SELF-STIMULATION AND SINGLE DROPLET/PARTICLE ENCAPSULATION IN THE CONTROLLED BREAKUP OF LIQUID JETS

Lead Research Organisation: University of Oxford
Department Name: Engineering Science

Abstract

The breakup of liquid jets into droplets has been the focus of study for more than two centuries. The fast production of microjets and microdroplets has gained additional importance beyond its pure scientific interest motivated by their application in microfluidics devices and in some modern digital technologies, such as 2D and 3D-Printing. Most current studies of this topic aim to improve the control over the position, number and directionality of droplets and their satellites. The objective of this project is two-fold: (i) we will investigate and exploit self-stimulation (resonance) of liquid jets for a better control of the breakup frequency and length; and (ii) once we are able to extract the most unstable (most efficient) frequency we will study the generation of single drops from a continuous liquid jet by means of intermittent pressure pulses. A liquid jet/column will break up into droplets due to the action of surface tension. In continuous inkjet applications the breakup of a jet (or column) of ink is induced and controlled by applying external perturbations in the pressure (or velocity) of the fluid via piezoelectric elements. If the frequency and amplitude of these perturbations are within the so-called 'most unstable modes' range, droplets of uniform size will be obtained. Although these frequencies are roughly predicted by the Rayleigh/Weber equations, in practice this still requires much adjustment and fine tuning; this fine tuning is an empirical process that has to be repeated when different fluids, or inks, are used, which is both limiting and time consuming. We propose to detect and exploit self-stimulated modes in which the system tunes itself to its most unstable frequency by means of feedback. This, by definition, is the most efficient breakup. In this part of the project, mechanisms for self-stimulation will be investigated. The clear advantage of this approach is that the fine tuning is not needed and the breakup frequency can be readily found for a wide range of fluids (within a reasonable operating regime).
The second part of the project, the generation of single drops from an otherwise unperturbed jet will be investigated. These single drops could be used for precise deposition, on demand, of small volumes of fluids for a variety of applications (e.g. Inkjet Printing). Moreover, it is envisaged that within these drops single particles (or cells, or other immiscible liquids in emulsion, etc.) can be trapped in real time and selectively delivered to a specific target. These 'particles' may be functional materials, chemical reactants, cells, etc. which are normally dispersed in a carrier fluid on purpose (e.g. fluids with the correct nutrients to sustain life, or functional materials in 'latent' mode) or unintentional and undesired (e.g. solid pollutants). These two overlapping and complementing studies would increase the predictability and reproducibility of the velocity and volume of droplets, and as a consequence these would increase reliability, efficiency and quality of printing technologies.

Planned Impact

Through careful laboratory experimentation we aim at elucidating some of the physical phenomena underlying the breakup of liquid jets. Direct comparison with industrial systems will allow us to translate our finding directly to industry, via our partners. This will provide them with tools to improve the generation of drops for inkjet applications (Continuous Inkjet at Domino), and to explore the encapsulation of active/reactive inks, functional materials, and composites for additive manufacturing and even biotechnological applications (Trijet). We will also aim at producing short articles for non-specialists to disseminate our findings, and how these can be used by industry involved in digital printing, especially nowadays when 3D printing is one of the technologies expected to revolutionise the manufacturing industry.

Direct impact is expected to occur during the development of the project due to the following:
-Having industrial partners and collaborators supporting this proposal presents us with the potential of our results being directly applicable to their research and development. Therefore, we will work in close collaboration with our industrial supporters (Trijet and Domino) and promptly present our findings. Trijet and Domino are already looking forward to working with us as many parts of our research, such as the experimental setup (the visualisation rig in particular - Trijet) and feedback assembly (Domino) are of great interest to them.
-Moreover, we will continuously communicate our results to our network of industrial collaborators working on inkjet and deposition of small volume of biocompatible gels and complex inks (e.g. Biogelx, Inca Digital, and TTP).
-The group also maintains collaboration with MERCK, and they are becoming increasingly interested in novel methods for the precise deposition of novel material with optical properties which, unfortunately, cannot be dispensed with traditional methods - our single-drop technique could potentially solve some of these issues.

Other non-academic beneficiaries will include:
-Adhesive and paint developers (e.g. Magna International): there is a need to find new ways of depositing drops of glues and paints onto their novel substrates for the measurement of surface energy and wettability properties in order to test the quality of their products.
-The general public and schools: we plan to develop a dedicated experiment and provide online resources for the dissemination of the project's outcomes for non-specialist audiences.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Arcenegui-Troya J (2019) A simple levitated-drop tensiometer. in The Review of scientific instruments

publication icon
Denner F (2021) Reversal and Inversion of Capillary Jet Breakup at Large Excitation Amplitudes in Flow, Turbulence and Combustion

publication icon
García FJ (2019) Evolution of Gaussian wave packets in capillary jets. in Physical review. E

publication icon
González H (2021) Self-Stimulated Capillary Jet in Physical Review Applied

publication icon
Quetzeri-Santiago MA (2019) Role of the Dynamic Contact Angle on Splashing. in Physical review letters

 
Description The proposal consists the study of the breakup of liquid jets, including self-stimulation of liquid jet via feedback of naturally growing surface perturbations and generation of single drops for with the use of intermittent pressure pulses. Moreover, this was expanded to the use of the generated droplets by this and other mechanisms to print Liquid Crystals (with an article published in Optical Materials Journal), to further the development of alternative ways of producing drops (Article in Soft Mater Journal) and to improved numerical models for the better description of droplet dynamics (Article in J. Non-Newtonian Fluid Mechanics). Our experimental results clearly show that self-stimulation of the jet is possible and easily obtainable. By extracting information of the shape of the jet after it leaves the nozzle, we can filter (in real time) the signal, acquire it and feed it back to the system via an electromagnetic shaker which imposes a pressure perturbation which induces a faster breakup of the jet. A steady breakup is reached within 5-10 wavelengths (~4ms for our system), and the breakup frequency reaches the most unstable mode - which can be affected by the mecano-acoustic coupling of the system (the transfer function between the shaker and the system itself) This confirms that we can actually exploit self-stimulation of the jet to extract the frequency that would result in one of the shortest breakup lengths - this is what is sought by industry. A manuscript detailing our results has been published in Physical Review Applied. The system was further used to generate symmetric liquid filaments at the most unstable frequencies to study the breakup dynamics of free-falling liquid jets - this investigation resulted in a high-impact manuscript in Journal of Fluid Mechanics.
On the other hand, the theoretical framework describing the breakup dynamics resulting from intermittent single pulse packages together with the experimental results demonstrating the generation of single drops from continues jets form the basis of a scientific manuscript published in Physical Review E. Moreover, from these experiments we have discovered that the passage of particles through the nozzle induce a perturbation large enough (depending on the size of the particle/nozzle) to induce the breakup of the jet as well - a combination of theory and experiments (finished during the tenure of the grant) together with ongoing numerical simulations will help us understand the dynamics better, from which we can then explore interesting regimes for industrial applications.
Exploitation Route 1- Academic community: Colleagues working on the dynamics of liquid jets, feedback and self-stimulation, and particle encapsulation problems may find this particular problem very attractive as it is very simple and relatively straightforward to modify. 2- Industry: we may be be able to help industry developing Continuous Inkjet Systems (e.g. Domino) with a technique to pinpoint a unstable frequency that will lead to one of the shortest breakup lengths, without the need for time-consuming trial-and-error processes. Short breakup lengths are better for printing purposes. Moreover, this part of the project may find applications in various disciplines, from chemistry to bio-sciences as the separation/encapsulation of functional materials or individual cells is of great interest.
Sectors Chemicals,Education,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology

 
Description The results of the grants were many. This included publications, and conferences, and a postdoctoral position. Importantly, it allows us to interact closely with industry: inkjet printing in particular. As the results of these investigations are well overlapping with industrial inkjet printing, and we have established collaborations with Domino Printing, Aricode, and Richo. Domino/Aricode supported this grant in-kind, and they have been sent our main results which they find interesting and further meetings to explore ways to incorporate/understand these results in the industrial settings are on the scope. Moreover, a 'by-product' of this grant was the development of an acoustic levitator of droplets which allow us to manipulate the levitated drops in such a way that we can extract fluid properties, such as viscosity and surface tension. This setup will now be used in a new collaboration with Ricoh, to better understand the dynamic surface tension effects of surfactant-laden liquids - part of an IAA grant which will hopefully lead to an invention. On the other hand, a more robust and portable version of the perturbed liquid jet setup has been developed, which has been used in demonstrations as part of access events and science fairs.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Education,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description CBET-EPSRC: Droplet Impact on Fluid Interfaces: 3D Effects Across Scales
Amount £472,463 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/W016036/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 09/2021 
End 09/2024
 
Description Royal Society University Research Fellowships Renewals 2018
Amount £335,670 (GBP)
Funding ID URF\R\180016 
Organisation The Royal Society 
Sector Charity/Non Profit
Country United Kingdom
Start 10/2018 
End 09/2021
 
Description UNIVERSITY OF OXFORD: EPSRC IMPACT ACCELERATION ACCOUNT
Amount £65,453 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/R511742/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2018 
End 07/2019
 
Description Collaboration with Domino LTD 
Organisation Domino (UK)
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution As part of the collaboration with Domino, we are studying the interactions, both hydrodynamics and mass transfer, between isolated pair or drops and between deflected drops and the main train of drops in a commercial/prototype Continuous Inkjet System provided by them and a large scale system developed in the laboratory.
Collaborator Contribution Domino has provided us with the state-of-the-art Continuous Inkjet System capable of producing diminutive solvent-based drops (60um) at high speeds (~20m/s). This also includes a camera, a high power LED flash, a synchroniation box and a PC. Moreover, preliminary data showing potential interaction between nearby drops was also provided.
Impact So far, the preliminary results consist ok: 1- Successful visualisation of the droplets' trajectories using a high speed camera, 2- Strong indication that consecutive drops interact hydrodynamically, 3- we managed to scale-up the system (drops of 1mm instead of 60um) for a more detail study.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Outreach and Aspiration Days at Wadham College Oxford 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact I regularly present my current research activities at a level appropriate for students in year 10-12. In particular, I deliver these seminar to schoolchildren from disadvantaged backgrounds and regions in the country from where student don't normally apply to University. In 2017 I delivered approximately six of these, with about 30 pupils each. As part of the chat, I present a hands-on experimental setup to show the 'freezing' of water droplets by the use of a speaker and a stroboscopic light, which that resembles the actual laboratory experiment funded by this grant. The presentation always generate very good and positive feedback and I am often requested to repeat the presentation throughout the whole year.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018
 
Description Royal Society Summer Exhibition 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact The activity formed part of the Royal Society Summer Exhibition in which we brought am experimental system for the demonstration, in a very interactive and hands-on way, the breakup of liquid jets. The activity was interactive and members of the public had to 'sing' at a constant pitch in order to synchronize that frequency with that of a strobe-light and the liquid jet. The result is that the droplets generated by the forced breakup of the jet seem 'frozen' in space when illuminated by the strobe. This sparked a lot if discussions at various levels, from young students to scientists working in biology, chemistry, physics and engineering.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
URL https://royalsociety.org/science-events-and-lectures/2018/07/lates-sing-til-you-drop/