Cultural Heritage Transformations of Weddings and Marriage among Women in the Tamil and Parsi diaspora communities in India and the UK

Lead Research Organisation: University of Exeter
Department Name: Drama

Abstract

The network project will examine the effects of migration and diaspora on transformations of tangible and intangible cultural heritage in diaspora communities in India and the UK, and the effects this has on the homeland of origin in India. Weddings and marriage are a significant driver of migration for women, and we will focus on women in the Tamil and Parsi diasporas in Bengaluru, Mumbai, and London to examine contrasting examples of cultural heritage transformations in different communities due to both internal and external migration. Through this, we will explore what is gained, lost, exchanged and preserved in the diaspora, and how this affects the homeland in India, as well as questioning the tensions between preservation and adaptation of cultural heritage. Women are seen as bearers and preservers of cultural heritage objects and traditions, however pressures of different cultures, economics, marrying outside the community, changes in fashion, and intergenerational conflict can lead to changes to cultural heritage in the new home of the diaspora. This may create contestation over the diaspora wanting to preserve heritage as it was when they brought it with them, and the process of transformation through fitting into the new place of home. The project will conduct fieldwork in India and the UK to examine these tensions and transformations, including conducting interviews with women in the diaspora. We will also explore the economic benefit of the wedding industry in the diasporas to the homeland of India. This industry is part of globalisation and neoliberalism, and is bringing increased wealth to India through the NRI communities wanting to have a large-scale, lavish Indian wedding. Indian wedding fairs are increasingly popular in both India and the UK, and the related tourism of travel to India to buy wedding goods, and attend weddings, has led to increased economic benefit. The effects of digital technology, the internet, and social media have a major impact on the transformations of cultural heritage in the diaspora, but also act as a connector with the home, and a means of influence for changing practices at a global level.

The project will bring together a team of interdisciplinary and international scholars to share research, and exchange knowledge and methodologies. This will create a multi-perspectival approach with academics in India and the UK from disciplines including archaeology, history, cultural studies, performance and ritual studies, social anthropology, and gender studies. We will meet as a team for two workshops in Bengaluru for core network discussions, including holding a public symposium. We will also share and exchange relevant literature though a scoping exercise, which will identify gaps of literature in the other country, to then approach publishers and booksellers to address this gap. In addition to the academic team, we will engage with cultural heritage institutions with curators from the DakshinaChitra museum in Tamil Nadu, and the Royal Albert Memorial Museum (RAMM) in Exeter, UK, being part of the workshop discussions. Through this, we will explore how museums display and represent cultural heritage relating to weddings in both India and the diaspora, and develop new creative methodologies for the museums to engage visitors with their collections. We will show the project exhibition in both museums, and hold community engagement workshops with women from local Indian communities to engage them with the objects in the museum, and issues of migration and transformation in cultural heritage.

Outputs from the project include a journal article, symposium, and literature review. There are a number of public outputs including the website, which will include extracts from the interviews, and the exhibition, which will include replicas of Tamil wedding jewellery from the RAMM collection made by jewellery craftspeople in India, and a policy document regarding abandoned women in the diaspora.

Planned Impact

The network project aims to create a range of forms of economic and societal impact in India which will benefit a number of different groups and communities within India, and Indian diasporas.

The focus on women in the project will give a voice to women in the domestic sphere who will be able to tell their story and express their own feelings in response to their experience of migration and living in a diaspora, and the effects this has on transformation of cultural heritage. This will provide them with a greater sense of reflection on their position and identity within their community and society, and enable a stronger sense of agency through feeling that their story and voice is important. Within Bengaluru, we will consult with Vimochana who have conducted research in the district of Ulsoor which has a high migrant population, and where Tamil women who have migrated due to marriage have experienced high levels of domestic violence. The project will also consider the part that cultural inheritance in the form of dowry plays in instigating this abuse. This will lead to greater awareness of the work of Vimochana, and contribute to a policy document produced by the project focusing on women who have been abandoned or divorced in the diaspora, and the precarious place this leaves them in. The suggestions in the policy document will benefit the women through highlighting their plight to government institutions in India. UNESCO has recognised the Parsi community as being endangered through dwindling numbers, so the research will benefit this community through documenting cultural heritage objects and practices which are dying out. The women who attend the cultural engagement workshops in museums in Tamil Nadu and Exeter will benefit through being encouraged to reflect on their cultural heritage and community identity.

Craftspeople in India will benefit through jewellery makers in Moradabad, UP, being commissioned to produce replicas of Tamil wedding jewellery items held at the RAMM in the UK. This will provide immediate economic benefit to them, and the project also aims to test the potential commercialisation of this through selling the jewellery, which would create greater economic benefit for the makers and their community, and increase knowledge of their practices. Designer Ashdeen Lilaowala will benefit through increased global knowledge of his Parsi gara saris through the project's symposium, website, and exhibition.

Third sector cultural heritage institutions of museums will benefit from the transnational dialogue and sharing of practices between the two partner organisation museums on the project. These dialogues will address ideological and practical ways of displaying cultural heritage items, and how to engage local communities with the collections. DakshinaChitra museum in Tamil Nadu will benefit from hosting the project's exhibition leading to increased visitors, and from holding the community workshop to engage directly with local Tamil women to reflect and discuss transformations in their cultural heritage due to migration. They will also be given a set of replica jewellery for their collections as a form of repatriation of the jewellery to the homeland of Tamil Nadu, thus adding materially to their collection of cultural heritage objects. The RAMM in Exeter will benefit from hosting the exhibition and the community engagement workshop. The RAMM has been developing relationships with the local South Asian communities over the past five years, so this project will benefit this. The transnational dialogue, and replicas of items being produced in India, will contribute to ongoing discussions of 'decolonising' the museum, which is a major concern for the RAMM. The two project PIs will also meet with Richard Blurton, curator of the South Asia gallery at the British Museum, to discuss these issues with him, which will further enhance the dialogue about migration of cultural heritage between India and the diaspora.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The interdisciplinary workshop discussion sessions held by the network have been very beneficial in drawing together a range of ideas and theories related to the topic of the project. This has led to transnational as well as transdisciplinary re-thinking of terminology such as 'diaspora', as well as a sharing of literature and knowledge that has developed more complex research than originally planned. We are now going to develop this research into an edited book to create an academic output that will allow for this complexity and richness through an innovative methodological and creative approach to the publication, which is in the planning process.

The project has strengthened the collaboration between Co-PIs Daboo and Haricharan, furthering the interdisciplinary dialogue across archaeology and performance and cultural studies. This has resulted in us giving a joint presentation, as well as being invited to co-author three chapters for edited collections planned for the next two years.

We have undertaken community engagement events with women and organisations in India to discuss and further the research from the project. This has highlighted significant issues connected to women and movements of cultural heritage due to migration and diaspora that has enhanced our thinking.

We have continued engagement work with museums in India and the UK to explore issues of cultural heritage in relation to museums, and questions of repatriation. This has furthered our thinking surrounding the movements and display of cultural heritage in different contexts.

However, the research project and outputs have been significantly affected by Covid-19. We have not been able to undertake fieldwork, network meetings in India, or in-person engagement work with partner organsiations in India, and meant we were not able to undertake the exhibition planned in the project propsoal. As we can no longer have a no-cost extension, this has severely limited the events that we were hoping to undertake.
Exploitation Route The outcomes may be beneficial for scholars in a range of disciplines and countries. We aim to expand the research to other global communities, and use our findings as the foundation for future research in these contexts.
Sectors Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://heritagemarriagemigration.wordpress.com/
 
Description We have been working with the Royal Albert Memorial Museum to research the histories of some of their donors. This work has been beneficial for the museum who did not have this information, and is making their collections more accessible. This has resulted in a website, and the making of a short film, which will engage wider public audiences with the museum and work of the project. We have worked with the UNESCO organsation Parzor to help digitise some of their audio recordings of songs by an endangered community, leading to the better preservation of these recordings. We held a meeting with members of the Parsi community and Parzor to share findings from the project, and discuss their responses and ideas relating to this. This has helped to further explore issues relating to women in India, and transnational connections to the UK. We held discussions with Southall Black Sisters to consider the important concern of transnational marriage abandonment, and aim to consider ways to connect women's organisations in India with SBS in order to address this issue further (this has not been possible to date due to Covid-19).
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description Parzor Foundation (UNESCO) 
Organisation United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization
Department Parzor Foundation
Country France 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We have digitised audio recordings made by Parzor of songs by the endangered Parsi community that would otherwise have been lost. We have promoted the organisations work through the public symposium and website. This has benefited the endangered community in India, an ODA country.
Collaborator Contribution We have used research undertaken by the Parzor Foundation as part of the research for the network project.
Impact Digitisation of audio recordings. Promoting of work in symposium and website. This has benefitted the Parsi community which is endangered in India, an ODA country.
Start Year 2020
 
Description Royal Albert Memorial Museum 
Organisation Royal Albert Memorial Museum
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution I have researched on some of their collections of Indian jewellery, in particular researching the history of the women donors, and their transnational connections to India. This information is available publicly through the project's website, and a short film made in association with the RAMM. The project has hosted discussions about issues of repatriation and colonial histories with museum curators in India. Another plan was that Co-PI Dr Smriti Haricharan would visit to research some of the Indian bronze artifacts in the museum to provide more information about them, but this has not been possible due to Covid-19.
Collaborator Contribution The RAMM has given access to their collections of artifacts from India. They have enabled discussions about the place of museums and issues of repatriation with museum curators in India. They took part in the production of a short film about the research from the project.
Impact Website page. Multi-disciplinary - history, sociology, cultural studies, archaeology, museum studies Short film - history, sociology, cultural studies, archaeology, museum studies
Start Year 2022
 
Description Engagement activity with members of the Parzor organisation and members of the Parsi community 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact With the Co-PI Dr Smriti Haricharan, we organised an event in Mumbai with members of the UNESCO Parzor Foundation, a partner organisation with the project, and members of the local Parsi community to discuss our findings from the research, and hear about their experiences. The participants were all women, fitting in with the focus of the project, and allowed them to reflect on and share their stories of cultural heritage transformations. The Parzor Foundation shared details about their work as well, promoting this further. One of the community members was a Parsi jewellery who was sharing information about transformations to jewellery designs for weddings over the past 50 years, including showing some drawings and photographs of designs, which made this information publicly available.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Engagement with Southall Black Sisters 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Discussion event with Pragna Patel, director of Southall Black Sisters, about the issues of transnational marriage abandonment of Indian women in the diaspora in the UK. This has been a significant part of their research, and will be further promoted through the work of the project. We had an aim to work further with women's organisations in India on this, and link them up with Southall Black Sisters, however this was not possible due to Covid-19. We still hope to find a way to make this happen
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Engagement work with RAMM, Exeter 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact We researched the list of donors of Indian jewellery to the Royal Albert Memorial Museum in Exeter, UK. The RAMM only had a list of names, with no other details. We conducted research to discover who they were, and their transnational connections with India and Devon. We focused in particular on the two women on the list. This has created new knowledge for the RAMM about their donors, and furthered research into transnational links of India and Devon.

The resulting research is available as a page on the project's website. In addition, the PI made a video of a discussion with the ethnographer of the RAMM, discussing the jewellery and related issues of cultural heritage and museums, which is publicly available through the URL below.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020,2021
URL https://heritagemarriagemigration.wordpress.com/transnational-movement-of-jewellery/
 
Description Interdisciplinary presentation on the research project 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Professor Daboo and Dr Haricharan were invited to give a talk on their project for the event 'Archaeological Heritages and Mobilities' . This was mainly attended by archaeologists and historians, so our input offered an interdisciplinary take that led to very fruitful discussions. Professor Daboo has continued to be in touch with the event's convenor, Dr Tiago Muniz, who is now working on a related project, with the aim of a future collaboration on cultural heritage coming out of the event.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Presentation: "'Movement and Cultural Heritage Transformation due to Migration among the Tamil and Paris Diaspora Communities" 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact A public online talk titled "'Movement and Cultural Heritage Transformation due to Migration among the Tamil and Paris Diaspora Communities" about the project given by myself and Co-PI Dr Smriti Haricharan in India. The event was hosted by Pilgrim Chat, an organisation promoting research and discussions around cultural heritage and archaeology, aimed at a range of public audiences.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Short film made in association with the Royal Albert Memorial Museum 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact I made a short film in association with the Royal Albert Memorial Museum on my research from the project relating to their collection of Indian jewellery. I researched the donors of the jewellery, particularly the women, to uncover information about their transnational movement between Devon and India. This has promoted the collection and work of the RAMM, as well as raising points about the effects of colonialism in India, and the financial benefit this brought to Devon. It also gave a name and story to the women donors who were not known about before. Further related research and outputs are being planned.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
 
Description Talk by Dr Shernaz Cama, a member of the project team, on Parsi embroidery 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Dr Shernaz Cama, who is a member of the project team, visited Exeter and gave a public talk on Parsi embroidery and cultural heritage, which is an aspect of the project. The talk was given live, and live-screened internationally. The recording of the talk was given to Dr Cama to include on the Parzor website and youtube channel. Over 120 people attended in person and online, from the UK, India, Iran, and the United States.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022