Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments: Dance-Based Approaches to Data

Lead Research Organisation: Royal Central Sch of Speech and Drama
Department Name: Faculty

Abstract

While dancers and dance scholars understand movement and gesture to be sites of knowledge production, the field of dance history has been reluctant to adopt data-driven analytic methods, which are presumed to be dematerializing and reductive. Grounded in the specific needs of dance scholarship, 'Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments' engages with emerging digital techniques and technologies from the perspective of dance-based knowledge practices, with the aim to develop a methodology of 'visceral data analysis' that explicitly focuses on data drawn from and reflective of bodily experience. The Fellow's previous collaborative research pioneered the application of scalable digital methods to the field of dance history; this new work focuses on the adaptation of data-driven research to the medium of dance that serves to enable this broader paradigm shift. The new methodology of visceral data analysis will offer an interdisciplinary approach to the challenge of analyzing moving bodies as subjects of data-driven historical inquiry, which will further benefit all fields that grapple with maintaining the complexity of bodies when they are represented as data.

'Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments' draws together individuals and ideas from dance studies, artistic research in dance-technology, archival science, museology, digital humanities, critical data studies, human computer interaction, visual communication, and data science. The Fellow will engage in a three-phase programme of research with Collaborating Organizations and Project Partners, including museums and archives exploring digital innovation (the San-Francisco-based Museum of Dance; the Harry Ransom Center in Austin, Texas; the National Archives of Data on Arts and Culture; The National Archives), emerging technology and design centres at two US universities (Advanced Computing Center for the Arts and Design at The Ohio State University and Augmented Environments Lab at Georgia Institute of Technology), and community dance stakeholders (the US-based Institute for Dunham Technique Certification). In the process, the Fellow will build international peer networks of interdisciplinary and intersectoral interlocutors and develop research leadership by mentoring and inspiring innovative research, including among next generation ECRs. These substantive knowledge exchanges will provide access to technical domain knowledge and resources, enabling the Fellow to address the conceptual and technological challenges of developing data-driven analytic approaches tailored to the medium of dance. Collaborators will benefit from new insights into the qualitative dimensions of visceral data, including what such data may feel like, and how these feelings can translate into palpable visual arguments for historical dance data in the form of digital visualizations and immersive experiences that are guided by choreographic principles.
The Fellow will convene a bi-monthly Visceral Data Discussion Group to establish an interdisciplinary community of practice and shared vocabulary, and ultimately set the trajectory of future research in visceral data analysis. Findings will be disseminated through an edited collection of essays and additional digital and print peer-reviewed publications, including a dataset, an essay, and a research blog, and through scholarly and cultural industries presentations and networking opportunities, and two interactive digital installations. The Fellow will be mentored by an internal mentor who has a track record of leading data-driven research in theatre history, an external CLORE mentor who specializes in arts leadership, and by senior advisors drawn from Partner organizations. Collaboration will provide pathways to impact for Project Partners in the cultural sector to develop and enhance their own practices and ways of working by centering dance-based knowledge in technological innovation, and making dance's historical archives more accessible to broader publics.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Commissioned Series of Dance Data Visualizations for Edges of Ailey 
Description Radical Accounting: Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater's Data as a Framework for Historical Imagination consists of three time-based interventions that were presented in the gallery as part of the Whitney Museum of American Art's Edges of Ailey exhibition, open from September 25th, 2024 through February 9th, 2025. These three time-based interventions transform archival materials to visualize the interconnections of time, space, and bodies across the history of The Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater. The Radical Accounting series traces the retention and transmission of embodied knowledge across generations of dancers. It particularizes how the AAADT grew from a small touring company to a global phenomenon. And it helps us understand the importance of Alvin Ailey not only as a choreographer but also as someone who shared a living history of dance with audiences around the world. The underlying datasets were composed over three years from more than 30,000 documents gathered from archives across the United States. Materials ranged from programs and tour itineraries, to performer diaries and other personal materials, as well as data previously compiled by AAADT. Drawing movement out from static records, the process of intentional data curation and visualization constructs a new framework for historical imagination. Radical accounting brings each artist, performance venue, and choreography into view, foregrounding how dance histories are collective. The Radical Accounting series consists of: "Generations of Embodied Knowledge: The Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater's Dance Artists, 1958-2023", Radical Accounting Series 1 of 3, 2024. Available at: https://whitney.org/media/61535 "Global Architectures: The Alvin Ailey American Dance Theatre, City by City and Year by Year, 1958-89", Radical Accounting Series 2 of 3, 2024. Available at: https://whitney.org/media/61534 "Repertory as Living Dance Museum: The Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater's Performance History, 1958-89", Radical Accounting Series 3 of 3, 2024. Available at: https://whitney.org/media/61533 In the context of the Edges of Ailey exhibition, these visualizations were presented on three 75" screens, near the windows overlooking the Hudson River, a collection of posters, and Ailey's square from the NAMES Project AIDS Memorial Quilt. There is also an accompanying essay with a foldout of static visualizations in the exhibition catalogue. 
Type Of Art Artistic/Creative Exhibition 
Year Produced 2024 
Impact Key Outcomes: - 410,000 visitors to The Edges of Ailey exhibition and associated events - Positive reviews for the exhibition, some of which specifically mention the visualisations - Exhibition made several 'best ten' lists of 2024 - Potential ongoing activity with Alvin Ailey Dance Theatre, and a collaborative relationship with them and the Whitney developed as part of the project - Nominations for the Dance Studies Association 'Dance in the Public Sphere' award and a Data Visualization Society 'Information is Beautiful' award. Both will be announced later in 2025, but at the time of submission, the project had just been longlisted for Information is Beautiful - Creation of a new consultancy company to facilitate future data visualisation work. Key Impacts to Date: - New ways of thinking and doing, influencing creative practice in both the Alvin Ailey archive and the Whitney - Preservation of Ailey archival information in a form that can be displayed and used - Production of new cultural artefacts in the form of the visualisations, a catalogue essay, and online videos - Audience understanding of and engagement with the subject matter in the exhibition Potential impacts The potential impacts of this project are wider than those realised to date and include resources to enable the visualisations to be used in education settings and the use of the techniques and methodologies in other settings. These are currently being investigated by the project with Alvin Ailey's Archivist and include the extension of visualisations to include the whole company history, the development of an online interactive web interface for use in education and marketing and new visualisations to support educational initiatives planned by Ailey. 
URL https://whitney.org/media?search=radical+accounting
 
Description Changed public understandings of dance history; changed museum curation practices; changed organizations' understandings of themselves; changed perspectives on the limitations of data visualization; changed practices in archival storytelling. See Creative Outputs for details.
Sector Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

Societal

 
Description Creative AI Grant for Artificial Intelligence for Creative Movement Analysis and Synthesis: Overcoming racial bias in algorithms for spinal motion tracking in Black dance performance capture.
Amount $44,800 (USD)
Funding ID PI Harmony Bench 
Organisation Ohio State University 
Sector Academic/University
Country United States
Start 01/2023 
 
Description Look at These Oral Histories!: Graphic Recording and Visual Data in Dance Research, PI Seika Boye
Amount $9,945 (CAD)
Organisation University of Toronto 
Sector Academic/University
Country Canada
Start 04/2023 
End 07/2024
 
Description Royal Central School of Speech and Drama, Impact Acceleration Account, 2022-25
Amount £607,329 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/X003418/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2022 
End 03/2026
 
Description Commission from the Whitney Museum of American Art, including further knowledge exchange with Alvin Ailey American Dance Theater 
Organisation Whitney Museum of American Art
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Exhibition visualizations, catalogue essay, datasets.
Collaborator Contribution Commissioned data curation and visualizations for the exhibition Edges of Ailey (September 2024 - February 2025). See URL for press release.
Impact Exhibition visualizations, catalogue essay, datasets.
Start Year 2022
 
Company Name MOVING DATA LLC 
Description Moving Data is a historical data/design consultancy founded in order to hold museum and other commissions resulting from the model of dance historical data curation, analysis, and visualization developed under Dunham's Data, with further research and development conducted under Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments. 
Year Established 2022 
Impact Moving Data is currently finalizing the contract for its first commission with the Whitney Museum of American Art. This is for visualizations that will be exhibited in the upcoming Whitney museum exhibition on choreographer Alvin Ailey, opening in September 2024, plus included in the exhibition catalogue. This provides an opportunity to test the proposition that such methods can change public understandings of dance history. Research conducted in conjunction with this commission is drawing on the in-house archives of the Alvin Ailey American Dance Theatre and the unprocessed collection at the Library of Congress, and will have further impacts with regard to these collections.
 
Description Full List of Public Talks Related to Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact March 2025 . Invited talk for Music, Dance, Drama, and Performing Arts Research Group, University of Portsmouth (UK)
March 2025 . Panel on AI in Performance, Centre for Performance, Technology, and Equity (UK)
January 2025 . OnTAP Podcast, Episode 77 (US)
January 2025 . Archives as Data, Columbia University History Lab (US)
December 2024 . Invited early career researcher workshop for Digital Black Dance Ecologies on Developing a Competitive Research Profile (UK)
November 2024 . Invited talk for Quantitative Theory and Methods and Department of Dance, Emory University (US)
November 2024 . Convened working session for American Society for Theatre Research (US)
October 2024 . Invited talk for the Shapiro Digital History Seminar, Massachusetts Historical Society (US)
September 2024 . Opening for Edges of Ailey, Whitney Museum of American Art (US)
September 2024 . Invited Keynote for Dance Research Matters Conference (UK)
June 2024. Performance Studies international (UK)
May 2024 . Movement Computing Conference (Utrecht)
October 2023 - Invited Keynote for German Society for Dance Research and German Dance Archive Cologne, (Virtual) Ecologies in the Field of Dance (Germany)
October 2023 - Invited Keynote for Data Kinesthetics, MetaLAB, Harvard University (US)
September 2023 - Digital Humanities Research Association (Italy)
September 2023 - Convened Race, Motion Data, and Artificial Intelligence, Second Gathering (UK)
August 2023 - Convened Race, Motion Data, and Artificial Intelligence, First Gathering (US)
July 2023 - Invited Keynote for Discovering Collections, Discovering Communities (DCDC) 2023, Radical Reimagining: Interplays of Physical and Virtual (UK)
June 2023 - Association for Computers and the Humanities (ACH) 2023
February 2023 - Invited talk for National Archive of Data on Arts and Culture/ICPSR, Love Data Week, Ann Arbor (US)
February 2023 - Invited talk for National Dance Education Organization (US)
January 2023 - Invited talk for Body and AI Lecture Series, C-Dare, Coventry University (UK)
December 2022 - Invited talk for UPES School of Liberal Arts, International Conference on Digital Humanities, Dehradun (India)
November 2022 - Invited talk for Newberry Library, Smith Center for the History of Cartography, Kenneth Nebenzahl Jr. Lectures in the History of Cartography, Chicago (US)
October 2022 - Dance Studies Association, Vancouver (Canada)
June 2022 - Movement Computing, Chicago (US)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023,2024,2025
 
Description Gatherings on Race, Motion Data, and Artificial Intelligence 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Gatherings on Race, Motion Data, and Artificial Intelligence held in Columbus and London, co-sponsored with local projects. The first gathering was held in August at The Ohio State University's Advanced Center for Computing in Arts and Design, convened by Crystal Michele Perkins on behalf of Archiving Black Performance: Memory, Embodiment, and Stages of Being and Harmony Bench for Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments: Dance-Based Approaches to Data, and sponsored by OSU's funding for Artificial Intelligence in the Arts, Humanities, and Engineering: Interdisciplinary Collaborations. This second gathering was convened by Tia-Monique Uzor, PI on Digital Black Dance Ecologies, which was recently funded through the AHRC's Dance Research Matters Network call, together with Kate Elswit for Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments: Dance-Based Approaches to Data.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.cssd.ac.uk/blog/race-motion-data-and-artificial-intelligence-gathering-2
 
Description Visceral Histories, Visual Arguments Blog 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Maintained a blog with periodic sharing of research and development related to VHVA
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022,2023,2024,2025
URL https://visceralhistories.wordpress.com/