United Nations Television in Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina

Lead Research Organisation: University of Hull
Department Name: Histories

Abstract

This network brings together historians, film scholars, museum professionals, migration researchers, peacebuilding experts, journalists, filmmakers, and survivors of displacement and genocide to re-examine the work of United Nations Television (UNTV) in Croatia and Bosnia-Herzegovina (BiH) during the Yugoslav Wars. The UNTV film unit, active in 1993-5, aimed to provide content for TV broadcasts to support UN peacekeeping operations in former Yugoslavia, and recorded more than 200 reports about conditions in front-line areas from which refugees had been displaced, plus 'video letters' in which refugees sent messages to separated family members. UNTV's collected films and papers (including these recordings, more than 2000 unedited rushes, and contextual documents such as administrative correspondence, newspaper clippings and interview transcripts) were saved from disposal by the UNTV series producer Roy Head as UN peacekeeping in BiH wound up. IWM acquired this collection in 1996. It now sits alongside other holdings related to audiovisual media, war and conflict, including the NATO Collection of more than 350 hours of film from the 1940s-90s and the British Army Film and Photographic Unit's 'dope sheets' from the Second World War.
The UNTV films differ from other broadcasters' footage because they were recorded to inform displaced survivors and formed part of UN humanitarian and peacekeeping strategy. While the UNTV team viewed the videos as interventions made to further immediate UN objectives during the Bosnian crisis, they have since acquired unforeseen documentary functions of interest to filmmakers, museum curators, and survivors. This network will be investigating UNTV's role in peacebuilding and the meanings of its films today at a time when historians, heritage professionals and refugee support charities are using evidence from 20th-century European refugee history to inform public understandings of migration in the present, including IWM's own Displacement public programming season in 2020. This reassessment takes place after two decades of political and economic stagnation in BiH, which call the record of international peacebuilding there - always overshadowed by the UN's wartime failure to protect civilians from genocide - into question even further. The prominence of EU border and refugee resettlement policies as a factor in today's refugee crisis, which have readily been viewed through postcolonial lenses, meanwhile invites scholars to link this earlier European refugee crisis into the same global framework. In these regards, the under-used UNTV collection offers a valuable prism through which to explore questions about media, peacebuilding, and the aesthetics of testimony and memory.
Across three workshops at IWM London in 2019-20, the network will engage with questions arising not only from the UNTV films' content but also the context of their creation, broadcast, reception, archiving and long-term use:
Workshop 1: UNTV and the Media in Former Yugoslavia (the films' production history, their impact at the time, and the limitations of mass media in peacebuilding)
Workshop 2: Meanings of the UNTV Films Today (the films' value now for communities affected by the wars, and the use of audiovisual testimony in memorialising the wars, including the Srebrenica genocide)
Workshop 3: Europe's 1990s 'Refugee Crisis' in a Global Context (comparisons/contrasts with forced migration from the Global South in the late 20th century and the reception of refugees today)
The network's findings will feed into IWM's Displacement season. A dedicated microsite on the IWM website will host blog posts and videos based on workshop contributions, and public events at IWM London and in Hull will link into the 25th anniversaries of the Srebrenica genocide and the end of the Croatian/Bosnian wars. Together, participants will explore what role the UNTV films could play in peacebuilding and what lenses audiences view them through today.

Planned Impact

The network activities have three layers of beneficiaries: curators and digital engagement professionals at IWM, which after successfully and creatively leading a wealth of events to mark the First World War and Armistice centenaries will be focusing its activities increasingly on contemporary conflict in 2020 and onwards; other museum and heritage professionals dealing with similar themes; other non-academic partners whose representatives will take part in the workshops and/or have input into project management as Advisory Group members. Additionally, the findings will benefit users of the resources which will disseminate the workshops' results to non-academic audiences.
Immediate benefits for IWM professionals will include enriching IWM's Displacement public programming in 2020 and enhancing curators' practice for handling other audiovisual holdings related to contemporary conflict. Perspectives from the reunion of former UNTV staff in Workshop 1 in particular will feed into the organisation of a 'conflict café' at IWM London during the Displacement season. Methodological and ethical considerations identified during Workshop 2, including implications of GDPR and digital ethics, will inform the work of IWM's Head of Film, Matt Lee (an Advisory Group member), in liaising with film archives in conflict-affected countries about extending access to and use of other audiovisual material held by IWM depicting conflict there, and it is hoped that networking activities during the workshops and Advisory Group meetings may identify potential local partners in BiH (likely to be film collections and/or arts organisations) for future collaborations that will address GCRF-eligible challenges by making use of the UNTV collection. IWM's Learning Department, which will be producing an activity programme for schools during the Displacement season, will use recordings and transcripts from the UNTV films plus blog posts generated from the workshops in resources targeting topics on the GCSE and A level syllabus.
Further non-academic partners will also benefit from being invited to consider how the network's findings could impact their practice. The network's examination of first-person video testimony from the Yugoslav wars (especially BiH) and what it has been used and reused to communicate will benefit genocide education and prevention organisations such as Remembering Srebrenica and Protection Approaches, who have been invited to take part in Workshop 2 (in recent years, video testimonies by Bosnian genocide survivors produced for YouTube and social media have been increasingly important to genocide education campaigns in the UK). Organisations dealing with refugees and the families of the missing, including the International Commission for Missing Persons (which led forensic investigations of mass graves in BiH) and the National Children's Bureau, will gain insights into the possibilities and limitations of communicating with refugees and separated family members through video letters and documentary, and the secondary significance such footage can acquire after war's end.
Finally, results of collaboration through the workshops will benefit educators and members of the public with interests in displacement and contemporary conflict. These include users of IWM's Displacement resources for schools, users of digital resources accompanying the Displacement season (including the dedicated UNTV microsite), and visitors to in-person events including the Yugoslav Wars 'conflict café' and a session in the University of Hull's 'OpenCampus' lifelong learning programme (allowing IWM's Displacement programming to reach a region of the UK where IWM has no physical presence). These will have been shaped by input from Bosnian experts, some with first-hand experience of displacement or surviving genocide, thanks to the network's international dimension.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Interview with former UNTV journalist 
Description Oral history interview with former UNTV journalist who had previously served in British UNPROFOR battalion, conducted by the CI 
Type Of Art Artefact (including digital) 
Year Produced 2020 
Impact Added to IWM Sound Collection (accession in progress) 
 
Description The three workshops for this project, all successfully completed despite the impact of the Covid-19 pandemic, and have identified that the UNTV material held by IWM is a rich but delicate collection which significantly enhances IWM's audiovisual holdings relating to war and conflict after the end of the Cold War. The collection relates primarily to the television unit re-established by UNPROFOR's Department of Public Information in March-April 1994 but also contains some material pertaining to UNPROFOR television production before that. After studying the UNTV document and film collections, the PI has been able to publish the first peer-reviewed article from the project in a leading media history journal, explaining what the documents reveal about how UNTV after March-April 1994 conceptualised what 'peace' would mean in former Yugoslavia and arguing that the unit attempted to intervene in what historians have described as former Yugoslavia's 'media war' between the broadcasters of states involved in the conflict.

While the first project workshop was held at IWM London in September 2019 as planned, many project activities between March 2020 and February 2021 were severely disrupted due to the Covid-19 pandemic, especially all those activities involving IWM staff or facilities (including the digitisation of most of the UNTV films, a prerequisite before participants could take part adequately in the second and third workshops). Once the films had been digitised, the remaining two workshops took place as virtual events in May and September 2021: without the need to book and reimburse travel and accommodation for participants, this format in fact permitted a wider range of participants from beyond the UK to join the workshops and enabled the team to be more agile in making invitations, so represented a net positive impact of the disruption and will influence networking practices at IWM going forward. These workshops revealed further significant aspects of the collection but also further sensitivities. It is, for instance, relatively rare for broadcasters' wartime footage from the Yugoslav Wars to deal with the everyday, 'behind-the-lines', scenes that UNTV tended to film. Since memory of the conflict among young people in the region is so powerfully mediated by television footage from the war years, films from the collection might have potential value for peace education, and at a length of up to ten minutes per film are an excellent length for classroom use. On the other hand, the fact that many of the films have never been seen in the region is partly due to the fact that UNTV's output did not achieve widespread distribution across former Yugoslavia, and therefore its importance to the history of broadcast media during the Yugoslav Wars should not be overstated. Some of the films that workshop participants found most analytically interesting were not, according to UNTV's own documents, even broadcast. Additional sensitivities come from the fact that certain films contain distressing footage of the aftermath of massacres including images where there is community sentiment that these should not be shown, and from the fact that the UNTV documents held by IWM do not on their own provide full context around how UNTV and its personnel operated within the wider system of UN peacekeeping in former Yugoslavia. The fact that IWM has now become the custodian of these films does however create further opportunities for partnership research with organisations from the communities where they were filmed.
Exploitation Route Other researchers would be able to use the digitised films and documents to advance research on UN peacekeeping, media, television and humanitarianism during the Yugoslav wars
IWM will be able to use excerpts from UNTV films and some documents in future exhibitions and digital activities, and have a stronger sense of the scope and significance of the collection
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.iwm.org.uk/research/research-projects/filming-for-peace
 
Description The project had impact through the inclusion of sections from the videos in the exhibition Refugees: Forced to Flee a major exhibition which ran at IWM London from April 2020 to June 2021. Forced to Flee confronted common perceptions by focussing on the personal experiences of people who have been forced to flee their homes and the challenges they face in making their journey to safety and re-settling. The project drew the attention of the collection to the curator of the exhibition who in the event made a recurring feature of the footage throughout the display. The project has produced an interesting interaction with Adnan Ahmetaševic one of the civilians interviewed and filmed by a UNTV camera unit who got in touch with IWM to enquire whether the film he remembered being made when he was just 16 years old was available to be viewed. IWM's film curator Michelle Kirby spoke several times online to Adnan Ahmetaševic about his memories of that time resulting in a blog which both praises the film with its insights into how a group of teenagers played rock music in a makeshift underground rehearsal space in Tuzla and provides thoughts on the role of music as a source of strength and bonding during conflict.
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural

 
Description Excerpts from 5 UNTV films used in IWM Refugees exhibition
Geographic Reach National 
Policy Influence Type Influenced training of practitioners or researchers
 
Title Digitisation of UNTV films 
Description 95% of the UNTV films in IWM's Film Collection have now been digitised as of the date of reporting. 93% of these have been ingested and are available for research. Work to complete digitisation/ingestion is ongoing after severe delays caused by closure of IWM and physical site of the Film Collection under Covid-19 restrictions in 2020-1. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Excerpts from films used in IWM's 'Refugees: Forced to Flee' physical exhibition and online presence, and on IWM UNTV microsite. 
 
Description Collaboration with International Commission for Missing Persons, Bosnia Hercegovina 
Organisation International Commission on Missing Persons
Country Bosnia and Herzegovina 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution IWM had an existing relationship with the International Commission for Missing Persons whose staff had been key partners in the creation of the Srebrenica Memorial Room (opened 2007) for which IWM lent consultancy skills. The UNTV project reconnected IWM with this important organization dealing with post-conflict issues in Bosnia Hercegovina.
Collaborator Contribution Nihad Brankovic Senior Adviser for Cooperation with Governments, ICMP, contributed to the project's second workshop 'First-person narrative on video: testimony, uses and afterlife' held on 19 May 2021 with a paper on 'Disseminating the collection within the region'.
Impact The paper given at the second workshop gave valuable insights into the likely reception of screening elements of the collection within Bosnia Hercegovina.
Start Year 2006
 
Description Collaboration with Künstlerhaus Büchsenhausen 
Organisation Künstlerhaus Büchsenhausen
Country Austria 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Contributed to an event contextualising an exhibition by a Künstlerhaus Büchsenhausen fellow
Collaborator Contribution Hosted the fellowship and exhibition, and organised the event
Impact Informal agreement on a future joint publication. Multidisciplinary collaboration including history, sociology and art history.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Collaboration with Professor James Gow, Kings College London 
Organisation King's College London
Department King's College London War Crimes Research Group
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The PI and CI shared details of the project with Prof Gow and sought his expert contribution to the third and final workshop.
Collaborator Contribution Prof Gow's interest in this area benefited the project both during the third and final workshop and in a meeting held to consider future directions.
Impact Professor Gow has advised on the options for future further investigation of the UNTV collection.
Start Year 2006
 
Description First project workshop (13 Sept 2019) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact 25 people including an international participant attended the first project workshop, 'UNTV and the Media in Former Yugoslavia: Lessons for Peacebuilders'. Participants included former UNTV producers who engaged in dialogues with researchers about what themes in the collection are of particular interest today, and IWM staff who learned more about the political and organisational contexts in which the films in the UNTV collection had been made.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Invitation to research seminar, UEA (5 Feb 2020) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact 10 people including postgraduate students attended this invited research seminar, which sparked discussion about the objectives of peacekeeping in Bosnia and the place of UNTV's distribution technology in media history. While on campus I also discussed the research with 1-2 others who could not attend the talk itself.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Modern Conflict Research Symposium (IWM North), 31 Jan 2020 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact 50 participants including researchers, postgraduates, heritage professionals and military history enthusiasts attended the presentation. It sparked follow-up discussion about the aims of UNTV.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Workshop 2 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The workshop
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Workshop 2 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The workshop was titled 'First-person narrative on video: testimony, uses and afterlife' and considered how filmed testimony has been used within memorial spaces and exhibitions; at the issues arising from IWM's custodianship of UNTV collection; the media and the conflict today; and issues surrounding justice and reparation, activism and gender.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Workshop 3: Reflections 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Virtual workshop held on Teams with 25 attendees. Former UNTV personnel, journalists who covered the Balkans conflict, policy makers and academics who considered the lessons that can be learned from the UNTV project. This final workshop also asked what research questions the collection can pose for future projects.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021