GCRF Development Award: The Political Economy of Education Research (PEER) Network

Lead Research Organisation: University of Ulster
Department Name: Sch of Education

Abstract

Almost half of all children who are out of school live in conflict affected countries (at least 27 million children in 24 countries). Children in these countries are twice as likely to die before their fifth birthday and countries with conflict have some of the largest inequalities between girls and boys and the lowest literacy levels in the world. Good quality education can protect children from violence and provide life-saving messages concerning health and safety, as well as the knowledge, skills and attitudes to survive, recover and rebuild their society after conflict. Yet, education is often given a low priority in situations of conflict.

We know that modern conflicts can last more than 20 years and often involve multiple armed groups competing for control of government institutions [such as schools], natural resources and territory. This also means that provision of education can be highly politicised in situations of conflict and this can prevent much needed assistance reaching those who need it most - it is usually the poorest or most marginalised who suffer the worst consequences of violent conflict. Education is usually considered 'a good thing', but we know that in certain circumstances education may actually be 'part of the problem' as well as 'part of the solution'. For example, unequal access to education and distribution of education resources may fuel grievances between groups in society, particularly if they are already in conflict. Exclusion of minority voices from decision-making will cause resentment. Insensitive or politically biased education policies in terms of the language of instruction or content of the curriculum may create mistrust between different ethnic, religious or cultural groups by fuelling stereotypes, xenophobia and other antagonisms.

We therefore need to better understand the underlying political, economic and social reasons why some forms of education may make conflict worse. This is known as Political Economy Analysis (PEA) and is highly relevant to the provision of education in conflict affected countries. However, there are problems with current approaches. There is a reliance on international consultants to undertake 'one-off' assessments that lack sensitivity to local history, politics, culture and knowledge of power-relations that are better conveyed in local languages. There is also a tendency to ignore the impact that international agencies have on national policy and practices and the different political circumstances that operate in different parts of a country. There is often a reluctance to raise critical questions about education provision because they are too sensitive or may challenge vested interests. These severely limit the potential of analysis to improve the planning and development of socially just education systems.

Planned Impact

The stated aim of the GCRF Strategy is to facilitate "a positive transformational impact on development research and on sustainable global development. The overarching goal of the PEER Network is to inform socially just education systems and provision for children and young people in contexts of conflict and protracted crises.

To achieve this, the PEER Network will:

- Identify new solutions to the problems of 'why good technical policies fail' through a process of endogenous knowledge production.
- Inform intelligent policy and planning decision-making that directly recognises the trade-offs inherent in activities targeting the drivers and the legacies of conflict.
- Produce sustainable solutions by building networks of social accountability at the national and regional level to monitor progress and take account of changing circumstances.
- Create regional hubs of expertise to facilitate joint analysis of political economy analysis of bottlenecks that extend beyond national borders.
- Transform the global knowledge base and increasing standardisation of global education governance response by challenging postcolonial approaches to political economy analysis.

We will achieve these impact objectives through the following activities:

1. Develop three Challenge Papers to provide intellectual leadership and set the research development agenda
2. Produce three state of the art reviews to assess the extent of, and synthesise findings from, existing political economy analysis of education in the three regions.
3. 60 policymakers, practitioners and academics across the three regions commit to a year long process to co-develop PEA expertise and resources.
4. 20 case studies will explore political economy analysis of education in context
5. Creation of an online Community of Practice (CoP) to promote the sharing of the co-produced body of political economy analysis resources.
6. Support for Masters Level and PhD dissertations in the field
7. Commitment to funding one PhD studentship up to the value of £130,000 by Ulster University.
8. Workshops carried out at conferences for ECR
9. Disseminate and engage with 'global education actors' through attendance at workshops, conferences, meetings, blogs and social media.

By meeting these objectives, this research will provide benefits to the following groups:

1. Children and young people in the context of conflict and protracted crises
2. National level policymakers & practitioners seeking to make sustainable and informed choices in the context of constrained resources
3. Policymakers and practitioners working across national borders in the region.
4. International architecture of humanitarian aid and development actors supporting the provision of education for increasingly prolonged periods in the context of conflict and protracted crises.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description For this Development Award, our overall aim was to undertake preparatory tasks for the submission of a Full Proposal by 19 September 2019 and initiate inception activities to enable the PEER Network to be up and running by April 2020. Significant achievements were reached in both these key areas.

1. PEER Network proposal development
Three team meetings were convened in Belfast 2019, London 2019 and Cape Town 2020 which allowed for the following activities:
• Revision of outline proposal based on feedback from GCRF.
• Submission of full proposal in September 2019 and successful interview in December 2019.
• Discussion of management arrangements, identifying lead roles for project partners and potential challenges.
• Early preparation for recruitment requirements and planning of job descriptions.
• Preparation for recruitment of 2 PhDs funded by Ulster
• Discussion of challenges related to ethical review processes, practicalities of transfer of funds for specific activities and institutional capacity.
• Identification of potential members of the PEER Network advisory board and incentives for their continued support.

2. Early inception activities
• The PEER Network team members convened a session for early career researchers at the UKFIET Conference in September 2019.
• A strategy was agreed for identifying participants for the PEER Network workshops focusing on 1) Scoping and invitation. Individuals working in the field will be identified as part of the scoping and invited to attend. 2) Institutional leads. Key institutions will be approached and invited to elect representative(s) to attend. This has advantages in terms of continuity. 3) Formal open call. Applicants will be assessed according to certain criteria
• A Research Assistant has been recruited to undertake initial literature review and scoping of key political economy specialists in the Central Asian region.
• Agreed topics of challenge papers and lead authors.
• A framework was agreed for the content of the workshops focusing on three themes: 1) contextual issues relating to PEA of education in the regions; 2) information on the background and evolution of PEA of education in context of conflict; 3) methodological approaches and tools for conducting PEA of education in the context of conflict.
• PEER Network team members met with PhD students in University of Cape Town in February 2020 to discuss their research.
• The PEER Network held a public seminar for students and staff at UCT on 12th February 2020.
Exploitation Route The development award allowed the team to submit a much more practical, thoughtful and equitable proposal than would otherwise have been possible. It demonstrates the impact of funding that supports key activities across the entire research cycle.
Sectors Education

 
Description AHRC Research Grant, Large Grants
Amount £1,840,762 (GBP)
Funding ID AH/T008075/1 
Organisation Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2020 
End 09/2023
 
Description INEE 
Organisation Inter-agency Network for Education in Emergencies
Country United States 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution Ulster University, UNESCO Centre is the lead institution in the establishment of the Political Economy of Education Research (PEER) Network.
Collaborator Contribution Inter-agency Network for Education in Emergencies (INEE) is an open, global network of members working together within a humanitarian and development framework to ensure that all individuals have the right to a quality, safe, relevant, and equitable education. INEE collaborates with the PEER Network as part of a communications strategy to . • Raise awareness of the PEER Network through the INEE website to share news, events, tools, resources, research outputs,; • Help identify Early Career Researchers, particularly in ODA countries and facilitate communication, meetings and involvement with the PEER Network; • Extend the reach of research calls, wider dissemination of findings and helping maximise impact
Impact N/A
Start Year 2019
 
Description Narazarabayev University, School of Education 
Organisation Nazarbayev University
Country Kazakhstan 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Ulster University, UNESCO Centre provides overall leadership and co-ordination for the Political Economy of Education Research (PEER) Network with Nazarabayev University, Kazahkstan as the main regional partner in Central Asia.
Collaborator Contribution Nazarabayev University, Kazahkstan is the lead regional partner for the Political Economy of Education Research (PEER) Network hub in Central Asia. Nazarabayev hosts regional workshops for capacity development of early career researchers on the political economy of education.
Impact N/A. Partnership just established.
Start Year 2019
 
Description University of Cape Town, School of Education 
Organisation University of Cape Town
Department School of Education
Country South Africa 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Ulster University, UNESCO Centre provides overall leadership and co-ordination for the Political Economy of Education Research (PEER) Network with Nazarabayev University, Kazahkstan as the main regional partner in Central Asia.
Collaborator Contribution The University of Cape Town, School of Education is the lead regional partner for the Political Economy of Education Research (PEER) Network. It hosts workshops for knowledge exchange and capacity development workshops for early career researchers from the Sub Saharan Africa.
Impact N/A. Partnership just established
Start Year 2019
 
Description University of Sussex, Centre for International Education 
Organisation University of Sussex
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Ulster provides overall leadership for the establishment of the Political Economy of Education Research (PEER) Network with the University of Sussex, Centre for International Education as the main UK partner.
Collaborator Contribution The University of Sussex, Centre for International Education is taking the lead on development of material and resources to be used in regional workshops on the political economy of education. The resources will be made available online. Sussex is also leading on the engagement of early career researchers in the PEER Network.
Impact An extensive list of previous Research Outputs from this collaboration can be found at: https://educationanddevelopment.wordpress.com/rp/research-consortium-education-and-peacebuilding/
Start Year 2010
 
Description ECR engagement, UKFIET, Oxford (17-19 Sept 2019) 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact A workshop was held for 16 early career researchers as part of the UKFIET Annual Conference on education and development. The purpose was to brief them of the PEER Network and encourage them to become engaged with the Network to support their professional development.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.ukfiet.org/2020/highlights-from-ukfiet-september-2019-conference-part-3-of-3-emerging-is...
 
Description Presentations on Political Economy of Education for PhD students at University of Cape Town (12 Feb 2020) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Presentations on political economy of education were given to 12-15 Masters and PhD students in Education at University of Cape Town.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020