Tackling the looming spectrum crisis in Wireless Communication

Lead Research Organisation: University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Engineering

Abstract

The advent of the first mobile phones in the 1980s marked the beginning of mobile communications for commercial purposes. Now, thirty years later, wireless connectivity has become a fundamental part of our everyday lives and is increasingly being regarded as an essential commodity like electricity, gas and water. This unparalleled success means that we are today facing the imminent shortage of radio frequency (RF) spectrum: It is predicted that the amount of data sent through wireless networks will increase by a factor of 10 during the next five years. Moreover, data from Qualcomm demonstrates that the spectrum efficiency (number of bits transmitted per Hertz bandwidth) is saturating. Therefore, the US Federal Communications Commission has warned that a "spectrum crisis" is looming.

The proposed work in this EPSRC Fellowship is aimed at providing radical new solutions to this fundamental and far reaching challenge. A key pillar of the proposed work is the extension of the RF spectrum to include the infrared as well as the visible light spectra. The recent advancements in light emitting diode (LED) device technology now seems to let the vision of using light for high speed wireless communications become a reality.

Using light has many key advantages as compared with RF. The available spectrum is vast, the visible light spectrum is 10,000 times larger than the RF spectrum; it is free as it is not subject to government regulations; it is more secure than the radio frequency spectrum the signals of which can be intercepted outside a premise; it can achieve three orders of magnitude higher data density per unit area. Compared to the infrared spectrum, the visible light spectrum has additional advantages. First, it is not power-limited due to eye-safety concerns. Second, it can serve two purposes at the same time: illumination and high speed data transmission, resulting in a better use of energy. However, while several hundred megabit per second (Mbps) have been demonstrated for a single link using an off-the-shelf white LED, 1 gigabit per second (Gbps) and room coverage is still an open issue. In addition, there is little research for multi-user networked OWC systems. Also, the effects of dimming on the achievable data rates are not well understood. In addition, there are environments and scenarios where the use of light is difficult or not possible such as when there is heavy blockage between transmitters and receivers, or when terminals move with high speeds. In those situations, it will still be more appropriate to use the RF spectrum. To sum up, there are potential large overall performance improvements when wireless systems can select their transmission medium autonomously and in a dynamic as well as self-organising fashion.

A second essential pillar of the proposed research is to overcome the RF spectrum efficiency saturation of current cellular systems while at the same time reducing the energy consumption. A key to solving this issue is to successfully tackle interference in wireless networks which occurs when multiple communication links in close vicinity use (or reuse) the same bandwidth or frequency. On the one hand frequency reuse is beneficial since the more often transmission resources are used per unit area, the higher the spectrum efficiency. On the other hand, intensive frequency reuse results in the aforementioned interference issues. Radically new approaches will be followed that include interference already in the design of a new wireless air-interface. In the past, wireless air-interfaces were optimised for single transmission links, and performance degradations due to interference in a system deployment were mended subsequently, but existing solutions are either impractical or sub-optimum. We will investigate a new air-interface that is based on the recent successful demonstrations of and world-wide research on the concept of spatial modulation which was originally proposed by the applicant.

Planned Impact

Industry: The applicant and his team will create intellectual property rights (IPR) in the course of the Fellowship programme. The IPR will be used to either create new spin-out companies, or to license the technology to industry. A recent example for the first is pureVLC Ltd which the applicant spun-out from a university project. There is a general opportunity to establish a new UK industry that sits between the traditional lighting industry and wireless communication industry and is world-leading. We will also work with industrial partners such as Bell Labs / Alcatel Lucent (Ireland) on combining their RF femtocell work with our OWC technology, and we will use their existing testbed to demonstrate the world's first optical femtocell.

Academia: The applicant will publish the research in the most respected journals and top conferences in the area. Visits to and from leading international research teams will be organised as a means of sharing and discussing latest research findings and to further advance the field.

Society: Through the transfer of knowledge into industry, there will be new products that will enable safe, green and secure wireless communications. The World Health Organisation issued the following statement on 31 May 2011: "The World Health Organization's International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) today classified mobile phone use and other radiofrequency electromagnetic fields as a possible carcinogen (group 2B)". While clearly there is no evidence of any health risks stemming from RF communication, the statement suggests that research has not fully eliminated health concerns. The visible light spectrum, on the other hand, is not subject to any health concerns, and in particular schools and hospitals could benefit from the technology. Moreover, the work in both OWC and RF communication targets energy reductions of cellular communication systems of at least an order of magnitude which will lead to substantial reductions in CO2 emission. Smart-home environments enabled through low complex OWC systems will further contribute to the reductions in CO2 emission.

Economy: There are a number of sectors and industries that could benefit from this work:
- Oil and gas industry: Wireless communications in hazardous environments such as oil platforms and petrochemical plants (no danger of electric spark discharges)
- Transportation:
* Aircraft: In-cabin wireless communication to save weight and enhance passengers services (no interference with sensitive RF communication systems)
* Cars: Intra- and inter-vehicle communications (exploiting existing lights and their directional radiation)
* Traffic and street lights that broadcast local information (exploiting existing signalling and illumination units for smart cities)
- Businesses:
* Corporate and organisation security (exploiting directional radiation of LEDs as well as the fact that light does not propagate through walls)
- Communication industry:
* WiFi and cellular spectrum relief (OWC provides significant additional and free wireless transmission resources)
* Energy efficient wireless communication systems (saving energy through illumination AND wireless data transmission at the same time)
- Defence and military (OWC for secure wireless communications by exploiting directional radiation of LEDs as well as walls and other objects that will block light)
- Museums (lights that illuminate objects and at the same time broadcast information about them)
- Toy Industry (cheap transceiver modules for toy-to-toy communication)
- Retail:
* Large shopping malls, airports and large public buildings (exploiting the localised illumination of lights bulbs that broadcast a unique identifier for indoor positioning and navigation systems)
* Shops (local information broadcast through lights)
- Underwater communication (high data rate wireless communication to enable communication between divers and between remote operated vehicles)

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Alshaer H (2018) Bidirectional LiFi Attocell Access Point Slicing Scheme in IEEE Transactions on Network and Service Management

publication icon
Basnayaka D (2017) Design and Analysis of a Hybrid Radio Frequency and Visible Light Communication System in IEEE Transactions on Communications

publication icon
Basnayaka D (2014) Overcoming Large-Scale Fading in Cellular Systems With Network Coordination in IEEE Transactions on Communications

publication icon
Basnayaka D (2017) A New Degree of Freedom For Energy Efficiency of Digital Communication Systems in IEEE Transactions on Communications

publication icon
Basnayaka D (2016) Massive But Few Active MIMO in IEEE Transactions on Vehicular Technology

publication icon
Basnayaka D (2016) MIMO Interference Channel Between Spatial Multiplexing and Spatial Modulation in IEEE Transactions on Communications

publication icon
Burchardt H (2014) VLC: Beyond point-to-point communication in IEEE Communications Magazine

 
Description 1) We have discovered for the first time that solar cells can be used as high speed data detectors. Data rates of up to 15 mega bits per second have been received by an off-the-shelf solar cell. Energy harvesting and data detection is now possible through a single device, and this symbiosis could revolutionise self-powered and autonomous wireless communication (achieving a key goal of the project)

2) A real-time high definition video transmission with an off-the-shelf solar cell acting as data detector has been developed and used at an invited TED Global 2015 talk. The talk has been watched more than 1.3 million times after 6 months of release.

3) In a collaboration with St-Andrews University (Samuel/Turnbull) we have shown that organic solar cells developed in that group together with our data encoding and decoding techniques and algorithms can achieve up to 50 Mbps.

4) We developed novel VLC/LiFi transmission algorithms that are of low computational complexity, high energy efficiency and high spectrum efficiency. The patented enhanced unipolar orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (eU OFDM) techniques doubles the data rate compared to all known techniques, and achieves about 2 dB improvements in energy efficiency. These gains are achieved at a marginal increase in computational complexity.

5) Developed multiple input multiple output (MIMO) algorithms for intensity modulation / direct detection based on space shift keying and spatial modulation (the latter was invented by the PI, and investigated in EPSRC grant (EP/G011788/1, Spatial Modulation)

6) Published two invited papers in OSA/IEEE Journal of Lightwave technology following tutorial invitations at OFC (Optical Fibre Communication) 2015, and ECOC (European Conference on Optical Communication) 2015. The papers summarised key achievements in LiFi research, and showed first results of the performance of LiFi attocellular systems.

7) We first proposed the novel double-source cell configuration for indoor optical attocell networks to mitigate co-channel interference.

8) We have shown that spatial modulation achieves high capacity in massive MIMO system while it greatly enhances the energy efficiency and hardware complexity as spatial modulation reduces the number of active transmission chains significantly.

9) We have developed novel load balancing techniques for hybrid WiFi/LiFi networks, and have shown that WiFi greatly benefits from a LiFi attocell networks as the overhead due to contention and re-transmission in WiFi is significantly reduced. The sum throughput of both systems is always greater than the throughput of a single system since there is no interference between the radio frequency spectrum and the visible light spectrum.

10) We have developed novel interference mitigation techniques for LiFi attocellular networks based on fractional frequency reuse concepts

11) We have demonstrated for the first time that it is possible to achieve 100 Gbps with an LED light bulb producing white light.

12) We have shown for the first time that spatial division multiple access (SDMA) in combination with optimum user grouping can achieve more than an order of magnitude performance improvements compared to time division multiple access (TDMA) in LiFi attocell networks.

13) We have shown that load balancing between radio frequency (RF) and LiFi attocellular networks can be improved by applying methods such as game theory and fuzzy logic.

14) We have shown that the superposition modulation and specially arranged frame structures in combination with multi-stream transmission can be applied to discrete multi-tone (DMT) and asymmetrically clipped optical orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (ACO OFDM) to double the spectrum efficiency in intensity modulation / direct detection (IM/DD) systems.

15) Is has been shown that spatial modulation can be used to eliminate spectrum losses in direct current optical orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (DCO OFDM).

16) It has been found that non-orthogonal multiple access (NOMA) in intensity modulation / direct detection exhibits performance improvements compared to orthogonal multiple access techniques by exploiting particular properties of intensity modulation / direct detection signals.

17) It has been found that indoor LiFi attocell networks with angular diversity receivers can achieve indoor positioning precision with an error of less than 10 cm at a probability of 90%.

18) It has been found that angular diversity receivers and angular diversity transmitter can be used to mitigate interference in LiFi attocellular networks,

19) It has been shown for the first time that single photon avalanche diodes (SPAD), which work in the Geiger mode, can be used to receive orthogonal frequency division multiplexing (OFDM) signals.

20) It has been demonstrated that a LiFi access point can communication to neighbouring LiFi access points forming a mesh network, and cooperative multipoint transmission can be applied to achieve throughput improvements for cell edge users in a LiFi attocellular network.

21) We have developed new channel models for LiFi cellular systems which enable computationally efficient system level simulations to establish complex network performance metrics.

22) LiFi has been first introduced and pioneered by the Prof Haas. Independent market studies now regularly report that wireless light-based data communication has a market potential of GBP 50bn -100bn within next 4-5 years. This is a direct result of Haas' pioneering work.

23) Multinational lighting companies such as Philips Lighting, now Signifiy, and Zumtobel have now adopted 'LiFi' as one of key future strategic areas of development:
https://www.signify.com/global/innovation/lifi and https://www.ledsmagazine.com/articles/2019/02/zumtobel-ceo-li-fi-will-play-a-decisive-role.html
Exploitation Route Finding 1) may be instrumental in overcoming the rural divide. Lasers could beam data to roof-tops that are equipped with solar cells to harvest energy from sun-light. Classic free-space optical (FSO) systems use a dedicate receiver of small diameter. Alignment is, therefore, difficult, but not so with large solar cell panels. The LiFi R&D Center is currently engaging with industrial partners to develop a proof-of-concept pilot.

2) The University of Edinburgh has established the LiFi R&D Centre and has invested in 3 PDRA (1 experimental officer, two pdra), two junior academics, Dr. Popoola, and Dr. Safari, and a senior business development executive. The total investment is in excess of £2M.

3) The two RAs supported by the University of Edinburgh are engaged in integrating a LiFi receiver chip, aLiFi transmitter chip (both developed in EP/K00042X/1, UP-VLC) and the PASTA-2 baseband chip (EP/I013539/1) into a single reference platform of low form factor. The target TRL (technology readiness level) of the reference platform is 6, and the goal is to license the reference platform to industry.

4) The LiFi R&D Centre is currently engaging with various industry sectors to license the reference platform.

5) eU OFDM has been patented, and licensed to the spin-out company, pureLiFi Ltd.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Electronics,Energy,Environment,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Retail,Security and Diplomacy,Transport

URL https://www.lifi-centre.com/
 
Description - LiFi was first introduced by Haas in an invited TED Global talk, 2011 (2.5m views to date) - Haas has been interviewed by Rory Cellen-Jones (BBC Technology Correspondent) - LiFi is considered in industry - rumors of 'LiFi Capability' in future Apple phones emerged. - Have created industrial impact by spinning out pureLiFi Ltd - Have patented eU-OFDM, and licensed to Edinburgh spin-out company pureLiFi Ltd - Haas and his LiFi work had an international media reach of 1.8 bn people, November 2015, (using Meltwater) - media: BBC, CNN, TIME, Times, el Pais, etc. - Haas regularly invited at international conferences, trade-shows and public lectures such as LuxLive, Tate Modern, Cheltenham Science Festival, etc. - Haas regularly interview by international journalist as the inventor of LiFi. - Haas invited to deliver second TED Global talk in September 2015 based on his groundbreaking research on use of solar cells as broadband LiFi detectors (1.3m views after 6 months after release) - Haas is invited at TEDxWHU 2016, Otto Beisheim School of Management in Vallendar, Germany - Invited tutorial at OFC 2015, "Visible Light Communication", 22-26 March 2015, Los Angeles, USA - Invited tutorial at ECOC 2015, "What is LiFi?", 1-4 October 2015, Barcelona - Invited to present Li-Fi at the 2015 Royal Institution Christmas Lectures, broadcast by the BBC to estimated 2 million viewers - Invited keynote at China SSL 2014, "Light as a Service Enabled by Li-Fi", Guangzhou (China), 6-8 November 2014 - Invited to join the International Solid State Lighting Alliance as Advisor - Keynote at Edinburgh University North America Office opening, along with the Principal and Vice Chancellor, Sir Timothy O'Shea, and Sir Tom Devine, "How Light can Change the World", New York, USA, 22 October 2014 - Keynote, ForumLED, 2014, "Intelligent Lighting"; Intelligent Building", Paris, France, 15 October 2014 - Invitation to give Plenary Keynote and keynote at the workshop on Terrorism and Counter Terrorism Innovation at the World Summit on Counter-Terrorism, International Institute for Counter-Terrorism, Herzliya (Israel), 8-11 September 2014 - Keynote at NI Days, Austin, "Improving Spectral Efficiency in 5G With Visible Light Communications", USA, 6 August 2014 - Keynote at NI Days, Austin, "LiFi for IoT", USA, 3-6 August 2015 - Invitation as speaker at BoldTalks 2014, Dubai, 22 March 2014 - Invitation as speaker at the Global Leader Forum (organised by Chosun TV), 29 November 2013, South Korea - Invitation as keynote speaker at SPAWC, 2017, Hokkaido, 7 July 2017 - Invitation to second TED Global Talk, 30 September 2015, "Forget Wi-Fi. Meet the New Li-Fi Internet". We demonstrated for the first time to the public the dual use of solar cells as energy harvesting devices AND high-speed LiFi detectors. This video has since been watched more than 2.5 million times. - A full classroom at Kyle Academy / Ayrshire / Scotland was equipped with LiFi units including plug-and-play LiFi dongles for Tablets and Laptops. This is the first School in the United Kingdom that benefited from LiFi. This was in collaboration with pureLiFi who provided LiFi equipment. - LiFi is now been standardised within IEEE 802.11bb. This is a new Task Group within IEEE 802.11 which is the standard body that standardised WiFi. A new LiFi standard is expected to be ratified in 2021. - There is now an industry association for LiFi - the Light Communication Alliance (LCA) which includes major multinationals in the lighting and communication sectors.
First Year Of Impact 2012
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Communities and Social Services/Policy,Construction,Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software),Education,Electronics,Energy,Environment,Healthcare,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Retail,Security and Diplomacy,Transport
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Terabit Bidirectional Multi-user Optical Wireless System (TOWS) for 6G LiFi
Amount £6,604,394 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/S016570/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 04/2019 
End 03/2024
 
Description Towards 100 Gigabit Wireless Networking by Light (Go-by-Light) (Ext.)
Amount £1,085,375 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/R007101/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2018 
End 02/2021
 
Description Memorandum of Understanding with Practical Action 
Organisation Practical Action
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Charity/Non Profit 
PI Contribution The Digital Divide is a pervasive and growing challenge. Access to the internet has transformed economies, education, and healthcare around the globe. The digital divide is aggravated as economies are becoming more and more data-centric, a phenomenon described as the third industrial revolution [Rifkin]. However, four billion people - 60% of the world's population - are excluded from the fundamental benefits which access to the internet brings. Without intervention, the digital divide will significantly exacerbate the disparity between the world's rich and poor. LiFi, an Edinburgh pioneered and a proven communications technology which uses the visible light spectrum, holds the solution and will be explored with Practical Action.
Collaborator Contribution Practical Action will explore how LiFi technology could be developed and applied to address the problems associated with poverty and quality of life in poor communities.
Impact Demonstrated the world's first proof-of-concept LiFi backhaul system where ordinary solar cells double as energy harvesting devices and high speed LiFi devices. This technology readiness level (TRL) 6 demonstrator was installed on the roof of James Clerk Maxwell Building at the King's Buildings of the University of Edinburgh.
Start Year 2020
 
Title COMMUNICATION APPARATUS AND METHOD 
Description A method and associated transmission system, signal processor and communications system for converting a signal from a bipolar signal Into a unipolar signal, the method involving applying a pulse shaping filter to the bipolar signal to produce a pulse shaped bipolar signal; and subsequently transforming the negative values of the pulse shaped bipolar signal to produce the unipolar signal. Preferably, the bipolar signal and/or the shaped bipolar signal and/or the unipolar signal have a plurality of frames, and the frames have at least one guard interval, wherein the guard interval(s) include a prefix provided before or at the start of at least one frame and/or a suffix provided after or at the end of at least one frame. 
IP Reference US2015318925 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2015
Licensed No
Impact Industrial interest in LiFi R&D Centre.
 
Title ENHANCED SPATIAL MODULATION 
Description A method of spatial modulation and associated transmission apparatus, receiver apparatus, computer program product and system for identifying a transmitter element within a transmission array of at least two transmitter elements, wherein a signal is transmitted by one active transmitter element at a time over a channel to a receiver. Power is allocated to the transmitter elements, wherein the power is allocated differently between at least two transmitter elements. The transmitted data is received at the receiver. The location of the active transmitter element is detected using knowledge of the power allocated to the transmitter elements. 
IP Reference US2013058390 
Protection Patent granted
Year Protection Granted 2013
Licensed Yes
Impact The patent has been licensed to pureLiFi Ltd.
 
Title RECEIVER FOR COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS 
Description A receiver system (100) having at least one receiver(101)for receiving optical communications signals(103b)that encode or transmit information; wherein the receiver system (100) is adapted to produce one or more electrical signals(104)from the received optical signal(103b)and/or from ambient light(103a)such that the receiver system (100) is usable as a source of electrical power and the encoded or transmitted information from the received optical communication signal(103b)is recovered or recoverable from the electrical signal(s)(104). Embodiments of the invention also relate to a communications system(400)that further comprises one or more transmitters(406)and a device having the receiver systems(401), along with associated methods of using and producing. Particular embodiments relate to identification tags(1000)and user devices(300)having a display(301)that at least partially overlaps the receiver(s)(302). 
IP Reference WO2015082907 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2015
Licensed No
Impact Industrial interest in LiFi R&D Centre
 
Title SYSTEM AND METHOD FOR COMMUNICATION BETWEEN TRANSMITTERS AND RECEIVERS HAVING AN ANGULAR DEPENDENCE 
Description A communications system having at least one transmitter for transmitting one or more signals and at least one receiver for receiving the one or more signals, wherein the transmitters and/or receivers have an angular dependence, such that at least one response of the receivers to a received signal and/or at least one property of the signals transmitted by the transmitters is angularly dependent; the receiver and transmitter and/or the signals transmitted by the transmitters of two or more transmitter-receiver pairs have a distinct associated angular arrangement or relationship, wherein the at least one angularly dependent response of the receivers to the signal and/or the at least one angularly dependent property of the signal is dependent on the angular arrangement or relationship; and the system is configured to use the angularly dependant property and/or response to identify or discriminate the transmitter from which the signal was transmitted and/or at least one communication channel associated therewith. Associated receivers, transmitters, devices and methods are also provided. 
IP Reference WO2015082914 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2015
Licensed No
Impact Industrial interest in LiFi R&D Centre
 
Title TRANSMISSION SCHEME FOR COMMUNICATIONS SYSTEMS 
Description A transmission apparatus that produces, generates and/or transmits a unipolar signal representative of an original bipolar signal having one or more data frames, wherein each of the one or more frames of the original bipolar signal are converted into and/or transmitted as a plurality of unipolar portions, frames or frame portions of one or more information streams; and the transmission apparatus is configured to concurrently transmit the one or more information streams and at least one other information stream. Preferably, the different information streams are transmitted simultaneously on the same channel/link. Advantageously, one or more of the information streams are optionally arranged such that the interference due to the at least one other information stream on the at least one information stream does not adversely affect the information carried in the at least one information stream. The present invention also includes a corresponding receiver, system device and methods. 
IP Reference WO2015036786 
Protection Patent application published
Year Protection Granted 2015
Licensed No
Impact Industrial interest in LiFi R&D Centre
 
Company Name pureLiFi 
Description pureLiFi are the leaders in LiFi. LiFi is a new wireless communications technology. pureLiFi have delivered three products. Spatial modulation is a key licensed technology underpinning the product portfolio. 
Year Established 2012 
Impact The company has successfully demonstrated LiFi products at the world's leading mobile communications trade-show, the Mobile World Congress in 2015 and 2016. In 2016 it demonstrated the world's smallest plug-and-play USB powered LiFi dongle. http://www.digitaltrends.com/cool-tech/why-li-fi-light-internet-could-replace-wi-fi-in-10-years/
Website http://purelifi.com/
 
Description Invited TED Global talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Invited TED Global talk: "Wireless Data from Every Light Bulb" - the talk has since been watched more than 2.5 million times.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2011
URL https://www.ted.com/talks/harald_haas_wireless_data_from_every_light_bulb?language=en
 
Description Short Course delivery 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Delivered short course on visible light communication (VLC) and LiFi at the IEEE/OSA Optical Fibre Conference (OFC)
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018,2019,2020
 
Description TED Global Talk 
Form Of Engagement Activity A broadcast e.g. TV/radio/film/podcast (other than news/press)
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Invited TED Global Talk: "Forget Wi-Fi. Meet the New Li-Fi Internet. The talk has since been watched more than 2.4 million times.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL https://www.ted.com/talks/harald_haas_a_breakthrough_new_kind_of_wireless_internet?language=en