The Application of Gestural Interactivity Technology to Online Fashion Retailing

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: Materials

Abstract

This research examines how fashion retailers can use image interactivity technology on touchscreens to improve consumer product visualisation. Retailers report that the inability to physically interact with an item prevents consumers shopping online for fashion (Hughes, 2012a). Inaccurate, incomplete or unsatisfactory product information results in abandoned online shopping carts, incorrect product selection and product return (Quick, 1999). The returns rates for online fashion currently average 25% of all online sales (Morell, 2013) and managing the returns represents a significant retailer cost. Our focus is the challenge of cross-channel inconsistency in browsing and purchasing experience for customers. One solution is to improve product representation online through removing the uncertainty that comes with lack of touch, feel and try-on possibilities. Novel forms of image interactivity technology enable better product visualisation for consumers buying fashion online. This research aims to reduce consumer decision-making mistakes and thus reduce the costs associated with retailers processing returned items and the opportunity costs of abandoned online shopping carts.

We focus on fashion retailing as it is the fastest growing and most popular category of online shopping, outperforming all other categories including books, travel and music (Mintel, 2010; Mintel, 2012). In addition, smartphone and tablet penetration has led to growth opportunities in m-commerce, with smartphones becoming increasingly integral to the shopping experience from research to purchase (Gallagher, 2013). However, despite this growth, online sales remain dwarfed by bricks and mortar sales, with clear challenges remaining for fashion e-commerce and m-commerce revenues (Hughes, 2012a). We focus on the SME fashion retailer, for whom the online sales channel has many benefits, providing not only cost savings but also an effective means of competition with larger firms, greater access to national and international markets, scope for increased breadth and depth of stock, and increased customer service without the need for a physical store. However the online sales channel also presents risks and additional costs; this research specifically addresses the risks and costs of online presentation of fashion items.

Touchscreen technology has the potential to provide a more intuitive and enhanced consumer interaction with a product but this potential has not been fully realised. Consumers increasingly use their own touchscreen devices for product research, browsing and shopping while in the physical store (Thomson, 2013) and more retailers are bringing digital technology into the physical store by providing touchscreens for consumers to browse and place orders for items not in stock (Goldfingle, 2012). Touchscreen technology permits greater interactivity between consumers and websites due to multi-modal (vision, touch, sound, vibration) capabilities, without the need for a mouse. This project applies Shoogleit technology that has been developed by Heriot-Watt University's School of Mathematical and Computer Sciences to both online and offline fashion retail contexts. Shoogleit is a web application that create interactive media from short video clips (http://www.shoogleit.com/). This technology supports production of engaging and interactive product representations at low cost and with ease and without the need for expensive or specialist equipment. Our research will gather data on the perceptual gap between digital and physical product evaluation both online and in the physical store environment, will examine the potential of image interactivity technology in fulfilling consumers' utilitarian and hedonic online shopping motives and will identify the barriers and facilitators of adoption by fashion retailers with a focus on SMEs. The research outcomes will enable further refinement the technology so that it delivers value to retailers and consumers.

Planned Impact

The key beneficiaries of the research outputs will be SME fashion retailers with online operations and the wider public, both current online fashion shoppers as well as fashion shoppers who have not yet fully engaged with online sales channels.

The research outputs have the potential to increase revenues for SME fashion retailers by reducing the cost of managing high returns rates and reducing the opportunity costs of abandoned shopping baskets online. The successful application of the technology to online fashion retailers will enable them to compete more effectively with larger companies who have greater resources to invest in online product visualisation technology. SME fashion retailers dominate the economy in terms of revenue as well as employment, and the fashion e-commerce business sector provides excellent start-up opportunities with low barriers to entry for creative entrepreneurs. As such, the research outputs could contribute towards the sustainable success of online fashion retail start-ups.

There are also beneficiaries within the charity sector that could use the research outputs for their advantage. As charity retailers e.g. Oxfam increasingly use the online sales channel as a means of increasing revenues for donated clothing items, the implementation of improved product visualisation technology could increase conversions and consumer engagement with the webshop, as well as reduce returns and customer frustration where the item is not as expected.

For consumers, the research outputs have the potential to overcome a key barrier to online shopping, which is the intangibility and lack of product visualisation possibilities, and therefore enable a wider demographic beyong the typical 18-34 yr old online fashion shooper to engage with the online sales channel for fashion shopping. The benefits for this user community would be increased ability to evaluate products online and therefore to make an informed purchase decision, which would result in less frustration when the item received is not as expected. The technology also has the potential for increasing engagement and enjoyment with the online shopping task itself, thereby providing an improved consumer experience and encouraging consumers to return to this sales channel.
 
Description This research has generated significant insight into the process of knowledge exchange between academic researchers and the retail industry sector.
Firstly, we identified how recent change within the University and technology transfer sectors resulted in hurdles to commercialisation of digital innovation developed in academia. Specifically, the focus upon research excellence in academia (in terms of academic publications and grant funding) and the reduction in willingness of the web developer community to work for free for equity options (rather than for cash) meant that the tech partner required significant proof of concept to further commercialise the technology developed in academia, whilst the academic developers felt they had limited ability to achieve this within the bounds of their academic roles.
Secondly, our research into consumer motivations for online shopping shows that fashion shoppers use online technology to enhance and improve their shopping experience, not only to save time but also to relax and to learn about clothing trends. Previous studies into online shopping behaviour focussed upon task-driven behaviours and did not reflect how ongoing digital technology development, in particular the opportunities for novel behaviours on tablets and smart phones, are used to satisfy pleasure seeking motivations. We also discovered that female fashion consumers of all ages value increasing levels of product visualisation technology which helps them overcome the lack of touch and feel when shopping for fashion online. We also discovered they overwhelmingly prefer to see the clothing worn on a real model rather than a mannequin.
Thirdly, we learnt that whilst small independent retailers face a range of challenges, they are also engaging meaningfully with online shopping, for example via social media or a brochure website, even if they did not have a full transactional website. There was an appetite to use new forms of digital technology on their digital platforms, however, crucially, this sector is dependent upon reliable and economically viable support from web developers. Whilst the online channel is said to level the playing field between larger and smaller retailers, in practice, small retailers felt their ability to create a visually appealing website that effectively translated the aesthetic and personality of their store and provided an enjoyable and informative online shopping experience, that could match the websites of larger retailers, was very much dependent on finding the right web developer. Despite the presence of many web developers available in the marketplace, they perceived a 'knowledge gap' regarding their ability to assess web developers' skills and ability to judge their suitability for creating a fashion website at an economically viable price. They felt that greater levels of product visualisation would be beneficial for their website but were concerned about the extra time, effort and expense that this might entail.
Fourthly, we discovered benefits from working collaboratively with other projects within the ESRC Retail Knowledge Exchange call for funding. It was useful to learn insights and share knowledge with the other projects and the networking opportunities enabled us to build relationships for potential future research collaborations.
Exploitation Route There is considerable scope for research that could identify commonality across the business process of small independent retailers and adapt an online product that fits their requirements. There is a demand amongst small independent retailers for online products that need limited effort to configure and which are both easy to use and extremely useful to the small business owner, in other words they should be at the stage to be made available as a generic plug-in, for example within the Magento or Shopify ecommerce platforms. There is a role for trade associations and government to draw on these findings to develop programmes to close the "knowledge gap" by either providing training or networking events for small retailers and web development agencies who wish to serve the fashion retail sector. There is a role for using the findings to guide further programming of the technology into an accessible, easy-to-use and useful product for small retailers. There is also a role for using the findings to provide a foundation for a "proof of concept" project involving a larger retailer or a consortium of smaller retailers to work in partnership with a tech partner.
Sectors Creative Economy,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Retail

 
Description Findings have been used in teaching materials for final year undergraduate students on fashion business BSc programmes in the School of Materials at The University of Manchester.
First Year Of Impact 2015
Sector Education
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Doctoral Training Partnership from EPSRC
Amount £67,606 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/M506436/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2015 
End 10/2018
 
Description Participation in Manchester Science Festival 2014, 26 October 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Interactive demonstrations at the Museum of Science and Industry in Manchester sparked questions and discussion from the audience (members of the public) and tweets on social media platform Twitter.

After the interactive demonstrations, we noticed a higher level of web traffic to Shoogleit.com
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
URL http://www.manchestersciencefestival.com/whatson/msf14piinteractivetextiles
 
Description Presenting digital fashion technology to Scottish textile and fashion retailers, Glasgow, 9 June 2015 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? Yes
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The talk sparked questions and discussion afterwards. It promoted networking between academia and industry for future collaboration in research or knowledge exchange projects.

After the talk, a company contacted me to enquire about future participation in the research. The co-hosting organisations invited us to submit a blog post summarising the event and futher opportunities for their website, which may reach up to 300 readers and people who were unable to atend the event in person. Here is the blog post: http://blog.creativeclyde.com/design/digital-innovation-research-online-fashion-textile-retailing-comes-glasgow/
InCube Renfrewshire business incubator invited me
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL https://events.scottish-enterprise.com/events/ClientApps/Silverbear.Web.EDMS/public/default.aspx?tab...
 
Description Talk at Entrepreneurship in Fashion public conference, Edinburgh, 5 March 2015 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact The PI gave a talk about the aims and outcomes of the project to an audience of around 90 students, academics, the general public and industry practitioners, which resulted in requests for further information from a number of small businesses (e.g. textile manufacturers and retailers) and service providers (e.g. photographic services for fashion designers).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www.enterpriseofculture.leeds.ac.uk/upcoming-events/fashion-design-entrepreneurs-overcoming-g...