Non-local theories and stochastic mechanics: Two convergent directions for structural modelling?

Lead Research Organisation: Loughborough University
Department Name: Civil and Building Engineering

Abstract

Many Civil Engineering structures are made of non-homogeneous materials such as concrete, masonry and composites, and understanding their response to different loading regimes is crucial to assess performance under ordinary and extreme events.

Nowadays computer simulations of structures and materials have seen a rapid expansion as a result of the progress in computing technology. However, many issues are still unsolved, including the accurate modelling of man-made materials. One may choose to include every single detail into the analysis, but for large structures this approach is time consuming and requires sophisticated computer capabilities. An efficient alternative is to replace the complex material with an equivalent continuum. This is done in the everyday engineering practice when classical elasticity models are adopted for finite element analyses, delivering accurate solutions to many practical problems in a reasonable time. However, classical elasticity may overlook many important phenomena caused by the underlying microstructure. Stress wave propagation in heterogeneous materials due to dynamic/impact loading is one of such phenomena.

This is of significant concern because many of the experimental techniques used in structural health monitoring, damage detection and seismic wave analysis require deep understanding and reliable models of wave propagation in heterogeneous structures. A key challenge for the research community is to develop new analytical and numerical models that bring microstructure information into the structural scale model.

This issue can be successfully tackled by enriched continua, which enjoy non-local behaviour, i.e. they include also a microstructural length scale parameters to account for the influence of stress and strain at neighbouring points. Moreover, as mechanical properties of such materials and structures show great variability, engineers are challenged by problems where also uncertainties play a crucial role. This suggests stochastic methods as the theoretical framework where uncertainties in material and geometric properties can be successfully treated to improve reliability and safety and prevent catastrophic structural failure. In analogy to the non-local theories, random materials are described by some functions related to the "length scale" of the distribution of the heterogeneities.

Motivated by the observation that non-local theory and stochastic mechanics are alternative strategies to tackle multiscale problems involving heterogeneity and uncertainties, this project aims to shed new light on questions such: How does stochastic description of material properties interact with non-local continuum models for dynamic problems? Would one or the other modelling philosophy work better for some engineering problems? Can we establish a relationship between the two strategies and then take advantage of the tools used exclusively for one or the other?

This project will seek answers to these questions by investigating the dynamics of concrete beams, selected as a case study because concrete has an inherent randomness due to the irregular arrangement of the constituents and it is possible to capture its microstructure with a digital camera. This is important because the research will also develop a new approach for the identification of the length scale parameters by using digital images of the microstructure, and a sensitivity study of the model's parameters will be conducted in a full stochastic mechanics setting.

Planned Impact

Diagnostic tools based on wave propagation in natural and man-made structures and materials are used in many fields of engineering for material characterisation or detection of components failure. We can mention the aerospace industry where ultrasounds are used for detecting damage in ultra-light composites, or bio-medical inspections for the characterisation of bone strength. Wave signals are also commonly employed in non-destructive techniques to detect early damage in civil engineering structures, for example bridges, power plants or dams, whose failure may cause loss of money and lives. Furthermore, the analysis of wave propagation in soils due to earthquakes or impacts provides fundamental information for designing a more resilient built environment. Structural failures have a tremendous impact on society: the collapse of buildings, infrastructures or strategic facilities unfortunately often results in loss of lives, but certainly in a huge financial disruption. This is a fundamental driver behind the increasing use of computational simulation as an advanced prediction and design tool to complement expensive (and not always achievable) experimental tests.

Computational mechanics is a major component in engineering design and manufacturing. Many technological achievements have been possible thanks to detailed computer simulations. While computational mechanics had a profound impact on the growth of major established industries such as aerospace, chemical and high-tech electronics, recently also the construction industry has relied on simulation software to design complex systems and as a tool to complement and validate experiments.

The proposed research suggests a new computational technique for modelling engineering structures which is based on mathematical modelling and will put forward a new point of view for the interpretation of the results of the experiments. In the PI's vision, a modelling strategy based on the tools of probabilistic analysis combined with advanced continuum theories allows reliability assessment whilst preserving ease of implementation. The target audience for the proposed advances are national and international researchers in the field of structural mechanics but there are also strong links with other communities, like materials, aerospace and chemistry. The use of the proposed approach has the potential for profound impact when assessing the performance of new and existing structures under severe loading conditions. If implemented in engineering practice, it is expected that the new multi-scale strategy will reduce the cost of design.

It is well known that probabilistic methods and reliability assessment are already established tools for engineering design of many strategic constructions and mechanical components, but a systematic use in everyday Civil Engineering practice is still not common even though it would result in more economic design and construction cycle. Considering all the mentioned motivations and aiming to impact also the construction industry, concrete has been selected as the subject of investigation. Many projects use such material and there is an increased urgency for the widespread adoption of structural health monitoring. Not only will the current infrastructure network benefit from a new multiscale reliability assessment, but also designers of new systems may benefit from the predictive capabilities of new simulation tools. As follow-on activities, the PI will utilise the excellent links with industry of the School of Civil and Building Engineering to disseminate the results of the project by organising a workshop at Loughborough University in collaboration with other academics working to advance structural design. A possible route for knowledge exchange in structural engineering design practice can be the dissemination of the outcome of the project through the IStrucE or ICE journals which are read by structural engineers working across UK design practice.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The study has developed a new multiscale computational strategy for modelling and analysis of structural materials with uncertain properties. In particular, wave propagation problems have been investigated from an experimental and numerical point of view, demonstrating that the effect of material uncertainties is more significant at high-frequency regimes where wavelengths become smaller. The study has been developed and tested for concrete structures. The results of ultrasonic tests have demonstrated that the microstructure of the material affects the wave propagation characteristics. The analytical/numerical study has demonstrated a relationship between two approaches, namely the non-local theory and the stochastic mechanics, leading to a more accurate physical understanding of the model/material parameters involved and to a more accurate computer simulation of the wave propagation phenomenon.
Exploitation Route Future work will need to include the attenuation phenomena which have a deep impact on the wave propagation through materials like concrete. This should be investigated further with lac tests and a new computational model should be developed to include attenuation.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction

 
Description IStrcuctE Undergraduate Research Grant
Amount £800 (GBP)
Organisation Institution of Structural Engineers 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2015 
End 05/2016
 
Description Workshop on Assessment of Structural Integrity of Civil Engineering Structures 
Organisation Free University of Brussels
Country Belgium 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Funds have been obtained from Loughborough University under the "Changing Environments & Infrastructure Challenge call" to host an international workshop at Loughborough University to facilitate a new research network between the Civil and Building Engineering's applicants and two leading researchers in the field of structural dynamics (including wind and earthquake engineering) and structural health monitoring, namely Prof Pol Spanos (PS), from Rice University in Houston, and Prof Dimitrios Aggelis (DA), from Vrije Universiteit Brussel .
Collaborator Contribution The two guests have both given a seminar in our School: • DA on Studying Materials Fracture by Acoustic Emission, in mid April; • PS on Emerging Joint Time-Frequency Analysis Techniques for Structural Dynamics Applications, in early June. Both seminars have provided useful inputs on ongoing research (DA on dispersive behaviour of concrete materials, linked to the EPSRC First Grant (EP/M004163/1); PS on random vibration for earthquake engineering). In addition to research meetings with the academics, they have also met with CBE's young researchers. In particular: • post-doc Dr Marco Donà, working on the EPSRC-funded grant "Non-local theories and stochastic mechanics" (EP/M004163/1); • PhD student Daniela Codeglia, from the Geothechnics group, with interest in acoustic emissions; • PhD student Stavros Kasinos, from the Structures group, participating in the EPSRC-funded grant "Non-local theories and stochastic mechanics" (EP/M004163/1); • Prof Stephanos Theodossiades, from the Wolfson School, with interests in non-linear dynamics.
Impact Following DA's visit at Loughborough, the academics of the research group have applied (early June) for a Royal Society International Exchanges Scheme (Ref No: IE150479; PI: Mariateresa) to fund future exchanges with his research group, but unfortunately the application was unsuccessful (end of September). DA was also named as collaborator in the recent EPSRC outline application for Strategic Equipment that has been submitted early October (PI: Dr Alessandro Palmeri).
Start Year 2015
 
Description Gradient elasticity theories for static and dynamic applications - Cardiff University 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Research seminar @ the School of Engineering
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
 
Description Seminar at Vrije Universiteit Brussel (The Department of Mechanics of Materials and Constructions (MEMC)) 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Future application for funding to support a joint research with the Brussel team have been planned.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017
 
Description Workshops on Structural Integrity of Infrastructures 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The visits facilitateD the development of new collaborative research ideas, as well as further enhancing the lines of research currently pursued by ml. Publications with the invited overseas researchers will also increase the international visibility of ML, with the consequent increase in the number of citations.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description organizer of a conference Special Session: CC2015-18 - Enhanced Continuum Theories for Multiscale Modelling of Materials and Structures 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact The special session has been organised in collaboration with prof Harm Askes from the University of Sheffield within The Fifteenth International Conference on Civil, Structural and Environmental Engineering Computing, Prague, Czech Republic, 1-4 September 2015.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2015
URL http://www.civil-comp.com/conf/conf2015/cc2015-s18.htm