Deathscapes and Diversity in multicultural England and Wales. Making space for minorities' and migrants' bodily remains, ritual and remembrance.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Reading
Department Name: Geography and Environmental Sciences

Abstract

In light of increasing ethnic and religious diversity in the UK (ONS 2012), many challenges have been raised practically and politically about living together in difference within in Britain (Keith, 2005). Much attention has focused upon Black and Minority Ethnic (BME) patterns of housing, education, employment and leisure, but migrant and established minority needs relating to cemetery, crematoria and sites of ritual and remembrance ('deathscapes') are less well understood or provided for.

While death, sites of bodily disposal and practices of mourning and remembrance are universal phenomena, they are negotiated, practiced and ritualised in diverse ways within a multicultural society. Given the lack of systematic planning policy for this at national or local levels, we argue that diversity-ready deathscapes are a necessary but currently neglected aspect of an integrated multicultural society. Creating the conditions for integration is a government priority in multicultural Britain (UK Gov 2012). Government policy recognises that challenges are multifaceted and that integration comes from finding common ground in everyday life; it seeks to 'inspire and enable civil society and local areas to take action on integration issues that are important to them' (ibid., p19). Here, we propose using four case study towns in England and Wales (Huddersfield, Northampton, Swindon and Newport) in order to explore everyday deathscapes and diversity issues across a range of geographical regions and varied dynamic multicultural settings.

This project will work with members of a range of minority and migrant communities to bring new insight to understanding diversity, death and remembrance in England and Wales, investigating:
a) demand for culturally-specific spaces of bodily disposal and remembrance, both physical and virtual
b) evidence of shared socio-cultural practice and diversity within communities of place, practice and/or belief
c) the role of lifecycle rites such as funerals and memorialisation in identity formation and sense of belonging within a multicultural society
d) how local authority planners and Bereavement Service providers can respond to better meet these needs.

The project will be innovative in its use of Death Cafés to meet local people and learn about death-related issues and concerns in each area before collecting data through focus groups and biographical interviews, as well as using creative practices of drawing, model-making and photo-logs to understand current provision and ideal cemetery/crematoria/memorial site design. This visual material will feature in the end of project feedback touring exhibition which will be shown in each case study town, alongside a final Death in each exhibition venue.

The project will prompt public debate around the subject of minority deathscape provision in England and Wales, especially in the case study towns, as well as providing policy recommendations to local authority Planners and public and private Bereavement Service providers, which will feature in a report launched at a public workshop with participants, providers and policy-makers, including the Royal Town Planning Institute and Institute of Cemetery and Crematorium Management. We anticipate local and national media interest in the project findings, recommendations and its end of project touring exhibition.

Planned Impact

The 'Deathscapes and Diversity' research project will produce a series of outputs which will be of interest to public audiences, prompt public debate, and shape public policy and professional service provision, as well as addressing gaps in wider academic research in Geography, Planning and Death Studies.

Who will benefit and how?
The project will 'map' existing cemetery, crematoria and sites of remembrance provision, which will be compared with participant-identified migrant and minority cremation, burial and remembrance needs in the four case study towns. This will allow the identification of specific and evolving needs, leading to the identification of good practice and any shortfall of provision within the case study towns. The project will provide participants (both providers and users) with an opportunity to identify ideal provision, opportunities for community involvement and voice issues and concerns; it will provide each town with an agenda to address any shortfall in provision which will inform local authority Plans and both public and private service provider practice.

Participants will include first generation migrants and established minorities, from a range of ethnic and religious/ secular backgrounds, age groups and genders, in order to represent a wide range of groups, including those who may be marginalised in public debate e.g. elderly women.

A website will be designed at the start of the project, to include project updates and news of events, including a Twitter feed, links to outputs, including a PDF of the project report and policy booklet, and the end of project virtual exhibition. This will allow maximum access, locally, nationally and internationally to the project's programme, findings, recommendations and outputs.

An Executive Summary booklet of findings and policy recommendations will be launched at the end of project knowledge exchange workshop to be held at UWE with project participants, case study town local authority representatives, the Royal Town Planning Institute (RTPI) and Institute of Cemeteries and Crematoria Management (ICCM) and academics, coupled with the project's participant-focused visual exhibition. The report will be of particular insight and use for Planners, Bereavement Service Providers e.g. cemetery managers and funeral directors, as well as any minority groups lobbying for improved provision, locally, and in the wider UK and EU. Policy for and improved provision of diversity-ready cemetery, crematoria and remembrance sites, will enhance migrants' and established minorities' sense of 'belonging' and social integration in multicultural Britain, supporting UK government policy for social inclusion.

The 'Deathscapes and Diversity' touring exhibition will provide feedback to participants and case study towns and will be curated at a suitable venue for two weeks at each case study town as a means of communicating findings back to the towns and participants. This will include participant-curated photo-log images, sketches and Lego models of current and ideal memorials, cemeteries etc. from focus groups, as well as researcher photos. Copies of the policy report will be available at each exhibition, where there will also be an interactive pop-up display allowing visitors to express their own views/ ideals regarding memorialisation on postcards for display and a visitor book for additional comments. All participants including LAs, planners, local clergy, community leaders and Bereavement Service providers, plus local secondary schools will be invited. A second Death Café will be held in conjunction with each Exhibition to encourage people to continue public dialogue on death-related issues. A digital version of the exhibition will be curated on the project website for 3 years after the end of the project to ensure widespread access, impact and longevity. A press release will go out to local and national media highlighting the report and exhibition
 
Title Touring Exhibition: Diversity-ready cemeteries and crematoria 
Description Touring Exhibition: Diversity-ready cemeteries and crematoria - highlighting project key findings through visual images Exhibit displayed at the University of Reading report launch workshop, and at public venues in the case study towns: Newport, Swindon, Northampton and Huddersfield 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2018 
Impact Participants valued feedback from the project as a whole and placed their experience/ concerns/ recommendations in the context of the wider project findings Practitioners, participants and members of general public identified strategies/ practices to implement as a result of the findings shown in the exhibition and accompanying report 
 
Description Key findings include:
1. Towns in England and Wales do not have the same range of diversity-sensitive cemetery/crematoria/ funerary practices and procedures as can be found in larger cities (e.g. non-invasive autopsy and availability of seven day/ week death certificate sign-off)
2. Cemetery and crematoria provision for established minorities and migrants varies by local authority and private providers in the studied towns
3. Some providers work closely with minority and migrant groups to understand and address needs in imaginative and constructive ways, others are less aware of and able/ willing to meet specific needs, including varying preferences within religious communities
4. Some providers are not fully aware of the additional emotional and religious anxiety experienced by mourners if they are not able to fulfil their religious and cultural obligations to their deceased kith and kin
5. Some local authority provision is impacted and limited by budget cuts and/or outsourcing of cemetery services (e.g. weekend burials)
6. Diverse meanings and uses of cemeteries etc. as public spaces can create conflict (e.g. sacred space versus leisure use)
7. Information about varied local community beliefs and practices and opportunities to meet and engage with varied cemetery and crematoria users can enhance understanding and engagement in multicultural communities e.g. cemetery open days, events, consultations, volunteer networks, information boards.
Exploitation Route The project has produced a briefing report, briefing note and exhibition, disseminated through a launch and travelling to the four case study towns. The findings are being used by local authorities, the RTPI and ICCM (who are supporters of the project) and community groups. The briefing note and selected visual images are available via the project webpage.

Professor Avril Maddrell and Dr Yasminah Beebeejaun were invited to give a keynote address to the Institute of Cemetery and Crematoria Managers Annual conference in 2018.

The team organised a workshop with partners and participants and are taking the findings forward with representatives from the Royal Town Planning Institute, Institute of Cemetery and Crematoria Managers, other practitioners and community groups to identify diversity-training needs for the planning, cemetery and funerary sector.

The project investigators are building on this work in European context in a new HERA-funded project (2019-21) exploring cemeteries and crematoria as spaces of cultural integration in Europe, looking at 8 case study towns in 6 countries in North West Europe.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Government, Democracy and Justice,Other

URL https://blogs.reading.ac.uk/deathscapes-and-diversity/
 
Description To date project findings have been shared with delegates at the Institute of Cemetery and Crematoria Managers annual conference and all ICCM members via the Institute's website; feedback collected from the conference evidenced: a) changes of opinion, priorities and practice for c 15/ 60 present (e.g. need for awareness of diversity within minority groups; training community volunteers for weekend funerals; and the importance of community engagement and consultation events); and b) willingness of 10 to collaborate to developing diversity training materials for the sector. One of the researchers on the team has been invited to join a city Muslim Burial Council and will draw on findings from the project to inform the group's policy and practice. The team are currently working with the ICCM, RTPI, service providers and Minority community representatives to identify and develop diversity training materials for the cemetery, crematoria and funerary sector in UK. In 2020-21 issues around minorities cemetery and crematoria needs have come to the fore during the Covid-19 pandemic. A blog post based on this work, calling for sensitivity to minorities religious funerary needs during the pandemic was posted on the HERA-funded CeMi (next project) website and accessed by c 500+ visitors. https://cemi-hera.org/diverse-funerary-needs-at-a-time-of-crisis-reflections-on-covid19-in-multicultural-europe/
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Other
Impact Types Cultural,Policy & public services

 
Description Appointment of team member to Bradford Muslim Burial Council
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
Impact Findings and recommendations of the project, including creative solutions to the challenges of ensuring timely burial in local authority cemeteries, have been disseminated with local and National Muslim Burial Council.
 
Description 'Diversity-ready Cemeteries and Crematoria', keynote address, Institute of Cemetery and Crematoria Managers Annual Conference, Oxford. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Avril Maddrell and Yasminah Beebeejaun, gave a presentation on 'Diversity-ready Cemeteries and Crematoria', (invited keynote address) to the Institute of Cemetery and Crematoria Managers Annual Conference, Oxford, 2018 October.
This address, reporting key research project findings and disseminating the project report was given to an audience of c 60 attendees; the project Briefing Note was then made available to all ICCM members via the ICCM website.
ICCM members identified a range of useful insights and changes to be made to practice; they were also invited to participate in a follow up workshop to discuss priorities for developing diversity training materials for the sector c 14 volunteered to participate in this follow up workshop.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Convened workshop on diversity issues in UK cemeteries and crematoria 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact This workshop built on the deathscapes and Diversity project and brought together previous project partners (RTPI and ICCM), project participants and interested professionals recruited through our Keynote address to the ICCM, with a view to identifying a future agenda for developing planning tools and communication channels between cemetery and crematoria service providers and planners, and diverse user groups. It is intended to carry this forward through follow on work.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Death Research Network workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Death Research Network 2 day workshop, University of Fribourg, Switzerland, with researchers and postgraduates, including Crematorium visit.
Presentation on diversity issues in cemeteries and crematoria in UK and Europe.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Deathscapes and Diversity project website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Deathscapes and Diversity webpage, currently used for information about the project; to host blogs, policy-briefing report and a virtual exhibition later in 2018.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018
URL http://blogs.reading.ac.uk/deathscapes-and-diversity/
 
Description Deathscapes and Diversity webpage and blog 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Project webpage with information on the project and project activities, plus blog posts.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018
URL http://blogs.reading.ac.uk/deathscapes-and-diversity/
 
Description Diversity in the Heritage Sector workshop, University of Reading and English Heritage 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Workshop exploring diversity issues in the heritage sector - displays, curation, visitors, audiencing, employment strategy and volunteer base, as well as grassroots exhibitions.

This workshop included academic researchers, Heritage sector professionals from English Heritage, Welsh Heritage, Manx National Heritage and the National Museum of Iceland, museum professionals and third sector participants.
The programme and discussions focused on diversifying exhibitions, visitors and staff/ volunteers.
40 people attended and there was wide spread agreement to apply examples of good practice e.g.: i) including migrants and refugees in exhibition design, ii) interactive elements allowing visitors to respond to exhibits, and iii) more varied methods of volunteer recruitment.

This event also brought representatives from the National Museum of Iceland and Manx National Heritage into dialogue for a second time, developing plans for future collaboration, as well as these partners with representatives of English and Welsh Heritage.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Diversity-Ready Cemeteries and Crematoria in England and Wales Report Launch and workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Diversity-Ready Cemeteries and Crematoria in England and Wales Report Launch and workshop, June 2018, University of Reading

This workshop was attended by project participants, representatives of the Royal Town Planning Institute and the Institute of Cemetery and Crematoria Managers, other professionals from local government and private sector cemetery and funerary services, and academics.
Activities:
1. a presentation was given by the research team of project findings as summarised in the project report
2. invited respondents representing the Royal Town Planning Institute and the Institute of Cemetery and Crematoria Managers, other professionals and participants responded to the project report
3. participants viewed and commented on the visual exhibition to tour case study towns
4. all participants took part in workshop activities exploring needs and future directions
Numerous participants reported new insights and understanding, as well as a desire to contribute to subsequent initiatives/ applied projects stemming from the research.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Katie McClymont presented a public lecture: 'Deathscapes and Diversity: Planning for Death and Remembrance in Multicultural England and Wales' 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Katie McClymont presented a public lecture entitled 'Deathscapes and Diversity: Planning for Death and Remembrance in Multicultural England and Wales' as part of the University of Leeds Living with Dying Series, Tuesday 18th September 2018
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description RTPI South West Young Planners' network event: Planning for Death, Arnos Vale Cemetery 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Katie McClymont spoke at the Royal Town Planning Institute South West Young Planners' network event on 'Planning for Death', Arnos Vale Cemetery
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Touring Exhibition: Diversity-ready cemeteries and crematoria 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Touring Exhibition: Diversity-ready cemeteries and crematoria (July 2018)
Locations: Huddersfield, Northampton, Swindon, Newport
The exhibition was held in order to:
1. disseminate research findings and report to wider audiences including planners, policy-makers and practitioners in case study towns
2. to feed back to participants in case study towns
3. to use exhibition to engage wider audiences from the general public with the project research agenda and findings, including through craft, Lego and design activities, discussions over refreshments and feedback cards

Visitors from a variety of backgrounds reported greater knowledge and understanding of diversity issues and potential strategies in cemeteries and crematoria
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018