Genetics of host responses to Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome virus (PRRSV)

Lead Research Organisation: University of Edinburgh
Department Name: The Roslin Institute

Abstract

This project uses novel and innovative methods to develop tools to help control the most important viral disease affecting pig industries in Europe and North America, viz. Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome (PRRS). We will focus on infections with the PRRS virus (PRRSV) in the reproductive sow. Pigs differ genetically in their resistance to PRRS. Hence, our ultimate aims are to identify genetic markers that are associated with these between-animal differences and can therefore be used to breed for increased resistance. However, studying the impacts of PRRS in sows is expensive and difficult, so we will use novel methods to overcome this problem.

We have developed in-vitro methods to assess host responses to PRRSV infections: from a blood sample taken, we isolate monocytes from the white blood cells. By stimulation with CSF-1, these are then cultured into macrophages (MDM), the cell type that PRRSV infects. We then infect MDMs with PRRSV and measure their responses to infection, by image analysis and measuring genes that are expressed post infection. To relate these in-vitro phenotypes to infection outcomes in the living animal (in-vivo), we will use a herd in which gilts are vaccinated with a live vaccine, and therefore have a controlled PRRSV exposure. Blood samples will be taken before vaccination, to get MDMs, and at regular intervals post inoculation, and virus levels (viraemia) measured as an indicator of their resistance to infection. We will also perform the in vitro studies on naïve, unvaccinated, pigs, to study PRRVS responses in pigs naïve to the virus.

First, we will explore the genetic control of PRRS resistance, using viraemia as phenotypes. We will genotype each vaccinated pig with high density (750K) SNP arrays, these being DNA chips that detect genetic variation at about 750,000 locations across the genome. Unvaccinated pigs will be genotyped with a mix of 60K and 750K SNP chips. We will then do the in-vitro infection studies on MDMs from all animals. MDMs from each animal will be infected separately with each of three different PRRSV strains, giving detailed information per animal. Using the SNP chip genotypes we will identify genetic markers associated with all of the in-vitro measurements. We will also explore the relationships between the in-vitro and in-vivo measurements, to determine which in-vitro phenotypes are truly predictive of outcomes in live animals. Doing this on ca. 1150 pigs will give us good resolution to map loci affecting resistance and identify associated genetic markers.

Our analyses of the genetic markers and all phenotypes should identify loci with major impacts on PRRS resistance; the markers defining these loci can be used to select animals. However, we wish to know how these loci affect PRRS resistance and the consequences of breeding from pigs with these markers. To achieve this, we will choose the two most significant loci from our results, then identify animals of contrasting genotypes (10 high & 10 low for both). We will then infect MDMs from these animals with PRRSV and assess their responses over a 24 hour period, measuring viral load and expression of immune genes known to be involved in response to PRRSV infection. Further microarray analyses will assess global gene expression and comprehensively describe responses to infection. These results will provide insight into mechanisms of genetic differences in host resistance and pinpoint the consequences of selection using these markers.

Finally, we will bring together all our results, compare them with other available data, and determine SNP markers that may be used to breed pigs for increased resistance to PRRS. These results will be of immense value to the pig breeding industry, and our results and techniques will be of great interest to the wider scientific community, particularly those wishing to research animal disease genetics whilst minimising the impact on animals (i.e. respecting 3R principles).

Technical Summary

This project addresses PRRS, the most important viral disease affecting the pig industry, focussing on reproductive sows. We will use in-vitro methods to quantify responses to infection, genetic variation in such responses and identify loci to breed pigs for increased resistance.

Our in-vitro methods utilise monocyte derived macrophages (MDM), created by stimulation of monocytes with CSF1. We will infect MDMs with PRRSV (three contrasting strains per pig) and measure responses to infection by image analysis. Measurements include % of PRRSV-positive cells, distribution and density of staining, shape, size, granularity, complexity, intensity of staining and viability of bystander cells. After genotyping each pig with a mix of 750K and 60K SNP arrays (imputing denser genotypes for 60K) we will perform a GWAS.

Our sample size will be ca. 1150 pigs, to give good experimental power. 500 sows will be vaccinated (MLV vaccine), and with the remainder PRRSV naïve. In vaccinated sows, blood samples will be taken at regular intervals post vaccination, with viraemia as the indicator of resistance. GWAS will be repeated for the in-vivo traits, and the in-vitro phenotypes will be calibrated against the in-vivo traits.

These analyses should identify loci affecting PRRS resistance. We will explore the function of these loci using animals of contrasting genotypes for the 2 most significant loci (10 high & 10 low for both). We will infect their MDMs with PRRSV and assess responses over a 24 hour period, using microarray-based transcriptomic profiling and viral load.

Our results will identify SNP markers to breed pigs for PRRS resistance, and pinpoint consequences of such selection. This will be of immense value to pig breeders, and our results and techniques will be of great interest to the wider scientific community, particularly those wishing to research animal disease genetics whilst respecting 3R principles.

Planned Impact

The goal of this proposed project is to help tackle the endemic viral disease Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome (PRRS). This is the most costly disease to pig industries in developed countries, and new control measures are urgently sought. Here we take a novel approach combining in vivo and in vitro approaches, to ultimately derive a marker panel which can be used to select pigs for increased resistance to infection and reduced disease impact (i.e. increased disease resistance). At the same time, we will enhance our knowledge of the mechanisms of resistance and the consequences of genetically increasing resistance. Critically, unlike most research efforts into this disease, we target the reproductive female, this being where the greatest costs of PRRS are incurred.

The major output from this project, if successful, will be an enhancement of the health, welfare and productivity of pigs, not only in the UK but also more widely in Europe and North America. This will add to food security and contribute towards evidence based policy-making and disease control at farm, industry and international levels. This leads to both economic and societal impacts, as PRRS is a costly and distressing problem to the pig industry, and the emergence of ever-more virulent strains in Eastern Europe and East Asia simply adds to these concerns.

This project will complement and enhance on-going international research efforts, especially in the US and Canada. Here, we fill gap in the current knowledge of host responses to PRRS, particularly for virus strains of relevance to the UK and Europe, providing information not only of value to the participating breeding company, Genus, but also to all breeding companies in this sector. Further, the ultimate results, viz. SNP markers associated with PRRS resistance, by their very nature are easily implemented into practical breeding programmes. Thus, the results should have widespread impact on pig breeders and pig producers across the board. Further, through the activities of the now-completed COST Action FA902 "Understanding and combating porcine reproductive and respiratory syndrome in Europe" [EuroPRRS] which was chaired by Co-I TAA, and also through the strategic partnership of Roslin with Zoetis, we have secured excellent links to the animal health sector with interests in PRRS. Our insights into the mechanisms of resistance will be of value to this sector as well.
 
Description The project objectives are interdependent and built primarily on the in vitro challenge experiments. We blood sampled pigs from three local farms isolated and stored blood monocytes. The monocytes were differentiated in vitro to yield monocyte derived macrophages. Aliquots of these macrophages from each pig were infected in triplicate in vitro with each of three different strains of the Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Virus (PRRSV) and the responses analysed.

Analyses of these in vitro challenge experiments meet our expectations with evidence of variation in responses both between host genotypes (i.e. between different pigs) and between virus genotypes (i.e. between the three different PRRSV strains).

DNA was also isolated from each pig and genotyped with the Affymetrix Axiom Porcine Array that assays ~650,000 independent single nucleotide polymorphism (SNP) loci in parallel for each DNA sample.

Genome-Wide Association Study analyses were undertaken in order to identify any evidence of associations between SNP variants and variation in the different responses to infection with PRRSV. We found some evidence for associations between SNP variants and variation in the level of infection detected in the cells challenged with PRRSV in the laboratory.

We identified pigs, from which we had retained aliquots of blood monocytes, that exhibit the extremes of responses to PRRSV infection in vitro. We repeated the in vitro infections of macrophages derived from such extreme individuals. We captured additional information on responses in these repeat infections. Specifically, we isolated RNA post-infection and are currently analysing changes in gene expression in response to infection. The gene expression data will be analysed for evidence that the differences in response are mediated by changes in gene expression of genes in the genomic regions of interest.
Exploitation Route Once we have completed the analyses and identified any concordance between the genomic regions associated with variation in infection in vitro and i) genes exhibiting changes in expression in response to infection in vitro and ii) previous results from research by ourselves and others. The findings could be used to shape breeding objectives. For example, a Dutch pig breeding company recently announced that it is already including the chromosome 4 genetic marker associated with variation in viremia discovered by a US consortium into its selection index.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Title In vitro infection model for Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome 
Description Peripheral blood monocytes (PBMC) are isolated from blood and either cryopreserved or used immediately. PBMC are cultured in vitro in the presence of CSF1 for 5 days.Growth in the presence of CSF1 facilitates the differentiation of PBMC into macrophages. These in vitro differentiated macrophages are subsequently infected with Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome Virus, 
Type Of Material Model of mechanisms or symptoms - in vitro 
Year Produced 2015 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The in vitro PRRS infection model facilitates studies of genetic variation in both host (pigs) and pathogen (e.g. PRRSV) simultaneously. Unlike for the laboratory mouse there is an absence of inbred strains or lines of pigs. The PBMC resource allows the same pig to be infected separately with multiple different pathogens or genetic variants of a pathogen. The PBMC resource and in vitro PRRS infection model also facilitates genetics studies that require population or sample sizes of hundreds to thousands that are not feasible through animal challenge experiments. Thus, the in vitro infection model also contributes to the 3Rs agenda. 
 
Description BBSRC Animal Health Research Club Final Dissemination Event 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact A final presentation was given on the BBSRC Animal Health Research Club project on "Genetics of host responses to Porcine Reproductive and Respiratory Syndrome virus (PRRSV) was given followed by discussion of the results. There was also a wider discussion on the challenges of studying the genetics of host responses to infection in pigs - challenge experiments in animal research facilities lack the power as the numbers that can be studied are too small on the one hand, but field data from natural exposure to disease can be noisy and logistically challenge to acquire.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description BBSRC Animal Health Research Club Fourth Dissemination Event 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact A progress report on the BBSRC Animal Health Research Club project on Genetics of host responses to Porcine Respiratory Syndrome virus (PRRSV) was presented followed by questions and discussions from/with scientists engaged in other BBSRC Animal Health Research Club and with representatives from the industrial co-funders of the BBSRC Animal Health Research Club.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016
 
Description BBSRC Animal Health Research Club Second Dissemination Event 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact Plans for the BBSRC Animal Health Research Club project on Genetics of host responses to Porcine Respiratory Syndrome virus (PRRSV) were presented followed by questions and discussions from/with scientists engaged in other BBSRC Animal Health Research Club and with representatives from the industrial co-funders of the BBSRC Animal Health Research Club.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
 
Description BBSRC Animal Health Research Club Third Dissemination Event 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact A progress report on the BBSRC Animal Health Research Club project on Genetics of host responses to Porcine Respiratory Syndrome virus (PRRSV) was presented followed by questions and discussions from/with scientists engaged in other BBSRC Animal Health Research Club and with representatives from the industrial co-funders of the BBSRC Animal Health Research Club.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2016