Bradford.

As part of the research design, the project will identify transferable and widely applicable methods for refounding museums in their local communities. The project will do this through projects which test and refine the methods identified in Bradford in new contexts. It will do this in the first instance with two of the NMeM's sister museums, MOSI in Manchester and National Railway Museum in York.

We will then undertake two exchanges beyond the UK. The first with the Smithsonian Institution in Washington DC through the project partnership with the Smithsonian Center for Learning and Digital Access and in Pakistan via Beaconhouse National University and our partnership with Professor Salima Hashmi.

By this point of dissemination a series of stages of crystallization will have been undertaken so that final phase of dissemination is high quality and usable for a wide range of museum practitioners and policy makers in the UK and beyond. This will be done through publications, workshops and conferences sharing these ideas more widely. Alchemy, one of the project partners, will play a key role here in deploying their well established practitioner networks both in museums and in the wider cultural sector.

Bradford as a local authority will benefit from the project through the ways in which the NMeM be able to play a clearer and better developed role within urgent issues and challenges facing Bradford, from schools to inward investment through the representation of both Bradford Metropolitan District Council and Bradford University on the Project Advisory Network. At the same time, the NMeM will contribute towards Bradford and its development by using itself as a platform for sharing a rich and wider range of stories about the city than those most common heard in UK media and policy. Policy makers in local authorities UK wide will benefit form the learning via our end of project publications and events.

Funders will be engaged throughout the project though our Project Advisory Network. This will enable the project to develop useful and resonance knowledge about how different funding regimes might contribute towards museums paying a rooted and contributing role in their local areas yet also, translocally and connected beyond.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Above the Noise: 15 Stories from Bradford 
Description Above the Noise: 15 Stories From Bradford is part of the action research design for the Arts and Humanities Research Council-funded Bradford's National Museum project. The project was collaboratively developed from the beginning between researchers at the University of Leeds, the National Science and Media Museum and partners in Bradford - Alchemy, BCB, Tim Smith, Kahani and Tim Smith - each with their own established community development practice and flourishing networks. Drawing on the strands of research from the first phase of the project - including open conversations with lots of different people in Bradford - we've decided that the exhibition will explore how different communities in Bradford have made their own worlds by bypassing and confronting national power structures and mainstream media. In particular it will explore how people from Bradford have recorded their own histories, created their own cultural spheres and made political and social change and the ways they have done this using local-to-local and alternative distribution networks and by adapting or re-purposing available technologies. We're telling 15 such stories, the majority of which are being developed in collaboration with people in Bradford who have a stake in telling the story. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact The exhibiton will open on 14th March 2019 so we will report on impacts to Research Fish next year. 
URL https://www.scienceandmediamuseum.org.uk/whats-on/above-noise
 
Title Bradford's National Museum Collaborative Publication 
Description Bradford's National Museum explored how the National Science and Media Museum can become locally-rooted and more open, engaged and collaborative. Over 150 people were involved in different ways in shaping the research and the ideas that have emerged. This publication is not simply giving a retrospective account of the research findings. It was developed as an intrinsic part of our action research. We used the process of creating the publication to enable a final phase of reflection and dialogue and to draw out future directions for the National Science and Media Museum in and with Bradford. Approaching the issues from many different people's perspectives sharpened our understandings of the significant tensions produced by a national museum seeking to be rooted and collaborative. It also identified ways in which the tensions could be activated as strengths, dynamically creating pathways between the national and the local and expanding what the museum is and might become. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Created a new approach to working in Bradford for the National Science and Media Museum 
URL https://bradfordsnationalmuseum.org/
 
Description Through the Bradford's National Museum research process, it became obvious that significant challenges are created by the National Science and Media Museum connecting to Bradford and seeking to become more open, engaged and collaborative. It is possible to see and experience these challenges as contradictions which are frustrating and exhausting. And it is important to acknowledge that, alongside elation, feeling tired and dispirited was part of the story of Above the Noise: 15 Stories from Bradford for both museum staff, the project team and our story collaborators who live and work in Bradford.

The factors that produce the tensions represent different facets of the mission of the National Science and Media Museum. They are related to the ways in which the National Science and Media Museum is 'national': the fact that the National Science and Media Museum is part of the Science Museum Group, the implications of decision-making in a large multi-sited organisation, the process and procedures deployed to manage the museum's responsibilities to collections and the pressures created by seeking to produce exhibitions, a film programme and events that attract large numbers of visitors.

As a result, the tensons that arise when the museum has sought to work locally and in a collaborative way are not fully or finally resolvable. Yet where we have arrived - with the final push offered by this publication process - is that the tensions, once honestly acknowledged, can be approached in a way that turns them into strengths. To put it another way, the tensions created by navigating what it means to be national while being located outside a capital city are precisely what makes the National Science and Media Museum the National Science and Media Museum.

The Future Directions for the National Science and Media Museum and its relationship with Bradford are set out in two ways, through a letter to Bradford from the museum and through focusing more specifically on the ways of working that will make the Tensions as Strengths approach meaningful.

The letter and ways of working have cohered a 'we' of the museum - it is a statement which seeks to make visible the issues the museum faces in working locally and how it wants to approach the negotiation of these tensions as a creative and fruitful part of organisational culture and a culture of collaboration. The ways of working are more specific and suggest tactics to enable greater alignment between the national and local where possible and a positive activation of the tensions where alignment is not possible.

However, in the spirit of the multiple perspectives that have animated the Bradford's National Museum project from the first, the collective 'we' of the museum letter and the ways of working are accompanied by personal postscripts by staff and our collaborators. The personal postscripts act as both affirmations and qualifications, they enable individual voices to be heard and underline aspects of Tensions of Strengths to make visible what might need to be in place or be considered to make them as useful as can be. The personal postscripts also work as a performance or enactment of the commitment to challenge, discussion, reflection and learning evoked in the letter.
Exploitation Route The findings of the Bradford's National Museum project are directly relevant to the policy and practice of the National Science and Media Musuem and have already shaped their work through the action research methods. The insights are also relevant to other national museums seeking to connect to local places and be more open, engaged and collborative - and to other musuems seeking to find more transparent ways of make visible their ways of working as part of collborative projects.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://bradfordsnationalmuseum.org/
 
Description The findings of the Bradford's National Museum project have been co-created with and used by staff at the National Science and Media Museum. We produced a collborative publication as part of the process of reflection on the three years of different inquiries. This publiction sets out the future of the working relationship between the National Science and Media Museum and Bradford. Our exhibition Above the Noise: 15 Stories From Bradford (2019) was include in the Bradford City of Culture submission.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description The Congruence Engine: Digital Tools for New Collections-Based Industrial Histories
Amount £2,941,948 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/W003244/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2021 
End 11/2024
 
Description Collaboration with Bradford Grand Mosque 
Organisation Bradford Grand Mosque
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Seán McLoughlin visited the mosque and spent time with its members. He took part in an independent visit of a small number of museum staff to the mosque and arranged to speak at greater length to a key member of mosque media staff, presenting the idea of participating in an exhibition at the National Science and Media Museum to him. He interviewed this member of the mosque media team and liaised with him and the museum's volunteer co-ordinator to discuss a return visit of mosque students to the museum. McLoughlin also introduced a sound artist to the mosque, orientating them to its place in Islam, Bradford and Pakistani Muslim diaspora networks. He guided them through initial rituals.
Collaborator Contribution Bradford Grand Mosque considered McLoughlin's request and consented to participate in the exhibition project, both agreeing for key staff to be interviewed by Seán McLoughlin and ultimately several recordings of sound in the mosque and on its app to be recorded by sound artist, Alex De Little. De Little also interviewed a religious scholar associated with the mosque. The mosque media team also brought its students to the museum and played an active role in preparations for the final exhibit.
Impact An exhibit on Islamic Sounds in Bradford which is part of 'Above the Noise', an exhibition at the National Science and Media Museum, April to June 2019. The exhibit is in two parts, an immersive sound art installation composed by Alex De Little based in part upon recordings made at Bradford Grand Mosque and an audio-based interpretation curated by Seán McLoughlin exploring Islamic sounds across the spaces of home, mosque, on the move and the wider world. Interview material gathered in Bradford Grand Mosque is included in this part of the exhibit too. The collaboration works across museum studies and Islamic studies.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Bradford's National Museum Above the Noise Exhibition - talk to Visitor Studies Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A team from the Bradford's National Museum project and the National Science and Media Museum gave a presentation and workshop at the Visitor Studies Conference (5th and 6th March 2020) exploring the reflective process we conducted after the end of the Above the Noise: 15 Stories From Bradford exhibition (April-June 2019).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Museums and Civil Society after Brexit. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I presented on the Bradford's National Museum project, with a focus on the Above the Noise Exhibition (14th March-19th June). I explore specificially non-representational approaches to participatory practice in museums.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://wiserd.ac.uk/events/symposium-museums-and-civil-society-after-brexit
 
Description UK Participatory Research Network 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact I explore the participatory and action research approaches being undertaken in the Bradford's National Museum research project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019