Season extension of UK asparagus using dynamically controlled atmosphere

Lead Research Organisation: Cranfield University
Department Name: School of Water, Energy and Environment

Abstract

Currently, UK asparagus production is unable to provide year round supply, necessitating the import of large quantities of spears from overseas. This practise has a significant environmental impact and burden as much of the product is transported by air freight, primarily from Peru. The independent Carbon Trust has calculated that importing one kilogram of asparagus from Peru generates 11.0 kgs of carbon dioxide whereas UK production produces 2.1 kgs of carbon dioxide per kg. A new opportunity exists whereby the seasonality/ availability of UK asparagus could potentially be extended and gluts in production smoothed by implementing, validating and optimising the use and efficacy of UK-designed dynamically controlled atmosphere technology (DCA). Increasing the availability of UK asparagus through better understanding and modelling of how DCA can suppress postharvest senescent processes will reduce the UK's dependence on imported asparagus, reduce waste and help towards greater self sufficiency.
Fresh produce waste in the UK supply chain is estimated to be between 2 -10% (Terry et al., 2011). Indeed, it is generally acknowledged that a third of consumer derived waste is attributable to fruit and vegetables. Currently, UK asparagus production is unable to provide year round supply, necessitating the import of large quantities of spears from overseas. This practise has a significant environmental impact and burden as much of the product is transported by air freight primarily from Peru and thus results in higher waste levels due to the extended supply chain. An opportunity exists whereby the seasonality and thus availability of UK asparagus could potentially be extended and gluts in production smoothed by implementing, and optimising the use and efficacy of novel UK-designed storage technology. The proposed project seeks for the first time to extend the seasonality of UK-grown asparagus using dynamically controlled atmosphere (DCA); a technology which has been successfully deployed on apples. Although standard controlled atmosphere and modified atmosphere packaging has been previously demonstrated to extend UK asparagus storage life by 4-5 weeks it has resulted in reduced shelf life and poor skin finish. What has not be validated is the manipulation of gaseous composition during storage according to the temporal change in physiological behaviour [e.g. respiration and water loss] and whether senescent processes can be suppressed and waste levels and quality loss reduced. A new dynamic physiological model will be developed to capture the variable effects and factors which influence temporal and spatial changes in physiology and associated senescent processes in asparagus spears. This will be used to develop and further refine the implementation of optimum DCA conditions for different scenarios and markets in a real world setting.
Increasing the availability of UK asparagus through better understanding how DCA can suppress senescent processes will reduce the UK's dependence on imported product, reduce waste and help towards greater self sufficiency. DEFRA figures show that 2,748 tonnes of asparagus (with a wholesale market value of £9.9 million) was imported into the UK during the months of July and August 2014. A significant proportion of this market is potentially available to UK growers through the development of dynamically controlled atmosphere storage.

Technical Summary

Currently, UK asparagus production is unable to provide year round supply, necessitating the import of large quantities of spears from overseas. This practise has a significant environmental impact and burden as much of the product is transported by air freight, primarily from Peru. The independent Carbon Trust in 2012 calculated that importing one kilogram of asparagus from Peru generates 11.0 kgs of carbon dioxide whereas UK production produces 2.1 kgs of carbon dioxide per kg.
A new opportunity exists whereby the seasonality/ availability of UK asparagus could potentially be extended and gluts in production smoothed by implementing, validating and optimising the use and efficacy of UK-designed dynamically controlled atmosphere technology (DCA). Increasing the availability of UK asparagus through better understanding and modelling how DCA can suppress postharvest senescent processes will reduce the UK's dependence on imported asparagus, reduce waste and help towards greater self sufficiency.

Planned Impact

Successful development of dynamic controlled atmosphere (DCA) storage for UK asparagus would result in the marketing season for British asparagus being extended by 4 to 6 weeks. This could result in import substitution with some 2,000 tonnes of British asparagus (a wholesale market value of £7.0 million). The UK asparagus industry currently has an annual production of some 5,300 tonnes sold with a wholesale value of some £30 million. The industry employs 2.0 people per hectare during the season to harvest and pack - a total of some 4,362 people. Successful development from this project could result in a 50% increase in employment. An extended season for UK asparagus will bring significant economic benefit to growers and packers with potential market expansion from 5,300 to 7,300 tonnes (£30 million to £41 million). Most British asparagus packhouses currently operate for only two months per year, this project could increase this activity by 50%. Greater availability of UK asparagus will create up to 2,180 additional seasonal jobs, increase consumption of a very healthy green vegetable and save the production of up to 17,800 tonnes of carbon dioxide each year by not flying asparagus to the UK from Peru. This reduction in the UK's dependence on imported asparagus will help towards greater self sufficiency and food security. A week of hot weather in May can result in the wastage on farm of some 5% of the crop (265 tonnes, £1.5 million) due to temporary oversupply of the marketplace. DCA could eliminate this waste. The shelf life of asparagus bundles once in the supermarket is typically 4 days and accepted waste is 5%. Improving shelf life by one day could reduce waste to 4% saving circa £500,000 per annum for British asparagus alone.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description Some of the research is covered under a collaboration agreement and as such not all results cannot be disclosed. We are pursuing a patent application.

In this work, we studied multiple factors affecting spear quality at harvest and storability. Three main green UK grown asparagus cultivars were included and a wide range of storage regimes were examined to optimise Controlled atmosphere (CA) conditions to extend UK asparagus season. LabPodsTM were employed to continuously record respiration rate (RR) and RQ during cold storage in an effort to improve our understanding of how different gas combinations influence asparagus metabolic rates in situ and subsequent changes to physiology and biochemical profile. Biochemical changes in sugar metabolism and hormonal flux were measured during cold storage and subsequent shelf life enabling an insight into senescence processes under different storage regimes. Cultivars with lower susceptibility to tip breakdown retained quality traits for up to 4 weeks under optimum storage conditions. Other than cultivar, favourable conditions at harvest were important factors for maintaining quality during storage. Further work has been conducted to delay tip breakdown incidence and to understand the pre-harvest and postharvest factors. A patent application is being pursued on this work.
Exploitation Route The research is covered under a collaboration agreement and as such some of the results cannot be disclosed. We are pursuing a patent application

Efforts to apply DCA for extending UK asparagus season were unsuccessful as critically low oxygen concentrations had a detrimental effect on spear quality and RQ monitoring did not yield a spike typical of a shift to anaerobic respiration. A physiological and biochemical model was constructed which successfully differentiated samples based on CA conditions and storage duration both in cold storage and during shelf-life demonstrating the commercial potential of CA application.

The results of the research can be used by asparagus producers and breeders to identify suitable cultivars with extended storability potential under the identified optimum CA conditions. The findings on seasonal variability can be used to devise guidelines to better predict shelf life during the course of the season.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink

 
Description The findings have been used to set up new Controlled Atmosphere Facilities [manufactured in UK] at Cobrey Farms. Cobrey have also funded four additional MScs at Cranfield allied to the main project [i.e. on extending asparagus storage life]. In addition, Cobrey have employed Dr Emma Collings [previous Cranfield postdoc] - she was working at Cranfield [seconded from Cobrey] as a visiting scientist on the continuation of the project although it has officially finished [extension funded by the industry partner]. Please note that Dr Emma Collings is a former BBSRC funded CASE student. She is now employed by Cranfield and has supported an application under the Transforming Food Production call which was successful and started in 2020 [Development of a decision support tool to reduce asparagus tip breakdown in the UK]
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Agriculture, Food and Drink
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Development of a decision support tool to reduce asparagus tip breakdown in the UK
Amount £63,088 (GBP)
Organisation Innovate UK 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2020 
End 02/2022
 
Description Horticultural Crop Quality and Food Loss Prevention Network
Amount £375,715 (GBP)
Funding ID BB/T010819/1 
Organisation Biotechnology and Biological Sciences Research Council (BBSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 01/2020 
End 01/2024
 
Title Underpinning data 'Investigating the role of abscisic acid and its catabolites on senescence processes in green asparagus under controlled atmosphere (CA) storage regimes' 
Description This dataset contains the data used for statistical analysis and predictive modelling in the paper entitled "Revisiting CA Protocols and Their Effect on Hormonal Flux in Asparagus". Specifically it contains physiological and biochemical changes in asparagus spears from three different cultivars during cold storage under different CA and DCA regimes and subsequent shelf-life. Physiological changes include moisture loss, respiration rate, cutting energy, objective colour. Biochemical data include individual sugars, abscisic acid and its catabolites. Also the data capture spatial differences along the asparagus spears (apical and basal regions). 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Underpinning_data_Investigating_the_role_of_abscisic_a...
 
Title Underpinning data 'Investigating the role of abscisic acid and its catabolites on senescence processes in green asparagus under controlled atmosphere (CA) storage regimes' 
Description This dataset contains the data used for statistical analysis and predictive modelling in the paper entitled "Revisiting CA Protocols and Their Effect on Hormonal Flux in Asparagus". Specifically it contains physiological and biochemical changes in asparagus spears from three different cultivars during cold storage under different CA and DCA regimes and subsequent shelf-life. Physiological changes include moisture loss, respiration rate, cutting energy, objective colour. Biochemical data include individual sugars, abscisic acid and its catabolites. Also the data capture spatial differences along the asparagus spears (apical and basal regions). 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
URL https://cord.cranfield.ac.uk/articles/dataset/Underpinning_data_Investigating_the_role_of_abscisic_a...
 
Description farming business 
Organisation Cobrey Farms
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Cranfield has embedded scientific rigour and expertise into Cobrey Farms
Collaborator Contribution Cobrey have enable Cranfield to have a through understanding of the commericial imperatives of Uk asparagus production
Impact Joint publications. Anastasiadi et al., 2020a. Anastasiadi et al., 2020b to be submitted. Joint submission under the Transforming Food Production Call MSc students (n =4) funded by Cobrey Farms
Start Year 2015
 
Description 14th International Asparagus Symposium (Potsdam, Germany) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact An oral presentation was given entitled Effects of low O2 controlled atmosphere on spear quality changes in British asparagus during storage which sparked questions and further discussion.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description 14th International Asparagus Symposium (Potsdam, Germany) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact An oral presentation was given entitled 'Temporal changes in physiology and biochemical profile during storage of two UK-grown asparagus cultivars with different chilling unit requirements' which sparked questions about the research being undertaken.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Institution of Agricultural Engineers (IAgrE) SEM meeting 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The on-line meeting of the Institution of Agricultural Engineers (IAgrE SEM) gathered ca. members at the time. However, the presentation entitled 'Reducing food loss and waste through postharvest technology' was recorded and made available to all IAgrE members. My talk sparked interest from the audience and open a debate.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020