Swarm Intelligence: insects, humans and information on the move

Lead Research Organisation: University of Warwick
Department Name: History

Abstract

This follow-on funding application is connected to The War of the Locust: science, politics, culture and collaboration in the Anti-Locust Research Centre, 1940-45, an AHRC Science in Culture ECR Developmental Award for 2016-17. Over the past year the team's four Investigators have generated new dialogues between history, entomology, ecology and art in examining the work of the British Empire's 'Anti-Locust Research Centre': a remarkable organisation that sought, across the twentieth-century, to counter one of mankind's oldest threats. The current follow-on funding application is to develop our engagement with new non-academic audiences and in more ambitious and creative ways than originally conceived.

The records of the ALRC, housed in the Natural History Museum's offsite store in south west London, are unique, substantially uncatalogued, and prior to the commencement of our project were essentially unexplored. The time spent engaging closely with such a rich body of archival material has opened up exciting possibilities for collaboration which could not have been anticipated at the project's conception.

The current application seeks funding to support two opportunities for collaboration, both of which have been the subject of preparatory discussion with relevant stakeholders. The first is with the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organisation (UNFAO) in Rome, whose 'Locust Group' is the contemporary equivalent (and the direct successor) of the ALRC today; here we seek funds to support two knowledge exchange seminars with this international policy organisation. The second collaboration is with the National Museum of Wales in Cardiff, home to 80,000 locust specimens collected by the ALRC and unintentionally separated from the documentary material in London; here, we seek funds to develop a public installation in the Cardiff Museum which will present the complexities of interdisciplinary work, the puzzle of reassembling the disaggregated elements of this archive, and the ALRC's own efforts to gather and sort complex information in the pre-digital age.

While the activities for which we seek support engage with different publics, all aim to bring the contents of this hidden archive, and our research reflections upon it, into wider view.

Planned Impact

The outputs from our current project privilege academic understanding, with a secondary focus on impact gained from engagement with public audiences. These activities have acted as a proof of concept for this application, which extends the original pathways to impact by developing sustainable and long-term relationships with two key non-academic stakeholders.

The two UNFAO seminars are designed to address a clearly articulated non-academic need, including extending the range of data on which forecasts might be made, and comparing tensions between centralisation and de-centralisation in the history of anti-locust campaigns. We anticipate that disseminating our work on the information-processing capabilities of the ALRC, as well as the human stories underlying them, will enrich UNFAO's understanding of the political, social and cultural environments that affect their work: the experiences and reflections of participants in both knowledge exchange seminars will be captured (SurveyMonkey) and compared with the results of the pre-meeting questionnaire. The second meeting, with representatives from across North Africa and the Middle East, will reach a particularly wide user audience, but staff of Locust Group will further promote the outcomes of both seminars through its website and communications platform (Spark). At the project's end the Director of Locust Group will deliver a short report assessing its impact on practice; we anticipate this will be the launch pad for deeper collaboration in a larger grant.

Our collaboration with the National Museum of Wales seeks to restore to view a forgotten collection and to create an engaging public installation that addresses wider themes of interest to the Museum. As such, the project will deepen curators' knowledge of their own collections and build capacities in the Natural Sciences division for collaborating with arts and humanities researchers. The work of identifying and contextualising archival materials for display will also ensure that the project's benefits extend beyond the award period. An important part of this will involve creating original film content to convey the scope of both the ALRC's work and our own investigations into its past. In doing so we shall make particular use of digital files and film in preparing the installation so as to maximise opportunities for subsequent dissemination, including online (as will the modular design of the installation itself, and NMW's strong connections with other interested audiences and display spaces, including Aberystwyth University). The NMW has established systems of measuring impact with which we will work closely to develop appropriate means of assessment as part of the installation design process. At the project's end, we intend to draw on this information to explore pathways to further impact and collaboration.

Together, our initiatives with UNFAO and NMW allow for a wider and more innovative dissemination of our research than originally proposed, while meeting a set of clear non-academic needs concerning man's relationship with this powerful organism. Both arise out of unexpected connections that emerged from our research on the ALRC archive, and both seek to generate relationships that will outlast the grant itself.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The project is ongoing. The aim of this specific project grant was to conduct impact and engagement opportunities, rather than primary research. Nonetheless, we have continued to refine our understanding of the ALRC archive, to increase our knowledge of how the various component parts used to interact with one another, and to get a more complete understanding of the complexity of its data system and its blind spots. Preparing objects and film for exhibition required original research into their specific provenance and historical context. The UNFAO meeting was particularly instructive for the research team, who - through comparing past and present locust control methods - came to a deeper understanding of both the limitations and achievements of the British Empire's system of global locust control.
Exploitation Route The installation we are preparing for Cardiff is designed to be modular, facilitating subsequent display at other locations. The topic of the constructive dialogue between scholarship and the culture and heritage sector has loomed large in the project and is a point of considerable wider interest. Our research findings will be of interest to scholars of imperial and global history; data visualisation; forensic entomology and methodologies of DNA analysis with historic samples; food security; arts practitioners; and all scholars interested in the dialogues between disciplines. The purpose of the UNFAO collaboration was to facilitate our research findings being used by other audiences and practitioners. A key part of UNFAO's forecasting work is predicated upon identifying analogous situations in past locust outbreaks. Yet much of the dataset on which these forecasts are calculated dates back only to the mid-1980s. The raw data for earlier periods - the heart of the ALRC archive - is effectively concealed, as it is difficult and time-consuming for non-researchers to access and analogue in format. In disseminating our research on this material to UNFAO audiences, the research team has increased the visibility of an important archive and shared valuable information with a real opportunity to inform policy debates.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

 
Description The records of the antilocust research centre, housed in the Natural History Museum's offsite store in London, are unique, substantially uncatalogued, and prior to the commencement of our project were essentially unexplored. The time spent engaging closely with such a rich body of archival material has opened up exciting possibilities for collaboration which could not have been anticipated at the project's conception. As a direct result of our work on this collection we are in the process of creating a public exhibition at the National Museum of Wales, Cardiff - this was scheduled to open in March 2019 (the date of submission) and to run until September 2019. This installation at the National Museum of Wales brings to light the forgotten swarm collection; reunites it with elements of the wider ALRC archive; and contextualises both the ALRC's activities and our own ongoing efforts, as interdisciplinary team of researchers, to explore its meanings. The installation was co-created by the research team, the Museum's Department of Biodiversity and Systematic Biology and conservators within its Collections Services. For the museum, this was not merely an opportunity to display exciting but forgotten material, but to refresh part of the public galleries (into which our exhibition was inserted) and to engage public audiences in pertinent questions that also intersect with our research, including: shifting perceptions of the natural world (how an organism became a global 'problem'); and the challenges surrounding food security (see Letter of Support). The team held preparatory meetings with Mike Wilson (Curator of Entomology) and Julian Carter (Principal Conservator, Natural Sciences), prepared text panels, scanned and printed 3d locust models, created original artworks, digitised and contextualised historical film, and arranged for select archival materials to be loaned for the installation Finally, the team met with the members of the UNFAO who are responsible for global locust control today - the successors of the system we are exploring in the ALRC archive. In June 2018 we held a scholar-practitioner knowledge exchange workshop at the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organisation headquarters in Rome, on the subject of the past and present of international locust control. This workshop generated a number of possibilities for future research collaboration, particualarlya round the theme of identifying case studies in which the ALRC responded to 'unpredictable' events. Such 'unpredictable' events are, in the context of contemporary climate change, now occurring with increasing frequency, and thus provide UNFAO with instructive case studies from which to reflect on their own capacities and flexibility. We intend to make these case studies the subject of a future research collaboration.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Environment,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Policy & public services

 
Description Exhibition at National Museum of Wales 
Organisation National Museum Wales
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution This installation at the National Museum of Wales (MARCH-SEPT 2019) brings to light the forgotten swarm collection; reunites it with elements of the wider ALRC archive; and contextualises both the ALRC's activities and our own ongoing efforts, as interdisciplinary team of researchers, to explore its meanings. The installation was co-created by the research team with the Museum's Department of Biodiversity and Systematic Biology and conservators within its Collections Services. It was afforded space within the main Museum site in central Cardiff, witha projected footfall of 20,000 visitors across its installation. For the museum, this was not merely an opportunity to display exciting but forgotten material, but to engage public audiences in pertinent questions that also intersect with our research, including: shifting perceptions of the natural world (how an organism became a global 'problem'); and the challenges surrounding food security (see Letter of Support). The team held extensive preparatory meetings with Mike Wilson (Curator of Entomology) and Julian Carter (Principal Conservator, Natural Sciences); selected archival materials for the installation in dialogue with NHM (Andrea Hart and others), prepared and translated explanatory text and films, and displayed the original artwork of Co-I Dr Amanda Thomson.The ALRC's impressive and important collection of locust specimens came to Cardiff in the 1980s. Through the installation they were displayed in public for the first time, while the wider themes addressed by the installation (on shifting perceptions of the natural world, 'pests' and food security, and the challenges of interdisciplinary work) offered visitors an enhanced understanding of themes of noted interest to NMW.
Collaborator Contribution At Cardiff, the Curator of Entomology and Principal Conservator, Natural Sciences liaised with the research team on best methods of communicating their research findings to a public audience; provided AV equipment, museum display boxes and an installation space as an in-kind contribution; and assisted with loans of external material as appropriate. This collaboration is ongoing (the installation is from March2019-Sept 2019), and in this the Museum's role will be to: • prepare the insight gallery at NMW (various upgrades to this gallery are a direct result of our creating the installation there) • advise the research team on communicating their research to visitor audiences • provide the support of staff from Entomology, Conservation and Interpretation to ensure the installation is compatible with the Museum's aims and policies • loan AV equipment, archival material and display boxes for the installation - provide Welsh-language translation of relevant information panels and displays • assist with arranging loans of original material from other museums where appropriate
Impact The exhibition, its interpretive panels and the artwork of Dr Thomson are the chief outputs of this collaboration; all are interdisciplinary. The work is still in progress.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Natural History Musem 
Organisation Natural History Museum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Myself & research team working w/ Andrea Hart (Head of Special Collections), Jane Smith (Head of Library) and Library staff to identify important material in the uncatalogued antilocust collection, to raise awareness of its significance and value to wider audiences, and to explore pathways for the digitisation and display of this material.
Collaborator Contribution Logistic support in access to the material. We will need further support from NHM staff in order to digitise this material and to put it on display in the future.
Impact Major outcome has been the identification of - photographs - films - maps - locust specimens - documents --- all of which of great potential in communicating the important work of the antilocust research centre and its part in the histories of economic entomology; man's complex relationship with flora and fauna in Africa and SW Asia; histories of colonialism and global exchange. The identification and selection of material from the archive for loan to NMW for the Cardiff exhibition has also resulted in select items being restored and sent to preservation; a number of 35mm films were specifically digitised for the exhibition - the first time these films had been rendered into a viewable state since their accession. This material has supported our ongoing academic outputs, a brief summary of the scope of which is provided in our "evolve" piece. The identification of suggestive visual material has also laid the groundwork for an exhibition application, which became the subject of a subsequent UKRI grant application.
Start Year 2016
 
Description Research Fellow at Natural History Museum 
Organisation Natural History Museum
Department Life Sciences Department
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution - working with Library and Archives staff to develop collections. Working with uncatalogued material; sharing information about the context and scope of the collection with library and archives staff; producing new catalogues of material - discussing material, particularly on the anti-locust collection, with entomologists in the museum, including Andy Polaschek - working with the Centre for Arts and Humanities Research in group seminars to share news about these collections and promote an Arts and Humanities approach to Museum collections - as part of this, developing a further research grant application on a focused part of the Museum's collections (this grant was successful, through the Science in Culture theme)
Collaborator Contribution - provision of library support and study space in CAHR office
Impact - forthcoming article in EVOLVE magazine, the NHM's member magazine, on my research - conversations about future research grant collaboration - multidisciplinary - entomology, ecology, art, history
Start Year 2015
 
Description UNFAO 
Organisation Food and Agricultural Organisation (FAO)
Country Italy 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Collaboration with United Nations Food and Agricultural Organisation focused on a workshop at UNFAO Headquarters in Rome, with ongoing dialogue around the possibilities of future collaboration. We have developed these activities in close consultation with Locust Group's Director, Keith Cressman, who has articulated a clear need for an historical and comparative exploration of the origins of his organisation, especially in light of the recent passing of some of the ALRC's last surviving members. The main seminar, attended by 3 of the 4 members of the research team and an equal number of Locust staff at UNFAO, focused on sharing insights from the past and present of locust control to explore gaps in the scientific, administrative and political capabilities of both past and present organisations. The seminar involved an all-morning tour of Locust headquarters at UNFAO during which the team learned a great deal about the operational capacity and systems of UNFAO locust watch. In the afternoon we held a structured workshop with the Locust team at UNFAO in which we prepared materials from the archive and used these as the basis for an active discussion of what this older information might add to understandings of the methodologies, shortcomings, work and cultures of locust monitoring and forecasting in the present and the future, with the potential to influence current policy and practice. The workshop ended with an outline for potential future collaboration around intensive research of specific 'case studies' from the archive which could be of particular interest to UNFAO today in understanding how to respond to the increasingly unpredictable nature of locust control - a particular feature of some of the earlier plagues in our archival record, but which UNFAO has not had to face in more recent memory.
Collaborator Contribution UNFAO's tour and hosting of the workshop helped our research to come to the attention of critical practitioner communities, while enriching our mutual understanding of the wider contexts of international anti-locust campaigns and the challenges of interdisciplinary collaboration. The seminar also worked to support the pursuit of new user contacts in the world of international development, helping to build capacity for subsequent funding applications on a larger scale.
Impact The seminar included activities that actively used and compared the data, methods and forecasts uncovered by the research team in the ALRC archive with the contemporary systems and practices of UNFAO Headquarters. The dialogue around the implications of this material and the possibilities of future collaborative research around it is still active.
Start Year 2017
 
Description UNFAO 'Locust Watch', Rome 2018, Knowledge Exchange Seminar 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact See report impact activities for full description. UNFAO collaboration was a key part of this project.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description UNFAO link 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Series of conversations with head of 'Locust Watch' at the United Nations Food and Agricultural Organisation in Rome. The result of which was their agreement to participate in a collaborative research project with us, starting late 2017.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description UNFAO workshop, Rome 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact June 2018 workshop at UNFAO HQ in Rome on locust control, past and present. Fascinating knowledge exchange event, identifying real structural differences in how global locust control has been conducted in the past and present, in turn leading to a number of possible future lines of enquiry. Discussion formed the basis of ongoing discussions about future research grant collaboration.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description exhibition public workshop - Cardiff, 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Scheduled activity for summer 2019 - workshop around the locust exhibition at NMW in Cardiff. This is yet to run at time of reporting.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019