Digital Destinations: Exchanging Digital Technology Knowledge in Local Tourism Economies

Lead Research Organisation: Bournemouth University
Department Name: Sch of Tourism

Abstract

This proposal offers the opportunity to capture change in the adoption and use of digital technologies and to develop a strong, competitive local tourism economy. Through their increased understanding and use of emerging digital technologies, tourism businesses will be in a position to increase their marketing and management effectiveness, and develop new products and services that will provide an enhanced experience for visitors to their destinations. This proposal will accelerate tourism business growth via an improved understanding and implementation of digital technologies and facilitate the exchange of knowledge between tourism academics and tourism professionals. Knowledge will be exchanged between businesses that have already reached an advanced state of digital adoption (as well as those who have yet to engage), and leading tourism academics, with support provided by experienced digital and destination management professionals.

In the context of SMEs in local tourism economies, six outputs are proposed in the geographic context of Bournemouth & Poole and the New Forest:

Co-production of Learning Materials:

Using the existing BUDigitalHub website, research-informed 'bitesize' components of learning for tourism businesses will facilitate the transfer of contemporary, relevant and accessible knowledge on the adoption of digital technologies. The existing website will be enhanced significantly to cater for the interactive, networking demands of this project as it will serve as the key vehicle for the exchange and transfer of knowledge across the entire project.

Events to Launch and Disseminate Learning Materials

Local tourism businesses will be made aware of the existence of the appropriate learning materials through a launch event at the University's Executive Business Centre in the centre of Bournemouth which is easily accessible by road and rail. Two additional sub-regional launches will also take place, one at Kingston Maurward College on the outskirts of Dorchester and one at a hotel in the New Forest.

Development and Dissemination of Webinars on Digital Technologies

The co-development and dissemination of a series of webinars is of particular importance to the project due to the ease with which such outputs can be accessed locally or through the Internet. Six webinars will be developed on the following themes: (i) co-working strategies; (ii) online selling; (iii) search engine optimisation; (iv) effective use of online social networks; (v) benefitting from mobile technologies; (vi) developing enabling communities through digital technologies.

Co-production and Delivery of Partnership Marketing Seminars

Three separate seminars will be developed at different levels and covering different themes. Each seminar will be delivered on four separate occasions with 12 seminars taking place across the year. Seminars will run at venues across the area and will adopt a variety of different formats in order to cater to the specific needs of the businesses and to ensure the knowledge is brought effectively to them. Emphasis will be on the exchange of knowledge in a manner that sets the foundations for a longer-term self-sustaining knowledge network 'Digital Destinations'.

Digital Destination Knowledge Networks

Two cohorts of between 8-12 businesses will participate in 10 Digital Destination Knowledge Networks throughout the year commencing in September 2012. Each session will be facilitated by BU and DNFTP staff with each session featuring invited speakers on a specific aspect of digital technology, time for critical self-help, and mentoring activity.

Student Employer Engagement

This component will involve the participation of 40 businesses assigning consultancy projects to final-year students across the spectrum of digital technologies.

Planned Impact

Impact outside of the academic arena is primarily behavioural and economic in that the means by which tourism organisations amend their adoption, implementation and interpretation of digital technologies will ultimately have a profound economic impact on their own organisations and the tourist destinations within which they sit. In turn, the public benefit emerges from the strengthening of competitiveness and better economic performance for both private and public organisations. Achieving higher levels of visitation and higher income from tourism is critical for the creation of employment and wealth and as a means of creating and supporting the infrastructure required to support the needs of visitors and resident communities alike. This project will enable SMEs in local tourism economies to use digital technologies to increase their internal coordination and management, improve their global visibility, engage dynamically with their shareholders, manage their online reputation, attract more visitors, strengthen their overall competitiveness and ultimately improve their income and their long-term sustainability.

The key outcome of this proposal is to record an increase in the economic and social value of tourism to the local economy via demonstration that SME tourism businesses across the Dorset and New Forest area have become more proficient and effective in their use of digital technologies. It is critical for this project to show that activity has led to growth in the use of digital technology and with regard to the means by which consumers of the destination product are using and responding to it positively. In this regard, the first to benefit are those SMEs that voluntarily receive the knowledge being transferred in that the knowledge obtained will help enhance their awareness and use of a range of digital technologies. It is anticipated that through their increased awareness of such technologies SMEs will gain benefit from more cost effective and tailored marketing activity, the creation and existence of customer or client communities, and an ability to more accurately research the needs and wants of customers or clients. Additional beneficiaries will be those stakeholders at the destination level who either directly or indirectly come into contact with those SMEs partaking in the transfer of knowledge. Benefits will come in a variety of forms but will primarily be economic in that the composite nature of destinations ensures that non-participants or so-called 'free riders' will also benefit from improved knowledge attained by others. That said, the more SMEs that engage with digital technologies is likely to serve as a catalyst for others whereby eventually a critical mass of digitally-engaged SMEs will be in existence within local tourism economies which over time will enhance the overall competitiveness and sustainability of the local tourism economy. The only way to measure such an outcome is to include an element of longitudinal market research in the proposal which gauges the adoption, implementation and reaction of organisations to their more effective use of digital technologies. Such research is to consist of secondary research to analyse the extent to which tourism businesses are currently using digital technologies in their online marketing activity and postal questionnaires to measure anticipated and actual usage of digital technology and its value to the organisation.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Video case study of micro business impact 
Description This video was produced by the owner of a micro enterprise participating in the project and documents her involvement in the project and the impact that it has had on her business. The video demonstrates not only the tangible benefits she accrued from the project but also the growth in her confidence with digital marketing. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2013 
 
Description Digital marketing is a relatively new paradigm, which has transformed business to customer marketing and yet little is understood about how small businesses perceive the challenges and opportunities in this area. This project aimed to address that gap through a qualitative study of 60 small businesses operating in the visitor economy and found that there was a strong appetite for digital marketing and a clear recognition of its opportunities. The study found that small businesses were nervous about digital marketing but, with hands-on help, were able to grow in confidence as revealed in the following blog post on the project website: http://www.budigitalhub.co.uk/blog-post/norburton-hall's-journey-digital-dalliances-digital-destination.



"We started the Digital Destinations Project with great anticipation that turned_to trepidation, in January 2013, as we realised the enormity of the task ahead.

Six months on, with the help of the project team at Bournemouth University we are relieved to have survived our plunge into the_digital deep end and are now enjoying going with the flow of a digital current."



The study found six key themes, which businesses associate with digital marketing: market orientation, measurement, strategy, barriers, collaboration and benefits. Together these themes accounted for over 90% of the text references which were coded as part of the content analysis of cluster discussions. Market orientation was the dominant theme accounting for 28% of all coded references and containing nine concepts: Unique selling points, targeting, customer conversation, customer insight, customer database, linking channel to customer, customer retention, product-market match and customer journey. The businesses developed a clear understanding of how digital marketing can enable a strong market orientation and this is reflected in their action plans which each business prepared and presented in the final workshop and which have been uploaded to the research outcomes section and can also be viewed at www.slideshare.net/DigitalHub. Participants joined the project with varying levels of digital marketing knowledge and expertise, however none had attempted to put a plan in writing and therefore this outcome represents a significant development for the small businesses involved.



However, the study found that the ability to take advantage of digital marketing opportunities was constrained by a lack of understanding and skills and an inability to measure the Return on Investment (ROI); this in turn led to a difficulty in securing a focus for digital marketing. There is a paucity of research in this area and the project team plan to follow up this project with an in depth study of how small businesses can measure the impact of their digital marketing over short planning cycles. At least 10 of the 60 businesses involved in DDP have expressed a keen interest in participating in that study.



The study found that businesses enjoyed the opportunity to share knowledge and support each other in their cluster groups as captured in the following blog post (which has been uploaded to project outcomes and can be viewed at http://www.budigitalhub.co.uk/blog-post/benefits-shared-learning-paultons-park); this element of collaborative working will be a feature in the methodology for future research.
Exploitation Route It is anticipated that this project will have economic and societal impact on small business digital marketing in a number of areas. Firstly, the project has provided a focus on the role of digital marketing analytics and measurement and the PI has secured external funding to progress this as a follow up to Digital Destinations. Around 10-15 of the 60-strong project cohort have expressed a strong interest in participating in this study. This study will test a small business digital marketing planning framework which was an outcome of the project.

Secondly, the PI in his capacity as a Board member of VisitWiltshire Limited and Chair of the VisitWiltshire Online Marketing Group (OMG) has disseminated the learning from the project to the OMG and the group will be running a pilot project starting in May 2014 on digital marketing planning. The results of this pilot will then be disseminated to the wider VisitWiltshire membership which comprises over 500 organisations.

Thirdly, the project has achieved a mindset-shift among the users involved in the project and enabled them to prioritise digital marketing and to plan more carefully. This includes a more formal approach to planning customer engagement through a range of online channels including the website, social media and email marketing. it is anticipated that the growing awareness that businesses are able to generate among their target customers will convert into interest and ultimately additional business.

Finally the project will have a wider societal impact in terms of the benefits of the knowledge which the user community has attained and the growing confidence that it has instilled encouraging them to seek out further similar opportunities.
The project team disseminated the findings of the study through a number of routes in order to maximise impact. Firstly, the project was launched at the Tourism Management Institute conference in October 2012 with a presentation entitled "The Learning Destination: Developing productive relationships between higher education and destination management". Then in May 2013, the PI on the project facilitated a workshop at the TMI annual convention under the theme "Broadening Our Horizons", reporting on the outcomes of the project to date. These two events were attended by leading Destination Management Organisations from across the UK.



Secondly the PI was invited to be a guest blogger on the VisitEngland (National Tourism Organisation) blog on the theme of 'innovation', which featured an article entitled "Working together for innovation" which described how the project had fostered innovation among the participating businesses. Details at: http://www.visitengland.org/Blog/post/2013/10/01/Working-together-for-innovation.aspx.



Thirdly the PI presented a summary of the project at the ESRC-funded Festival of Social Science on the theme of 'Social Media: Make or break your online reputation'. This event was attended by academics and small business practitioners and provided a forum for disseminating the key findings.



Fourthly in October 2013 the project participants were invited to a final event where the key findings were presented providing an opportunity for the businesses to ask questions and explore opportunities for future projects.



Lastly the PI was invited to the Tourism School in the Zilltertal region of Austria to present to tourism college tutors from across Austria on digital marketing which included a presentation on the Digital Destinations project.
Sectors Creative Economy,Education,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Retail

URL http://www.budigitalhub.co.uk
 
Description The findings have been used by the tourism SME community to engage more effectively with digital marketing. In particular there has been a growing confidence in the approach taken towards digital marketing by a significant portion of those SMEs participating in the study. Particularly encouraging is the decision by 20 participating businesses and organisations to re-engage with the university in a more in depth follow up to the study. In addition, the findings of this study were instrumental in establishing a partnership with a region in Denmark that was keen to develop SME capability in the digital marketing field and, following that collaboration, a successful bid was submitted to the European Union Erasmus+ programme.
First Year Of Impact 2012
Sector Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Retail
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Policy at VisitWiltshire
Geographic Reach Local/Municipal/Regional 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact The Board of VisitWiltshire have instructed the VisitWiltshire Online Marketing Group to run a special project on digital marketing analytics. The work of the OMG informs Board policy and this has come about as a result of the PI's role on the Board.
 
Description ERASMUS+ PROGRAMME STRATEGIC PARTNERSHIPS (KEY ACTION 2): PROJECT NAME: Professional SMEs in tourism - transnational development of skills acquisition
Amount € 337,774 (EUR)
Funding ID KA202-2017-014 
Organisation European Union 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 09/2017 
End 03/2020
 
Description Partnership with Destination Management Organisations in Denmark 
Organisation Visit Djursland
Country Denmark 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution visitdjursland is interested in using digital technology to enhance the marketing of their destination and also to upskill the SMEs in the region. They were searching for a best practice partner to visit to learn more in this area. Several Google searches led to 'Digital Destinations' appearing in the results and they made contact with me (Dr Philip Alford, PI in the project).
Collaborator Contribution There will be an exchange of information and an opportunity for the co-creation of knowledge concerning SMEs and digital marketing.
Impact The trip from the Danish delegation will take place in May 2016 however a programme has been developed for the visit and opportunities have been discussed for ongoing collaboration. Provides an opportunity to compare best practice in UK and Denmark. The partnership has developed and we are now preparing an application to the ERASMUS+ EU programme "Cross national skills development of SMEs in the tourism industry". The application will be directly informed by the learning that took place during the Digital Destinations study.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Blog post by Karen Venn owner of Norburton Hall 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Blog posts by one of the participants uploaded to the project website which reveals attitudes and practice of digital marketing at the beginning, during and at the end of the project.

The blog post influenced other small tourism businesses and inspired them to engage in digital marketing.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://budigitalhub.com/blog-post/norburton-hall's-journey-digital-dalliances-digital-destination
 
Description Digital Destinations workshop at Tourism Management Institute conference Broadening Our Horizons 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Project PI facilitated a workshop at the Tourism Management Institute annual convention under the theme "Broadening Our Horizons", reporting on the outcomes of the project to date. The workshop was attended by approximately 40 practitioners in the field of tourism destination marketing and the workshop stimulated considerable interest and debate in the ways in which small businesses can be better supported in the destination.

I made contact with a representative from VisitEngland - the national tourism body which led to a later request to contribute a blog to their website.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.slideshare.net/DigitalHub/digital-destinations-workshop-at-tourism-management-institute-c...
 
Description Digital Destinations: Be inspired by best practice 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A presentation made to a Danish delegation comprising policy makers and practitioners. The theme for their visit was the "learning journey" and "be inspired by best practice" and it focused on Dorset's Jurassic Coast, traditional ports and resorts, and the New Forest National Park. The PI presented on how Digital Destinations contributed to destination development and marketing.

A number of practitioners from Denmark reflected on how the challenges facing SMEs in Denmark mirrored those reported by UK tourism SMEs participating in the study.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.slideshare.net/DigitalHub/digital-destinations-be-inspired-by-best-practice
 
Description Digital Destinations: Key results and next steps 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Final presentation to project participants summarising key results and discussing opportunities to follow up the study.

As a result of my presentation a number of the project cohort expressed a strong interest in being part of a follow up study; 20 businesses from the study have re-engaged with the university as part of a follow up project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.slideshare.net/DigitalHub/digital-destinations-key-results-and-next-steps
 
Description Google advertising value questioned by eBay 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact An interview by the BBC based on my work with small businesses during the Digital Destinations project

BBC News Technology
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-21769533
 
Description Media interest - interview with BBC Technology 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact "Google advertising value questioned by eBay". An interview by the BBC based on my work with small businesses during the Digital Destinations project

The prominence of the BBC channel generated regional interest in my research. The interview with the BBC was a direct outcome of the digital research I was involved with.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/technology-21769533
 
Description The learning destination: Developing productive relationships between higher education and destination management 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Launch of project at Tourism Management Institute (http://www.tmi.org.uk) conference which attracted mainly industry delegates from Destination Management Organisations.

After my talk a number of DMO practitioners expressed an interest in hearing more about the progress of the project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012