Geospatial Design of Energy Systems for Africa: Citizen Science

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Engineering Science

Abstract

Geospatial Design of Energy Systems for Africa (GeoDESA) Citizen Science aims to integrate citizen science in rural electrical grid planning for developing regions. As over 800 million people still lack reliable access to electricity, and the UN is targeting affordable clean energy access for all by 2030, innovative electrification strategies are needed to close the gap.

Data-driven geospatial system planning can be an effective way to accelerate electrification. High-resolution geographic data and modern computing power can be leveraged to plan community-specific grid development cheaply and quickly, reducing costs by an order of magnitude compared to traditional methods.

One key challenge in this approach is the need for detailed home location data. Home locations are necessary to design grid topologies and architectures. This level of specificity enables better grid cost estimates and community-appropriate design. Currently available home location datasets, such as OpenStreetMap, are typically incomplete, particularly in the hardest-to-reach rural poor areas.

High-resolution satellite imagery and modern computer vision algorithms can fill the gaps in these datasets. While many algorithms have been trained to detect housing in the past, they are typically based on rich urban contexts. The full diversity of rural and remote housing styles must be taken into account to enable the dwelling detection needed for electrification design.

By engaging citizen scientists fluent in local rural housing styles in the labeling of homes in satellite imagery, local knowledge can be incorporated in a scalable data-driven approach. With accurate and context-informed labelled satellite data, computer vision algorithms can be trained to reliably locate rural dwellings in the hardest to reach areas, allowing grids to be efficiently designed to suit community needs.

This proposal complements past and ongoing work undertaken at the University of Oxford in rural Africa electrification from the SONG and RELCON projects. The methods developed and data generated will be useful for electrical system planning in many rural and remote contexts, and can cross-apply into other geographic planning disciplines, such as urban planning, migration tracking, and geospatial poverty estimation.

Technical Summary

This research will involve outreach engagement with citizen scientists in sub-Saharan Africa. The intended focus for engagement is Ethiopia. 56% of Ethiopia's population still lack access to electricity. The government of Ethiopia has a strong interest in geospatial electrical system planning. Existing connections at universities in Bahir Dar and Addis Ababa will enable citizen science engagement. However, should there be any challenges in the political environment in Ethiopia which make on-the-ground engagement problematic, we also have connections in Kenya through past and ongoing projects, particularly in universities in Nairobi and Mombasa, which will enable us to work there.

GeoDESA Citizen Science will bring on-the-ground citizen science engagement to rural grid design through rural home identification. Workshops will be arranged on sustainable grid planning using geospatial methods highlighting the importance of local knowledge to this problem. An accompanying Zooniverse-hosted citizen science platform will be made available to participants. This platform, called "Home Sweet Home" (currently viewable in pilot: www.bit.do/geodesa) will allow citizen scientists to label homes in high-resolution satellite imagery. Imagery is provided by Earth-i through an ongoing Oxford collaboration with Satellite Applications Catapult. The citizen science platform will be disseminated through Zooniverse's participant email lists, as well as through academic networks. Many participants reached through Zooniverse communications will likely be from England; this will provide us with internationally-produced labels to compare with the locally-produced labels resulting from on-the-ground outreach. The data labelled by citizen scientists will be used in the training of object detection computer vision algorithms for dwelling location. It will be analysed how the data labeling varies between local citizen scientists and international citizen scientists using label metadata.

Planned Impact

This project has the potential for far-reaching impact, with cross-sector utility and insights. The citizen science methodologies, if successful, can be used to accelerate myriad data-driven research efforts. In this particular project, the outputs of the work have the potential to create electrical planning tools useful in diverse rural and remote developing contexts. If adopted widely, these could accelerate electrification and provide more contextually appropriate system designs, with the potential benefit of improved energy access to millions of people worldwide.

The University of Oxford Energy and Power Group has ties with relevant Ethiopian and Kenyan policy-makers in energy system planning, who we anticipate will find this work of interest. The methods produced have the potential to be used widely by multilateral organisations, government agencies, and private-sector developers.

The data and methods developed in this project will be made openly available. This is both in the spirit of open citizen science and to avoid gate-keeping resources which could have great impact in public- and private-sector electrical development. There is a precedent for open-source geographic models being used widely by multilateral organisations, as shown by the use of the OnSSET tool by the World Bank. This work could create a similarly beneficial tool to be used widely and openly.

Through work on this project, the University of Oxford's Energy and Power Group will familiarize themselves with best practices for citizen science engagement. This will equip them to integrate citizen science methods in further projects and set a precedent for citizen science engagement in rural grid design.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Through GeoDESA Citizen Science, a novel training dataset of rural homes was created to be used in computer vision object detection algorithms. This dataset will be made openly available for research use.

However, alongside this achievement of intended research outcomes, this project also created significant community impacts. These are outlined in the following sub-sections.

A) Understanding (changes in knowledge, mindset, attitudes or motivation):

This project proved to be a learning experience for many of our contributors. Nearly two-thirds (65.5%) of respondents to our evaluation survey reported that they learned something by engaging with the project. Topics they learned about included satellite imagery analysis, home construction in rural sub-Saharan Africa, landscapes and settlement patterns of Kenya, Sierra Leone, and Uganda, and the need for rural energy access.

Participating in this project also prompted 17.6% of respondents to do their own investigations into concepts relevant to the project. Most of those who sought further information did so via internet search, and the most popular research topic was information about the countries of Kenya, Sierra Leone, and Uganda.

B) Capability (changes in ability or skill):

Various evaluation survey respondents reported learning how to analyse satellite imagery in a way they hadn't before. Others reported gaining more familiarity with AI and how it can be used in rural mapping. The following quotes provided by evaluation survey respondents when asked to describe what they learned illustrate these capabilities being built:

"How to 'read' satellite imagery; something about conditions on the ground in rural Kenya"

"I learnt about the existence of satellite imagery analysis and that AI is used in it. I also have a general idea of how rural areas look like in different countries that I didn't have before."

C) Innovation (changes in practise or new ways of working):

Through our online citizen science approach, data was collected effectively, quickly, and in an engaging way. This is a much more interactive, pleasant, and interesting process than having researchers label data themselves or employing a service such as Amazon Mechanical Turk. 87.4% of our evaluation survey respondents said that their experience contributing to the project was either good or excellent; this reflects very well on this innovative approach. Through the two-way street of citizen science communication, our researchers learned to define and present their research goals in a digestible way, and citizens gained the agency to help guide the design of scientific research.
Exploitation Route The Energy and Power Group at the University of Oxford is interested in running additional citizen science initiatives in the future. The power of this approach has been communicated to the broader group through a seminar conducted by GeoDESA Citizen Science researchers, which was met with positive feedback.

Sharing the results of GeoDESA Citizen Science will be important should we wish to revitalize this project for another "round" - or, to conduct similar citizen science engaging the project community. We will be communicating the results through open-access journal publications, accompanying blog and social media posts, through the online citizen science platform, and through other channels to maximise reach.
Sectors Communities and Social Services/Policy,Energy,Government, Democracy and Justice

 
Description The grant had an immediate impact on the citizen scientists involved, in that the feedback demomnstrated that they learned actively through participating about global electricity access and about the geographies and lifestyles in Kenya, Uganda, and Sierra Leone. They overwhelmingly reported that they found meaning and fulfillment during the COVID 19 lockdowns by being able to participate in this scientific research remotely from home. The outcomes of this research have directly informed the impact agenda of the FDCO-funded Climate Compatible Growth programme. Specifically, it has helped to shape geospatial electrification planning policy interventions at the regional, national, and international stage (e.g., at COP27). The full economic impact of this work will arise over the next 5-10 years as policy recommendations are taken up and implemented.
Sector Energy
Impact Types Policy & public services