Towards a children's museology: developing child-led practice in museums and cultural institutions

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leicester
Department Name: Museum Studies

Abstract

Over the last decade, children and young people have powerfully demonstrated their ability to shape the ways in which we think about some of the most serious challenges in the present, including climate change and human rights (Charles et. al 2018). This fundamental shift in young people's roles in public debate is accompanied by an emerging body of work that sees young people as more capable and more complex than is often assumed, a 'new sociology of childhood' (Prout 2000; 2011; Kehily 2009; Davis, Prout and Tisdall 2004). However, in museums and heritage sites, engagement with these ideas and the adoption of practices that empower children through active participation is only just beginning (Patterson 2016).

As of yet, this kind of work is often limited to 'child-friendly' topics, underresourced or temporary in nature, and contained within the safe realm of museum education alone. There have been very few more substantive efforts to involve children in making decisions that shape the organisation more fundamentally. New theories and methods are needed to address issues relating to ethics, power and authenticity. The work I will undertake as part of the fellowship advances a critical practice that actively engages children within all aspects of the museum by developing new networks, generating new insights and sharing research.
The monograph will provide the first in depth and rigorous study in this area, drawing on my PhD research which explored the challenges and opportunities of engaging children as experts on themselves. Taking contemporary photographs involving children as an example, the thesis revealed that the most complex images of childhood and adolescence are often seen as challenging topics for display and are commonly the subject of curatorial self-censorship. Where museums do collect, interpret and exhibit portrayals that recognise how aspects of gender, sexuality, ethnicity, and class begin to affect our identity from a very young age, children's own voices have been largely excluded. Drawing on innovative case studies in the UK, US and Europe, the monograph is a collective call for museums to involve children in making decisions about the topics that matter to them and realise their potential as sites at which children can meaningfully shape their rights and representation.

To take this work forward, the fellowship facilitates the development of a longer-term proposal for a collaborative research project on children's museology, bringing together a network of researchers and practitioners that have begun to experiment with strategies involving young people as shared decision-makers, co-creators and project leaders. This network will form the basis of a grant application for a 3-year postdoctoral project. Through action research with campaigning and issue-based museums, the project will demonstrate how these institutions can be sites at which child-led practice is, despite its significant challenges, embedded within everything the museum does. A key outcome will be an ethical framework for children's participation that considers the universal capacities of children, currently underacknowledged in museum practice (Mai and Gibson 2013), and recognises children's particular vulnerabilities.
Both my current and future research are situated within the Research Centre for Museums and Galleries (RCMG) and draw on the centre's legacy of ethically shaped museum research, innovative methods for collaboration and a network of practitioners and researchers. The work of RCMG has profoundly impacted the thinking and practices of the cultural sector; the centre's studies have shown how museums are active in creating the conditions within which human rights are experienced - fought for and claimed, realised and refused - in the everyday (Sandell and Dodd 2010; Marstine et al 2015). By seeing children as a marginalised community, this project will explore new pathways to build on and enrich this body of research.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The main objective of my award was to produce a monologue. During the time of the award, I secured a book contract with Routledge and my first monologue will be published as part of the Research in Museum Studies series this summer (August 2022). I used the fellowship year to reframe and update my doctoral thesis and make this work more accessible for a wider audience.

My second objective was to organise a symposium to bring together researchers interested in child-centred collaborative museum practice. Due to the pandemic, I was unable to do this in the way I had envisioned (in-person, at the University of Leicester). However, I organised an online working group with researchers from the UK, the US and Canada, and these meetings have resulted in a call for papers and a proposal for an edited volume on Children's Museology, edited by myself and Dr Monica Patterson, Carleton University, Canada, submitted to the Routledge Museum Meanings series. This book will be a direct result of ideas and relationships developed during the fellowship and will include contributions from the UK, US, Canada, South America, Asia and Australasia.

Although the conferences initially identified in my proposal were cancelled, I presented a key note speech at the ICOM Hands On! conference, the most important international conference focused on children and museums. This presented a significant opportunity to promote the newly emerging idea of children's museology and spark interest for my two upcoming books.

Lastly, my objective was to secure further funding. I was nominated by my department to develop a proposal for the UKRI Future Leadership Fellowship and developed projects with National Museums Liverpool and Sudbury Hall before my proposal was put forward by the University of Leicester. The proposal attracted positive reviews (scoring 6,6,5,4,3 out of 6) but lost out on competition in the last round. I continue to develop my work on children's museology and child-centred collaborative museum practice in my role as Research Associate at the Research Centre for Museums and Galleries, University of Leicester.
Exploitation Route One of the major outcomes of the award is a network of researchers interested in engaging children in museums not (only) as learners but as contributors with a unique perspective. My monograph provides evidence analysis underpinning this claim and the edited volume which I am now producing with Dr Patterson presents an opportunity for scholars and practitioners across the world to develop these ideas, share new methods and approaches, and inspire further practice.

The usefulness of these ideas is evident in very recent attempts by for example the National Trusts' Sudbury Hall and Eureka! to co-create their social and physical spaces with by and for children.
Sectors Creative Economy,Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description Thinking Through the Museum (Partnership Development Grant) 
Organisation Carleton University
Country Canada 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Although not a named participant on the application, I became part of the Children's Museology research cluster for the Thinking Through the Museum network during my ESRC fellowship. My contributions include expertise in developing new networking ideas, input on the network's ethical charter and my participation in regular knowledge exchange events.
Collaborator Contribution Thinking through the Museum is a SSHRC-funded Partnership Development Grant that brings together researchers, curators, artists, and community members seeking new terms of engagement for learning from histories of violence and conflict in museum space. Monica Patterson, who leads the Children's Museology cluster within Thinking through the Museum, has been a partner in the development of new ideas and is my co-editor on a forthcoming book on Children's Museology. In addition, the partnership has been a key opportunity for me to network and exchange ideas with researchers from the Global South.
Impact Children's Museology (edited volume to be submitted to Museum Meanings, Routledge). Call for Papers: https://carleton.ca/childrensmuseology/call-for-papers-for-an-edited-book/
Start Year 2020
 
Description AAM MSN Conversations 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Co-delivered a session and led a break out group on ethics for the American Association of Museums Museum Studies Network, using the ideas developed through the award to share thinking.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.aam-us.org/2020/12/10/msn-conversation-3-making-the-future-museum-we-want/
 
Description Sudbury Hall Children's Consultation 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Attended and supported professional staff at Sudbury Hall during a consultation day with families and children to inform the redevelopment of Sudbury Hall.
Children were empowered to contribute to the redevelopment plans by testing and commenting on new areas.
May lead to future book chapter and/ or a research collaboration with Sudbury Hall.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021