Intercultural creativity in electroacoustic music: Integrating Indian music cultural sound emblems into new works.

Lead Research Organisation: Liverpool Hope University
Department Name: Faculty of Arts and Humanities

Abstract

Incorporating culturally unfamiliar sound into one's own creative output has been an increasingly popular activity among electroacoustic music composers over the last few years; yet work of this nature is difficult to develop without being accused of appropriation or exploitation, and even of indulging in a contemporary version of musical exoticism, with its overtones of nineteenth-century colonialism.
This project will explore the inclusion of cultural-specific sound in new electroacoustic music works (composition using technology to explore, create and perform sounds) by working collaboratively with Indian musicians and UK audiences for Indian music. Unlike traditional note-based instrumental music, which may engage with exotic musics through evocation, electroacoustic music can express exotic sound quotations literally, via audio sampling.
This research will examine the process of collecting and incorporating Indian cultural sounds originating from Indian musical instruments into two new electroacoustic music compositions. The project, coordinated and supported by Milapfest (the UK's National Indian Arts Trust) based at Liverpool Hope University, will enable interaction with world-renowned musicians to establish a unique collaborative experience investigating the perceptions and understanding of cultural sound (that is, sound experienced as culturally specific). Practice-led research (composition work) will question the openness of the electroacoustic music sound world through the borrowing of sounds from a culture different to my own cultural background and experience, and will be documented in the form of an online research blog and presented more formally in a new journal article. The musical output, testing a variety of methodologies, techniques and tools to disguise or emphasise cultural manifestation in electroacoustic music creation will build upon a discourse concerning the benefits, implications and issues of cultural sound use. Through these outputs, this research aims to address a current lack of contextual documentation on the now-frequent act of incorporating culturally unfamiliar sound into creative output.
Public concert presentation of the new works will unite the usually separate worlds of Indian music and electroacoustic music, while audience perspectives will collate public reception of exotic sound via interviews and questionnaires. Research dissemination at the International Computer Music Conference (ICMC) and Electronic Music Studies Network conference (EMS) will encourage further scholarly interest in, and consideration of, creative uses of cultural sound, while exposing aspects of Indian music to a research field traditionally unacquainted with these practices.
Further to this, creating an online sound archive from the Indian musical instrument recordings will establish a freely-accessible education and research resource appearing within Milapfest's online portal. Commissioning new electroacoustic music works making use of the sound archive will continue the research's influence and impact beyond the project's funded duration.

Planned Impact

The research project proposes a unique collaboration between Liverpool Hope University and Milapfest (the UK's National Indian Arts Development Trust), currently based within the £6.5million newly developed Capstone building for music and creative practice. Establishing a two-way link between these two organisations and drawing upon Milapfest's non-academic expertise in Indian music will provide a number of long-term impacts, within and beyond the project's funded lifetime:
(a) Increasing public engagement with the cultural sonic emblem: As an established practitioner of electroacoustic music, I have received over 120 performances both nationally and internationally. Accessing new audiences through Milapfest's performance platforms and my own international connections will facilitate greater and more diverse dissemination. Utilising performance opportunities at the Capstone theatre (Liverpool Hope), seating audiences sizes up to 280, will encourage local community members to consider the manifestation of traditional Indian music in new media. Milapfest's current monthly concert series 'Music for the Mind and Soul' attracts maximum capacity audiences from a wide range of communities including Indian, non-Indian musicians, academics, non-academics, and local community members from the Liverpool area. Hybridising the usually separate sound worlds of electroacoustic music and traditional Indian music will educate audiences in new and unknown musical activity from both cultural spheres achieving cultural enrichment.
(b) International and national partnerships: Working directly with Indian music performers will entail cross-fertilisation of knowledge. Compositional work with world-renowned performers Roopa Panesar (Sitar), Dr Rajeeb Chakraborty (Sarod) and Kousic Sen (Tabla) will forge international links between the University and global performance networks. International performances and research presentations will be pursued in India beyond the project's funded lifetime as a means of monitoring cross-cultural engagement and reception issues.
(c) Encouraging the electroacoustic music community to think differently about cultural sound emblems: Journal publications outlining the research project and resulting methodologies, concepts and cultural engagement will present new approaches, techniques and compositional styles within new literature to contextualise the practice-led research. Paper and music presentation at the annual Electronic Music Studies Network conference (EMS) and International Computer Music Conference (ICMC) will reach international audience members. Regularly updated research blogs will ensure the most current research and findings are available for both academic and public readers.
(d) Wider impact: An online archive of Indian music sound and music will be established, contributing to an extensive and unrivaled sound library for scholarly research, compositional application and creative practice. This resource will enable the collaboration between Liverpool Hope and Milapfest to commission works from international composers wishing to make use of this archived resource and knowledge base. This will create opportunities for local and international composers of electroacoustic music to develop new works in response to this rich and under-explored cultural resource. New works produced from this venture will be produced and released on Milapfest's current CD label. The sound archive will additionally feature as an educational resource within Milapfest's online Indian music portal, benefiting school groups across the UK and India. This online information portal will widen exposure of Indian music instruments and will draw attention to Liverpool Hope University's activity in electroacoustic music practices and Indian music research.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Blackburn M (2014) Editorial in Organised Sound

publication icon
Manuella Blackburn (2013) Performer as sound source: interactions and mediations in the recording studio and in the field in Electronic Music Studies Network Conference

publication icon
Manuella Blackburn (2013) New Shruti for Sarod and electronics in N/A

publication icon
Manuella Blackburn (2013) Javaari in International Computer Music Conference (ICMC 2013)

publication icon
Manuella Blackburn (2013) Instruments INDIA website in N/A

 
Title Composition 1 
Description Javaari (2013) is a fixed media composition for loudspeaker diffusion. Programme note: Javaari is the term given to the bridge of the sitar where the melodic and sympathetic strings run and create the sound. The bridge is made traditionally of deer horn and is made in a certain shape, width, and length, while the surface is flat with a slight semi-circle bend. The term also refers to the unique buzzing tone produced by the sitar. This piece explores these fascinating timbres originating from this instrument and pays particular attention to the beautiful pitch bends that arch over and under like vocal melismas. The work is structured into four episodes, each exploring a different intensity of explicit cultural sound use - often the sitar material is in the fore and sometimes it recedes or pokes through intermittently. This acousmatic work is the first in a series of pieces composed in collaboration with Milapfest (The UK's leading Indian Arts Charitable Trust) based at Liverpool Hope University. This piece of research was conducted to examine the translation and transference of cultural sound to electroacoustic music. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
Year Produced 2013 
Impact This piece has received multiple concert performances and has engaged wider audiences through the intercultural activity leading to its conception. Audiences of Indian classical music and electroacoustic have been brought together due to the use of non-Western instruments (live and recordings) and have been integrated with technology. 
 
Title Composition 2 
Description New Shruti for sarod and electronics (2013) Programme note: In the same way that a shruti box or tampura provides the supporting drone for many Indian Classical music performances, my composition seeks to create a complementary line for the sarod material within the piece. Derived from recordings of sarod, sitar, veena, violin, tanpura, swarmandal and ghungroo ankle bells, New shruti forms a montage from all these sounds while exploring the possibilities of sound transformations common to electroacoustic music. In places New shruti goes beyond just a drone function - it aims to instigate, provoke, and energize the performer through three main sections (i) glitch and crackle (ii) pitch curves and (iii) minor slow section. Through creating this work I have discovered the beauty of both the timbres of Indian instrumental sounds, and also stylistic features commonly associated with the tradition and performance practice such as gamakas (pitch bends) and tihai rhythmic cadences. Interpreting and reworking these features into my own music language has brought me closer to a musical culture previously unknown and unfamiliar. This work composed in collaboration with Dr Rajeeb Chakraborty is the second of a series of works exploring the transference and translation of cultural sound use to the medium of electroacoustic music, funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council (AHRC). Many thanks go to Rajeeb Chakraborty, H.N Bhaskar, Gaurav Mazumdar, Aditi Sen, Shyla Shan, Rashmi Patel and the whole Milapfest team. 
Type Of Art Composition/Score 
Year Produced 2013 
Impact The composition of this work led to the completion of a journal article for Organised Sound journal and a conference paper for the Electronic Music Studies Network Conference. Both of these outputs outlined the complexities of working with non-Western musical instruments and the challenges involved in intercultural music creation. The composition received a second performance in EMPAC, New York at Rensselaer Polytechnic Institute which introduced many audience members (accustomed to sonic arts practices) to the sarod musical instrument. 
URL http://vimeo.com/94519863
 
Description The development of the Instruments INDIA website has made headway in consolidating information, sound recordings and performer profiles on Indian classical music. Prior to this no such educational resource existed or was freely accessible. The website shows potential to grow and include further instruments, musical practices and styles. This website has become integrated into the activities of Milapfest (the UK's leading Indian arts development trust) and is this year being developed into an interactive mobile phone/tablet downloadable app, supported by HEIF funding.
Much needed documentation on the processes of integrated cultural sound material into new music has been published. A whole issue of Organised Sound journal (Cambridge University Press) was edited and curated by the PI (Dr Manuella Blackburn) as a key output to the research undertaken. This documentation included articles from other practitioners and theorists reaching across cultural boundaries when working with recorded sound. This output revealed the great increase of interest in working with cultural sound sources (including non-Western musical instruments) and addressed the need for greater discourse to be established for this niche practice to continue.
The research revealed unexpected findings associated with the differing contributions from Indian classical musicians and the role they played in the collection of data for the project. Aspects of performer origin, diaspora, geographic locations and performance styles had major impacts upon the sound recordings and data collection. Assessing differences amongst 28 instrumentalists became a focal point not anticipated at the start of the project. This has led to new research questions for future study regarding how the UK, as a home to many of these musicians, is conducive to a new 'brand' or playing style of Indian classical music.
The research moved towards the area of 'performer as sound source' and several key findings were made regarding the collaborative nature of extracting sound from musicians suitable for use within compositional work and for an online educational sound archive (Instruments INDIA). The relationship between composer and sound source could be categorised into 'directional', 'explorative' and 'unstructured' as encountered after recording 28 different performers of Indian classical music. Within the 'give and take' of this intercultural collaboration, the research demonstrated the possibilities in exerting one's creative and personal compositional voice when considering cultural identities and nuances.
The research activities solidified a working relationship with a non-academic organisation - Milapfest. The process of collaboration and overseeing project partner relations was key to the success and outcomes of the research.
The two new compositions, created as practice-based research, revealed the significant impact of studio techniques and software/ transformation processes on the retention and dismantling of cultural identity.
Exploitation Route The research resulted in the creation of the Instruments INDIA website (http://www.milapfest.com/instruments-india/), which showcases Indian musical instrument sound recordings made as part of the project. These sounds along with context, images and performer profiles can form the basis of school workshops on Indian classical music delivered to learners in Key Stage 3 and 4 (and beyond). The National Curriculum for Music at key stage 3 and 4 importantly states the need for understanding a wide variety of musical traditions - pupils are expected to "understand musical structures, styles, genres and traditions and identify the expressive use of musical elements from a wide variety of music." (Cited from the new Draft Updates for Music in the National Curriculum Key stage 3, from September 2013). Further to this, "The way we respond to music is determined to a large extent by our culture. We need to learn how and why music is different if we are to appreciate unfamiliar music" (cited from The Department for Education Key Concepts for Music website).
The creation of two new electroacoustic music compositions featuring Indian classical music instruments have received multiple international performances (New York, Perth, Manchester, Liverpool) and one received an award (European Regional award, International Computer Music Association, 2013). These pieces have reached new audiences, communities and laypeople outside of academia and have contributed to cultural enrichment.
Sectors Creative Economy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Other

URL http://manuellablackburn.blogspot.co.uk/
 
Description The online educational sound archive: http://www.milapfest.com/instruments-india/ is a freely accessible website that was launched in October 2013. Since then, this new resource containing data and findings from the research project has been used by concertgoers as a guide to Indian classical musical instruments. This educational site provided supportive information about instruments seen at Milapfest (the UK's leading Indian arts development trust) events (concerts, workshops, art schools and talks). The website has also been taken into schools and has been publicized widely (Classical music magazine) to encourage the general public and interested laypeople to engage with this research output. The compositional work arising from the research has received multiple public concert performances including showcases in New York (USA) and Perth (Australia) contributing to cultural enrichment and ongoing interest in the research.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Creative Economy,Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Milapfest 
Organisation Milapfest
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution As part of the research project Milapfest and I as PI created the Instruments INDIA online educational website (http://www.milapfest.com/instruments-india/) together. This activity involved recording approximately 28 musicians of Indian classical music, using Milapfest contacts of high quality performers and building a freely accessible resource to accompany these sound materials so that the general public could hear, see and learn about this genre of music. As PI, I met with each musician and recording the sound material. I was also responsible for editing and curating material for the website.
Collaborator Contribution Milapfest organised all musicians visiting Liverpool and arrange a field trip to India for further sound collection. Context, photos and videos were all coordinated by Milapfest. Milapfest provided opportunities for networking, meetings and introductions to musicians and data collection. They provided publicity opportunities, event promotion schemes and website space for communication of research updates and findings.
Impact Instruments INDIA website: http://www.milapfest.com/instruments-india/ Conference paper given at the Electronic Music Studies Network conference (Lisbon, 2013) http://www.ems-network.org/ems13/EMS13Abstracts.html
Start Year 2012
 
Description Concert performances 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Example concert: Approximately 150 members of the public attended a Milapfest concert (27th April 2013) at the Capstone Theatre, Liverpool. This was proceeded by a question and answer session after the concert which attracted much discussion regarding the use of technology in an Indian classical music concert programme.

As a result of this concert, I received many follow up emails about further information about my research project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.milapfest.com/tag/dr-rajeeb-chakraborty/