The American Indian Poet of the First World War: Modernism and the Indian Identity of Frank 'Toronto' Prewett 1892-1962

Lead Research Organisation: Swansea University
Department Name: College of Arts and Humanities

Abstract

My research on The American Indian Poet of the First World War uses as yet untapped archival resources in Canada, the United States and the United Kingdom to provide access to the premier Native American Indian literary figure of the early twentieth century. It allows us to explore for the first time his friendships with some of the most famous names in British literature since Frank 'Toronto' Prewett, 1893-1962, had an exceptional and in many ways glittering life. Known as an Iroquois Indian from the North-Eastern United States, his experience of war brought him into close association with the British literary elite. His archives, recently acquired by an institution in Ottawa, reveal that he was published by Virginia Woolf, was the lover of Seigfreid Sassoon and that he had close friendships with both Robert Graves and with the doyenne of Bloomsbury, the rich and exceptional 'daughter of a thousand earls' Lady Ottoline Morrell. This research also reveals his friendships with Leonard Woolf, W.B. Yeats, Thomas Hardy, Wilfred Owen, Edmund Blunden, T.E. Lawrence, Aldous Huxley, Mark Gertler, S.S. Koteliansky and Dorothy Brett.

This research not only unearths Prewett's centrality to the literary vanguard of the time, it also more generally explores the relationship of Native American Indian identity to modernist sensibility or sensibilities. It asks how Prewett was able to tap into an antimodern impulse that, strange as it may seem, ultimately acted in unison with the concerns of the modern, dominant, bureaucratic corporate state. The American Indian Poet of the First World War presented himself as an antidote to the spiritual homelessness and 'unreality' of the times and as such offered the kind of psychological self-sufficiency the élite associated with aboriginals. It was a brand of psychological calm which in the aftermath of a crushingly brutal war, they found they profoundly needed access to themselves.

The project takes archival research gleaned from ten sites and uses it to attempt to re-focus modern Native literary scholarship and to explore fresh perspectives on how writers such as Philip Deloria, Marianna Torgovnick, Charles Taylor and Daniel Howe contextualised both the American self and Indian identity. It also brings primitivism to the centre of a number of disciplinary debates on war and modernism. Prewett is compared with the period's other famous inauthentic or 'white Indian' veterans and his harrowing experiences within the Royal Artillery and Royal Welsh Fusiliers contrasted with actual Indian war experiences presented by historians such as Russel Barsh and Tom Holm. Prewett's 'Indian' war correspondence is further contrasted with how historians on both sides of the Atlantic (Strachan, Keegan, Ferguson, Tuchman, Fischer and Bond) contextualized the First World War with particular emphasis given to Paul Fussell's The Great War and Modern Memory in contrast with Jonathan F. Vance's Death So Noble.

Along with so many of his generation, Prewett suffered from depression or neuresthenia and this project questions whether this can be seen as part of the psychic crisis or 'therapeutic world view' that came to characterise the times. Investigation of archives held at Oxford and Cambridge archives in this regard allow us to explore the relationship between Prewett and the eminent anthropologist and institutional founder of the psychological discipline Dr W. H. R. Rivers. Rivers profoundly influenced the relationships to war of Sassoon, Owen and Graves and thsi research suggests that his engagement with Prewett marked a turning point for modernism within psychology.

Overall, this research seeks to make a series of conceptual arguments about Native American identity on both sides of the Atlantic during the First World war and its aftermath by bringing a wholly new set of archival sources into scholarly view.

Planned Impact

It is intended that this research will have multiple impact across the three countries concerned, within the museum context, within specific Native American Indian communities and across and within a number of academic disciplines as discussed in the previous section. Perhaps the primary immediate impact will be upon the Frank Prewett Correspondence held by The Literary Archives at Ottawa. They will be delighted to see their new archival resource showcased within a volume published by a premier North American press. Not only will the resource gain essential exposure, it will do so within a monograph that speaks to themes, issues and complexities that transcend the specific history of the personality whose papers have been so carefully sourced, catalogued and archived. The link forged between UK scholarship and Canadian institutions concerned with First Nations history such as this is likely in itself to have specific value and to act as a springboard for further international research.

It is intended that this research will also greatly benefit New York State's premier Native American Indian owned museum, the Six Nations Indian Museum at Onchiota, New York. Run by the Iroquois artist and scholar John Fadden, the Museum is keen to organise an exhibit about Prewett to coincide with this research bringing his story to a wider audience through publication of the proposed monograph. I have a long-standing and positive relationship both with the Museum and its Director, having donated to the Museum a set of Indian archives once donated to me by Indian families so that I might write a previous book, To Be Indian, published in 2001 by The University of Oklahoma Press. Other Indian Museums in the Northeastern United States have also expressed an interest in mounting exhibits based upon this research including The Iroquois Indian Museum at Howe's Cave, New York and the Rochester Museum and Science Centre, Rochester New York. This last museum was run in the early decades of the twentieth century by another famous Seneca- Iroquois intellectual Arthur C. Parker. Another museum which has expressed interest in the potential of including this research within a wider exhibit on twentieth century Indian leaders is the National Museum of the American Indian in Washington. D.C.

Aside from its appeal to American museums, particularly those in the Northeastern United States, this research will be of significance to Iroquois Indian communities within the region. In particular, to communities connected with Prewett and his family at Tonawanda, New York and Tuscarora, New York. Amongst Native communities surviving in spite of some of the highest poverty levels in the nation, the work of reclaiming important Indian figures from the past has an immediate and powerful significance. The Indian contribution war, especially the First World War remains an under-researched area and the dissemination of research on Prewett will go some way towards rectifying this.

The University of Toronto Press have advised me that the proposed monograph is likely to sell well and to find a receptive audience within North American libraries generally. I also intend to write a journal article on an analogous theme using this research and to speak on this research within all the usual academic contexts as well as within a number of public forii, including local history groups, fraternal organisations and school and college history and literary groups. This research will also be disseminated within a series of academic networks including the Native Studies Network run out of the University of East Anglia and the British Association of Canadian Studies Aboriginal Studies Circle.
 
Title "A New WW1 Poet: Frank Prewett", Western Front Association podcast 
Description 2021 Mentioned in Dispatches, Western Front Association, "A New WW1 Poet:Frank Prewett" 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Broadened network links and disseminated book of project. 
URL https://play.acast.com/s/mentionedindispatches
 
Title "That Talented Canadian, Mr Frank Prewett: Trauma & Indigenous Masquerade in the Wake of the First World War" 
Description "That Talented Canadian, Mr Frank Prewett: Trauma & Indigenous Masquerade in the Wake of the First World War", Laurier Centre for Military Strategic & Disarmament Studies, Canada, Sept 21. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact New networked connections between with Laurier Centre for Military and Strategic & Disarmament Studies, Canada 
URL https://canadianmilitaryhistory.ca/events-page/speaker-series/past-speakers/
 
Title 3 New artworks by Mary Hebert inspired by the book of the project "Trauma, Primitivism and the First World War" 
Description 3 new fine art paintings inspired by the book of the project, 2 sold by: Mary Herbert Bio/ cv / contact Selected works Installation views Instagram Contact maryanneherb@gmail.com enquiries: Moskowitz Bayse info@moskowitzbayse.com b.1988, Lives and works in London Mary's work is an intuitive exploration of memory and sensation. Working at the intersection of drawing and painting, she creates subtle and enigmatic works which oscillate between the recognised and the unknown. Her current work is a series of dream-like pastel drawings and paintings formed of a composite of feelings, lived-sensation, unconscious processes and observation. Mary studied art at Goldsmiths College in London, where she developed a fascination with the materiality of the photographic image and it's unreliability as a container of memory, and later at the Royal Drawing School where she re-connected with the physical and unconscious aspects of image making through drawing. Editorial Elephant Magazine, "Drawing Conclusions; Artists Tell Us Why They Draw", October 2021 Brenda Magazine, Issue 7, May 2021, interviewed artist Art Maze Mag, Autumn Edition 19, 2020, 'Mary Herbert's Pastel Hazed Topology of the Unconscious Mind', Rebecca Irvin It's Nice That 'Illusion, experience and dream: the soft pastel drawings of Mary Herbert', Nov 2020, Harry Bennett Elephant Magazine, May 2020, 'Gaze into the Unconscious Mind with Mary Herbert's Fantastical Drawings', Rosalind Duguid Interview with Eve Leibe Gallery for the exhibition Somewhere Else for a Little While, July 2020 The Fourdrinier, January Edition, 2020 'Mary Herbert: From Mesopotamia to the Cairngorm Mountains', Sara Jaspan Selected Exhibitions 2022 - Upcoming/Current Drawing attention: emerging British artists, The British Museum, London 2022 - Past Anonymous Was A Woman, Clint Roenisch, Toronto Here Come The Suns, Bark Berlin Gallery, Berlin 2021 Like Glaciers, Moskowitz Bayse, LA (solo) Unfair Weather, Lychee One, London Les Danses Nocturnes, curated by East Contemporary, Entrevaux, France A Tiger In A Tropical Storm, Louise Alexander Gallery, Porto Cervo, Sardinia Nine Lives, Fortnight Institute, New York Bloodroot, Arusha Gallery, Edinburgh (duo with James Owens) To See Through It, Lychee One, London (solo) The Lonely Ones, Curated by Katelyn Eichwald, Fortnight Institute, New York (Online) 2020 Winter Solstice, Fortnight Institute, New York - online Lychee One, London, solo online presentation Unmasked, Daniel Raphael, London - online Union Gallery London, solo online presentation Dance First Think Later, General Practice, Lincoln Somewhere Else for a Little While, Eve Leibe Gallery London - online Hot Paper x Charlie Roberts, GIFC - online 2019 Bloomberg New Contemporaries, Leeds Art Gallery/South London Gallery A High Hang, Eccleston Project Space, London Trinity Buoy Wharf Drawing Prize, London 2018 The Ingram Collection Young Contemporary Talent Purchase Prize, The Cello Factory, London The Best of the Drawing Year 2018, Christie's, London Awards and Residencies 2019 The Royal Drawing School Dumfries House Residency, Scotland 2019 Trinity Buoy Wharf Drawing Prize - finalist 2019 Sunday Times Watercolour Competition - finalist 2019 Lynn Painter Stainers Prize - finalist 2018 The Ingram Collection Young Contemporary Talent Purchase Prize 2018 - finalist Education 2018 Postgraduate Diploma in Drawing, The Royal Drawing School, London 2010 BA (Hons) Fine Art and Contemporary Critical Studies, Goldsmiths University of London 2007 Foundation Diploma (Distinction), Byam Shaw School of Art, London Collections The British Museum The Royal Collection 
Type Of Art Artwork 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Not known 
URL https://www.signalhouseedition.org/product-page/card-game-mary-herbert
 
Title A series of poems by the subject of the project were performed by professional actor Luke Mullins and professionally recorded for permanent display on The Signal House Edition website. 
Description The poems of Frank Prewett are read by LUKE MULLINS, music is composed by STANDAMID, and the recording is edited by EOIN DUGGAN. (Image credits: (top) Frank Prewett by Dorothy Brett. 1923 (left) Frank James Prewett by Lady Ottoline Morrell, © National Portrait Gallery, London, (right) Colin de la Mare, Siegfried Sassoon; Frank James Prewett by Lady Ottoline Morrell, © National Portrait Gallery, London.) 
Type Of Art Performance (Music, Dance, Drama, etc) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact The actor's rendering of the poems were performed at the British Library in a subsequent book launch event, of which a permanent recording was made. 
URL https://www.signalhouseedition.org/issue-12-interview
 
Title British Library Eccles Centre Book Launch: Trauma, Primitivism & the First World War (May 2021) 
Description British Library Eccles Centre Book Launch: Trauma, Primitivism & the First World War (May 2021) 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Book of funded project formally launched and disseminated to British Library audience worldwide. 
URL https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCVnaA5DPUYMmn1OuBVmTbwA
 
Title Fulbright Snapshot, "Trauma, Primitivism and the First World War by Joy Porter", Mar 19, 2021. 
Description Fulbright Snapshot, "Trauma, Primitivism and the First World War by Joy Porter", Mar 19, 2021. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Dissemination and showcase of the book of the project, led to further exposure and invitations to speak and extended PI's work as Fulbright US-UK Ambassador. 
URL https://fulbrighternetwork.com/news/393117
 
Title New Books in Military History Podcast Joy Porter, "Trauma, Primitivism and the First World War: The Making of Frank Prewett" (Bloomsbury, 2021) 
Description New Books Network podcast dissemination of book of the project 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Broad international dissemination of the book of the project published by Bloomsbury. 
URL https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5tZWdhcGhvbmUuZm0vTElUNTg2ODUzOTE4Nw/episode/NTUy...
 
Title Podcast interview with the PI and author of the project output "Trauma, Primivitism and the First World War" (Bloomsbury, 2021) by the Signal House Edition Art Magazine 
Description An interview with Joy Porter The Signal House Edition Download Single Track paused The Making of Frank Prewett 35:08 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Dissemination of the project output , new artwork was then inspired by the project book and actor readings of the project subject's poems were performed. 
URL https://www.signalhouseedition.org/issue-12-interview
 
Title The Many Lives of Frank Prewett", Witness to Yesterday, The Champlain Society Podcast on Canadian History, 17 Sept. 2021. 
Description The Many Lives of Frank Prewett", Witness to Yesterday, The Champlain Society Podcast on Canadian History, 17 Sept. 2021. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Broadening of research links with University of Toronto funded Institute and dissemination of book of project. 
URL https://podcasts.google.com/feed/aHR0cHM6Ly9mZWVkcy5zb3VuZGNsb3VkLmNvbS91c2Vycy9zb3VuZGNsb3VkOnVzZXJ...
 
Description I have unveiled to the reading public and scholarly audience the archival history of the poet of the first world war who was the subject of my grant award. I have added a new dimension to the scholarship and understanding of the Bloomsbury context, of Canadian poetry, of the history of neureasthenia and trauma in the first world war era and provided a new reading of the growth of modernity in the early decades of the twentieth century.
Exploitation Route I very much hope that the indigenous museums which have made use of my research in the United States and Canada continue to foster scholarship on Frank Prewett and that my book The Indian Poet of the First World War has a considerable impact.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www2.hull.ac.uk/fass/department-of-history/our-staff/joy-porter.aspx
 
Description My findings have been used to create the monograph Trauma, Primitivism and the First World War: The Making of Frank Prewett, published with Bloomsbury 6 May, 2021 (https://www.bloomsbury.com/uk/trauma-primitivism-and-the-first-world-war-9781350199729/). The project had expanded significantly from the original grant specification to include new archival resources at National Records Scotland and from individuals who have written to me with information on the subject. I have delivered research papers on my findings at a number of venues across the UK, United States, Europe and Canada and disseminated my findings through research networks such as the British Association for American Studies and the Native Studies Network. The Northeastern US museums with which I have research links have also made use of my research, in particular the Six Nations Indian Museum at Onchiota, New York. In Dec 2021 The Literary Review of Canada carried a review piece on the book entitled "Living a Fiction Who Was frank Prewett?" by Shazia Hafix Ramji which can be accessed here: https://reviewcanada.ca/magazine/2021/12/living-a-fiction/ The review praised the book's approach: "Porter's positioning is not simply a matter of phrasing or word choice. It is situated in a scholarship that emphasizes knowledge as historically conditioned - tied to the cultural, social, and economic moment that surrounds a work's inception. And while a term like "transculturative figure," rather than "pretendian" or "appropriation," could certainly strike a dissonant chord if not read care­fully, Porter's historicist approach is a generous method that both avoids anachronistic interpretations and eschews descriptive liberties." It ends: "Trauma, Primitivism and the First World War is an engrossing read, particularly if one has experienced racial passing or has family members who can pass for other races. It offers a rare insight into the long reach of trauma and presents the story of a complicated figure through a lens that pairs decidedly contemporary anecdotes with detailed evidence. In doing so, it neither redeems nor attacks Frank Prewett. Instead, it conveys the insurmountable nuances of recovering from a near-death experience, an ordeal from which a Canadian poet ultimately surfaced." I have carried out 7 book podcasts to date, and the book has inspired 3 new paintings, and was excerpted in the War Poetry Review, 2020, the journal of the War Poets Association.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Communities and Social Services/Policy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Fulbright All-Disciplines Scholar Award
Amount £20,000 (GBP)
Organisation US-UK Fulbright Commission 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 08/2015 
End 01/2016
 
Description Museum Exhibition 
Organisation Six Nations Indian Museum
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution My research was the basis for a museum exhibit which doubled footfall 2013.
Collaborator Contribution The museum displayed the exhibit and acted as an information for further research gathering from local communities.
Impact All Museum literature produced 2013
Start Year 2013
 
Description PI Porter Book Launch for Trauma, Primitivism & the First World War with British Library Eccles Centre 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact JOY
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=DF9Qid2_WRc
 
Description PI Porter Podcast for Laurier Centre for the Study of Canada Studies 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact On War & Society E42: A Curious Case of Shell Shock with Joy Porter
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://studyofcanada.ca/on-war-society-podcast-a-curious-case-of-shell-shock-with-joy-porter/
 
Description PI Porter Presented at Laurier Centre for Military Strategic & Disarmament Studies on That Talented Canadian, Mr Frank Prewett: Trauma & Indigenous Masquerade in the Wake of the First World War 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact JOY
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021