High performance X-ray detectors with sub-100eV energy resolution

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Electronic and Electrical Engineering

Abstract

Soft X-ray detection is used in a wide range of applications ranging from material research, medical imaging, to industrial manufacturing inspection. This proposal aims to develop a new class of detectors for soft X-ray (<20keV) with potential to achieve better energy resolution and sensitivity than existing cooled Ge and Si detectors. These new X-ray detectors wil be made using InAs, a III-V semiconductor material which has a rare combination of properties for X-ray detection superior to Si, including high X-ray absorption coefficients, high number of carriers generated per absorbed photon, and ability to produce high gain without introducing excess noise (recently discovered at Sheffield).These InAs X-ray avalanche photodiodes (APDs) will be cooled to reduce unwanted leakage current. Our InAs APDs have the potential to achieve the fundamental Fano factor limited energy resolution rather than avalanche gain limited, thus improving on the best data from Si X-ray APDs. This could be the enabling technology to harvest the benefit of high internal gain without incurring significant energy resolution degradation, which has long been the main drawback of X-ray APDs. Its attenuation length, the distance by which the 63% of the X-ray is absorbed, is more than 6 times shorter than that of Si at 5.9keV photon energy, with increasing advantage at higher energies. This enables much shallower InAs pixel to be fabricated and could lead to a new generation of large format arrays that are compatible with digital X-ray imaging. Thus the ultimate aim of this proposal is to demonstrate shallow (<30micron) single-pixel InAs APDs with high gain and excellent energy resolution for soft X-ray detection. This new capability could underpin the next generation X-ray detection for applications such as non-destructive imaging (failure analysis and inspection in material research, electronic component/circuit board inspections and mechanical parts/assemblies), medical imaging (large area imaging of patients, angiography to selectively show blood vessels in the body), real-time imaging (to assist surgeries), and security screening of concealed objects through imaging.Developing InAs X-ray APDs is now finally feasible, owing to exciting developments in wafer growth and device fabrication at Sheffield in the recent years for InAs infrared APDs. Although there are significant different challenges in the development of InAs X-ray APDs, progress in both projects will be accelerated by the synergy. The investigator, who has years of experience with APDs and is currently developing AlGaAs X-ray detectors for room temperature operation, is well-placed to carry out the work. In addition to demonstration of high performance InAs X-ray APDs, this project aims to develop a device simulator of X-ray APDs which will be available to other X-ray detector researchers. This simulator has the unique ability to predict energy resolution limit, taking into account the statistical contribution of the avalanche gain process. In addition to the X-ray APD simulator, the proposed work will establish wafer growth conditions and device fabrication procedures appropriate for InAs X-ray APDs and eventually demonstrate devices with high gain and excellent energy resolution.

Planned Impact

The InAs X-ray APD has the potential to supersede current commercial solid state X-ray detectors with superlative energy resolution and sensitivity so can have transformative effects on a number of X-ray applications, some of which are described below. Novel scanners at border and security checkpoints: Security screening systems based on metal detectors and chemical sniffers are the common techniques employed for detection of weapons and explosives respectively. However there is a wide range of plastic and ceramic weapons developed using modern technology that is transparent to these systems. X-ray scanners are now being used for these applications for more comprehensive screening. The use of low dosage X-rays is essential to protect the personnel and travellers, resulting in a trade-off between achieving high image resolution, speed and low radiation exposure. InAs X-ray APDs could lead to new, sensitive and high resolution scanners requiring very low radiation levels. Single photon counting camera: Single-photon counting hybrid pixel detectors utilising Si-based readout electronics and compound semiconductors such as GaAs and CdTe has attracted much attention recently. The excellent avalanche gain behaviour in InAs can provide extremely high gain without incurring significant excess noise so can provide orders of magnitude improvement in the photon detection efficiency. Such InAs based photon counting cameras are attractive for space applications (see letter of support from David Lumb, ESA Scientist) since InAs APDs have several advantages including; i) low operation voltage of <30V (Si APDs typically operating at >100V, requiring high voltage supplies), ii) potential large, dense arrays, iii) faster speed (shorter depletion region than Si and the avalanche process is fast since only electrons can impact ionise), iv) better X-ray stopping power, v) high X-ray energy resolution, and vi) better radiation tolerance. X-ray fluorescence: Emission of X-ray spectrum has been widely used for elemental and chemical analysis for characterisation of materials such as metal, glass, and ceramics, as well as for research in geochemistry, forensic science and archaeology. High energy resolution detectors are essential to resolve the X-ray signature(s) of the material being studied. InAs APDs with sub-100eV resolution can improve the resolution of current energy and wavelength dispersive spectrometers. The analysis of forensic samples is often carried out using a combination of techniques, including X-ray and infrared microscopy, to extract as much information as possible. Therefore InAs has the potential to not only provide very high resolution but also provide added detection in the infrared spectrum up to 3 micron leading a new class of microscope. UK companies such as Centronic Ltd, Photek, e2v Scientific Instruments, Rapiscan Systems and Kromek that are likely to benefit from our novel InAs APD development and provide possible a exploitation route. This promising Sheffield invention, when fully developed, can have significant economic impact and propel the UK as the leader in high energy resolution X-ray detectors. The PI is also collaborating with Centronic Ltd in a STFC-funded X-ray project. The PI is currently collaborating with Dr John Lees and Centronic Ltd in a STFC-funded X-ray project so progress made in the proposed work will be communicated to Centronic Ltd in the STFC project meetings. The PI will make contact with the UK-based companies after some progress in InAs X-ray detectors has been made, seeking to communicate progress through presentations during visits. For companies which the PI has already had contacts with, dissemination of progress reports will increase their awareness of the development of InAs X-ray detectors.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Barnett A (2015) Characterization of room temperature AlGaAs soft X-ray mesa photodiodes in Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment

publication icon
Chee Hing Tan (2011) Avalanche Gain and Energy Resolution of Semiconductor X-ray Detectors in IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices

publication icon
Gomes R (2012) Effects of Dead Space on Avalanche Gain Distribution of X-Ray Avalanche Photodiodes in IEEE Transactions on Electron Devices

publication icon
Gomes R (2011) InAs avalanche photodiodes for X-ray detection in Journal of Instrumentation

publication icon
Lioliou G (2016) Characterization of gallium arsenide X-ray mesa p-i-n photodiodes at room temperature in Nuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment

publication icon
Meng X (2015) InAs avalanche photodiodes as X-ray detectors in Journal of Instrumentation

 
Description We demonstrated good X-ray detection using InAs Avalanche Photodiodes (APDs), when prior literature only consisted of reports of poor X-ray detection performance from InAs diodes.
Our results showed that the X-ray detection performance in terms of energy resolution improved with the APDs' gain. As the APD's gain increases to 10, the detected peak narrows significantly, with a full-width-half-maximum value of 401 eV at 5.9 keV energy. The reason for the large improvement is that the internal amplification provided by the InAs APDs boosted the signal, moving it away from noise.
However, the performance of an APD is not solely determined by its gain. Our work also covered minimising the leakage current of the APD, which can degrade the APD's performance as an X-ray detector. The minimisation of leakage current required us to modify processes we used to produce the APDs and the packaging process that facilitate the actual measurements.
As part of our effort in device design, we developed an X-ray APD simulator that is free for anyone to download and use. It is available on https://www.sheffield.ac.uk/eee/research/smd/research/apd_simulator

The project also supported demonstration of another X-ray APD made using other materials, GaAs and AlGaAs. Again, the internal gain provided by the APD improved the energy resolution considerably.
We did not meet our original objective of achieving sub-100 eV energy resolution. This was largely caused by the experimental setup having fairly high system limit of around 1 keV (the project did not have resources to re-design the circuit).
Exploitation Route Further work is required to improve the sample production of the InAs X-ray APD to demonstrate its capability as an array detector, which is essential for target applications in defence, healthcare, and Manufacturing.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Healthcare,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description EU Initial Training Network PROMIS (number: 641899) 
Organisation Lancaster University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We develop X-ray avalanche photodiodes, using experience and skills accumulated during this award.
Collaborator Contribution Partner listed is the coordinator of the consortium.
Impact Two journal publications so far.
Start Year 2015