Influence of prebiotics on human gut microbiota LPS and markers of metabolic syndrome.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Reading
Department Name: Food and Nutritional Sciences

Abstract

Obesity is fast becoming the greatest health challenge of the 21st century. Central to our ability to intervene in this situation is a clear understanding of the link between diet and obesity and the ability of industry to deliver food products capable of reducing risk. This project will lay down the scientific rational linking the gut microbiota with obesity, and provide a rational for using functional foods in the obese for improved health, targeted towards modulating the gut bacteria. Traditional risk factors for obesity and associated metabolic disorders are dietary, genetic and exercise linked. However, there is the contention that these cannot fully explain the explosive increase seen in recent years. This was given added significance in 2006 when the first reports appeared suggeted that gut bacterial profiles in obese and lean persons differed. It was hypothesised that the bacterial profiles variably affected calory extraction rates from food and that some of their metabolites could influence satiety. This is still an area of some debate (and it may be that the traditional risk factors themselves affect microflora profiles), however what is not in question is that the gut microbiota has a major role to play in human metabolism. This is because of the huge numbers that are present and their constant supply of nutrients (principally diet). Should the gut microbiota differences be a factor in obese related conditions, then this opens up the possibily of altering the situation by using dietary ingredients that have a selective fernentation in situ. Prebiotics are functional foods ingredients that exert major composition and metabolic changes in the human gut microbiota. Together with probiotics, they are attracting much attention for their ability to improve gastrointestinal health. New products are constantly being developed, with the main remit being improved digestion and wellbeing. Research on modulating the gut flora has largely targeted gut infections including links into chronic disorders like IBS and ulcerative colitis. Given the recent link between gut microflora and obesity, it makes sense to research whether prebiotics can exert a modulatory role. In this project, these have been chosen over probiotics as they are more efficacious in exerting change in bacterial populations within the gut. Our collaborative research in an animal models has shown that LPS, a cell wall constituent of Gram -ve bacteria, can exert a metabolic endotoxaemia which is characteristic of diabetes in humans. Prebiotics target Gram+ve flora (principally bifidobacteria). Further studies in the murine showed that the toxic effects of LPS could be reversed by repressing Gram -ves at the expense of bifidobacteria. Here, we aim to replicate these experiments in humans at risk of metabolic syndrome. We will use a proven prebiotic (BiMuno, a type of galactooligosaccharide GOS), that was originally developed in our laboratories and is now commercially availble, to target bifidobacteria in a human feeding study. Prior to this, food quality experitise will be applied towards assessing the most appropriate dietary delivery vehicle that maintains functionality of the ingredient and has optimal sensory qualities. A placebo will also be trialled. The outcomes will be an in vivo assessment of the capacity to alter gut microbiota and concomitant effects upon validated markers of metabolic syndrome. If the research is successful it will lead towards a dietary intervention product that positively affects the risks associated with obesity in a manner that changes the microflora influence. This would have much impact upon a major 21st century dietary problem and tally that with an extremely topical functional food approach. The outcome would also partly inform on the health attributes that can be expected from altering a person's gut microbiota and has relevance for both the probiotic and prebiotic industries.

Technical Summary

A fat-enriched diet induces diabetes, obesity and vascular diseases. This is a societal problem with substantial and long lasting social and economic implications. Current pharmacological strategies appear ineffective since the number of diabetic and obese people continues to rise and is set to reach 600 million over the next two decades worldwide. Physical activity and lowered calorie diet can reduce the outcome of metabolic and vascular diseases. However, the level of compliance required by this dietary and life-style approach is often poor. Obesity is characterised by low grade inflammation which has been linked to insulin resistance, type II diabetes and cardiovascular disease. It has also been linked to a number of putative diet-related aetiologies associated with gut microbiota. Our previous collaborative research indicated that metabolic bacterial lipopolysaccharides (LPS) could onset the inflammatory process linking fat-enriched diet to metabolic/vascular diseases. In mice, the intestinal LPS content was increased by a fat-enriched diet. We have therefore shown that the LPS of G-ve gut bacteria is able to induce a toxic reaction in rats that resembles diabetes in humans. Importantly, this could be reversed by a dietary prebiotic, which increased G+ve numbers, principally bifidobacteria. We intend to extrapolate these findings to humans. Food processing characteristics will be carried out to ensure optimum prebiotic functionality and sensory qualities, testing a range of food vehicles. An acceptable product will be tested in humans to determine effects upon faecal microflora, LPS and markers of metabolic syndrome. The overall aim is to prevent and reverse metabolic inflammation, the cornerstone of metabolic and vascular diseases, by altering indigenous gut microbiota composition towards increased bifidobacteria. We will develop a prebiotic food that modifies the intestinal flora to reduce risk of of metabolic/vascular diseases related to LPS.

Planned Impact

Obesity is arguably the single greatest global health challenge of the 21st century. In the UK the Department of Health attributes 58% of type 2 diabetes, 21% of heart disease, and between 8% and 42% of certain cancers (endometrial, breast and colon), to excess body fat, and estimate that obesity is responsible for 9,000 premature deaths annually in England alone. They also foresee an additional £7.7 billion in annual NHS costs for treating obesity by 2050. This figure reaches £49.9 billion per year when the wider societal costs are included. While the root causes are fairly well understood (a higher energy intake than expenditure over extended periods of time), less is know about the societal, life-style and other environmental factors comprising the obesogenic environment. There is likely to be a genetic component to obesity at least in some individuals but this does not account for the sudden rise in the incidence of obesity at the population level. Differences in gut microbiota composition and activity is a newly recognised contributor towards this obesogenic environment and the key hypothesis of this project is that the gut microbiota is a marker of obesity and can be modulated using prebiotics. Prebiotics are dietary ingredients (non-absorbed carbohydrates) that are selectively fermented by positive gut microbiotia components. By establishing the gut microbiota as a modifiable risk factor in obesity, this project aims to provide supportive evidence for the anti-obesity use of prebiotics which can be added to foods consumed by the population. The development of efficacious functional foods is critical to tackling this challenging health crises and the food industry will play a critical role in the design and scientific testing of these products. Direct beneficiaries are widespread: One principal beneficiary will be the partner company (Clasado) who will be able to develop novel products for the European and worldwide marketplace - ultimately leading to improved consumer health. In terms of user groups, the following may benefit from a successful project outcome: 1) Prebiotic consumers: who may be given straightforward dietary recommendations that help prophylactically manage, or even treat, gut disorder - with the focus here on obesity. 2) Food industry: information for generating new designer prebiotics. Peer review publications from the data could be used to consolidate new product developments. 3) Academia: who would access new information on further mechanisms underpinning prebiotic use. In terms of social benefits, there exists a number of different aspects: a) Prophylactic management of gut disease There remains an increase in gut bacterial dysfunction which may manifest as both acute (e.g. gastroenteritis) and chronic (e.g. inflammatory bowel disease) disorder. Many consumers experience symptoms of gut disease, without considering prior management through the diet. The route of using prebiotics to reduce the risk of disease is attractive as it is user friendly, inexpensive, simplistic and has no adverse host and/or environmental consequences. With recent evidence that gut flora may be involved in obesity and related metabolic aspects, this opens up a new area of prebiotic application that (if proven efficacious) will be of major benefit. b) Socio-economic The economic aspects prebiotic developments has social aspects where the prevention of disease risk adds towards better financial status through reduced expenditure on pharmaceuticals. This has particular relevance for obesity given the statistics quoted above. c) Quality of life Improved quality of life and social functioning are important human factors. Whiler management of obesity is feasible through dietary and exercise issues - targeting of gut microbiota in this regard is a new avenue. Activities to target the impact will include public lectures, project fliers, use of extensive media links, workshops, reviews and the internet.
 
Description Prebiotic B-GOS fortified bread and orange juice, along with carbohydrate-matched placebo products, were developed during the project. These products were initially manufactured in the Food and Nutritional Sciences department of the University of Reading. Products were tested for sensory properties by human sensory panels and for prebiotic functionality using in vitro gut model experiments. Subsequently the products were produced on a larger scale, by Allied Bakeries and Coca-Cola, and used in human intervention studies, assessing both prebiotic properties and markers of the metabolic syndrome.

Interim work conducted during this project was presented at the Wellcome Trust, Cambridge, 2012 Exploring Human Host-Microbiome Interactions in Health and Disease. A further presentation occurred at the annual meeting of the International Scientific Association of Probiotics and Prebiotics, Cork, 2012. Oral presentations of this research have also been given at the RANK prize meeting in Grasmere 2012, at the Society for Applied Microbiology Annual Summer Conference 2013, Cardiff. A final project summary was given at the Wellcome Trust 2013 Exploring Human Host-Microbiome Interactions in Health and Disease Conference in Cambridge. Further presentations have been done at International conferences.

Two radio interviews on BBC radio Berkshire in July 2012 were given detailing the theory behind the project.

In 2012 September Dr. Gemma Walton participated in an evening event at the Science Museum (Science Uncovered - September 2012). An in vitro model of the gut was used to attract attention and members of the public were able to ask questions about any gut, or microbiology related work being conducted.

Further public engagements on Channel 4's Embarassing bodies, children's BBCs Absolute Genius and the BBCs Mysterious World of the Human Stomach with Michael Mosely have been carried out.

The PI gave a presentation to Science in Parliament in 2013, that included the project. This was a briefing on gut health to MPs, Lords and Key Opinion Leaders from universities, industry and the media.It was also presented at a workshop in Palmerston North, New Zealand in 2012. This was to develop links with scientists in Canada, Australia and New Zealand, draft FP7 submissions and help plan the content for Horizon 2020.

Lay lectures to University of 3rd Age, Oxford Speedwell Trust, Healthcare workers in UK (x4) were also given on the area of obesity and gut microbiome.
Exploitation Route Prevalence of obesity is increasing with abdominal adiposity playing a role in metabolic syndrome (MetS) development. The gut microbiota has been seen to influence dietary energy extraction, furthermore MetS has been linked to inflammation. In vivo studies have revealed that microbial fortification through prebiotic intervention can reduce inflammation and some associated MetS risk factors.
Research was therefore undertaken to design optimum food delivery systems for prebiotic intervention. This ultimately led to the incorporation of B-galactooligosaccharide (a known prebiotic) in bread and orange juice. The effects of food processing on the prebiotic products was assessed in in vitro gut model systems. Functionality of the two identified products was seen to be maintained. Furthermore sensory evaluation deemed the products appropriate for consumption.
The newly developed products were manufactured on a large scale with the help of industrial collaborators. The products were used in two in vivo studies to determine the effects of the products in modulating the gut microbiota composition in humans at risk of metabolic syndrome. Further objectives of the study were to assess the ability of these products to alter a range of biomarkers and risk factors associated with metabolic syndrome, such as inflammatory cytokines and blood lipid levels.
The intervention is complete and data has shown that one of the juice products led to a reduced level of triacylglycerides in those volunteers with initially elevated levels along with a prebiotic effect. Therefore results are encouraging for using a product targeting the gut microbiota to reduce risk factors associated with MetS.
Sectors Healthcare

 
Description Prevalence of obesity is increasing with abdominal adiposity playing a role in metabolic syndrome (MetS) development. The gut microbiota has been seen to influence dietary energy extraction, furthermore MetS has been linked to inflammation. In vivo studies have revealed that microbial fortification through prebiotic intervention can reduce inflammation and some associated MetS risk factors. Research was therefore undertaken to design optimum food delivery systems for prebiotic intervention. This ultimately led to the incorporation of B-galactooligosaccharide (a known prebiotic) in bread and orange juice. The effects of food processing on the prebiotic products was assessed in in vitro gut model systems. Functionality of the two identified products was seen to be maintained. Furthermore sensory evaluation deemed the products appropriate for consumption. The newly developed products were manufactured on a large scale with the help of industrial collaborators. The products were used in two in vivo studies to determine the effects of the products in modulating the gut microbiota composition in humans at risk of metabolic syndrome. Further objectives of the study were to assess the ability of these products to alter a range of biomarkers and risk factors associated with metabolic syndrome, such as inflammatory cytokines and blood lipid levels. The intervention is complete and data has shown that one of the juice products led to a reduced level of triacylglycerides in those volunteers with initially elevated levels along with a prebiotic effect. Therefore results are encouraging for using a product targeting the gut microbiota to reduce risk factors associated with MetS. The research also featured at: • Gut microbiology demonstrations at Universities Week (Natural History Museum, London) and BBSRC's Great British Bioscience Festival. The latter resulted in the 'Colon Café' exhibit now housed at Winchester Science Museum. • Throughout 2015, and until April 2016, the Reading gut model (used in the project being reported here) was present in the Science Museum, London as part of an exhibition on cravings. It was estimated that >3m visitors saw this. • In 2016, the cravings exhibition was in Manchester Science and Industry Museum. In 2017, three presentations to lay audiences were made about the project. Also, in 2017 a presentation on impact from this project was given to a BBSRC DRINC workshop.
First Year Of Impact 2013
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink,Healthcare
Impact Types Societal

 
Description Knowledge Transfer Partnership
Amount £111,065 (GBP)
Organisation Knowledge Transfer Partnerships 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2013 
End 10/2015
 
Description Develop of prebiotic foods 
Organisation Allied Bakeries
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution New research collaborations have been made with Allied Bakeries and Coco-Cola. They have manufactured bread and orange juice respectively for testing in the project. The aim is to assess the effect of a prebiotic (GOS), which is selectively fermented by gut bacteria, in terms of the metabolic syndrome. The companies have developed these foods for our human intervention study which is ongoing. The new foods have been tested for their sensory and taste qualities using volunteer panels. They have also been assessed for prebiotic activities in vitro.
Collaborator Contribution Industry partners helped to make the food products
Impact Costabile, A., Walton, G.E., Tzortzis, G., Vulevic, J., Charalampopoulos, D. and Gibson G.R. 2015. Effects of orange juice formulation on prebiotic functionality using an in vitro colonic model system. PLoS One. 2015 Mar 25;10(3):e0121955. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0121955. Costabile, A., Walton, G.E., Tzortzis, G., Vulevic, J., Charalampopoulos, D., Gibson, G.R. 2015. Development of a bread delivery vehicle for dietary prebiotics to enhance food functionality targeted at those with metabolic syndrome. Gut Microbes 6, 300-309. doi: 10.1080/19490976.2015.1064577
Start Year 2010
 
Description Media interaction 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact Two radio interviews on BBC radio Berkshire in July 2012 were given detailing the theory behind the project.

None
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012
 
Description Project presentations 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Interim work conducted during this project was presented at the Wellcome Trust, Cambridge, 2012 Exploring Human Host-Microbiome Interactions in Health and Disease. A further presentation occurred at the annual meeting of the International Scientific Association of Probiotics and Prebiotics, Cork, 2012. Oral presentations of this research have also been given at the RANK prize meeting in Grasmere 2012, at the Society for Applied Microbiology Annual Summer Conference 2013, Cardiff. A final project summary was given at the Wellcome Trust 2013 Exploring Human Host-Microbiome Interactions in Health and Disease Conference in Cambridge. Presentations were given in Tampa USA, Kuala Lumpar, Malaysia, Shanghai China, Yokohama Japan, Budapest Hungary, Gieesen Germany, York Liverpool, Scarborough, Leeds UK in 2015-2016.


general discussions
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2012,2013,2014,2015,2016
 
Description Science Museums 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Several science museums have existing demonstrations related tp the subject of the project. Researchers on the BBSRC funded work engaged with these:
• Gut microbiology demonstrations at Universities Week (Natural History Museum, London) and BBSRC's Great British Bioscience Festival. The latter resulted in the 'Colon Café' exhibit now housed at Winchester Science Museum.
• Throughout 2015, and until April 2016, the Reading gut model will be present in the Science Museum, London as part of an exhibition on cravings. It is estimated that >4m visitors will see this.
• In 2016, the cravings exhibition will be in Manchester Science and Industry Museum.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015,2016