System-mechanics of the kinetochore: operating principles of a complex mechanochemical engine

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: Warwick Medical School

Abstract

Human beings are built from 50 trillion individual cells. Each cell contains 46 chromosomes - the packages of genetic material (DNA), which provide the instructions for how a cell should work and how a whole organism should be built. This huge number of cells originates from a single cell, the zygote, which is the result of fertilization of an egg with a sperm. This single cell needs to be able to divide itself to generate two new daughter cells, which then also divide to produce further cells; this process repeats until the correct number of cells are generated. Moreover, cells do not live forever and are therefore constantly being replaced by new ones. Thus, cell division is fundamental to the existence of life. A key part of cell division involves the accurate separation of the chromosomes into the two daughter cells - a process called mitosis. It is crucial that each daughter cell receives a complete set of chromosomes. We know that having the wrong number of chromosomes is a cause of multiple human diseases: (1) greater than 80% of human solid tumors have the wrong number of chromosomes and changing chromosome number is known to cause cancer in mice. (2) Many developmental disorders are the result of mistakes in chromosome separation - a well-known example is Downs Syndrome in which cells have an extra copy of chromosome 21. (3) A large proportion of miscarriages are caused by problems in chromosome separation. Clearly, it is vital that we work out how chromosome separation works. To move a chromosome the cell makes use of molecular cables called microtubules that can grow and shrink. Each chromosome has a 'hook' called the kinetochore, which can attach to the end of a microtubule cable. As the cable grows and shrinks the chromosome can be pushed and pulled. This is a beautiful system whereby the cell can move chromosomes around inside itself. However, unlike a hook, the kinetochore is able to control how and when a microtubule cable grows and shrinks. This way the kinetochore is the 'control centre' and the 'engine room' that decides when and where a chromosome moves. Kinetochores move all the 46 chromosomes into a line at the centre of the cell. This is called metaphase. At this time the chromosomes move back-and-forth like the pendulum on a clock, and then, the chromosomes are pulled into the daughter cells. But, how does the kinetochore do this? Why and how do the chromosomes change direction? The experiments that we propose to carry out will help answer these exciting and intriguing question and therefore advance our understanding of how chromosomes are separated into daughter cells during cell division. To do this we will use state-of-the-art imaging technology (microscopes) to observe how chromosomes move in living human cells. We can then accurately measure what happens to how the chromosomes move when we remove parts of the machinery from the cell. Because this is such a complex biological problem we will use mathematics to build a model of how the system works. By combining the disciplines of biology and mathematics together we expect to make large advances in our understanding of chromosome separation.

Technical Summary

Kinetochores are adaptive, multi-layered mechanochemical machines that assemble at the centromere of each sister chromatid and engage on their outer face with the plus ends of k-fibres, microtubule bundles that emanate from the spindle poles. We envision the kinetochore as a set of interacting springs, clutches and motors and the problem of kinetochore mechanism as one of understanding how these functional modules assemble, disassemble and interact with one another to give rise the emergent properties of the kinetochore. Incisive experiments made over 17 years ago revealed that once sister kinetochores become attached to microtubules emanating from opposite poles (biorientation), they undergo a series of oscillations - termed chromosome directional instability - prior to anaphase onset. However, neither the mechanisms nor purpose of kinetochore directional switching in human cells is well understood. We propose a parallel approach employing mathematical modeling in tandem with higher-resolution tracking experiments of both native kinetochores and kinetochores specifically depleted of specific protein components. Oscillation is a high-level emergent property, providing a read-out of functional competence and a stringent quantitative test for the accuracy of our model. Iteratively refining the model in the light of our real-world data on oscillations will enumerate and deconvolve the contributions of mechanical components of the kinetochore to its emergent behaviour. We also expect to provide the first insight into the function of chromosome oscillations in animal cells.

Planned Impact

Economic and societal beneficiaries and impacts The general public: It is well understood that multiple human diseases are a consequence of errors in chromosome segregation. For example, mis-segregation of chromosomes during the cell divisions that generate gametes (meiosis) are responsible for a wide range of syndromes such as Down's and Turner's and are also associated with >70% of miscarriages and stillbirths. These risks worsen as women age and our work has the potential to improve our understanding of how the success of chromosome segregation diminishes with time. Mis-segregation events during mitotic cell divisions are associated with the development of cancer. Moreover, changes in chromosome number are involved with cells becoming resistant to existing chematheraputic drugs. We need to know how the process of chromosome segregation works before we can unlock new therapeutic routes to deal with these major diseases and healthcare issues. Such advances will be of direct benefit to the general population both in terms of health, well-being, and indirectly on the socio-economic state of the United Kingdom. Translational medicine: Translational medicine has established itself as discipline in which research inputs from basic and social sciences are converted into patient benefits. Given the importance of chromosome segregation in multiple human diseases, including cancer and developmental disorders our basic-scientific work will generate new knowledge that could be utilized by translational medicine. Drugs that affect kinetochore motion are in clinical trials as candidate cancer treatments. Pharmaceutical and Biotechnology industries: Pharmaceutical and Biotechnology industries are a vital part of the UK economy employing around 250,000 people and generating billions of pounds of income each year. However, this process of drug discovery relies heavily on a strong basic-science base to provide insights into potential drug targets as well as the development of new cell-based assays and technologies. Our work into the processes of chromosome segregation will contribute to the knowledge-base. In addition, we are developing state-of-the art live-cell imaging assays and computational methods, which we predict will become an important part of the drug-development and testing process. Science outreach: Science outreach is vital so that the general population is aware of scientific advances and understands how they fit into the pipeline that takes discoveries in basic science and converts them in to new therapies and health improvements.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Armond JW (2016) KiT: a MATLAB package for kinetochore tracking. in Bioinformatics (Oxford, England)

publication icon
Auckland P (2015) Building an integrated model of chromosome congression. in Journal of cell science

publication icon
Drechsler H (2016) Kinesin-12 motors cooperate to suppress microtubule catastrophes and drive the formation of parallel microtubule bundles. in Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America

publication icon
Drechsler H (2012) Exotic mitotic mechanisms. in Open biology

publication icon
Earnshaw WC (2013) Esperanto for histones: CENP-A, not CenH3, is the centromeric histone H3 variant. in Chromosome research : an international journal on the molecular, supramolecular and evolutionary aspects of chromosome biology

 
Description We have discovered new mechanisms involved in the control of chromosome segregation in human cells (see four key findings below). This work has involved the development of new 3D high resolution microscope-based assays and computational software tools, which are now publicly available (Armond et al, Bioimformatics, 2015).

1. New model of kinetochore switching (Burroughs et al, eLife, 2015): Here we implemented sub-pixel kinetochore tracking using mixture model fitting in order to track kinetochores with high precision during directional switches (these events are key to moving and maintaining chromosomes at the spindle equator during mitosis). Our findings questioned the long-standing "tension model" by showing how a threshold tension (in the chromatin linkage between sister kinetochores) does not explain how kinetochore initiate directional switches. Instead, our data show how tension is required to sustain microtubule polymerisation on the training sister preventing it from switching. The lead sister then switches by a mechanical clock" mechanism as its microtubules switch from depolymerisation to polymerisation. Overall, this "tension clock" model can explain how kinetochores communicate with each other to regulate their position in the spindle.

2. Estimated the forces acting on kinetochores in vivo (Armond et al, PLOS Comp. Biol., 2015): A major goal in the mitosis field is to determine the forces being exerted at kinetochores and then identify force generating mechanisms and molecules. Here we fitted a mechanical model (incorporating the 3 basic forces: kinetochore-microtubule connections, centromeric spring and polar ejection forces) to live cell imaging data (see 1 above). This powerful algorithm allows trajectories to be characterised by their mechanical properties, thus allowing future mapping of perturbations to mechanical effects.

3. K-fibres are incoherent (Armond et al, J. Cell Science, 2015): While we are able to track kinetochore dynamics we have little information on the dynamic properties of the attached microtubules. We therefore incorporated EB3-GFP - which marks polymerising microtubule tips - with our kinetochore tracking assay. We determined that EB3 localises to both the trailing (polymerising) and leading (depolymerising) kinetochores, with a small bias to the former. This contradicts the previously claimed polymerisation coherence of K-fibres, but supports a previous electron microscopy analysis. We also identified burst events where the K-fibre achieves near full polymerisation coherence for 2-4s, events that were predominantly localised to the AP kinetochore. Our data substantially alters the picture of K-fibre attachment and kinetochore control.

4. Swivel (Smith et al, eLife, 2016): We have discovered that that the outer microtubule-binding domain of the kinetochore (Ndc80 complexes) are capable of rotating around the inner kinetochore/centromere (featured in the ASCB cell news - http://www.ascb.org/ascb-post/cell-news-kinetochore-can-swivel-assemble-mitotic-apparatus/). This demonstrates that the kinetochore can function as a "swivel joint" that facilitates attachment to the mitotic spindle. We also started mapping the nano-scale position of multiple components of the kinetochore and determined that loss of microtubule binding induces a ~10nm conformation rearrangement of the Ndc80 complex. The next challenge is to understand how these mechanical events are coupled to mitotic checkpoints and error-correction processes.
Exploitation Route We envisage our kinetochore tracking software being if important use to the cell biology community and anticipate releasing new versions with additional features. We also see our discoveries concerning kinetochore function being important for further research advances in the mitosis field.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Healthcare

 
Description Kinetochore life-histories: understanding the mechanical events that ensure error- free chromosome segregation
Amount £1,105,331 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/R009503/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2018 
End 05/2022
 
Description Senior Investigator Award
Amount £1,180,100 (GBP)
Funding ID 106151/Z/14/Z 
Organisation Wellcome Trust 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2015 
End 06/2020
 
Title Kinetochore Tracking (KiT) 
Description KiT is a MATLAB program for tracking kinetochores in 2D or 3D, and in multiple channels forthcoming publication: Armond J.W., Vladimirou E., McAinsh A.D. and Burroughs, N.J. KiT: A MATLAB package for kinetochore tracking. Bioinformatics in press. Now published: doi: 10.1093/bioinformatics/btw087. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2015 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact Software is key to our recent advances in understanding how kinetochore function, see: 1. Armond J.W., Harry, E.F., and McAinsh, A.D. and Burroughs, N.J. (2015) Inferring the forces controlling metaphase kinetochore oscillations by reverse engineering system dynamics. PLOS Computational Biology 11:e1004607. PMCID: PMC4664287 2. Burroughs, N.J., Harry, E.F. and McAinsh, A.D. (2015) Super-resolution kinetochore tracking reveals the mechanisms of human sister kinetochore directional switching. eLife 2015;10.7554/eLife.09500. 
URL http://www.mechanochemistry.org/mcainsh/software.php.