Agri-system histories and trajectories: crops, landscapes, and heritage

Lead Research Organisation: Royal Botanic Gardens
Department Name: Collections

Abstract

We aim to create a holistic framework to study traditional agri-systems within their local agroecological, cultural, and historical settings, focusing on Tigray in the northern Ethiopian Highlands. Globally, agrobiodiversity has declined markedly since the mid-twentieth century, partly prompted by a focus on developing a narrow range of high-yielding crop varieties, shifts to mechanisation, intensive irrigation and the use of agro-chemicals. Genetic diversity within crops is largely preserved in small holdings, making them important areas for in situ conservation of crop landraces (local varieties). Ethiopia is a key location to study agrobiodiversity and the ways it is created and maintained within cultural systems as the Ethiopian Highlands are one of the centres of crop diversity famously identified by Vavilov, and are characterised by both indigenous crops and secondary diversity in several others. This diversity has been preserved in enclaves of the highlands, alongside traditional food processing and non-mechanised farming. Local crop landraces together with associated traditional practices and knowledge are, however, increasingly endangered due to new agricultural methods, urbanisation, and land use change. Northern Ethiopia is important to study as it is more drought prone, and experiences higher levels of food insecurity than central and southern zones. Droughts are increasing in frequency, and the region is feared to be particularly vulnerable to climate change.

It is not possible to fully understand local agricultural trajectories without studying soils and erosion histories, how land use (especially phases of terracing) influences soil variability over time, and documenting people's perceptions of landscape change. Crop diversification and soil preservation are essential for future resilience in the Tigray region. The project is urgently needed to capture knowledge from elderly farmers to determine any changes in crop/landrace roles and the ecological advantages or use properties of these crops. The relationship between land modification, soils and changing patterns of agrobiodiversity can be especially studied in Tigray due to detailed datasets available to the project on terrace development since the 1970s. These datasets will enable us to distinguish traditional and modern categories of land-use and erosion mitigation, and hence to study the legacy and efficacy of terraces over time. Also, by distinguishing local vs introduced terracing, we will contribute to studies of landscape as local heritage.

The project will establish a new multidisciplinary, international and cross-sector research partnership to study agriculture, crops and food systems within different agro-climatic zones across Tigray. We will undertake fieldwork to design and pilot interdisciplinary research methods to study traditional agri-systems, and will assess and locate a range of suitable case-study areas (e.g. contrasting local environments, preservation of traditions, connecting with local NGOs, or local archaeological projects that provide useful contextual data on long-term environmental histories). Methods development and pilot research will investigate (i) relationships between local crop choices, environments and cultural influences together with the main reasons for change; (ii) the ways in which current farming strategies are influenced by local patterns of soil variation, landscape modification (especially terraces), and erosion histories; and (iii) the ongoing relationship between traditional agricultural systems and cultural heritage (such as items made from crop-processing by-products, material culture connected with food processing, agricultural landscapes, intangible heritage such as songs sung during threshing).

Planned Impact

Local rural communities are direct beneficiaries. In Tigray, climate change and loss of traditional knowledge of agrobiodiversity and land management is a threat to future livelihoods. The project will help protect indigenous knowledge through new data and research tools capable of documenting local knowledge holistically via cross-disciplinary researchers and interdisciplinary approaches. This will create a better understanding of how agrobiodiversity connects to local ecological context (seasonality, soils, terraces), diversity of agricultural practices, cultural preferences, and temporal change. We will also explore local agriculture from a heritage perspective - and the connectivity between biocultural heritage (crops, cultivated landscapes), material culture (e.g. agricultural tools, terracing, thatching, basketry) and intangible heritage (e.g. farmers' knowledge, agricultural cycles, cuisine). We will consult with communities on the nature of locally produced/distributed outputs (leaflets, video, community meetings, school visits); and information crucial for co-designing a larger future project with and for local communities and third-sector partners.

Linking ethnobotanical studies of agrobiodiversity within a cultural and historical context, can contribute towards strategies for coping with climate change, by understanding drivers of change and reasons for landrace loss/preservation/distribution. Cross-sector research impact will be facilitated by communicating methods and results across the academic/agricultural research community and between local and international NGOs from the outset, many of which have a direct presence within Ethiopia and the Tigray region.

We will contribute to a better understanding of landscape change - created by both erosion and measures to contain it which can influence local, national and international policies. This will highlight how understanding past landscapes can inform strategies for future sustainable land-management. Whilst the character and efficacy of indigenous terraces will be explored, this will be compared and contextualised by identifying the locations and intended function of widespread terracing built by international agencies from the 1970s, the latter facilitated by unique archival information made available to the project. These data plus our ethnobotanical, ethnopedological and archaeological data will determine information on terrace efficacy over the last 50yrs of relevance to other regions in Ethiopia and beyond that have had analogous terracing within modern periods. Also, unraveling the complexity of local and introduced terracing will permit reconstructions of longer-term landscape histories related to local farming practices.

Agricultural heritage is a newly emerging category, taking its place alongside archaeological/monumental heritage and is a comparatively new and underdeveloped research area across Africa. The project will directly engage with local heritage preservation strategies. Supporting the development of cross-departmental interdisciplinary research at Mekelle University will also facilitate local capacity building, including through field training, and two-way knowledge exchange.

Hosted by RBG Kew, the project website and Plants of the World Online (POWO) portal will make selected plant-specific data widely available to all interested audiences, including the general public. Public engagement initiatives at Kew (e.g. Science Weekend) will promote and disseminate research results. We will share reports of project findings with local organizations (NGOs) during and at the end of the research project. Results will be communicated to diverse audiences in Ethiopia through AAU project partners and via local agricultural research collaborators in connection with Kew's existing network of stakeholders in Ethiopia - the latter developed through collaborations and projects covering plant diversity, genomics, resilience and conservation.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Currently we are mid-way through this project. It has been adapted to include a broader range of case study regions, in Ethiopia and additionally in Guinea.

Our new slightly altered title and summary of aims are:

Agri-system histories and trajectories: crops, landscapes, and heritage -
We aim to create a holistic framework to study traditional agri-systems within their local agroecological, cultural, and historical settings, focusing on case-study areas in the Ethiopian Highlands and in Guinea. Globally, agrobiodiversity has declined markedly since the mid-twentieth century, partly prompted by a focus on developing a narrow range of high-yielding crop varieties, shifts to mechanisation, intensive irrigation, and the use of agro-chemicals. Diversity within crops is largely preserved in small holdings, making them important areas for in situ conservation of crop landraces (local varieties). Local crop landraces together with associated traditional practices and knowledge are, however, increasingly endangered for many reasons, including due to new agricultural methods, urbanisation, and land use change. Ethiopia and Guinea are both key locations to study agrobiodiversity and the ways it is created and maintained within cultural systems as these regions are both centres of crop diversity.
A key aim is to develop approaches for identifying and recording endangered knowledge about changes in food crops, including about their resilient traits, commercial or cultural role. The project is looking to develop a broad framework to study local crop histories and heritage, and equally how such approaches will be needed to be adapted within each region. The extent and rate of agricultural change will always be variable between and within regions, with some traditional practices or crop uses persisting, being in a state of flux or being already disappeared. The scope of ethnobotanical research and oral histories would vary depending on the complexity of temporal change, the types of crops being studied, and the degree of existing botanical data collection. Equally, it is not possible to fully understand local agricultural trajectories without considering the local environmental context, including patterns of land use such as phases of terracing.
The project looks to establish new multidisciplinary, international, and cross-sector research partnerships to study agriculture, crops, and food systems within selected agro-climatic zones. Aims include to design and pilot interdisciplinary research methods to study traditional agri-systems, and to assess and locate a range of suitable case-study areas (e.g., contrasting local environments, preservation of traditions, connecting with any local NGOs, or local archaeological projects that provide useful contextual data on long-term environmental histories). Exploratory case-studies aim to scope how to investigate agri-histories and agri-heritage in different regions. Methods development and pilot research could include investigating (i) relationships between local crop choices, environments and cultural preferences (including foods) together with the main reasons for change; (ii) the ways in which current farming strategies are influenced by local patterns of soil variation, landscape modification (especially terraces); and (iii) the ongoing relationship between traditional agricultural systems and cultural heritage (such as items made from crop-processing by-products, material culture connected with food processing, agricultural landscapes, intangible heritage such as songs sung during threshing).

We have identified case-study regions with local partners, partners have undertaken pilot field trips in Ethiopia and Eastern Guinea, and the whole team has undertaken fieldwork in central Guinea, and currently we are planning further trips. We are currently developing ethno-botanical and historical methodologies for studying crops in these regions, centered on specific communities and crops.
Exploitation Route Yes, ultimately the knowledge generated and approaches developed will be of interest to cross-disciplinary and sector audiences spanning environmental/botanical humanities and sciences and policy related to crop diversity and heritage.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Education,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections

URL https://www.kew.org/read-and-watch/journey-to-discover-fonio
 
Description Our initial fieldwork in Guinea was partnered with a local NGO who reported that the information generated about the dynamics behind the local agricultural practices will be useful for their future conservation work in the region and that more such information would be beneficial. Our project is trialing methods that we hope to evolve into widely applicable approaches for better understanding and tracking diversity loss, and that emphases the need for historical and cultural approaches that are currently little included
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Education,Environment,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections
Impact Types Cultural,Societal,Economic,Policy & public services

 
Description Blog 
Form Of Engagement Activity Engagement focused website, blog or social media channel
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact 'Read and Watch' blog and webpage on our project fieldwork in Guinea.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.kew.org/read-and-watch/journey-to-discover-fonio
 
Description Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact Presentation at an international interdisciplinary Ethnobotanical conference, Society of Economic Botany - 'An integrated approach to the study of orphan crops and indigenous food systems: evidence from Tropical Africa'.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description Conference presentation - led by partner Alemseged Beldados (Addis Ababa University) Agri-system histories and trajectories: case-studies from central Ethiopia 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Study participants or study members
Results and Impact This presentation was based on preliminary project fieldwork which was led by, and presented by, colleagues from Addis Ababa University.
The workshop was also part of the project, bringing together case-studies on agricultural heritage.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://therai.org.uk/conferences/anthropology-and-conservation/panels#10279