Making the invisible, visible: co-creating novel approaches to endometriosis pain communication
Lead Research Organisation:
Manchester Metropolitan University
Department Name: Health, Psychology & Communities Res Ctr
Abstract
Endometriosis is a debilitating gynaecological condition in which tissue similar to the uterine lining is found outside the uterus. It affects one in ten women from puberty to menopause in the UK equating to around 17,000 people in Manchester city, and around 70,000 in Greater Manchester. Symptoms include painful periods, chronic pelvic pain, bowel and bladder problems, and difficulty getting pregnant. The average diagnosis takes 8 years and there are often multiple misdiagnoses during this time. Two key issues relating to pain have been identified as contributing to delayed/misdiagnosis: (1) perceived deficiencies in communication to effectively describe pain symptoms in early consultations and (2) perceptions of pain normalisation and dismissal from healthcare professionals. Our previous work has identified that people with endometriosis tend to use vivid imagery and metaphor to communication their pain, such as feelings of 'being stabbed by a thousand tiny men' and 'like barbed wire wrapped around my womb', which can be useful in making sense of the experience. However, our work has also identified that people with endometriosis do not always feel confident or have the physical resources to support them in having effective conversations about their pain. This project brings together health psychology, linguistics, and art and design to engage members of the public living with endometriosis in the co-creation of novel approaches to communicating pain, collated into a pain communication toolkit. This toolkit can be used to overcome the identified barriers to effective pain communication and to support conversations that can contribute to enhanced communication and understanding of endometriosis, along with reduced diagnosis delay.
This project will involve collaborations between Manchester Metropolitan University's Department of Psychology and School of Art, Arts for Recovery in the Community (ARC), Endometriosis UK, The Language of Endometriosis, Helen Mather (artist and educator with lived experience of endometriosis), and Manchester & Salford Pain Centre. Members of the public with endometriosis will participate in workshops hosted at the Arc Centre where they will co-create visual artefacts representative of their endometriosis pain which can be collated into a pain communication toolkit that also integrates health psychology theory and behavioural science to encourage effective communication behaviours. The draft toolkit will then be shared with the original workshop participants along with healthcare professionals from Manchester & Salford Pain Centre in further workshops at the Arc Centre to support the development of a broader understanding of how the resource can support two-way communication in a doctor-patient scenario. This will result in a co-created dissemination plan to ensure the toolkit will reach the groups that those with endometriosis feel need to use it and who can make a difference to their experiences. Feedback collated will be integrated into a final version of the pain communication toolkit.
At the conclusion of the project, original workshop participants, along with their friends and family members, will be invited to a launch event, where the final pain communication toolkit will be shared. This launch event will also mark the start of a 6-week exhibition of the physical artefacts at the Arc Centre, which any member of the public may visit to learn more about endometriosis. A dedicated webpage will document the life of the project, and a short film will document the process of developing the toolkit. The toolkit will then undergo further evaluation work and will be shared with anyone with an interest in endometriosis pain communication.
This project will involve collaborations between Manchester Metropolitan University's Department of Psychology and School of Art, Arts for Recovery in the Community (ARC), Endometriosis UK, The Language of Endometriosis, Helen Mather (artist and educator with lived experience of endometriosis), and Manchester & Salford Pain Centre. Members of the public with endometriosis will participate in workshops hosted at the Arc Centre where they will co-create visual artefacts representative of their endometriosis pain which can be collated into a pain communication toolkit that also integrates health psychology theory and behavioural science to encourage effective communication behaviours. The draft toolkit will then be shared with the original workshop participants along with healthcare professionals from Manchester & Salford Pain Centre in further workshops at the Arc Centre to support the development of a broader understanding of how the resource can support two-way communication in a doctor-patient scenario. This will result in a co-created dissemination plan to ensure the toolkit will reach the groups that those with endometriosis feel need to use it and who can make a difference to their experiences. Feedback collated will be integrated into a final version of the pain communication toolkit.
At the conclusion of the project, original workshop participants, along with their friends and family members, will be invited to a launch event, where the final pain communication toolkit will be shared. This launch event will also mark the start of a 6-week exhibition of the physical artefacts at the Arc Centre, which any member of the public may visit to learn more about endometriosis. A dedicated webpage will document the life of the project, and a short film will document the process of developing the toolkit. The toolkit will then undergo further evaluation work and will be shared with anyone with an interest in endometriosis pain communication.
People |
ORCID iD |
Jasmine Hearn (Principal Investigator) | |
Ian Whadcock (Co-Investigator) |
Title | Endometriosis pain artefacts |
Description | Participant-generated physical artefacts and digital copies of artefacts that represent endometriosis pain. |
Type Of Art | Artefact (including digital) |
Year Produced | 2023 |
Impact | All artefacts have been used in our endometriosis pain communication toolkit, and in pilot testing this toolkit has noted to help stimulate significant changes in public attitudes and perceptions of endometriosis. A selection of artefacts will also be available to view in the project exhibition which will take place from 28th March - 9th May. |
Title | Endometriosis pain exhibition |
Description | Exhibition of the 'making endometriosis visible' project at the Arc Centre, Stockport. This will include elements of the toolkit, posters and banners, participant-generated artefacts (both physical and digital), and participant quotes (from people with endometriosis and healthcare professionals). |
Type Of Art | Artistic/Creative Exhibition |
Year Produced | 2024 |
Impact | tbc - the exhibition starts on Saturday 30th March - 11th May 2024 |
URL | https://arc-centre.org/exhibition-making-endometriosis-visible/ |
Description | This award has led to the development of multiple key resources: a finalised endometriosis communication toolkit, which has been piloted with people with endometriosis and in healthcare settings (though requires further evaluation), with preliminary data demonstrating its effectiveness in improving understanding and communication of endometriosis pain, and public and health professional attitudes towards endometriosis. We have also developed a short film which summarises the project, which will be shared at the launch event and exhibition for the project on 28th March 2024. The work is anticipated to transform the doctor-patient consultation experience in the context of endometriosis. The work may be scaled up and rolled out nationally, leading to new ways of working with people with endometriosis and improving patient experience and satisfaction with care, along with reduced stigma/normalisation and diagnosis delay. There is scope for this work to be adapted to support communication in a variety of pain conditions beyond endometriosis pain using the model used in this project. - For people with endometriosis, healthcare professionals involved in their care, and for organisations supporting people living with endometriosis, we have demonstrated an enhanced understanding of and confidence in communicating about endometriosis pain and its impact between people with endometriosis and healthcare professionals in medical consultations as a result of the activities undertaken in the project. - We have enhanced the understanding of social engagement and sensitive design practice in MA Design for Health and Wellbeing students who may choose to study endometriosis and design further. - There has been important knowledge transfer on ethics and evaluation of public engagement in sensitive and gendered health-related issues between Manchester Metropolitan University, Manchester School of Art, and The Arc Centre, such as working with vulnerable people and health services, leading to greater engagement with people with endometriosis in arts-based initiatives. This collaborative relationship has been established and strengthened across the project (between Manchester Metropolitan University and Arc, and along with Endometriosis UK), resulting in enhanced awareness and implementation of interdisciplinary arts-based research in women's health at the Arc Centre. This has contributed to increased footfall at the Arc centre, demonstrating community value of the project to the Arc Centre and wider community (and enhanced awareness of Arc as a mental health charity). - A website and short film have been developed to capture the project and enhance public engagement with healthcare (in this case, endometriosis) through arts-based approaches. These have not been launched yet but will be monitored in terms of engagements/accesses and are anticipated to enhance public awareness and influence attitudes towards endometriosis pain and arts-based research. - The project has also resulted in the launch of a 'Making Endometriosis Visible' exhibition, which will be launched at the Arc Centre on 28th March. This captures key learning from the project, the toolkit, the film, and will also share the artefacts created by project participants. This is anticipated to increase footfall at the Arc Centre, awareness of the Arc Centre's work, and will enhance public understandings of, and will change attitudes towards, endometriosis and endometriosis pain, to contribute towards greater societal awareness of the condition. |
Exploitation Route | The work will transform the doctor-patient consultation experience in the context of endometriosis. The work may be scaled up and rolled out nationally (by researchers and healthcare providers) for use in clinical settings (such as psychological therapy), leading to new ways of working with people with endometriosis and improving patient experience and satisfaction with care, along with reduced stigma/normalisation and diagnosis delay. The toolkit may also be used in non-clinical settings such as peer support groups or friend/family networks to enhance shared understandings of endometriosis pain. There is scope for this work to be adapted to support communication in a variety of pain conditions beyond endometriosis pain using the model used in this project. |
Sectors | Education Healthcare Culture Heritage Museums and Collections |
Description | Making the invisible, visible: Endometriosis is a debilitating gynaecological condition that causes painful periods, chronic pelvic pain, fatigue, and poorer mental health. It affects around 1 in 10 women in the UK, which equates to around 17,000 women in Greater Manchester, where this research project is located. However, it can be really difficult to describe endometriosis pain to others. We're forced to rely on our language to communicate pain, but this language can feel particularly inadequate with endometriosis since the pain isn't visible to others and where it remains a condition that is not commonly talked about in the public domain. The 'Making endometriosis visible' project used an interdisciplinary blend of psychology and art and design to work with women with endometriosis to co-create these visualisations in workshops hosted at Arc Centre, Hat Works, Stockport. We worked with colleagues from across Manchester Met to facilitate conversations about endometriosis using participatory creative workshop methods to surface the lived experience of endometriosis pain, and its impact on daily life. As a way of publishing and making available the workshop outcomes we have collated the participant visualisations and insights into the endometriosis toolkit, which we hope can be used to support effective communication about endometriosis pain and enable people to feel more understood. Whilst we have tested the toolkit, further refinements are required in future research. However, there are a number of tangible impacts that have been identified from the work so far: - Collaborative relationships have been established and strengthened across the project (between Manchester Metropolitan University and Arc, and Endometriosis UK), resulting in enhanced awareness and implementation of interdisciplinary arts-based research in women's health at the Arc Centre. This has contributed to increased footfall at the Arc centre, demonstrating community value of the project to the Arc Centre and wider community (and enhanced awareness of Arc as a mental health charity). - Members of the public and healthcare professionals have been engaged in public involvement workshops to develop understandings of endometriosis pain, and to change attitudes and practices towards endometriosis. This has been captured in both people with endometriosis, who have reported finding it useful to use arts-based approaches to communicate their lived experience as a result of participating in our workshops and using the draft toolkit, and in health professionals, who have reported that the toolkit has enabled them to reach a more nuanced understanding and appreciation of endometriosis and women's health more generally. - A website and short film have been developed to capture the project and enhance public engagement with healthcare (in this case, endometriosis) through arts-based approaches. These have not been launched yet but will be monitored in terms of engagements/accesses and are anticipated to enhance public awareness and influence attitudes towards endometriosis pain and arts-based research. - The project has also resulted in the launch of a 'Making Endometriosis Visible' exhibition, which will be launched at the Arc Centre on 28th March. This captures key learning from the project, the toolkit, the film, and will also share the artefacts created by project participants. This is anticipated to increase footfall at the Arc Centre, awareness of the Arc Centre's work, and will enhance public understandings of, and will change attitudes towards, endometriosis and endometriosis pain, to contribute towards greater societal awareness of the condition. - This work has also resulted in the development of training materials, which have been delivered to postgraduate Design students, and postgraduate Psychology students, thereby enhancing their awareness of the research methods used in the project, and upskilling them in ethical, sensitive, and collaborative research methods. |
First Year Of Impact | 2023 |
Sector | Education,Healthcare,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections |
Impact Types | Cultural Societal Policy & public services |
Description | Training materials for postgraduate students - MSc Health Psychology, MA Design for Health |
Geographic Reach | Local/Municipal/Regional |
Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
Description | Endometriosis UK |
Organisation | Endometriosis UK |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Charity/Non Profit |
PI Contribution | Expertise in developing and conducting the project, and sharing of findings to Endometriosis UK for use in their work supporting people with endometriosis. |
Collaborator Contribution | Endometriosis UK reviewed and supported the project in its development and shared the call for participants with their membership/mailing lists. |
Impact | n/a |
Start Year | 2023 |
Description | Manchester School of Art |
Organisation | Manchester Metropolitan University |
Department | Manchester School of Art |
Country | United Kingdom |
Sector | Academic/University |
PI Contribution | The PI for this project has contributed time and expertise, including intellectual input and training of sub-contractors. |
Collaborator Contribution | The co-investigator for this project is employed at the Manchester School of Art, and has contributed time and expertise, including intellectual input and training of sub-contractors. They have also provided access to specialist equipment (such as photography/film equipment) and facilities for photography. |
Impact | Multidisciplinary collaboration - psychology and art and design |
Start Year | 2023 |
Title | Endometriosis Pain Communication Toolkit |
Description | Draft of the endometriosis pain communication toolkit funded by the Arts and Humanities Research Council. This will be exhibited across March, April and May at the Arc Centre, Stockport for further feedback from members of the public. We will seek further funding to formally evaluate the effectiveness of the toolkit. |
Type | Therapeutic Intervention - Psychological/Behavioural |
Current Stage Of Development | Refinement. Non-clinical |
Year Development Stage Completed | 2024 |
Development Status | Actively seeking support |
Impact | So far in preliminary review workshops we have noted improved understanding of endometriosis pain as a result of the toolkit. We have also noted enhanced understanding of and implementation of multidisciplinary research methods and ethics in the context of endometriosis pain research. |
Description | Exhibition at ARC |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Regional |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | A 6-week exhibition of the funded work takes place from 28th March to 10th April at the ARC Centre in Stockport for members of the public, study participants, and other audiences engaged in working in chronic pain or in the charitable sector. We have a visitor comment book that will be available and will monitor attendance at the exhibition. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
Description | Making Endometriosis Visible Website |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | A website is currently in development to host imagery and outputs from the project and to engage the public, professionals, students, study participants, and carers in further discussion on the topic of endometriosis pain. The website is under construction and has not yet been shared widely with the public (hence the low numbers of people reached with the activity so far). |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
URL | https://makingendometriosisvisible.org/ |
Description | Short film |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press) |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Public/other audiences |
Results and Impact | A 5-minute film capturing the funded work to promote the findings and disseminate more widely. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |
Description | Workshops with people with endometriosis and healthcare professionals |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Study participants or study members |
Results and Impact | 15 healthcare professionals and 15 study participants took part in workshops to review the draft toolkit and provide feedback for further development. Participants reported useful feedback that captured a change in perceptions about and understanding of endometriosis and endometriosis pain. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023,2024 |