National Trust libraries: an untapped resource. A pilot study of Italian holdings at Belton House, Lincolnshire

Lead Research Organisation: University of Cambridge
Department Name: Italian

Abstract

The National Trust owns and manages over 150 properties in the United Kingdom that contain collections of books, the majority still housed in the buildings where they were assembled and read by their original owners. Between forty and fifty of the libraries in National Trust properties have been described as being of 'major national significance' (Purcell and Shenton, 2005). The contents of these libraries constitute an unparalleled resource for the study of the history of private book ownership in the United Kingdom. To date, comparatively little work has been done on most of these collections, although the process of cataloguing the major libraries is underway and ongoing, the results accessible to researchers on the Copac Catalogue as they become available.

This network project will function as a pilot study, in order to showcase future research potential in these exciting collections, which form an intrinsic part of our national cultural heritage. The network will bring together interested parties from a variety of backgrounds to discuss initial findings and collaborate on the way forward in future.

The pilot study will shed light on one aspect of the long and intricate history of these various libraries, by examining the place of Italian books in an English great house library in the wake of the Reformation. The relationship between Italy and England in the early modern period is particularly rich and complex. On the one hand, Italy acted as a cultural reference point for English writers, dramatists, artists, architects, who looked to that country for models and inspiration, while at the same time religious differences divided the countries of Catholic and reformed Europe. How far do the Italian books in an English library from this period reveal the tensions inherent in the relationship between the two countries, and what can they tell us about the reception and understanding of Italian culture and history in England in the early modern period?

The pilot study will take place at Belton House in Lincolnshire. Belton houses the Trust's second largest library (over 11,000 titles), assembled by successive generations of the Brownlow family, and the collection has been fully catalogued. Within this rich and varied library are 229 works in Italian published between 1500 and 1800, across a variety of genres and subjects. A full analysis of these Italian holdings (conducted by the PI, a specialist in Italian literary history of the early modern period, and a research assistant specialising in book history and provenance), including a careful search for signs of readers' interaction with the books, will form the basis for the workshop presentations and initial discussion.

Two themed workshops will follow the initial analysis. The first workshop (at Belton House) will explore the theme of 'Cultural mobility in the early modern library', considering the passage of continental books into English collections, and the social and cultural history contained in these texts. This event will rely on direct access to texts from the Belton collection to guide discussion, and will aim to map the various ways in which the books in National Trust libraries can and should be drawn into the narratives that these houses tell about the families that owned them. The second workshop, hosted by the Centre for Material Texts at the University of Cambridge, will explore the theme of 'Great House libraries: an assessment of impact', and will seek to advance new ideas about the curatorship of great house libraries, in discussion with the curators themselves. An exhibition will be held at Belton House showcasing the connections between book and place for a general audience. Finally, a planning meeting will put in place the framework for a larger project, spanning major European languages, and looking at the acquisition and reception of continental books in a number of English great house libraries after the Reformation.

Planned Impact

Alongside the academic beneficiaries outlined above in a separate section, this project aims to have an impact that reaches beyond the academy to those working in curatorship and collections management in great houses across the United Kingdom, as well as to a significant section of the general public who regularly visit National Trust properties.

A broad aim of the project is to think in creative ways, from a collaborative and cross-disciplinary platform, about how to integrate the fascinating library collections in these properties more centrally into the general narratives related to visitors about the houses, their histories and the stories of the people who occupied them. This involves thinking both about how visitors are able to interact with and move around the library spaces themselves, and about how to draw the books off the shelves and into the stories being told in each property. As recent research in material textual culture has shown, texts need not be perceived only as pristine 'mental encounters', but are worthy of consideration as material objects in their own right, objects that reflect the lives of those who come into contact with them, often in casual, informal and surprising ways. Our tendency, in a contemporary 'great house' context, to expect to find books neatly arrayed on shelves within a formal library setting, indeed not to glance beyond the pristine leather bindings or ask ourselves what they contain as we pass through the room, ignores the capacity of these objects to convey a real social history, developed through the books that have over the centuries been messily and directly engaged with the lives of the people who lived there. The acquisition of books, adding new layers and depth to a library collection over time, reflects the passage of new people into a household, the traffic of ideas, the influx of outside influences. Thus books perform an archaeological function in permitting us to chip away at the accumulated cultural layers of the centuries. Books are mobile, passed from hand to hand, from owner to reader, and as they move they gather markings and annotations that reflect responses to them, or to unrelated events taking place simultaneously to the act of reading (a shopping list scrawled in a margin, a poem on a flyleaf). Books also interact with the objects that surround them in a home, with the paintings on the walls, with furnishings and other objects.

An opportunity for those working in the field of material textual culture to talk to those with responsibility for the curatorship of properties containing important libraries will allow new ideas to be aired concerning the potential display and use of these books, as well as ways to exploit the new research being done on them, as integral features of a National Trust visitor's experience of a great house. The exhibition at Belton House will be an opportunity to test out new ideas and advance current thinking in curatorial studies, by allowing visitors to interact with key Italian books from the collection and to witness the books' interaction with other objects in the house.

The National Trust recorded 17.2 million visitors to its pay-for-entry properties last year (Annual Report, 2009/10). These end users will benefit from the project directly as they come into contact with the books and their histories, and as the libraries are placed more centrally in their visitor experiences. Information about individual works in the libraries can be integrated into visitor guides and new research highlighted in the Trust's newsletters and magazine, as well as on their website. Clearly, impact on visitor experience across a range of National Trust properties is a long-term and ambitious aim linked to plans for a large-scale project in the future, with Belton House acting as a test case on a smaller scale in the shorter term.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description As well as answering my own specific research questions relating to the data analysed, I have initiated an on-going conversation with the National Trust about future research collaborations with HEIs - how to fund them, organise them and ensure their success.
Exploitation Route NT is open to future collaborations and willing to share resources and expertise, so future grants can certainly be targeted in this direction. Cambridge events have focussed on opening the dialogue between researchers and the NT in order to plan future collaborations. The success of my own pilot project has set the ground for other projects, as it has been a positive experience for my own institution and the NT.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL http://www.cam.ac.uk/research/features/an-enchantment-with-italy-one-family-and-their-books
 
Description Public outreach/information/cultural engagement. National Trust commitment to research collaborations with HEIs and in particular to the use and display of library materials.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Education,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description National Trust: change of policy around book exhibition
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Description Article for general audience (St Catharine's College Magazine) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A general interest article with images about work at Belton House, for the alumni of my college.

Article generated an invitation to speak to alumni at the annual event in Cambridge, as well as to visit alumni groups in other centres to repeat the talk.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2014
 
Description Exhibition of books 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Exhibition of books at Belton House, Lincs (NT), running from March to November 2013, curated by the PI with help from the Research Associate (Dr Dunstan Roberts), including accompanying captions, explanatory materials and printed leaflet. The exhibition had over 100,000 visitors during the year.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
 
Description Public Lectures (UK, USA, Italy) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Public lectures to Cambridge University alumni in 2013 and 2014 at the annual Alumni Weekends were attended by c.60 people on average. I also gave public lectures in Berkeley, CA (USA) and at the British School in Rome (Italy). All events stimulated discussion and questions, as well as invitations to give further talks to local history groups and other institutions.

Generated further interest in NT libraries and requests for talks/ requests for information about accessing NT collections.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013,2014
 
Description Web article on the Cambridge University website 
Form Of Engagement Activity A magazine, newsletter or online publication
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A web article on the Cambridge University website frontage, and linked via the University's 'research' pages.

Invitations to speak at other HEIs
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2013
URL http://www.cam.ac.uk/research/features/an-enchantment-with-italy-one-family-and-their-books