Mesh morphing strategies for image-based in-silico musculoskeletal biomechanics

Lead Research Organisation: University of Leeds
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

Background and benefits
Considerable growth in musculoskeletal intervention is predicted in the next two decades, increasing the need to develop, improve and target interventions. Such developments can be achieved through in-silico models, such as patient-specific finite element models. It is well known that a hexahedral mesh for such models is beneficial on the accuracy of the computational analysis. However, the automatic construction of hexahedral meshes is a research area on its own and therefore the development of image-specific hexahedral meshes is restricted to available tools which require multiple manual steps, making the accuracy of the process is highly user-dependent.

Aims
To facilitate reproducibility and accuracy in the next-generation of in-silico patient-specific musculoskeletal models by developing mesh morphing strategies, applicable to meshes from multiple tools.
The new mesh morphing strategies will allow existing image-based meshes, developed in the current time-consuming fashion, to be automatically adapted to a new subject, significantly speeding up the model development process, without compromising on mesh quality.

Three anatomic tissue sites have been strategically chosen for the development and testing of the tool. Each site provides unique challenges representing milestones in the technical development (detailed below). In addition, the tool can be applied to rapidly develop models from the available image databases (both internal and public) for each anatomic site chosen.

Research project
This PhD project will develop new morphing or warping algorithms. State-of-the-art will be advanced by creating multi-body meshes including image-based information such as grey-scale values.

The project will consist of several aspects:
1/ Building standard hexahedral mesh of the tissues on each anatomic site of interest (hip, ankle, spine) using meshing tools (IA-FEMesh, tools embedded in Finite Element Software's, or tools developed during the PhD).
2/ Development and implementation of relatively generic morphing or warping tools.
3/ Validation of the developed tool using (pre-)clinical image databases from iMBE, or public repositories, on the hip, the ankle and the spine. The superiority of using hexahedral meshes will be demonstrated in accurately modelling incompressible materials and tissues. The new developed meshes will be used to assess the difference in contact mechanics between tetrahedral meshes and hexahedral meshes.

The three applications (spine, hip and ankle) represent areas of existing image databases and modelling expertise within the IMBE. The hexahedral mesh development and morphing methods will be applied to each anatomical area in turn, with additional complexity introduced at each stage:

Spine: The intervertebral disc is responsible for the majority of the movement possible in the human spine and its degeneration is the source of debilitating pain. The relative simple overall shape makes the disc a good subject for initial mesh and morphing development in two and three dimensions. A possible extension is to capture the layered structure within the disc.

Hip: The cartilage covering the pelvic side of the hip joint is one of the sites where damage can occur at an early age, linked with osteoarthritis in later life. The shape of this tissue presents additional challenges. Applying the initial methods here will demonstrate how much shape change the morphing methodology can achieve. A possible extension is to include the 'labral' tissue which surrounds the cartilage at the edge of the cavity.

Ankle: The ankle joint is prone to post-traumatic osteoarthritis, with very small contact areas between bones and small anatomical changes linked to high functional change. Morphing a mesh to fit to the ankle bones will present the additional challenge of resolving multiple meshes at a contact surface, as well as capturing the shape of each bone.

Studentship Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Student Name
EP/N509681/1 01/10/2016 30/09/2021
1808811 Studentship EP/N509681/1 01/10/2016 31/12/2020 Adam Kelly
 
Description Two novel automatic mesh-morphing strategies have been developed, which modify an existing mesh of a similar geometry to match a different shape. Meshes of this nature are typically used for finite element simulations and similar methods. They are also used in the graphics communities for 3D animations. Additionally, novel techniques have been developed to automate the assembly and definition of finite element models. Novel methodologies to assess the performance of such strategies and mesh-generation procedures have also been developed.

The novel strategies provide significant speed improvements over gold-standard procedures, and generate meshes to an equivalent standard. The technical skill and time requirements to create such meshes and simulations are reduced with the introduction of these strategies. Also, the novel methodologies can be used to assess, compare, improve and validate the performance of mesh-generation procedures. Each of these aspects have been demonstrated in the research. The strategies can already be applied to a larger number of geometries and anatomies, and with relatively simple modifications can be applied more broadly.

Several specialist skills have been developed during this research, which include programming complex computational geometry algorithms, and the development and interpretation of finite element simulations. These skills were developed over the course of the research, and were initially established during a placement (computational geometry) and a two week training coarse (finite element models). Proficiency in these skills allowed a range of sophisticated algorithms to be designed, implemented, tested and improved. These skills were essential to the completion of the research objectives.

Several resources and gaps between the fields of biomedical engineering and computational geometry were identified. Specifically, the wide-range of techniques that are commonplace in the field of computational geometry could provide significant improvements by reducing the technical difficulty, and increasing the speed and accuracy of developing biomedical finite element models. Some of these concepts were used in this research, which highlight some of the benefits. Similarly, several breakthroughs in mesh-generation have been identified, which could also have a profound impact in the biomedical community. Currently, a significant proportion of important and recent research innovations in these areas have been not translated to other fields.
Exploitation Route Any industry or sector that uses finite element models and similar technologies can benefit from this research. In particular, those that acquire 3D geometries using scanning technologies, e.g. MRI, CT, ultrasound, laser, radar and sonar. Consequently, there are numerous industries and sectors that can take advantage of the rapid generation of high-quality meshes for their associated applications. This will lead to greater productivity and cost-effectiveness, which would have a positive impact on the economy and associated revenues.

Most notably, significant improvements to the development of patient-specific therapies and medical devices, and their wide-spread utilisation are now easier to achieve. This could allow medical practitioners to: diagnose a large range of diseases earlier with greater precision, prevent further complications, and provide more effective and tailored treatments. This also has the potential to provide significant economic savings, and lead to several disruptive technologies. Additionally, population studies have previously been limited by the technical difficulty and laborious nature of developing simulations, which can now be overcome. This would allow greater nuances and trends to be observed in the population from the ability to study larger cohorts. Also, the developed technologies provide a step forward towards the large-scale adoption of human body digital twins.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Agriculture, Food and Drink,Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Energy,Environment,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology,Transport,Other

 
Description Academic Placement 
Organisation Catholic University of Louvain
Country Belgium 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Learning how to develop and implement novel and existing computational geometry algorithms at the respective research institutions. Interpreting research, mathematics and descriptions into code, and vice versa.
Collaborator Contribution Prof. Geuzaine and Prof. Remacle provided their expertise in developing and teaching sophisticated computational geometry algorithms.
Impact The skills and knowledge developed were crucial to completing the PhD research objectives. The core discipline was based on computational geometry, which branches into numerous areas, such as: graphics, animation and various simulation methods for a variety of applications. Gained insight into the processes and teams involved in developing sophisticated software based on complex algorithms.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Academic Placement 
Organisation University of Liege
Country Belgium 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Learning how to develop and implement novel and existing computational geometry algorithms at the respective research institutions. Interpreting research, mathematics and descriptions into code, and vice versa.
Collaborator Contribution Prof. Geuzaine and Prof. Remacle provided their expertise in developing and teaching sophisticated computational geometry algorithms.
Impact The skills and knowledge developed were crucial to completing the PhD research objectives. The core discipline was based on computational geometry, which branches into numerous areas, such as: graphics, animation and various simulation methods for a variety of applications. Gained insight into the processes and teams involved in developing sophisticated software based on complex algorithms.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Acquisition of Meniscus Geometries 
Organisation European University of Madrid
Country Spain 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The acquired geometries were used to validate the technologies developed in this research.
Collaborator Contribution Prof. Pierce and Dr. Rodriguez-Vila provided 32 meniscus geometries, which were segmented from MRI images acquired from the osteoarthritis initiative.
Impact The developed mesh-morphing strategy was validated with a large, thorough dataset.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Acquisition of Meniscus Geometries 
Organisation University of Connecticut
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The acquired geometries were used to validate the technologies developed in this research.
Collaborator Contribution Prof. Pierce and Dr. Rodriguez-Vila provided 32 meniscus geometries, which were segmented from MRI images acquired from the osteoarthritis initiative.
Impact The developed mesh-morphing strategy was validated with a large, thorough dataset.
Start Year 2020
 
Title Novel Mesh-Morphing Strategies 
Description Two novel automatic mesh-morphing strategies have been developed, which modify an existing volumetric mesh of a similar geometry to match a different shape. These strategies combine principles from similar fields (e.g. surface parameterisation) and existing mesh-morphing strategies into a novel design. The strategies are based on centrelines, where novel improvements for generating these structures with respect to efficiency and speed were incorporated. Currently, the strategies can be used to develop hexahedral meshes and finite element simulations for a wide range of anatomies with a similar performance to gold-standard procedures, which requires significant technical skill and time. Overall, the software can allow biomedical engineers to develop patient-specific finite element models with greater speed and ease. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact The strategies have enabled a large number of finite element models of the knee to be generated automatically and rapidly, which is typically a laborious and time-consuming endeavour requiring technical skill and expertise. Currently, the developed technologies have not been used outside of the research. 
 
Description Business Innovation Competition (University of Leeds) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Two teams of biomedical engineering students developed hypothetical biotechnology products and associated business infrastructure. The competition involved the dissemination of the work to a panel of judges, participants, students and the general public. After the presentations and selection of the winning team, there was an opportunity for networking and discussions between the participants, judges and wider audience. This event enabled students to engage and share their knowledge with a wide audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
URL http://medical-technologies.leeds.ac.uk/blog-entry/medtech-best/
 
Description Mechanical Engineering Open Day (University of Leeds) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Approximately 30 prospective students attended the university to view the facilities and participate in engaging activities relating to the nature of mechanical engineering principles and practices at a high-level. During the prospective student tours, their parents were invited to ask questions and participate in discussions about the University of Leeds experience. Students and parents seemed engaged and interested in attending the university.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://engineering.leeds.ac.uk/info/201359/undergraduate/52/meet_us