Virtual Testing of Additively-Manufactured Hybrid Metal-Composite Structures

Lead Research Organisation: University of Bristol
Department Name: Aerospace Engineering

Abstract

Additive Layer Manufacturing (ALM) has the potential to revolutionise the design and manufacture of hybrid joints by enabling tailored metal-composite interfaces that promote the optimal load transfer between metal and fibres. This will enable high-performance / high-endurance hybrid structures which can be manufactured via 'co-curing' processes, i.e. consolidation in a single step without the need for secondary adhesive bonding. However, in order to achieve optimal designs a high-fidelity modelling strategy is necessary.

This project will develop and validate modelling strategies to:
1. Predict the detailed meso-scale structure of hybrid metal-composite materials after manufacture and consolidation, including local fibre orientation with respect to metallic surface protrusions. These methodologies will be validated against micro-CT scans of real specimens.
2. Resolve stresses at the level of individual tows/yarns and protrusions, accounting for thermal residual stresses and stresses due to externally applied loads. These data will provide an initial measure of the quality results can be used in the development of load path-based optimisation at the micro- or meso-scale levels
3. Analyse joint strength and damage/fracture propagation properties due to combinations of quasi-static, impact and cyclic loading. Validate the methodologies against mechanical tests on real specimens.


In a broader sense, this research introduces two new concepts for the design of hybrid metal-composite structures, namely:
1. Performance-driven design, with performance being evaluated at the level of individual material constituents (i.e. fibres, matrices and metals), considering realistic micro-structures obtained via in-depth knowledge of the manufacturing process.
2. Enabling the optimisation of damage tolerant designs where the objective measure of performance is related to both damage initiation and evolution. Due to time and resource constraints this First Grant research will enable the development of the virtual testing capability only, while the development of a closed-loop optimisation technique will be the focus of future work.

Planned Impact

This research falls within the EPSRC "Engineering" theme in the area of "Materials Engineering - Composites", which is classified by a "Maintain" research action. EPSRC has made a number of large investments in this area in recent years, including the establishment of the National Composites Centre near Bristol, and the opening of one CDT as well as one IDC at the University of Bristol. Cardiff University has strong collaboration links with the Advanced Composites Centre for Innovation and Science (ACCIS) who are supporting this application (Prof Stephen Hallett, see Track Record). This project will contribute to strengthening these links while developing a new topic of research for Cardiff University which will help raise its research profile on the analysis of composite materials and structures.
The outcomes of this research may have a direct impact on some of the design and manufacturing conducted by the aerospace industry, especially in civil aviation. The UK aerospace industry is very important for the economy of the country. According to the UK Trade and Investment Agency "The UK has the second largest aerospace industry in the world after the US, with over 3,000 companies employing about 230,000 people". By helping to develop innovative manufacturing techniques for aerospace structures, this research would also be contributing to this success story.
With composite materials being such a key area of expertise for British scientists and industrialists, and being so deeply rooted in UK's important aerospace industry, it is expected that research in the area of "Materials Engineering - Composites" will remain a priority for EPSRC and other funding bodies also in the foreseeable future.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The concept of producing inserts and reinforcements for composite materials via Additive Layer Manufacture (ALM) with surface patterns which promote direct load transfer between insert and fibres has been proven. Hybrid structures were successfully manufactured using ALM inserts (thermoplastic and Titanium alloy) and braided with carbon fibres. Preliminary results have proven that it is indeed possible to control the fibre paths around surface protrusions using an industrial braiding process, although some level of imperfection is inevitable. Common braiding defects are yarn 'splitting' and 'bridging' over multiple pins on the mandrel. It was found that the occurrence of defects correlates strongly with manufacturing paramenters such as initial alignment between pin pattern and braid pattern. More importantly, the numerical models developed in this project were able to capture quite accurately the occurence of such defects, enabling for the first time full 'virtual manufacturing' of metal-composite braided structures, which was the main objective of this work.
Exploitation Route Journal papers are currently being written for publication in open-access journals. The data generated in this project will be made available to the public via appropriate databases.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Transport

 
Description The research outputs of this grant have enabled a Technology Pull-Through (TPT) project with the National Composites Centre (NCC, a Catapult centre), with a total value of £70k, which will see the industrialisation of the process simulation tools developed during the original grant for the prediction of local resin permeability of carbon fibre braids, which is of considerable interest to the aerospace and automotive industries.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
 
Title Simulation of braiding and over-braiding processes onto structured mandrels, accounting for contact, friction and deformation. 
Description A novel modelling approach was devised for realistic simulations of braiding and over-braiding processes onto structured mandrels, which accounted for full contact (yarn-mandrel and yarn-yarn) including friction and deformation. This required the use of a dynamic explicit Finite Element solver and a novel approach for the 'feeding' of carbon fibre yarns in the simulation. 
Type Of Material Computer model/algorithm 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact This model enables the detailed prediction of fibre paths in hybrid structures produced by braiding fibres over structured surfaces. The prediction of fibre paths is a pre-requisite for the optimisation of such novel structures, which have great potential for improving structural performance and reducing energy consumption in the aerospace, transport and renewable energy sectors. 
 
Description Dresden ILK 
Organisation Technical University of Dresden
Department Institute for Lightweight Construction and Plastics Technology (ILK)
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Our research team designed and manufactured structured mandrels (with different pin geometries and densities) by Additive Layer Manufacturing. These were initially made of thermoplastic material, which has lower cost and allows for better imaging when using X-ray computed tomography scanning. These mandrels were then provided to Dresden for braiding trials. In addition, the team at Bristol helped co-supervise undergraduate students who did summer internships in Dresden in 2016.
Collaborator Contribution Dresden provided technician and equipment time for braiding trials (total of about 4 days including setup), plus academic supervision of two undergraduate projects over the summer of 2016. In addition, Dresden shared considerable data and expertise on the manufacture of hybrid struts/shafts for aerospace applications.
Impact A preliminary set of validation tests was conducted using Dresden's large carbon fibre braiding wheel and Bristol's 3D-printed structured inserts. The specimens manufactured were scanned in Bristol's X-ray computed tomography (CT) scanner which revealed the fibre structure around surface protrusions. These data are currently being used to validate the numerical models developed at Bristol.
Start Year 2016
 
Description National Composites Centre (NCC) Technology Pull-Through (TPT) programme on industrialisation of braiding simulations for resin permeability prediction. 
Organisation National Composites Centre (NCC)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution The braiding simulation tools developed and validated by the original grant are being "scaled-up" to full industrial scale for the prediction of local fibre preform permeability which is key for the quality and cost of braided composite parts.
Collaborator Contribution The NCC are providing access to their state-of-the-art braiding facilities, materials, and time of a Research Engineer to conduct manufacturing trials and validation tests.
Impact Software interfaces are being built to link the output of braiding simulations to local permeability predictions using the software FlowTex.
Start Year 2019