Understanding soil quality and resilience: effects of perturbations and natural variations on nitrous oxide emission water retention and structure

Lead Research Organisation: Rothamsted Research
Department Name: Sustainable Soils and Grassland Systems

Abstract

This project concerns the quality of agricultural soil. Roots need water, dissolved nutrients and oxygen, and good quality soil can transport all of these. Good soil is important for sustainable agriculture / specifically the production of grass or crops without damage to the soil or surrounding environment. The structure of soil can be damaged by compaction caused by tractor wheels or tillage. Also, if nitrate-containing soil becomes waterlogged, it exudes nitrous oxide (laughing gas). Nitrous oxide is a potent greenhouse gas causing global warming, and also adds to the destruction of the stratospheric ozone layer. If a soil is resilient, then even if it does become compacted or water-logged, it can recover. The aim of this project is to learn more about the structure and processes within soil, so that we can promote soil quality and resilience, and minimise emission of nitrous oxide. We intend to use four new, or newly improved, experimental methods, based at different research centres across the UK. These are X-ray computed tomography (similar to the CAT-scans used in hospitals), a device for measuring the water-holding ability of soil when it is being drained by gravity only, an apparatus capable of monitoring the nitrous oxide emitted from twelve laboratory samples, and a 'lysimeter' which measures the precise way nitrate is distributed and leashes through the soil under simulated rainfall. Soil is a very complicated material, and up until now studies have mostly correlated their properties without completely understanding them. To move beyond that, we enlist the help of a computer model called 'Pore-Cor' which simulates the porous structure of soil. We intend to make the model even more advanced by introducing arrays of closely packed smaller pores within the larger structure, as occur in real soil. Not only does the computer program correlate all the different properties, it also displays its results in a Virtual Reality environment / so we can climb inside the soil and see what is going on. The model will allow us to understand the geometric arrangements of the smaller pores relative to the larger, the pore environments in which the nitrous oxide is generated and vented, how nitrate distributes through the soil to feed the nitrous oxide-inducing bacteria, and how compaction and saturation affect the processes occurring. The model will also drive the experimentation forward because of its need for accurate data, and enable predictions to be made for nitrous oxide emission under other conditions and in varying soil systems. The emission of nitrous oxide is affected by other factors which will not be measured or modelled, for example temperature and wind speed. It also varies according to soil management / in particular the amount of fertiliser added, tillage, and the grazing or cropping regime. However, underlying all these effects are the fundamental structures and processes, and better understanding and prediction of these will help inform policy on land management to achieve optimum soil quality and resilience, and minimum nitrous oxide emission.

Technical Summary

This project will promote the improve the understanding and predictability of soil quality and resilience, and assist with the minimisation of nitrous oxide (N2O) production. Grassland and arable soils with similar clay contents, but variable organic carbon content and age of ley, will be studied at 7 cm core and 50 cm precision lysimeter scale. The samples will be studied at typical ambient density, or after fast or slow compaction. A hierarchical approach will be taken to the properties of the samples, ranging from void structure through quasi-static and dynamic fluid properties, to structure-mediated chemical and biological processes. The void structure of the soil samples will be measured by X-ray computed tomography, and water retention curves will be measured with the help of a novel gravity drainage cell. The dispersion and breakthrough of conservative (bromide) tracer and nitrate will be measured using a new precision lysimeter and rainfall simulator. Nitrous oxide emissions will be measured under conditions which are structure mediated but neither carbon-nor nitrogen-limited. Dominance of denitrification over nitrification will be checked by measurement of isotope and isotopomer ratios. The results will be interpreted by a new multi-scale pore model of soil structure. Two hypothetical structures of soil will be generated, with micropores which act hydrologically parallel to macro-pores, or which act in series with the macropores. Inputs to the model will be the macro-pore size distribution from X-ray CT scans, and the full range water retention curves. Outputs will be conservative tracer breakthrough characteristics, nitrate dispersion characteristics, and rate of N2O production. We aim to obtain outputs sufficiently aligned with experiment that they can not only explain the properties of the sample set, but also predict the properties of other soils and conditions, thus allowing the fundamental advances to inform policy on land management.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description A mathematical model for the simulation of denitrification in soils was developed representing micro-porous hot-spots of biological activity in addition to macro-porous connectivity. Hypothetical positioning of the hot-spot zones away from the critical percolation pathways slowed the increase and decline in emissions of gases. The model and parameters are suitable for use in assessing the effects of soil compaction and saturation on nitrous oxide emissions from soils. Isotope effects of denitrification were determined for the first time in a laboratory experiment under oxic atmosphere using a novel approach where nitrous oxide production and reduction occur simultaneously. Isotope fractionation factors were concluded to be potentially applicable to field studies as indicators of process. However, ratios of O18/N15 isotopes varied according to the product ratios of nitrous oxide production and reduction, and ratios previously accepted as typical (>2) are not valid for all conditions. At high soil moisture, gaseous N fluxes from nitrification/denitrification processes were shown to be less variable, with a more complete denitrification to N2 gas (because of slower diffusion of nitrous oxide through the soil). Under less saturated (but still relatively high moisture) conditions nitrification occurred. Isotope ratios of O18/N15 and isotope signatures are suggested as indicators of source process. The 2-pool theory of denitrification in which nitrogen added to soils was denitrified more rapidly than existing soil nitrogen was confirmed.
Exploitation Route These assessments were conducted under controlled laboratory conditions, necessary for model development and process understanding. There is a need to validate these findings and assess the suitability of using the model and the isotopemer tools in the estimation of and development of mitigation strategies for nitrous oxide emissions from soils under field conditions.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment