Synthetic chromosomes to decipher requirements for optimal transmission of DNA in yeast

Lead Research Organisation: University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Biological Sciences

Abstract

Cell division is the process by which organisms reproduce themselves. During this process, the genomic DNA, carried on chromosomes, must be replicated and equally distributed to the daughter cells. Errors in this process produce cells with the wrong number of chromosomes. This is associated with cancer and causes birth defects and infertility. Understanding how this process works is therefore medically important. Many of the features of chromosome segregation are common between humans and very simple single-celled organisms, such as baker's yeast. Yeast has a long history as a discovery tool in mechanisms of chromosome segregation since it is easy to grow and manipulate genetically. Furthermore, yeast has advantages over other microorganisms such as bacteria for some industrial applications. Yeast is non-toxic, easy to manipulate and, since the cellular machinery is closer to that of humans than bacteria, yeast cells are more likely to recapitulate the production of human biomolecules. To achieve this, yeast must faithfully transmit the DNA carrying the instructions to produce these biomolecules over many generations. However, we do not yet have a complete understanding of how DNA is transmitted accurately to daughter cells during cell division. This knowledge will not only help us understand what goes wrong in human diseases, such as cancer, but will also help us design better DNA carriers for biosynthesis.

This project will take a "synthetic biology" approach to address this problem. Natural yeast chromosomes are densely packed with important features for cells to grow and flourish. These include genes which are transcribed and translated to make protein products that build the machinery for chromosome segregation. Therefore, it is difficult to dissect out the properties of the DNA sequence itself that promote chromosome segregation, the aim of this study. To avoid these problems, we will chemically synthesise DNA and build chromosomes from scratch, first in a computer, then in a test tube and finally in yeast. These chromosomes will not be required for cell growth and will not carry any genes, allowing us to examine the role of DNA sequence and activity. We know already that chromosome length and circularization influences its segregation. We will build chromosomes of different lengths in both linear and circular form. We will then examine the ability of these synthetic chromosomes to recruit a key factor, called cohesin, that sticks chromosome pairs together. We expect chromosomes with poorer segregation to recruit less cohesin. Next, we will test the idea that the act of gene expression itself helps to recruit cohesin and improve chromosome segregation. We will add genes encoding protein products without a cellular function onto the minichromosomes and test the effect on cohesin recruitment and chromosome segregation. Endogenous chromosomes assemble a cohesin-rich domain, called the pericentromere, around the point at which pairs of chromosomes are attached to the spindle that will pull them apart. We will use the synthetic minichromosomes to identify the features important for pericentromere formation. Our final objective is to use the knowledge gained in this study to build a "designer" chromosome with "perfect" chromosome segregation.
Overall, this study will provide fundamental biological knowledge of the sequence features of DNA which ensure its accurate transmission during cell division. This research will be useful in the future in the design of DNA carriers for industrial applications. Furthermore, an important priority for this project is engagement with the public to encourage discourse around the new scientific area of synthetic biology and its potential.

Technical Summary

This project will use synthetic biology to uncover the features of DNA sequence, other than a centromere and DNA replication origin, required for "perfect" transmission of chromosomes in budding yeast mitosis. The length and organization of chromosomes influence their accurate segregation. Short (<50kb) linear chromosomes are poorly inherited through cell division. Increasing the length, or circularization, improves segregation fidelity: fragments of ~150kb show similar stability to endogenous chromosomes. The cohesin complex links newly duplicated chromosomes together and is essential for accurate segregation. We hypothesize that chromosomal DNA distant from centromeres is required to recruit and maintain sufficient cohesin to ensure chromosomes are robustly linked. Longer or circular chromosomes may recruit/retain more cohesin, increasing their stability. Transcription contributes to the loading and positioning of cohesin, suggesting that DNA sequence could promote segregation fidelity. We will design and assemble a library of artificial, non-essential minichromosomes made up of synthetic, transcriptionally silent DNA ranging from 26-150kb, in both circular and linear form. Using these unique tools, we will uncover the relationship between chromosomal size, circularization, segregation fidelity, cohesin recruitment and cohesion establishment. The requirements for building a specialized, cohesin-rich pericentromere, which directs and monitors chromosome segregation, will be determined. To test the idea that transcription and DNA replication influence cohesin position, cohesion and chromosome segregation, we will introduce synthetic transcriptional units and DNA replication origins. Finally, we will assemble an optimally segregating "designer" chromosome. This project will reveal fundamental requirements for chromosome segregation and provide tools for stable propagation of DNA in yeast.

Planned Impact

This research will have four broad impactful outcomes. First, it will lead to important insights into fundamental mechanisms of chromosome segregation that have been elusive so far. Second, it will promote and propagate the use of synthetic biology as a research tool. Third, it will produce a designer chromosome that can be adapted for academic and industrial applications. Fourth, by embedding a public engagement project "Big ideas, tiny tools" within the research programme, it will provide much-needed discourse around the discipline of synthetic biology.

Together these outcomes will benefit varied groups of people. First, the public will benefit through our engagement project "Big ideas, tiny tools" which will target adult audiences that may typically not engage with science. These include library book clubs and prisoners. These groups of people will benefit from being exposed to new ideas and we will benefit from hearing their opinions. We are particularly keen to hear from individuals sceptical about genetic engineering and understand the reasons for this concern. Second, the wider academic community will benefit both from the generation of new tools, protocols and reagents that they can employ in their own research, and from the fundamental knowledge gained which will promote further research in this area. Third, undergraduates will benefit from the introduction of the concepts and findings surrounding this research into their lectures, informing them of the very latest areas of research and enhancing their employability. Fourth, the UK economy will benefit as this project will help to consolidate the UK's position as a leader in synthetic biology and attract talent to pursue this exciting new area of biology. Fifth, industry will benefit by the availability of a designer chromosome with perfect segregation. Assembly of biosynthetic pathways on a stably maintained DNA carrier would be expected to increase productivity as it would allow culturing over many generations without loss of yield. During the later stages of the project we will engage with industrial partners and apply for a CASE studentship and pump priming funding to explore the possibility of using our tools/protocols for biosynthesis in yeast and beyond.

Our vision to achieve these impactful outcomes ranges beyond publication in scientific journals and attendance at scientific conferences. We will engage with organisations that connect industry and academics to raise awareness of our work and its potential applications. We will work with public engagement teams in the Wellcome Centre Cell Biology and (BBSRC-funded) UK Centre for Mammalian Synthetic Biology to deliver an innovative programme to the public. As the project progresses, we will incorporate developments into these activities and remain committed to ensuring that maximum benefit is derived from our work by as many people and organisations as possible.
 
Description Despite severe delays caused by the pandemic, we managed to make some progress on the project and met the following key objectives:
1. Establishment of methodology to assemble synthetic mini-chromosomes. Rather than our original "inch-worming" strategy, we have switched to a CRISPR-Cas9-dependent method. Although this required some time investment to set up, it allows much more efficient and rapid assembly. This will be an essential factor in making our aims achievable within the new timeframe requested in this extension.
2. The PDRA optimised the majority of the methods needed for the project on endogenous chromosomes. Hi-C, ChIP-Seq and the microscopy methods have all passed the optimisation stage. With these tools in hand, analysis of all synthetic minichromosomes once available will be rapid. We also developed Micro-C protocols for yeast in collaboration with Dovetail genomics.
3. A concern raised by the delay to the project was the effect on the career development of the PDRA. However, the optimisation of the methods above had the side advantage of allowing her to publish a joint first author paper, thereby advancing her career development (Barton, Massari et al., eLife 2022). In this work, we revealed that the organisation of meiotic chromosomes into positioned loops is critical for the generation of viable gametes. We found that acetylation of the chromosome organising complex, cohesin, anchors chromatin loops and cohesion in position. Our findings further showed the importance of loop anchoring at three distinct chromosomal loci. First, anchored loops on chromosome arms are important for successful meiotic recombination. Second, cohesin anchoring at centromeres directs the co-segregation of sister chromatids in meiosis I. Third cohesin anchoring at pericentromere borders maintains links between sister chromatids until meiosis II. Overall, our findings show how the loop organisation of meiotic chromatids is achieved and reveal the functional importance of these loops.
Exploitation Route Our chromosome assembly strategy could be used to generate bespoke chromosomes for other purposes, such as biosynthesis.
Sectors Education,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology

 
Description We are working with Dovetail genomics to adapt their Micro-C protocol for yeast cells. This is expected to be included in the protocol supplied with their kit.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Other
 
Title Further optimisation of chromosome assembly strategy 
Description We have developed CRISPR-Cas9 tools for assembly of synthetic chromosomes. This will expedite the construction phase of the project. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None yet but we intend to publish it. 
 
Title Micro-C for yeast cells 
Description We have worked with Dovetail genomics to develop a protocol for use of their kits to perform Micro-C chromosome conformation assay for yeast cells. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The protocol will be available to others once Dovetail have incorporated it into their products. 
 
Title New synthetic chromosome assembly strategy 
Description We have optimised procedures so that our synthetic chromosomes that we build will have the maximum flexibility in the future. However, the project has suffered a delay due to the COVID pandemic. Our laboratory was closed for several months and, upon opening, we are working at severely reduced capacity (~30%). Therefore, although feasibility has been demonstrated, the generation of biological insights has been delayed. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2020 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact None yet. 
 
Title Yeast strains and plasmids 
Description We have generated several yeast strains with synthetic chromosomes 
Type Of Material Cell line 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact The strains will be available upon publication. 
 
Title GSE185021 - Eco1 
Description Next generation sequencing dataset including all ChIP-Seq and Hi-C experiments in this publication Barton RE, Massari LF, Robertson D, Marston AL. Eco1-dependent cohesin acetylation anchors chromatin loops and cohesion to define functional meiotic chromosome domains. Elife. 2022 Feb 1;11:e74447. doi: 10.7554/eLife.74447. Epub ahead of print. PMID: 35103590. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact None yet. 
URL https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/geo/query/acc.cgi?acc=GSE185021
 
Description Dovetail Genomics collaboration 
Organisation Dovetail Genomics
Country United States 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We are optimising the use of Dovetail genomics Micro-C kit for use in budding yeast. This will allow Dovetail Genomics to market their kit to other budding yeast researchers.
Collaborator Contribution Dovetail genomics are providing their kit at a heavily discounted rate. This is providing exceptional value in our experiments. Dovetail are also sharing their experience to facilitate optimization.
Impact None yet.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Industrial Biotechnology Innovation Centre (IBiolC) Accelerator Programme IB Prime 
Organisation IBioIC
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The technology we developed for building a synthetic chromosome in Saccharomyces cerevisiae is being exploited as a collaboration with Professor Paul Barlow (Edinburgh) and IBiolC for use in Pichia pastoris for biosynthesis of therapeutics. My contribution is as a collaborator on the project and is mainly intellectual, sharing our knowledge gained through our fundamental biology project funded by the BBSRC. We are also sharing reagents in the form of synthetic DNA and assembly tools.
Collaborator Contribution The partners, IBiolC have provided funding for a postdoc in Paul Barlow's lab to assembly synthetic chromosomes in P. Pastoris, using a similar strategy to that which we developed in S. cerevisiae. Future plans will be to develop these synthetic chromosomes to harbour biosynthetic pathways for synthesis of therapeutics.
Impact None yet. The collaboration is multidisciplinary, involving synthetic biology, genomic and proteomic approaches, biochemistry and chemistry.
Start Year 2019
 
Title Scripts for visualisation of Hi-C data 
Description Script to draw the contact probability (P(s)) and slope (derivative) for Hi-C data. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2022 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact None yet. 
URL https://elifesciences.org/articles/74447
 
Description Invited talk at Edinburgh University Undergraduate Society 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Undergraduate students
Results and Impact I was invited by the committee of an undergraduate society called "Gene and Cell society" to give a talk on my research to their members (consisting of a group of undergraduates). I gave a research presentation, pitched to a general audience, and engaged in a lively discussion with the students thereafter.

As a result of this, a visiting student from the USA approached me to ask if she could carry out voluntary work experience in our laboratory as time allowed. This was a very rewarding experience for both of us. She is currently applying to medical school in the USA.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://www.ed.ac.uk/biology/study-with-us/undergraduate/meet-our-students/student-societies/gene-an...
 
Description Primary school summer programme days 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact The primary school summer program was for disadvantaged kids over the holidays. We worked with 15 primary school children each day, looking at interesting things under microscopes and making art inspired by what they saw.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019