Civic Media for Housing Rights: Lessons from struggles against evictions in São Paulo and Lagos

Lead Research Organisation: International Institute for Environment and Development
Department Name: Human Settlements Group

Abstract

The role of digital and social media technologies to advance social change is a key debate of our times. In this field, there is a range of literature discussing 'Civic Media' to examine how media practices and technologies employed by grassroots groups have helped to advance rights and social justice. We will contribute to this debate by focusing on the civic media practices utilised in the housing rights struggles across Lagos and São Paulo, where rights violations are threatening lives and livelihoods of marginalised groups living in insecure housing.

In São Paulo, local government has recently endorsed evictions that violate housing rights, while in Lagos, government-led evictions and harassment of informal dwellers have persisted even after court orders condemned these as unlawful. Social movements and their support networks in both cities have used digital and social media practices to share information about the threat of evictions and denounce these housing rights violations. In São Paulo, social movements have used on-line manifestos, webinars and digital mapping tools to generate public debates about these violations and to amplify the voices of the urban poor. Meanwhile, grassroots groups in Lagos' informal settlements have developed films, exhibitions and digital stories aimed at mobilising public support against evictions while also challenging social stigma associated with residents of informal settlements. In both cities, it is crucial that these civic media initiatives can be strengthened to improve their capacity to shape equitable decision-making processes and support more inclusive visions of urban development.

This project will support and learn from these initiatives by focusing on how civic media can influence policy and planning processes in Lagos and São Paulo. The research activities will identify specific short- and longer-term opportunities to support housing rights by reducing unlawful evictions and other violations, while at the same time securing policy instruments that can promote access to adequate housing and enhance recognition for marginalised urban citizens. During our participatory action research project, we will carry out civic media campaigns in both cities targeting these specific planning opportunities. At the same time, we will analyse the lessons learnt and impacts of these experiences, with the intention to inform debates and practice about how civic media can advance social justice in cities.

Our project's public-facing outputs will mainly target policy and planning processes in Lagos and São Paulo to raise policymakers' awareness of marginalised residents' voices and priorities. By doing this, we hope that urban plans are better able to recognise the diverse needs of the urban poor and support programmes that can upgrade informal settlements and other precarious housing via participatory processes. Through academic papers and a tool-kit on civic media for housing rights, we will share key lessons with international networks of practitioners, civil society organisations, and engaged academics interested in using civic media to enhance the capabilities of social movements to advance housing rights. Finally, we also seek to influence international donors and foundations by discussing how to promote housing rights using community-led communication activities.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Sesan Temilade (2023) Housing Policy Analysis

publication icon
Rodrigues, Evaniza (2023) Mapeamento e Análise de Mídia

publication icon
Rodrigues, Evaniza (2023) Análises de Políticas Públicas

 
Description Cities fit for Young People
Amount £878,814 (GBP)
Funding ID REG-22-011 
Organisation Fondation Botnar 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country Switzerland
Start 09/2023 
End 02/2026
 
Description Civic Media for Housing Rights 
Organisation Federal University of ABC
Country Brazil 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have set up the collaboration agreement, which is guiding the implementation of the research project in collaboration among the five institutions. IIED team will be coordinating the development of the research methodology, as well as the approach for knowledge exchange and dissemination. IIED will also provide any necessary support for the collaborators to implement the research activities associated to this project.
Collaborator Contribution They have agreed to implement the activities of the research project, which includes conducting research activities, setting up civic media labs, participating in knowledge exchange and dissemination activities.
Impact Completion of stage 1 of the research, which included: development and signing of collaboration agreement among all collaborating institutions; development and submission initial media landscape and housing analysis in Lagos and São Paulo; participation in knowledge exchange remote workshops.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Civic Media for Housing Rights 
Organisation Justice and Empowerment Initiative (Jei)
Country Nigeria 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution We have set up the collaboration agreement, which is guiding the implementation of the research project in collaboration among the five institutions. IIED team will be coordinating the development of the research methodology, as well as the approach for knowledge exchange and dissemination. IIED will also provide any necessary support for the collaborators to implement the research activities associated to this project.
Collaborator Contribution They have agreed to implement the activities of the research project, which includes conducting research activities, setting up civic media labs, participating in knowledge exchange and dissemination activities.
Impact Completion of stage 1 of the research, which included: development and signing of collaboration agreement among all collaborating institutions; development and submission initial media landscape and housing analysis in Lagos and São Paulo; participation in knowledge exchange remote workshops.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Civic Media for Housing Rights 
Organisation University of Ibadan
Country Nigeria 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We have set up the collaboration agreement, which is guiding the implementation of the research project in collaboration among the five institutions. IIED team will be coordinating the development of the research methodology, as well as the approach for knowledge exchange and dissemination. IIED will also provide any necessary support for the collaborators to implement the research activities associated to this project.
Collaborator Contribution They have agreed to implement the activities of the research project, which includes conducting research activities, setting up civic media labs, participating in knowledge exchange and dissemination activities.
Impact Completion of stage 1 of the research, which included: development and signing of collaboration agreement among all collaborating institutions; development and submission initial media landscape and housing analysis in Lagos and São Paulo; participation in knowledge exchange remote workshops.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Civic Media and the Right to the City 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Postgraduate students
Results and Impact This is a talk given at Federal University of ABC (in São Paulo on 03/03/2023) by Alexandre Apsan Frediani (IIED, project PI) and Evaniza Rodrigues (Uniao dos Movimentos de Moradia, project collaborator) focused on the role of civic media in advancing right to the city. There were 80 postgraduate students, as well as academic staff and representatives from different social movements. Discussions increased the audience's interest on the intersections between communications and the advancement of the right to the city.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
 
Description Communications and the struggle for the right to the housing 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Third sector organisations
Results and Impact Alexandre Apsan Frediani (project PI) participated in an on-line class by the 'Escola da Cidadania' of the Polis Institute. This course targeted representatives from Brazilian social movements and grassroots organisations as well as activists, engaged academics and professionals working in NGOs. There were 120 participants in the class, who were extremely interested in learning more about how communication practices can help to advance the right to housing.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=FPZq72fEeW8