Enggano in the Austronesian family: Historical and typological perspectives
Lead Research Organisation:
UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD
Department Name: Linguistics Philology and Phonetics
Abstract
Enggano, with about 1000 speakers, is spoken on Enggano Island, off the southern coast of Sumatra, Indonesia. Enggano is classified as "threatened": only the elder generation are fully competent and fluent speakers. Many children speak Indonesian and little to no Enggano. Intensified contact with non-Enggano speakers is likely to continue and spread throughout the island, to the detriment of Enggano.
The first aim of our project is to document the Enggano language: we will record, transcribe, translate, and analyse a body of traditional stories, conversations, cultural events, and descriptions of everyday tasks in the Enggano language. With the permissions of the speakers, we will make these recordings available on the project web page, and we will deposit the dataset in a standard archive at the end of the project. This will allow the data to be preserved for future research and, for the Enggano community and its descendants, as a record of possibly the last generation of fluent Enggano speakers.
The second aim of the project is to produce a grammar of Enggano in its Austronesian context, thoroughly describing the major structures of the language. Our research will draw on previous work on the language, the dataset that we will collect, and targeted work with Enggano speakers on the details of Enggano language structures. The resulting reference grammar will be valuable as a detailed study of the grammatical structures of the language, particularly to linguists specialising in the Austronesian language family, since it will allow for comparison of the structure of Enggano to corresponding structures in other languages of the region. We intend to publish the grammar through an open-access publisher: this will make our work accessible to researchers in linguistics and related fields worldwide, and in particular to researchers in Indonesia, for whom academic books are sometimes inaccessible or too expensive to acquire.
For linguists, Enggano is an intriguing puzzle: it has been claimed by some linguists to be a member of the Austronesian language family, like many other languages of the region, but by other linguists to be an isolate with no known relation to other languages. We believe that Enggano is an unusual Austronesian language, but further evidence is required to firmly establish the place of Enggano within Austronesian: almost all of the work that has been conducted on the genetic affiliation of Enggano is based on research by the linguist Hans Kähler, conducted on a single seven-month visit in 1937-8. Additional work is needed to test and supplement Kähler's data and to determine how the language has changed in the intervening years. We will devote one or more chapters of the grammar to an exploration of Enggano's genetic affiliation and relation to other Austronesian languages.
Finally, we will work to empower the Enggano community to document and preserve their own language. A central component of this effort is our plan to develop educational materials for teaching the Enggano language in local schools, targeting Years 7-9 (ages 13-15). We will work with local educators and community leaders to develop these materials and to raise awareness of language and cultural endangerment, and with local government institutions to ensure that our educational materials meet local government standards.
The first aim of our project is to document the Enggano language: we will record, transcribe, translate, and analyse a body of traditional stories, conversations, cultural events, and descriptions of everyday tasks in the Enggano language. With the permissions of the speakers, we will make these recordings available on the project web page, and we will deposit the dataset in a standard archive at the end of the project. This will allow the data to be preserved for future research and, for the Enggano community and its descendants, as a record of possibly the last generation of fluent Enggano speakers.
The second aim of the project is to produce a grammar of Enggano in its Austronesian context, thoroughly describing the major structures of the language. Our research will draw on previous work on the language, the dataset that we will collect, and targeted work with Enggano speakers on the details of Enggano language structures. The resulting reference grammar will be valuable as a detailed study of the grammatical structures of the language, particularly to linguists specialising in the Austronesian language family, since it will allow for comparison of the structure of Enggano to corresponding structures in other languages of the region. We intend to publish the grammar through an open-access publisher: this will make our work accessible to researchers in linguistics and related fields worldwide, and in particular to researchers in Indonesia, for whom academic books are sometimes inaccessible or too expensive to acquire.
For linguists, Enggano is an intriguing puzzle: it has been claimed by some linguists to be a member of the Austronesian language family, like many other languages of the region, but by other linguists to be an isolate with no known relation to other languages. We believe that Enggano is an unusual Austronesian language, but further evidence is required to firmly establish the place of Enggano within Austronesian: almost all of the work that has been conducted on the genetic affiliation of Enggano is based on research by the linguist Hans Kähler, conducted on a single seven-month visit in 1937-8. Additional work is needed to test and supplement Kähler's data and to determine how the language has changed in the intervening years. We will devote one or more chapters of the grammar to an exploration of Enggano's genetic affiliation and relation to other Austronesian languages.
Finally, we will work to empower the Enggano community to document and preserve their own language. A central component of this effort is our plan to develop educational materials for teaching the Enggano language in local schools, targeting Years 7-9 (ages 13-15). We will work with local educators and community leaders to develop these materials and to raise awareness of language and cultural endangerment, and with local government institutions to ensure that our educational materials meet local government standards.
Planned Impact
Enggano Island has a complicated history. For reasons that are unclear, the Enggano population dropped from 6,420 in 1866, to 870 in 1884, to 291 in 1913 (Suzuki 1958; Jaspan 1964). In 1937, Kähler estimated that there were 200 speakers of Enggano. The island was further affected when, in 1961, a juvenile/young adult detention centre was established in Enggano, leading to a heavy influx of non-Enggano-speaking offenders from elsewhere in Indonesia (Jaspan 1964). By 1963, indigenous Engganese constituted only 1/8 of the total population of the island. In the present day, Enggano is classified as a "threatened" language by Ethnologue (Simons 2018). Although we believe that the population of Enggano speakers has now increased to about 1000 speakers, only the older generation are fully competent and fluent speakers. The community is fully aware of the precarious state of the Enggano language, but there are currently no organized, community-based efforts to document and preserve the language, despite enthusiasm from younger members of the community. Our project will benefit the Enggano community in several ways.
First, we will strive to involve the entire Enggano community in the documentation effort, and in a wider discussion of reclamation and maintenance of local cultural heritage in the broader Indonesian context. The key stakeholders in this effort are community leaders, including Clan Elders who are fluent speakers of the language as well as university-educated young adults who are dedicated to finding a way of preserving traditional Enggano language and culture in a contemporary context. Their leadership will ensure the sustainability of this effort in the long term, after our project is finished.
A key component of this effort is our plan to produce educational materials to enable teaching of the Enggano language to students in Years 7-9 (ages 13-15) in local schools. Local impact from this activity will come in two waves. First, we will involve local educators, Clan Elders, and community leaders in the design, creation, and testing of these materials, using the Enggano data we will collect as a basis. This will ensure that these crucial stakeholders are perceived as leaders in the language and culture preservation effort. Second, deployment and use of the educational materials in schools will increase awareness, knowledge and use of the Enggano language among children and teenagers, and will enhance the viability of the language preservation effort in the long term.
A secondary effect of our work is our contribution to economic growth: in the short term, by employing members of the community as project consultants, and in the long term by increasing the worldwide visibiity of Enggano language and culture through our academic presentations and our website and hence promoting tourism and helping local businesses.
Finally, we plan to increase general awareness of linguistic issues in Indonesia by writing one or more general-readership articles on detecting relationships between languages, for publication in a prominent on-line Indonesian publication. We hope that a greater awareness of linguistic issues in Indonesia, in which 719 languages are spoken, will help in other language documentation and preservation efforts for other languages.
First, we will strive to involve the entire Enggano community in the documentation effort, and in a wider discussion of reclamation and maintenance of local cultural heritage in the broader Indonesian context. The key stakeholders in this effort are community leaders, including Clan Elders who are fluent speakers of the language as well as university-educated young adults who are dedicated to finding a way of preserving traditional Enggano language and culture in a contemporary context. Their leadership will ensure the sustainability of this effort in the long term, after our project is finished.
A key component of this effort is our plan to produce educational materials to enable teaching of the Enggano language to students in Years 7-9 (ages 13-15) in local schools. Local impact from this activity will come in two waves. First, we will involve local educators, Clan Elders, and community leaders in the design, creation, and testing of these materials, using the Enggano data we will collect as a basis. This will ensure that these crucial stakeholders are perceived as leaders in the language and culture preservation effort. Second, deployment and use of the educational materials in schools will increase awareness, knowledge and use of the Enggano language among children and teenagers, and will enhance the viability of the language preservation effort in the long term.
A secondary effect of our work is our contribution to economic growth: in the short term, by employing members of the community as project consultants, and in the long term by increasing the worldwide visibiity of Enggano language and culture through our academic presentations and our website and hence promoting tourism and helping local businesses.
Finally, we plan to increase general awareness of linguistic issues in Indonesia by writing one or more general-readership articles on detecting relationships between languages, for publication in a prominent on-line Indonesian publication. We hope that a greater awareness of linguistic issues in Indonesia, in which 719 languages are spoken, will help in other language documentation and preservation efforts for other languages.
Publications

Arka, I Wayan
(2024)
Projecting Voices: Essays in language and linguistics in honour of Jane Simpson


Bernd Nothofer
(2021)
Knowledge, Science and Local Tradition

Charlotte Hemmings
(2022)
Evidence of contact with Malay/Indonesian in the Enggano language

Charlotte Hemmings
(2024)
Historical development of relative clauses in Enggano

Charlotte Hemmings
(2023)
A corpus-based analysis of grammatical relations in Enggano

Charlotte Hemmings
(2023)
Grammaticalisation of kide? as a similative marker in contemporary Enggano

Charlotte Hemmings
(2023)
Reanalysis in the history of Enggano relative clauses

Charlotte Hemmings
(2021)
Challenges in Enggano Orthography Development

Dendi Wijaya
(2023)
Makna Asosiasi dalam Bahasa Enggano [Word Meaning Associations in Enggano]
Description | Our work is ongoing, but we have made several discoveries so far, in particular related to: the sound patterns and word structure of Enggano; the potential historical relation of Enggano to other languages of the region; how Enggano has changed over the past 150 years, on the basis of examination of historical documents and wordlists; dialect variation in contemporary Enggano. We have conducted in-depth work on the structure of Enggano at earlier stages as well as the contemporary language, and we continue to work with the Enggano community on the development of a practical orthography for Enggano. |
Exploitation Route | Our historical findings will help to clarify Enggano's place in the Austronesian family, and will inform our understanding of the prehistory of the region. Our work on Enggano orthograpy will support the community's efforts to develop written material in Enggano, including the textbooks which we are also working on. |
Sectors | Education |
URL | https://enggano.ling-phil.ox.ac.uk/ |
Description | Our dataset of Enggano audio and video recordings constitutes an important record of traditional stories and other oral performances by what may be the last generation of fluent speakers. Various community leaders, speaking on behalf of the community as a whole, have expressed enthusiastic support for the project; they are aware of the precarious state of their language and are anxious for it to be recorded while the opportunity remains. By involving community stakeholders and native speaker linguists in the documentation, several have been trained, including Mr. Engga Zakaria and Mr. Afrizon Rafles, in the use of language documentation software (such as ELAN and SayMore), data processing and planning and executing language documentation recording sessions. This has empowered them to become leaders in Enggano language and cultural maintenance and revitalization activities. Local educators and community leaders are working in partnership with us to develop educational materials for local schools, targeting ages 13-15. We have also made several general-audience presentations in the UK about our project to raise awareness of language endangerment; we have given a presentation at the Badan Bahasa (Language Development and Fostering Agency, Jakarta) about our Enggano project; and we have co-sponsored a training event for fieldwork, field-based linguistic research, local capacity-building and community engagement in language-culture maintenance at the University of Bengkulu, Indonesia. |
Sector | Education |
Impact Types | Cultural Societal Policy & public services |
Description | Perlindungan Bahasa Enggano Perspektif Lokal [Protection of the Enggano Language: Local Perspective] |
Geographic Reach | Asia |
Policy Influence Type | Influenced training of practitioners or researchers |
URL | https://enggano.ling-phil.ox.ac.uk/static/papers/PPT%20ENGGA%20ZAKARIA%20SANGIAN.pptx |
Description | AfOx Catalyst Grants, Africa Oxford Initiative, University of Oxford |
Amount | £5,000 (GBP) |
Organisation | Africa Oxford Initiative |
Sector | Academic/University |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 03/2024 |
End | 05/2024 |
Description | Lexical resources for Enggano, a threatened language of Indonesia |
Amount | £312,561 (GBP) |
Funding ID | AH/W007290/1 |
Organisation | Arts & Humanities Research Council (AHRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 11/2022 |
End | 10/2024 |
Title | Enggano keyboard for mobile phones and computers |
Description | The Enggano keyboard allows typing the special Enggano characters a~, e?, e?~, i~, o~, u~, u?, u?~ on mobile phone keyboards and desktop/laptop computers. It uses SIL's Keyman keyboarding platform. |
Type Of Material | Improvements to research infrastructure |
Year Produced | 2022 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Impact | The Enggano community is now able to communicate in the Enggano language via computers and mobile phones using this keyboard. |
URL | https://enggano.ling-phil.ox.ac.uk/static/keyman.html |
Title | Recordings and transcriptions of contemporary Enggano |
Description | Recordings of Enggano speakers, with transcriptions and translations. |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2020 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Impact | Informs our ongoing research on the Enggano language. |
URL | https://enggano.ling-phil.ox.ac.uk/static/recordings.html |
Title | Texts collected by Hans Kähler |
Description | Morphosyntactic analyses of the texts collected by Hans Kähler during his visit to Enggano Island in the 1930s, and of the examples in his grammar. The analyses were produced by Mary Dalrymple and Charlotte Hemmings, using SIL's FieldWorks (FLEx) tools. We also make available the FLEx backup file which produced these analyses. |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2022 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Impact | A full analysis of Enggano as it was spoken 90 years ago has informed our work on historical change in Enggano and the genetic affiliation of Enggano with other Austronesian languages. |
URL | https://enggano.ling-phil.ox.ac.uk/static/databases.html |
Title | Texts collected by O. L. Helfrich |
Description | Morphosyntactic analysis of the texts collected by O. L. Helfrich in the late eighteenth century. The analyses were produced by Mary Dalrymple and Charlotte Hemmings, using SIL's FieldWorks (FLEx) tools. We also make available the FLEx backup file which produced these analyses |
Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
Year Produced | 2022 |
Provided To Others? | Yes |
Impact | The analyses of Enggano as it was spoken 140 years ago have informed our research into historical change in Enggano. |
URL | https://enggano.ling-phil.ox.ac.uk/static/databases.html |
Description | BRIN (Badan Riset dan Inovasi Nasional/National Research and Innovation Agency) |
Organisation | Ministry of Research and Technology / National Research and Innovation Agency |
Country | Indonesia |
Sector | Public |
PI Contribution | Project member Dendi Wijaya is a researcher at the Indonesian research agency BRIN. |
Collaborator Contribution | Mr. Wijaya wrote his master's thesis on the Enggano language, and he has worked with us on collecting data on Enggano Island, and has coauthored several research pages with project members. |
Impact | Critical ecological factors and Enggano vitality. I Wayan Arka, Arono, Dendi Wijaya, and Engga Zakaria. 14th International Austronesian and Papuan Languages and Linguistics Conference, June 2022. Challenges in Enggano Orthography Development. Charlotte Hemmings, I Wayan Arka, Mary Dalrymple, Engga Zakaria Sangian and Dendi Wijaya. Language Documentation and Linguistic Theory 6, SOAS, London, December 2021. |
Start Year | 2022 |
Description | Bahasa dan Budaya Enggano / Enggano Language and Culture, |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
Results and Impact | Public lecture at the University of Oxford, sponsored by the Critical Indigenous Studies Network, The Oxford Research Centre in the Humanities. In this presentation, Engga Zakaria and Pak Milson discussed the Enggano language and culture from an indigenous perspective, and Engga, Pak Milson, Charlotte Hemmings, and Dendi Wijaya presented an introduction to the Enggano Documentation Project and a round table discussion on challenges for the future faced by the Enggano community. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
URL | https://enggano.ling-phil.ox.ac.uk/static/papers/Enggano%20Project%20Final.pdf |
Description | First International Symposium on Research and Community Service (The 1st ISRECOs)/2022 International Conference on The Austronesian and Papuan Worlds (ICAPaW) |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | International |
Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
Results and Impact | This workshop was sponsored and jointly organized by CIHRSS Udayana University-Australian National University; The Enggano Project, University of Oxford; Research Center for Language and Literature Preservation BRIN; and University of Bengkulu. This conference provided training in the form of master classes in language and culture documentation, field-based linguistic research, local capacity-building and community engagement in language-culture maintenance. The master classes were given by project members Prof. I Wayan Arka and Dr. Yishan Huang |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
Description | Introduction to Linguistics; Multilingualism in Indonesia; Language Diversity in Indonesia; Language Endangerment in Indonesia, using Enggano as an example |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Schools |
Results and Impact | 20 school children (aged 11-12) visited Oxford in February. Charlotte Hemmings gave a 1.5 hour workshop on linguistics, languages of Indonesia & endangered languages. Overall, feedback from the event was very positive. Many children reported that learning about endangered languages was the most interesting thing they learned. All children were able to articulate the value of supporting endangered languages |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
Description | Methods for Data Collection & Analysis in Language Documentation workshop |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | Local |
Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
Results and Impact | Charlotte Hemmings ran two graduate training seminars on "Methods for Data Collection & Analysis in Language Documentation" in the Faculty of Asian and Middle Eastern Studies, University of Oxford, drawing on experiences in the Enggano Project. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
Description | The Enggano Project |
Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | This was a presentation of our project by Charlotte Hemmings at the event "Celebrating Indigenous Languages - Defending Endangered Languages; Marking the 25th anniversary of the Foundation for Endangered Languages & Launching the UN International Decade of Indigenous Languages 2022 - 2032, April 2022". |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2022 |
URL | https://www.ogmios.org/anniversary2022.pdf |