Agronomic processes to optimise galanthamine content of daffodil biomass (AGROGAL)

Lead Research Organisation: Bangor University
Department Name: Sch of Biological Sciences

Abstract

This project aims to build on a previous one-year study undertaken by Alzeim in collaboration with IGER, where the feasibility of Narcissus cultivation was considered under selected environmental regimes and at different harvest dates (Morris et al 05). At that time, the economic returns were forecast to be only moderate, since pharmaceuticals containing galanthamine were protected by patents and API levels were quite low allied to high extraction and transport costs. Formulations containing the API are now generic and the research detailed in this proposal will build on sequential harvesting of different Narcissus tissues, containing significantly higher galanthamine levels, already piloted at Alzeim. The findings and research that will be addressed within this project will seek to further drive down costs by applying the latest biorefinery principles, coupled to entirely novel harvest and extraction regimes, which are then allied to developments in agronomy, choice of plant genetic resources and savings through reduced transport of feedstocks. Sales of the biorefinery 'side-streams' should result in spin-off benefits to the local economy through supply of products to support the tourism industry (perfume, paper, wax). Although focused on the objective of maximising the alkaloid content of daffodils, the research will also provide information that can be directly utilised by flower growers and indirectly by other producers seeking to use plants as sources of secondary metabolites. Specifically, the research will demonstrate the response required from growers to climate change. The innovative qualitative models produced by the research should capture all pre-existing knowledge and provide coherent tests of the results of the various trials. In addition, they should provide the foundation for models for analogous systems. The qualitative models should enable prospective growers to determine the expected returns on their investments.

Technical Summary

This project will build on a previous one-year study undertaken by Alzeim in collaboration with IGER, where the feasibility of Narcissus cultivation was considered under selected environmental regimes and at different harvest dates (Morris et al 05). At that time, the economic returns were forecast to be only moderate, since pharmaceuticals containing galanthamine were protected by patents and API levels were quite low allied to high extraction and transport costs. Formulations containing the API are now generic and the research detailed in this proposal will build on sequential harvesting of different Narcissus tissues, containing significantly higher galanthamine levels, already piloted at Alzeim. The findings and research that will be addressed within this project will seek to further drive down costs by applying the latest biorefinery principles, coupled to entirely novel harvest and extraction regimes, which are then allied to developments in agronomy, choice of plant genetic resources and savings through reduced transport of feedstocks. Sales of the biorefinery 'side-streams' should result in spin-off benefits to the local economy through supply of products to support the tourism industry (perfume, paper, wax). Although focused on the objective of maximising the alkaloid content of daffodils, the research will also provide information that can be directly utilised by flower growers and indirectly by other producers seeking to use plants as sources of secondary metabolites. Specifically, the research will demonstrate the response required from growers to climate change. The innovative qualitative models produced by the research should capture all pre-existing knowledge and provide coherent tests of the results of the various trials. In addition, they should provide the foundation for models for analogous systems. The qualitative models should enable prospective growers to determine the expected returns on their investments.

Planned Impact

This partnership is very well placed to provide the necessary know-how to enable farmers to produce the crop to required industrial specifications. NIAB has members associated with high affiliation of arable and horticultural growers. Alzeim has a well co-ordinated network of growers and farm specialists within Wales with whom the Consortium will place contracts and ensure a scientifically- led development of the crop. Grower guides and demonstrations plots will be made available via specialist meetings and workshops, such as Members Days at NIAB and. choice of cultivars and production methods will be published as part of the NIAB publication set when the crop is at a suitable stage of development. Meetings and workshops will be held to demonstrate the potential of this crop to meet the requirements of farmers, processors and the food companies. These will include the NNFCC at York and other bodies. It is probable that upland growers will be the first to participate and benefit, but when the `Black Mountains Effect' is understood it is hoped that growing can be extended to other altitudes and areas. At Bangor, in addition to published academic output in stress biochemistry and physiology and hydroponics, Prof Tomos has decades of experience of communicating science to lay audiences - including regular talks (live, radio and TV) and regular articles in magazines (eg Barn, Agenda, Y Naturieithwr). These include meetings with Farmers Associations (inc FUW in 2009). Other engagement activities include serving on the Board of Governors of BBSRC-IGER and as a (non-exec) director of an upland grasiers association (set up to manage changing regulations governing the use of uplands). This (galanthamine) project is particularly suitable for public engagement of science. Dr. Braganca is a member of WINR (Welsh Institute of Natural Resources) which has considerable outreach activities.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The objective of the Programme is to identify inividual agronomically-relevant processes and treatments that would increase the production of the anti-Alzeimer drug, Galanthamine, in Daffodils. (To identify the basis of the so called Black Mountain Effect observed in the field.) Extensive and reproducable analysis of some 20 different treatments applied individual (under laboratory conditions) have so far failed to find any that mimic the Black Mountain effect and have been eliminated from likely target processes. We consider this to be an unequivocal (and hence positive) result. (Some treatments increase concentration of alkaloids, but at the expense of fresh weight. The overall yield per plant remaining unchanged.)
Exploitation Route The explicit results will ensure that the industrial partners, and others, will have to look elsewhere for biostimulatory treatments in the case of the galanthamine harvest.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment

URL http://edata.bangor.ac.uk/44/
 
Description The company partner has created new jobs and sales on the basis of this work. The process is protected know-how with the company.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Galanthamine from Smart BioProcessing of Daffodils
Amount £120,000 (GBP)
Funding ID 131150 
Organisation Innovate UK 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2013 
End 04/2014
 
Description NitrogelCap (https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=105627)
Amount £127,799 (GBP)
Funding ID https://gtr.ukri.org/projects?ref=105627 
Organisation UK Government Investments 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 11/2019 
End 10/2020
 
Title GC-FID,GC-MS protocol to measure galanthamine and related alkaloids. 
Description Quantitative analysis of a range of compounds of interest. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2013 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact
 
Title Hydroponic procedure for daffodil growth 
Description A system for growing daffodil plants from bulbs to (flowering) maturity was developed. This was installed in both a conventional greenhouse and in a high light-intensity walk-in growth room. A range of treatments, including (mild) UV irradiation was applied. Th largest layout consisted of some 20 tanks with 25 bulbs in each. 
Type Of Material Biological samples 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact .. 
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation Agroceutical Products
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation Bangor University
Department BioComposites Centre
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation National Institute of Agronomy and Botany (NIAB)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation New Generation Daffodils
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation Sustanum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation Sustanum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation Suterra
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description AGROGAL Consortium (BBSRC-LINK) 
Organisation Suterra
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Hydroponic growth of daffodils. Application of physiological treatments. Assay of galanthamine and other alkaloid content. Interpretation of results.
Collaborator Contribution Provision of daffodil bulbs (New Gen Daffodils); Fine chemicals and advice (Sustanum); Field trials and data (NIAB and Velcourt); Advice on experimental design (APL and Suterra/Agrisense). Facilities for galanthamine assay (BCBU)
Impact Determination of the impact of a range of individual physiological treatments on galanthamine accumulation by daffodils. (By successful hydroponic growth of daffodils and assay of galanthamine (and other alkaloid) content.) Fuller details of outcomes will be included in URLs for the final submission in 2015 (integrating all consortium members).
Start Year 2009
 
Description NitrogelCap- a collaboration to produce neutraceuticals using Galanthamine 
Organisation Bangor University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We are planning to produce new Galanthamine based nutraceuticals
Collaborator Contribution Involved in separation of plant chemicals
Impact Collaboration starting.
Start Year 2019
 
Description Television Programme (Dibendraw, S4C. Teledu Telesgop Cyf) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact 30 minute programme (S4C) on Daffodils and Galanthamine (broadcasted May 2015 SC4)

NA
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014,2015
URL http://www.telesgop.co.uk/tv-production/dibendraw/