18-BTT EAGER: Controlling meiotic recombination in crops by manipulating DNA methylation

Lead Research Organisation: University of Birmingham
Department Name: Sch of Biosciences

Abstract

This consortium plans to develop highly innovative strategies to stimulate recombination in genomic regions that are normally refractory to genetic variation in key crop species. Developing ways to increase recombination rates in genome areas of low recombination will contribute to more efficient breeding. The outcome will allow reducing the time required to develop new elite germplasm and enable rapid introgression of desirable genes from diverse sources to facilitate developing more robust crops that will exhibit superior productivity in sustainable ways and be better suited to deal with the challenges arising from the climate change. The goal of this project is to gain an understanding of how DNA methylation influences the meiotic recombination landscape in plants. Meiotic recombination is initiated by the formation of numerous programmed double-strand breaks in chromosomal DNA, a small proportion of which are processed to form crossovers. Thus, genetic variation generated by a single round of meiotic recombination is limited. Furthermore, the distribution of crossovers in plants with large genomes, which include most crops, is highly biased towards the ends of chromosomes. As a result, extensive interstitial and centromere proximal chromosome regions rarely recombine. Yet, these large genome areas contain roughly one-fifth of the genes in maize and even larger gene fractions in some other crops, which presents a serious impediment to plant breeding. Recent studies indicate that DNA methylation is a critical factor shaping crossover landscapes. However, the exact relationship between recombination and DNA methylation is not understood. This project seeks to elucidate how DNA methylation affects recombination patterns at the mechanistic level and lay foundations for methods to control crossover landscapes in crops by altering DNA methylation. The study will be conducted in maize and Brassica rapa, to explore the behavior of both monocot and dicot genomes. To elucidate the effect of DNA methylation on meiotic recombination, a protocol to transiently alter DNA methylation patterns in meiosis will be developed. The chemically demethylated plants and selected mutants defective in DNA methylation will be used to determine which steps and processes of meiosis are altered by DNA methylation. It will be also established which specific aspect of DNA methylation affects crossover landscape.

Technical Summary

The goal of this project is to gain an understanding of how DNA methylation influences the meiotic recombination landscape in crops and to develop an efficient method for modulating the distribution of recombination events by manipulating DNA methylation levels during meiosis. Meiotic recombination is the main generator of genetic variation in plants. It underpins the breeding programs essential to deliver rapid improvements in crops required to ensure future food security. Meiotic recombination is initiated by the formation of numerous programmed double-strand breaks (DSBs) in chromosomal DNA, a small proportion of which are processed to form crossovers (COs). Thus, genetic variation generated by a single round of meiotic recombination is limited. Furthermore, the distribution of COs in plants with large genomes, which include most crops, is highly biased towards the ends of chromosomes. As a result, extensive interstitial and centromere-proximal chromosome regions rarely recombine. Yet, these large genome areas contain roughly one-fifth of the genes in maize and even larger gene fractions in some other crops. Hence, it would invaluable to develop methods to manipulate CO patterning and increase recombination in interstitial/proximal chromosome regions. Recent work by us and others indicates that DNA methylation is a critical factor shaping CO landscapes. Our studies found an increase in COs as well as CO redistribution from chromosome ends to pericentromeric regions in the maize DNA methylation deficient mutant zmet2. Thus, altering CO locations across the genome may be achieved by modulating DNA methylation patterns.
This project will (i) develop methods to transiently alter DNA methylation patterns in meiosis, and (ii) gain the understanding of how exactly DNA methylation affects CO distribution at the mechanistic level and which specific aspects of DNA methylation are responsible for shaping CO landscapes. We will use maize and Brassica rapa.

Planned Impact

Ensuring Food Security over the forthcoming years is one of the main challenges for society. Different factors like population growth and climate change will increase the necessity of sustained improvements in food production (by 2050 it is predicted that food production will have to be increased by at least 50%). Crop breeding would have to improve to deliver the required yields. Molecular plant breeding has transformed the available options for plant breeders in recent years. Nonetheless, crop breeding is highly dependent of meiotic recombination to generate genetic variation through the formation of crossovers (COs). This consortium plans to develop highly innovative strategies to stimulate recombination in genomic regions that are normally refractory to genetic variation in key crop species. In large-genome plants, COs tend to favor locations close to chromosome ends, resulting in large pericentromeric sections of chromosomes being CO-depleted In maize, one-third of the genome and one-fifth of genes are in the pericentromeric regions, which show on average 20-fold less recombination than the more-highly recombining distal chromosome regions. In wheat and barley, the fractions of the affected genes are even higher. This situation presents a serious impediment to plant breeding. Developing ways to increase recombination rates in genome areas of low recombination will contribute to more efficient breeding. The outcome will allow reducing the time required to develop new elite germplasm and enable rapid introgression of desirable genes from diverse sources to facilitate developing more robust crops that will exhibit superior productivity in sustainable ways and be better suited to deal with the challenges arising from the climate change.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The main goal of this project was to produce a methodological framework to control CO landscapes in crops by altering DNA methylation. Our lab at UoB has focused on Brassica rapa (dicot) and collaborated with Prof. Pawlowski at Cornell University who focused on maize (monocot). The most significant achievements from this award has been to develop easy, reliable and feasible methods to alter DNA methylation patterns which can be use in breading programs, and gain in the understanding of how changes in DNA methylation could reshape the CO landscape during meiosis.

Objective/Achivement 1. Use of chemical treatments to alter DNA methylation levels.
We have successfully developed different methods to alter DNA methylation patterns during meiosis by using chemical treatments. We have developed different methodologies to alter DNA methylation with DNA methylation inhibitors (5-azacytidine, Decitabine, RG108, SGI 1027, and 6-thioguanine) and chromatin silencing (H3K9me2) inhibitors (A366, BRD4770, UNC 0642, and UNC 0646). The methylation changes were analysed by direct cytoimmunolocalization of anti-H3K9me2 and anti-5mC on different stages of meiosis. High concentrations of these chemicals produced high methylation changes but also strong errors in meiosis (chromosome missegregation and fragmentation) producing inviable gametes (pollen grains) and infertility. Lower doses of these chemicals showed reduced methylation changes without changes in gamete viability. Cytological analysis of Metaphase I chiasma localization showed important changes in CO landscape, interestingly some chiasmata moved from distal regions to more interstitial regions, but this behaviour was not global among the chromosome pairs but with some chromosome pairs showing this changes and others not. Further research would be required to analyse in more detail why some chromosome pairs seem to be more affected than others. Additional research in chromosome/chromatin structure differences should be followed in new projects.

Objective/Achivement 2. Changing CO landscapes by altering DNA methylation patterns.
We generated two mutant alleles of the KRYPTONITE (KYP)/SUVH4 methyltransferase in Brassica rapa as well as chemical treatments to change DNA methylation on meiocytes to elucidate how DNA methylation could affect CO landscapes. TILLING mutants for kyp/suvh4 in B. rapa showed some changes in meiotic recombination behaviour. Some chromosome missegregation was observed but also after a systematic cytological chiasma analisys it was very clear that some COs were relocalized to different positions on the chromosome, towards more interstitial regions. This CO relocalization was not global, but some chromosomes were more affected than others. Similar results were observed when using chemicals to change the DNA methylation patterns.

Furthermore, similar results were obtained by our collaborators at Cornell University in maize. These results showed that DNA methylation patterns have an important role in the localization of COs in plants but this patterns are intrinsically affected by the individual chromosome structure as COs localization changes were not observed globally among all the chromosomes but in some specific ones. Further research would be needed to elucidate what other chromosome/chromatin elements would interfere with the methylation pattern changes and the COs relocalization.
Exploitation Route This project has helped to increase our understanding of the basic biology of recombination and could contribute to improvement of plant breeding methods by providing new methodologies/tools to plant breeders to alter CO locatization.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Description This partnership with Cornell University and the University of Birmingham has provided us with the opportunity to work in two crop species Maize and Brassica, to actually manipulate meiotic recombination outcomes on them by using chemicals affecting DNA methylation in meiocytes. The outcome in our research has provided us with new techniques to allow chemical treatments on living crops (maize and brassicas) and to allow changes in the pattern of meiotic recombination. This is a very important tool for plant breeders which use meiotic recombination in order to obtain crops with different agronomical traits. Meiotic recombination has different constraints that could be overtaken by the use of these methodologies. The project explored DNA methylation changes to produce different recombination patterns and although they didn't seem to be globally affecting all the chromosomes in these species at the same level, it was very clear that some chromosomes were more affected than others. This is showing us that only altering DNA methylation won't be sufficient to achieve global chromosome changes in meiotic recombination by itself but together with other changes in the landscape of chromatin patterns could actually be added to that final outcome.
First Year Of Impact 2022
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
 
Title Chemical treatments to manipulate Brassica meiosis 
Description Two different methodologies has been set up for B. oleracea and B. rapa in order to treat meiocytes during meiosis with different chemicals (e.g.: DNA/histone methylation inhibitors). The methods involved injection of chemicals on the stem of inflorescences and/or cutting the inflorescences and submerge them on the chemical. Both are working on these species with some changes on the methodologies in order to accommodate phenotypic changes of the species inflorescences. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The methodology will be published in the near future. 
 
Description Chris Franklin 
Organisation University of Birmingham
Department School of Biosciences
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Research contributiopn
Collaborator Contribution Research collaboration
Impact Articles/Grant proposals
 
Description Prof Wojtek Pawlowski 
Organisation Cornell University
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The main goal of this project was to produce a methodological framework to control CO landscapes in crops by altering DNA methylation. Our lab at UoB has focused on Brassica rapa (dicot) and collaborated with Prof. Pawlowski at Cornell University who focused on maize (monocot). The most significant achievements from this award has been to develop easy, reliable and feasible methods to alter DNA methylation patterns which can be use in breading programs, and gain in the understanding of how changes in DNA methylation could reshape the CO landscape during meiosis. Objective/Achivement 1. Use of chemical treatments to alter DNA methylation levels. We have successfully developed different methods to alter DNA methylation patterns during meiosis by using chemical treatments. We have developed different methodologies to alter DNA methylation with DNA methylation inhibitors (5-azacytidine, Decitabine, RG108, SGI 1027, and 6-thioguanine) and chromatin silencing (H3K9me2) inhibitors (A366, BRD4770, UNC 0642, and UNC 0646). The methylation changes were analysed by direct cytoimmunolocalization of anti-H3K9me2 and anti-5mC on different stages of meiosis. High concentrations of these chemicals produced high methylation changes but also strong errors in meiosis (chromosome missegregation and fragmentation) producing inviable gametes (pollen grains) and infertility. Lower doses of these chemicals showed reduced methylation changes without changes in gamete viability. Cytological analysis of Metaphase I chiasma localization showed important changes in CO landscape, interestingly some chiasmata moved from distal regions to more interstitial regions, but this behaviour was not global among the chromosome pairs but with some chromosome pairs showing this changes and others not. Further research would be required to analyse in more detail why some chromosome pairs seem to be more affected than others. Additional research in chromosome/chromatin structure differences should be followed in new projects. Objective/Achivement 2. Changing CO landscapes by altering DNA methylation patterns. We generated two mutant alleles of the KRYPTONITE (KYP)/SUVH4 methyltransferase in Brassica rapa as well as chemical treatments to change DNA methylation on meiocytes to elucidate how DNA methylation could affect CO landscapes. TILLING mutants for kyp/suvh4 in B. rapa showed some changes in meiotic recombination behaviour. Some chromosome missegregation was observed but also after a systematic cytological chiasma analisys it was very clear that some COs were relocalized to different positions on the chromosome, towards more interstitial regions. This CO relocalization was not global, but some chromosomes were more affected than others. Similar results were observed when using chemicals to change the DNA methylation patterns. Furthermore, similar results were obtained by our collaborators at Cornell University in maize. These results showed that DNA methylation patterns have an important role in the localization of COs in plants but this patterns are intrinsically affected by the individual chromosome structure as COs localization changes were not observed globally among all the chromosomes but in some specific ones. Further research would be needed to elucidate what other chromosome/chromatin elements would interfere with the methylation pattern changes and the COs relocalization. This project has helped to increase our understanding of the basic biology of recombination and could contribute to improvement of plant breeding methods by providing new methodologies/tools to plant breeders to alter CO locatization.
Collaborator Contribution The US and UK partners have brought to the project complementary expertise. The USA group has comprehensively studied the mechanisms of recombination and chromatin changes in meiosis whereas our UK group have extensive experience in molecular cytogenetics and its application in the study of meiotic chromosome structure. Furthermore, the US and UK partners bring the expertise of working with different plant species, maize (USA) and brassicas as well as Arabidopsis (UK). Both US and UK partners have participated in all goals comparing strategies between monocot (maize) and dicot (brassica) crop species. The two groups have a long track record of ad hoc collaboration as well as participation in several EU- and EU/US funded network research programs (7th Framework and ERA-Caps-3) as well as EU-funded training networks (MC-ITN and MC-ETN) and this collaboration will continue in the future. As partners we have developed extensive methods to analyze chromosome structural protein complexes and chromatin modifications and chemical treatments to manipulate meiosis in maize and brassicas, which will be used in future projects, individually and/or collectively in partnership.
Impact A research article is in the process of being developed. Further research funding is in process to be followed by both groups. e.g.: EU funding under revision (Jan 2022). More collaborations are developed among the groups at the moment.
Start Year 2019
 
Description British Meiosis Meeting Aberyswyth 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact British meiosis meeting in Aberystwyth
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.aber.ac.uk/en/ibers/news/events/britishmeiosismeeting/
 
Description Conference Madrid 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact ITN meeting in El Escorial, Madrid June 2019 invited external speakers from academic and industry (plant breeders) talks about where meiosis recombination research is going in the future.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://meicom-itn.com/meetings
 
Description Invited Speaker for Society for Experimental Biology Annual Main Meeting Antwerp from June 29th - 2nd July 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Invited speaker to SEB in Artwenp but now changed to an online meeting via Zoom.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.sebiology.org/events/event/seb-conference-2021
 
Description ONLINE workshop in meiosis 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Several meetings were carried out to engage during the lockdown with plant meiosis groups. Carried out via Zoom. With presentations and discussions.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Open Visit Days University of Birmingham 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Taster Lecture for Open Visit Days at University of Birmingham: "Using genetics to feed the World". Talk about our research and its impact.
Different days during 2019 and 2020 to interested future students and their families/friends accompanying them. Around 100-250 people per day.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019,2020
 
Description Outreach activity for School visit to University of Birmingham 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Genetic research outreach. Activities to show DNA extraction, DNA gel electrophoresis, mutation concept and evolution of mutations in agricultural interest vegetables (Brassica oleracea).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Seminar at the University of Birmingham "Manipulating meiotic recombination to produce the crops of the future" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact On line seminar via Zoom. Exposing our research in the lab.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Taste Lecture during Open Day 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Presentation of a lecture to future applicants and family/friends. Recorded on Feb 2020 and used as a video online since then. Presenting part of the reasons of our research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021