📣 Help Shape the Future of UKRI's Gateway to Research (GtR)

We're improving UKRI's Gateway to Research and are seeking your input! If you would be interested in being interviewed about the improvements we're making and to have your say about how we can make GtR more user-friendly, impactful, and effective for the Research and Innovation community, please email gateway@ukri.org.

Adolescent Parenthoods and Culture in Latin America

Lead Research Organisation: University of Kent
Department Name: Sch of Cultures and Languages

Abstract

This project investigates adolescent sexual and reproductive health (ASRH) and young parenthood in Mexico, Cuba and Colombia through three intersecting questions: (i) how does cultural production reflect and regulate understandings of ASRH and young parenthood? (ii) how do cultural representations work with or against ASRH policy and initiatives by governments and NGOs? (iii) how do such interventions correspond to the needs and lived realities of adolescents, especially young parents? Each line of enquiry will expand our understanding of teenage parenthood and improve the impact of future interventions.

Adolescent pregnancy is increasing in many Latin American countries, with significant negative social, economic and health-related consequences. Young mothers have often been the victims of sexual violence, and are also vulnerable to forms of obstetric violence. Teenage parenthood obstructs access to education, hinders social mobility and entrenches poverty, making teen parents and their babies more vulnerable to disease and death. Such outcomes are worse still in contexts marked by gendered violence, marginalisation and precarity. Despite broader advances in maternal health, in Mexico, Cuba and Colombia, adolescent pregnancy remains stubbornly high, especially within the local settings (Morelos and Granma) that this project foregrounds.

Statistical data dominates existing research in this area, obscuring a much needed understanding of the social and cultural factors that influence sexual behaviour, fertility choices (including early marriage), and access to ASRH services including abortion. During adolescence, as social norms become ingrained, culture takes on greater personal relevance. Many studies see education as key to preventing unwanted pregnancies. However, each of the three contexts are paradoxically characterised by atypically high investments in ASRH resources and education. Research has not satisfactorily explained why both unplanned and planned adolescent pregnancies continue to rise in the region.

This project engages a novel approach in investigating the limited success of existing policy and interventions. It focuses on the intersection of cultural production, policy, and lived experiences. First, the PI will examine the powerful but under-researched role that cultural production plays in reflecting and shaping ASRH, by analysing representations of adolescent sexuality, sexual violence, pregnancy and parenthood in contemporary digital and popular culture (television, film, vlogging, social media), and by interviewing cultural producers. Second, through a systematic review of current ASRH policy and initiatives in the three contexts, the PI will consider how these cultural representations reinforce or disrupt state and NGO interventions. Third, the project will analyse disjunctures between policy approaches to ASRH and their lived realities in local settings, through two creative workshops for young parents co-hosted by local organisations in Morelos (Mexico) and Granma (Cuba), which will engage cultural expression as a participatory method for both research and impact.

In order to foster an interdisciplinary, comparative and collaborative approach to these questions, the project will also bring the three contexts in dialogue through the development of an international research network. The network will directly engage local and national policymakers, regional development actors, NGOs, arts organisations, and media outlets. The project seeks to expand knowledge in terms of how ASRH is shaped by culture, and also positively influence future ASRH policy and initiatives, enhance public awareness of ASRH issues, and have a social impact on young people and their communities. Findings will be shared via conference presentations, a website, a podcast episode, a briefing document, a methodological toolkit, blog posts, and academic publications.

Related Projects

Project Reference Relationship Related To Start End Award Value
AH/W007479/1 16/01/2023 30/08/2023 £193,824
AH/W007479/2 Transfer AH/W007479/1 31/08/2023 15/01/2025 £152,029
 
Description The first two years of the APLA project have resulted in several publications, public engagement events, new findings in the field of and new collaborations which we hope will lead to significant impact.

The project's field trips were very fruitful in terms of the very rich data they allowed us to collect and in terms of developing links with researchers and partner organisations. Between April and June 2024, we held a series of creative workshops and symposia in Mexico, Cuba, and Colombia to explore the experiences of adolescent mothers and engage with professionals working in the field of teenage pregnancy.

In Cuernavaca (Mexico), Bayamo (Cuba), and Bogotá (Colombia), young mothers participated in creative workshops where they shared their journeys through drawing exercises, body mapping, and individual interviews. These sessions provided a safe space for them to reflect on and express their experiences of pregnancy and motherhood. Many brought their babies and toddlers to the sessions. The workshops revealed many new findings:
Alongside the workshops, we hosted symposia that brought together academics, healthcare professionals, social workers, and policymakers. These discussions, held in Mexico and Cuba, focused on the realities of adolescent pregnancy, barriers to prevention, and challenges in supporting young mothers. Experts from government agencies, social care agencies and NGOs shared invaluable insights on policy and frontline work.

Original findings gave a detailed picture of the lived experience of young motherhood in three distinct contexts, with expected impact on programme design. (Research in this field tends to be large-scale and statistics-driven, obscuring the social and cultural dynamics, such as cultural norms - often operating at a local level - which play a role in the understanding and exercise of adolescent reproductive and sexual behaviours). Our findings indicate that a) age-gap relationships were very common; b) all participants experience different forms of violence and social stigma; c) participants also reported increased respect from others after becoming a mother; d) narratives also reveal resilience and dedication to their children as well as motivation to reach personal goals - motherhood is viewed as a source of joy and duty, a destiny fulfilled; e) Families are the main source of support to young mothers, while partners' support is inconsistent. Young mothers had limited knowledge of government support. This discrepancy between policies of pregnancy prevention and support for young mothers is expected to have an impact in contributing to policy to be more inclusive.

This project was designed to focus on the intersection of cultural production, policy, and lived experiences, a novel approach in order to investigate the limited success of existing policy and interventions. It began with three intersecting questions: (i) how does cultural production reflect and regulate understandings of ASRH and young parenthood? (ii) how do cultural representations work with or against ASRH policy and initiatives by governments and NGOs? (iii) how do such interventions correspond to the needs and lived realities of adolescents, especially young parents?
In relation to the first and second objectives, the PI has begun to examine cultural production played in reflecting and shaping ASRH by analyzing representations of adolescent sexuality, sexual violence, pregnancy, and parenthood in contemporary digital and popular culture (television, film, vlogging, social media) and by interviewing cultural producers. This work will continue and will be shared in the form of academic publications, likely a monograph.
The project's researchers have analysed disjunctures between policy approaches to ASRH and their lived realities in local settings through three creative workshops for young parents co-hosted by local organizations in Morelos (Mexico) and Granma (Cuba), which engaged cultural expression as a participatory method of co-production. These findings have so far been published in a policy report (published in English and Spanish) and accompanying visual summaries. We plan to publish further reports sharing the findings from Cuba and Colombia. Further forthcoming publications include an edited book ('Ser mamá joven: localizando el embarazo adolescente en América Latina'/ Being a young mother: situating teenage pregnancy in Latin America) which will bring together scholarship analysing the needs and lived realities of young parents in the region and emphasising local dynamics affecting sexual and reproductive health.
Exploitation Route In terms of the impact of the project, we hope to make a case for programme design to account for the strong relevance of cultural norms which impact young people's relationships, views on contraception and their expectations of parenthood as well as explicitly acknowledge how structural and sexual violence limits reproductive agency in young people. The analysis of 'cultural scaffolding' to poor adolescent sexual and reproductive health are expected to highlight harmful norms and will be circulated via visual summaries to stakeholders. In addition, we recommend that programmes aimed at adolescent sexual and reproductive health foreground emotional and financial support of young mothers rather than focus predominantly on the prevention of pregnancy. Impact will be measured in terms of how addressing norms become part of programme design.
Sectors Healthcare

Government

Democracy and Justice

 
Description New collaboration with the Ministry of Education, State of Morelos (Mexico) 
Organisation Government of Mexico
Department Mexican Ministry of Education
Country Mexico 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution The Ministry of Education or SEP (Secretaria de Educacion Publica) in Morelos has replaced the Instituto de la Mujer para el Estado de Morelos (IMM), as one of the project partners. This change relates to a change of leadership in the IMM and a requested change by the new director to participate in the project as research participant rather than official project partner. The collaboration with the Ministry of Education means greater potential for policy impact. The contributions made by the research team to this collaboration are the organisation of a research symposium in April 2024, which will bring researchers together from different research institutions and international contexts and facilitate an exchange of expertise with direct usefulness to adolescent sexual/ reproductive health policy. The findings of the project will be shared with project partner via a briefing document.
Collaborator Contribution The SEP host the symposium and creative workshop. In hosting the workshop, the SEP will serve as a crucial gatekeeper to facilitate and safeguard the participation of young parents.
Impact No outcomes yet
Start Year 2024
 
Description Policymaker and Practitioner Symposium 17 May 2024 in Bayamo, Cuba 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact In our second symposia in Cuba, and together with project co-I Dr Diurkis Madrigal Leon, we brought together local professionals from a municipality of Bayamo, Granma province, who work on the front line with adolescent mothers. This included social workers, healthcare professionals, educators, and local representatives of Cuban government organisations. We were exceptionally grateful to hear from these professionals who work intimately with the local community and shared with us their invaluable knowledge and experience about the realities of young parents and adolescents in South East Cuba today.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://sites.google.com/sheffield.ac.uk/maternidadadolescentelatam/home?authuser=0
 
Description Policymaker and Practitioner Symposium 19 April 2024 in Cuernavaca, Mexico 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact In the first of our symposia, we brought together academics and frontline professionals, who work with adolescent mothers or on the topic of teenage pregnancy in Cuernavaca and the state of Morelos. We first heard presentations from Dr Catherine Menkes and Dr Itzel Sosa Sanchez from CRIM-UNAM regarding the prevalence of teenage pregnancy in Mexico, shared some preliminary findings from our creative workshop in Cuernavaca, and then opened the floor for a semi-structured roundtable in which professionals from a variety of different sectors, including higher education, social work, and healthcare. We were glad to have representatives attending from various government agencies including IMPAJOVEN, IMMS, ISSSTE, and INSP. We felt very privileged to have heard from so many frontline professionals and were very thankful for their openness and eagerness to discuss the existing barriers to teen pregnancy prevention, as well as obstacles for supporting already existing adolescent mothers in the state of Morelos and beyond.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://sites.google.com/sheffield.ac.uk/maternidadadolescentelatam/home?authuser=0
 
Description Project Website 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The website (created by project colleagues) shared information about project outputs, outcomes and preliminary findings.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024,2025
URL https://sites.google.com/sheffield.ac.uk/maternidadadolescentelatam/home?authuser=0
 
Description Symposium 21 May 2024 in Bayamo, Cuba 
Form Of Engagement Activity A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact In the second of our symposia in Cuba, we brought together local professionals from Bayamo, Cuba, mainly from government organisations that work on policy relating to teenage pregnancy, as well as frontline educators and campaigners. As always, we were very grateful to hear from these professionals who were embedded in the local community and shared with us their invaluable knowledge and experience of policy and how it relates to the realities of young parents and adolescents in the area.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://sites.google.com/sheffield.ac.uk/maternidadadolescentelatam/home?authuser=0
 
Description Webinar with Profamilia 23 September 2024 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I recently participated in a live webinar for project partner Profamilia (government-funded and the largest reproductive rights group in Colombia). The webinar had 103 registrations; 45 international attendees, and was included as part of their international Week of Pregnancy Prevention in Children and Adolescents. Webinar attendees commented that it was "a space for great learning".
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2024
URL https://sites.google.com/sheffield.ac.uk/maternidadadolescentelatam/home?authuser=0