Enacting Gregory Bateson's Ecological Aesthetics in Architecture and Design

Lead Research Organisation: University of Brighton
Department Name: Sch of Architecture Tech & Eng (SATE)

Abstract

Social and ecological transformation requires design and architecture fields to develop new, more expansive, ways of thinking and acting that better engage questions of ecology. This project examines how the work of anthropologist and cybernetician Gregory Bateson (1904-1980) might contribute an alternative frame of action to navigate this challenge. Drawing on the concerns of Bateson's later work, the project asks: What forms of thinking and acting can work through the particular complexities of environmental crises in the contexts of design and architecture, bridging between rich ecological ideas and the practical challenges of concrete situations?

As early as the 1960s, Bateson argued that the environmental crisis resulted from a broader crisis of ideas and the forms of organisation that resulted from this. Bateson criticised piecemeal approaches to environmental action in ways that continue to resonate today. By addressing only those 'problems' that are identifiable and solvable, one acts only on parts of an ecosystem, with unpredictable consequences that reverberate through the whole. Drawing on their anthropological work, Bateson pointed to various aesthetic practices that support fuller ecosystemic engagements. This idea of an 'ecological aesthetics' opens up new possibilities (as well as challenges) for creative disciplines in contributing substantial responses to environmental crises, in contrast to where environmental concerns are seen primarily through the lens of technology.

While there are a number of resonances between Bateson's work and the contexts of architecture and design, engaging Bateson's ideas is inevitably complex. Mobilising Bateson's work is not simply a matter of better articulating its concepts - these are ideas that need to be enacted not just explained. In later work, Bateson attempted to address the overly complex character of their ideas, reworking them in ways that were more open to practical contexts, often through forms of dialogue where form and content intersect. Taking its point of departure from these aspects of Bateson's work, the project explores, develops, and critiques Bateson's ideas in varied contexts of practice. These include: (1) a prototype installation for enriching urban eco-systems; (2) communication design mapping of Bateson's concepts across ecological domains; (3) storytelling that engages with pre-rational forms of knowing to speculate on alternative technology futures; and (4) the development of new modes of dialogical engagement. Coming out of these activities, the team will work collaboratively to produce accessible resources such as maps, illustrations, and games that can support new forms of engagement with Bateson's ideas amongst students, teachers, researchers, and practitioners in design and architecture.
 
Title Weimar prototype 
Description A responsive wood insect hotel, installed on a wall on the campus in Weimar. The artefact is part of an evolving series of designs by Davidova and the Stuttgart research team, that support urban biodiversity. As well as research on the effectiveness of the prototype, it will be used to explore Bateson's ideas about ecological aesthetics in a subsequent research meeting. The installation of the artefact itself involved collaborations between the Stuttgart research team and design students at Weimar, creating initial connections between the artefact and the local community on the campus. 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2023 
Impact It is too early to report on this, as it takes time to for species to make use of the prototype, and public engagement is planned for when it has had time to develop further. 
URL https://www.enactingecologicalaesthetics.com/installation-pol-ai2-prototype/
 
Title COLife_00 - Gigamap and Fabrication Data 
Description The dataset covers codesign gigamapping data and the 3d parametric models from Rhino 3d of a set of responsive wood insect hotels with pollinator's gardens from the year 2022/23. The first set of gigamaps are for the first intervention POL-AI1, the second for its iteration POL-AI2 within the 'Enacting Bateson Ecological Aesthetics in Architecture and Design' group. The first, POL-AI I, gigamapping was a sequence of codesign workshops achieved through a teaching block 'Synergetic Transformations' held with Leonie Fischer. This codesign information was turned into the fabrication drawings and installed in Seidenstrasse 36, Stuttgart in 2022. The iteration POL-AI II was installed at the Bauhaus University of Weimar at Geschwister-Scholl-Strasse 13 in 2023. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2024 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Development of protype installation at Bauhaus Weimar. 
URL https://darus.uni-stuttgart.de/citation?persistentId=doi:10.18419/darus-3981
 
Title COLife_01 - Gigamap and DIY Files 
Description The data cover codesigned gigamap and parametric and analogue DIY files of BioDiveIn more-than-human intervention. The gigamap was a product of digital participation in the Miro platform, updated by analogue workshops with stakeholders in feedback loops. The data were produced in the winter semester 2022/23 as a part of the design studio 'COLife: More-than-Human Perspective to CoDesign'. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2024 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Supporting ongoing prototype installation development. 
URL https://darus.uni-stuttgart.de/citation?persistentId=doi:10.18419/darus-3983
 
Title COLife_02 - Gigamap and Game Design 
Description The dataset covers a gigamapping of game design and execution of the game GoCOLife that introduces a more-than-human perspective to the players. The data were produced as part of a studio course 'COLife: More-than-Human Perspective to CoDesign' in the summer semester 2024. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2024 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Supporting ongoing prototype development. 
URL https://darus.uni-stuttgart.de/citation?persistentId=doi:10.18419/darus-3985
 
Title COLife_03 - Gigamap and DIY 
Description The dataset presents the more-than-human intervention, its codesigned gigamap that leads to it and DIY recipes for its reproduction. The dataset was achieved during the winter semester 2023/24. The gigamap was in feedback loops codesigned digitally in the Miro platform and analogue on the printouts. The DIY recipe is foldable to the user's pocket as well as unfoldable for a better overview. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2024 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Supporting ongoing prototype development. 
URL https://darus.uni-stuttgart.de/citation?persistentId=doi:10.18419/darus-3986
 
Description UK-German Collaboration 
Organisation Bauhaus University, Weimar
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The project is jointly funded by the AHRC and DFG, with research teams in the UK (Brighton, RCA, Bath Spa) and Germany (Weimar, Stuttgart). The teams are working together fluidly across national boundaries, with regular (weekly or fortnightly) online meetings as well as the main in person research events.
Collaborator Contribution The German partners have contributed their expertise in a variety of areas, including in exploring Bateson's positionality and in relating Bateson's thinking to contemporary developments in systemic design. The Weimar team have also led on the engagement aspects of the research, including the public conversation series.
Impact All aspects of the project are happening in the context of this collaboration. The following engagement events have all be collaborative across the UK and Germany teams: 'Engagement with academic community at Brighton', 'Engagement with academic community at RCA', 'Gregory Bateson at Esalen'. The 'Root Metaphors' conference proceedings is co-authored by UK and German (Weimar) team members. Please note that the German partners are funded by the DFG part of the grant, and so have a different reporting process and grant number. I have included these items in this report, but the German partners will have acknowledged the funding using the DFG reference numbers. Outputs from the Stuttgart partners include the datasets (all submitted), artefact ('Weimar prototype'), and Davidova's two publications ('BioDivIN' and 'COLIfe'). The 'Conversation series' engagement event series has been led by the Weimar partners.
Start Year 2023
 
Description UK-German Collaboration 
Organisation University of Stuttgart
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The project is jointly funded by the AHRC and DFG, with research teams in the UK (Brighton, RCA, Bath Spa) and Germany (Weimar, Stuttgart). The teams are working together fluidly across national boundaries, with regular (weekly or fortnightly) online meetings as well as the main in person research events.
Collaborator Contribution The German partners have contributed their expertise in a variety of areas, including in exploring Bateson's positionality and in relating Bateson's thinking to contemporary developments in systemic design. The Weimar team have also led on the engagement aspects of the research, including the public conversation series.
Impact All aspects of the project are happening in the context of this collaboration. The following engagement events have all be collaborative across the UK and Germany teams: 'Engagement with academic community at Brighton', 'Engagement with academic community at RCA', 'Gregory Bateson at Esalen'. The 'Root Metaphors' conference proceedings is co-authored by UK and German (Weimar) team members. Please note that the German partners are funded by the DFG part of the grant, and so have a different reporting process and grant number. I have included these items in this report, but the German partners will have acknowledged the funding using the DFG reference numbers. Outputs from the Stuttgart partners include the datasets (all submitted), artefact ('Weimar prototype'), and Davidova's two publications ('BioDivIN' and 'COLIfe'). The 'Conversation series' engagement event series has been led by the Weimar partners.
Start Year 2023
 
Description Conversation series 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact A series of conversation events, organised by Dulmini Perera. Four online events, and one in person. The events have explored the ideas of the project in relation to a variety of scholarly perspectives on Bateson's work, and opened up the project to a public audience. The most prominent event was held as part of the American Society for Cybernetics speaker series, and attracted over 100 attendees. The audience has been a variety of those interested in or just curious about Bateson's work, including students, designers, and practitioners and researchers in different fields. One outcome of the events has been the development of interest in design about Bateson scholars in other disciplines.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023,2024
URL https://www.enactingecologicalaesthetics.com/events/
 
Description Engagement with academic community at RCA 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact At the RCA, we presented the ideas of the project around 'the double bind of design' to the community of students and staff, in an evening event. The event featured a lecture (Goodbun) and a panel discussion featuring the other members of the team.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.enactingecologicalaesthetics.com/5290-2/
 
Description Engagement with academic community at University of Brighton 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact At the Brighton research event, we held two seminars that explored ideas from the project in relation to research and teaching interests in the department. These connected members of the research team from other institutions with staff at Brighton not involved in the project, and with the community of students, especially postgraduate students in MA Sustainable Design.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Gregory Bateson at Esalen 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact As part of the research visit to California (primarily to visit archives located at UC Santa Cruz), we held a seminar at Esalen, a counter cultural retreat centre with which Bateson was closely associated. We presented an introduction to Bateson to a small group of guests and staff, who were mostly not aware of Bateson before hand. The event, and exchanges with staff around it, has contributed to ongoing activity by Esalen in re-engaging with its history.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.enactingecologicalaesthetics.com/gregory-bateson-and-esalen/