'These shirts are our curriculum': artifacts, Blackfoot people and the retrieval of cultural knowledge (resubmission)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Pitt Rivers Museum

Abstract

This project brings together UK-based researchers with Blackfoot people in Alberta, Canada, and Montana, USA, to explore the cultural history and contemporary meanings of 5 Blackfoot men's shirts held in the collections of the Pitt Rivers Museum. Collected in 1841, the hide shirts are decorated with porcupine quillwork and beadwork; three, with human- and horse-hair fringes along the sleeves, are ritual garments. There are just two shirts of this age in Canadian museums, and Blackfoot people have had little access to them. However, some cultural knowledge relating to them has been retained, and elders wish to revive traditional practices associated with them. Blackfoot leaders have spoken of the shirts as important for youth and hope that learning about them will strengthen cultural identity: in the words of Frank Weasel Head, Kainai ceremonial leader, 'These shirts are our curriculum. That's how we learn who we are.'

The project will make the shirts available to Blackfoot people and the wider public for the first time, and explore how historic artefacts can be used by indigenous communities to revive, share and transmit cultural knowledge, and how they serve to anchor social memory and in the construction of identity. It will consider how the transmission of cultural knowledge can benefit different generations, and explore the implications of such knowledge for museum practice.

Through the exhibition of these shirts at Glenbow and Galt Museums in Alberta, and through handling workshops for Blackfoot people (including elders, artists, and youth), we hope to show how close examination of the shirts can allow for the retrieval, consolidation, and transmission of cultural knowledge embodied in such artefacts. Elders hope that access to the shirts will be a catalyst for reviving the knowledge of the making and uses of them: 'the Elders left us messages, it's up to us to understand them' (Narcisse Blood, Kainai).The exhibitions, an integral part of the research process, will provide an opportunity for discussions amongst Blackfoot community members, helping to raise fragments of memories which will then surface more readily in workshops. Information surfacing within each workshop, eg. relating to the manufacture/use of the shirts, will be recorded and shared with subsequent workshop participants in order to facilitate the exchange and transmission of knowledge. Workshops will be developed by the project team in collaboration with ceremonial leaders and educators from the four Blackfoot nations. An innovation in international museum access, they will be facilitated by a conservator (PRM staff member Heather Richardson, a specialist on First Nations material) and a Project Facilitator (Beth Carter, a Glenbow curator with extensive experience working with Blackfoot people), and will involve Blackfoot seamstresses, elders, ceremonial leaders, and youth. Curators Peers (Pitt Rivers Museum), Conaty and Carter (Glenbow), Aitkens (Galt Museum) together with Brown (Aberdeen), will observe and assist the workshops.

The project builds on previous AHRB-funded research carried out by Brown and Peers which explored how historic photographs of ancestors were culturally interpreted by Blackfoot people (Brown, Peers et al 2006). Based on relationships developed then and in Brown's D.Phil. research (1997-2000), and on specific community consultations regarding the shirts (2003, 2005, 2006, 2008), this proposal responds to repeated requests by Blackfoot ceremonial leaders, Elders and educators, who wish to study these artefacts to aid in cultural revitalization. The Glenbow and Galt Museums are offering considerable in-kind support including exhibition and workshop space. Outcomes will include an illustrated book with research findings, refereed articles, and a conference to bring together UK museum professionals with Blackfoot people to explore perspectives on such early collections.
 
Title Kaahsinnooniksi Ao?toksisawooyawa: Our ancestors have come to visit / Galt Museum 
Description 5 Blackfoot shirts (items core to the research activity) exhibited with other Blackfoot garments and interpretive material at the Galt Museum and Archives, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada, June-September 2010. During the exhibition period, the museum recorded, 5 Blackfoot shirts (items core to the research activity) exhibited with other Blackfoot garments and interpretive material at the Galt Museum and Archives, Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada, June-September 2010. During the exhibition period, the museum recorded 8874 entries (nearly all of whom would have seen the exhibition) including 231 who attended exhibit opening event; 527 who attended school programs; 808 who attended other community programs 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2010 
Impact Provision of first access to heritage objects for Blackfoot people since 1841; educational activities for schools and adult audiences; cross-cultural dialogues and activities; cross-cultural relationship-building 
 
Title Kaahsinnooniksi Ao?toksisawooyawa: Our ancestors have come to visit Glenbow Museum 
Description Exhibition of 5 Blackfoot shirts (key items core to research activity) and interpretive material at Glenbow Museum, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, April-May 2010. During the 8 weeks the shirts were on display, the museum had a total of 16,799 visitors of whom, Exhibition of 5 Blackfoot shirts (key items core to research activity) and interpretive material at Glenbow Museum, Calgary, Alberta, Canada, April-May 2010. During the 8 weeks the shirts were on display, the museum had a total of 16,799 visitors of whom the majority would have gone through the gallery with the shirts exhibit. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2010 
Impact Provision of access to important heritage objects for first time since 1841 to Blackfoot people; educational outreach activities to varied adult and school audiences 
 
Description The project demonstrated the importance of direct, hands-on access to heritage objects for indigenous peoples, and the value of working collaboratively with indigenous groups to plan access projects.



For Blackfoot First Nations people, direct access to heritage objects which have long been absent from their communities in UK collections was provided through loans to museums within tribal territory, accompanied by out-of-case supervised handling sessions and public exhibition of objects. Handling sessions targeted elders, ceremonialists, teachers, artists, and college and high school students. For conservation reasons, handling sessions were limited to small groups and pre-booked; we were able to accommodate over 500 participants. Exhibitions targeted children and larger numbers of Blackfoot people as well as non-Blackfoot people. Handling sessions, in particular, but also the exhibitions, stimulated memory and the transmission of cultural knowledge across generations and families, leading to the strengthening of cultural identity, support for endangered traditional arts, cultural education for high school students in Blackfoot communities about traditional arts and associated cultural knowledge, and the revival of a traditional ceremony after a long dormancy period due to historic assimilation pressures. The project thus demonstrated that UK museums have crucial roles to play in facilitating the strengthening of cultural knowledge and identity amongst indigenous groups by making historic collections accessible.



Collaborative planning and facilitation of the project with Blackfoot First Nations ceremonial leaders and educators, and integration of their concerns into core research goals and processes, also led to advances in museum knowledge. For museums, these included: the development of new packing/shipping techniques for fragile hide garments to facilitate loans; adding significantly to knowledge of historic collections (cultural information connected to the shirts; contemporary community perspectives about them; the identification of plant fibre woven with porcupine quills); and training for UK museum curators and conservators in cross-cultural issues related to Blackfoot museum collections (via conference).
Exploitation Route Indigenous communities and heritage/social health: Project demonstrated that group handling of historic museum artefacts can contribute to improved self-esteem and strengthened cultural identity; these are related to improved overall health and social cohesion in Indigenous communities.

Museum practice: Project demonstrated that museums which consult with source communities gain considerable knowledge about historic collections; improve professional practices of collections management and conservation; and enable museum staff to gain improved cross-cultural skills essential to museum practice for the care of ethnographic collections. Such collaborative and inclusive projects create better care and more informed displays of ethnographic objects.

Museum and cultural policy: the project demonstrated that museums need to acknowledge a responsibility to source communities to provide direct access to heritage objects in collections: not just photographs or online resources, but through loans, handling projects, and research visits by community members. Community development organisations should also consider increased use of heritage programs, museum visits, and intergenerational learning contexts around heritage objects as a catalyst for enhanced self-esteem, community cohesion, and relationship-building. Strong identities in the present rely on access to knowledge about heritage, and material culture provides tangible focus for learning about history and culture.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://web.prm.ox.ac.uk/blackfootshirts/
 
Description 1. Two of the shirts used in the project had plant fibre woven in with porcupine quills, a now lost technique among Blackfoot people. Dr Stephen Druce, Curator of the Oxford University Herbarium (typhus latifolia, cattail). This knowledge adds to museum understanding of the care and interpretation of historic northern Plains garments, and has been returned to Blackfoot artists who are now experimenting with bulrush as a fibre for decorative plaiting and embroidery. 2. Over 500 Blackfoot people--elders, ceremonial leaders, artists, youth, and teachers--participated in handling sessions with the historic shirts as part of core research activity. Participants shared and affirmed cultural knowledge and history with each other during the sessions, leading to strengthened cultural identity. 3. Research process led to significant advances in museum practice for ethnographic collections, including: the development of new packing/shipping techniques for fragile hide garments to facilitate loans; adding to knowledge of historic collections (cultural information connected to the shirts; contemporary community perspectives about them; the identification of plant fibre woven with porcupine quills); and training for UK museum curators and conservators in cross-cultural issues related to Blackfoot museum collections (via conference). Preparing for the loan and handling sessions integral to the research led to significant advances in museum practice for ethnographic collections, including: the development of new packing/shipping techniques for fragile hide garments to facilitate loans; adding to knowledge of historic collections (cultural information connected to the shirts; contemporary community perspectives about them; the identification of plant fibre woven with porcupine quills); and training for UK museum curators and conservators in cross-cultural issues related to Blackfoot museum collections (via conference held in Oxford in April 2011). 4. Across project research handling sessions with adults (including artists) and high school and college students and the historic shirts, and two related high school projects to teach hide tanning and quillwork in Blackfoot schools, adults and youth were inspired to learn endangered traditional artistic skills of hide tanning and porcupine quillwork. Artistic practices and techniques are related to cultural and spiritual knowledge in Blackfoot culture, so these activities also supported the retention of Blackfoot culture. Across project research handling sessions with adults (including artists) and high school students and the historic shirts, and two related high school projects to teach hide tanning and quillwork in Blackfoot schools, adults and youth were inspired to learn endangered traditional artistic skills of hide tanning and porcupine quillwork. Artistic practices and techniques are related to cultural and spiritual knowledge in Blackfoot culture, so these activities also supported the retention of Blackfoot culture. 5. As the result of working with the project, Blackfoot First Nations ceremonial leaders decided to revive a ceremony associated with hair-lock shirts which had been suppressed by government assimilation strategies. Two ceremonies were held for the first time in many decades. As the result of working with the project, Blackfoot First Nations ceremonial leaders decided to revive a ceremony associated with hairlock shirts which had been suppressed by government assimilation strategies. Two ceremonies were held for the first time in many decades.
First Year Of Impact 2011
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description 'These shirts are our curriculum': enhancing research on educational impacts of Blackfoot shirts project
Amount £7,976 (GBP)
Organisation University of Oxford 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2010 
End 02/2011
 
Description Blackfoot Cultural Protocol Advice to Pitt Rivers Museum
Amount £3,500 (GBP)
Organisation Arts Council England 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2009 
End 12/2009
 
Description Blackfoot Cultural Protocol Advice to Pitt Rivers Museum
Amount £3,500 (GBP)
Organisation Arts Council England 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2009 
End 12/2009
 
Description These shirts are our curriculum': loan/curatorial partnerships to facilitate research activity 
Organisation Galt Museum & Archives
Country Canada 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The Pitt Rivers Museum partnered with Dr Alison Brown at the University of Aberdeen (project community liaison and co-PI); Dr Gerald Conaty at the Glenbow Museum, Calgary, Alberta (Glenbow curator of Indigenous Studies and project advisor), and Mrs Wendy Aitkens of the Galt Museum and Archives in Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada (curator of the Galt version of the exhibition). These partnerships were necessary to provide cross-cultural guidance and institutional facilitation to enable research activities and all project outcomes. The partnership with the University of Aberdeen was essential as project team members from the Pitt Rivers Museum had limited fieldwork experience with Blackfoot people.
Collaborator Contribution Exhibition cases; direct financial contribution to exhibition transportation costs; staff time and resources to mount exhibition and facilitate workshops; space for workshops and exhibition preparation; networking with Blackfoot community; cross-cultural mentoring
Impact Cross-cultural dialogues; new museum practice and professional development; access to material heritage; publications.
Start Year 2009
 
Description These shirts are our curriculum': loan/curatorial partnerships to facilitate research activity 
Organisation Glenbow Museum
Country Canada 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The Pitt Rivers Museum partnered with Dr Alison Brown at the University of Aberdeen (project community liaison and co-PI); Dr Gerald Conaty at the Glenbow Museum, Calgary, Alberta (Glenbow curator of Indigenous Studies and project advisor), and Mrs Wendy Aitkens of the Galt Museum and Archives in Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada (curator of the Galt version of the exhibition). These partnerships were necessary to provide cross-cultural guidance and institutional facilitation to enable research activities and all project outcomes. The partnership with the University of Aberdeen was essential as project team members from the Pitt Rivers Museum had limited fieldwork experience with Blackfoot people.
Collaborator Contribution Exhibition cases; direct financial contribution to exhibition transportation costs; staff time and resources to mount exhibition and facilitate workshops; space for workshops and exhibition preparation; networking with Blackfoot community; cross-cultural mentoring
Impact Cross-cultural dialogues; new museum practice and professional development; access to material heritage; publications.
Start Year 2009
 
Description These shirts are our curriculum': loan/curatorial partnerships to facilitate research activity 
Organisation University of Aberdeen
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The Pitt Rivers Museum partnered with Dr Alison Brown at the University of Aberdeen (project community liaison and co-PI); Dr Gerald Conaty at the Glenbow Museum, Calgary, Alberta (Glenbow curator of Indigenous Studies and project advisor), and Mrs Wendy Aitkens of the Galt Museum and Archives in Lethbridge, Alberta, Canada (curator of the Galt version of the exhibition). These partnerships were necessary to provide cross-cultural guidance and institutional facilitation to enable research activities and all project outcomes. The partnership with the University of Aberdeen was essential as project team members from the Pitt Rivers Museum had limited fieldwork experience with Blackfoot people.
Collaborator Contribution Exhibition cases; direct financial contribution to exhibition transportation costs; staff time and resources to mount exhibition and facilitate workshops; space for workshops and exhibition preparation; networking with Blackfoot community; cross-cultural mentoring
Impact Cross-cultural dialogues; new museum practice and professional development; access to material heritage; publications.
Start Year 2009
 
Description 'Making Museums' educational programmes: schools visits, facilitated by Heather Richardson 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Public educational programme enabling school children and adult public visitors to visit conservation lab 'behind the scenes' while Blackfoot shirts were being conserved prior to project loan/research activity. Participants learned about the shirts, about conservation processes, and about museum processes.

Programs with up to 300 school children showing aspects of how museums work 'behind the scenes'; all children were brought into conservation lab to show how the Blackfoot shirts were being stabilised and cleaned prior to loan for the project. 'Making Muse
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2010
 
Description Lecture given at the Icon Ethnography Group seminar, Pitt Rivers Museum,16th November 2011, by Heather Richardson 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Talk sparked discussion afterwards amongst international, UK and European based conservation professionals.

Increased understanding of how to facilitate handling sessions for indigenous community members for audience of conservation professionals.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description Lecture given to Blackfoot students at Red Crow Community College, Kainai Nation, Alberta, Canada, Nov. 2011, by Alison K. Brown 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact Lecture strengthened student interest in cultural heritage and identity.

Photographs of shirts given to graduates as gifts.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description Lecture/seminar focussing on Blackfoot Shirts Project, University of Aberdeen. April 2011, by Alison K. Brown 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Talk sparked questions and discussion afterwards.

Increased knowledge of new collaborative methodologies.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
 
Description Research seminar/talk given to faculty and postgraduate students at University of Toronto, Canada, by Laura Peers 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Talk generated discussion afterwards and questions from students via email for one year afterwards.

Increased training in community-based museum work.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
 
Description School of Anthropology and Museum Ethnography Departmental Seminar, January 2012, by Laura Peers 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Colleagues and postgraduate students had improved understanding of museum anthropology.

Colleagues and postgraduate students asked for information.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012