Operando EPR study of automotive catalysts for NOx removal

Lead Research Organisation: University College London
Department Name: Chemical Engineering

Abstract

Selective catalytic reduction (SCR) is a reaction that used in every diesel vehicle to reduce the emission of harmful NOx gas. The EU 6 emission standard calls for efficient and selective SCR catalysts that reduce the NOx emission to less than 0.080 mg/km. Though commercial catalysts for vehicle SCR have been used for a decade, the actual active site and the reaction mechanism are still not understood and under debate. Operando spectroscopy, a methodology wherein the spectroscopic characterization of materials undergoing reaction is coupled simultaneously with measurement of catalytic activity and selectivity, can probe the active site behaviours and help understand the active site behaviours. This research program aims to apply operando Electron Paramagnetic Resonance (EPR) technique in order to study and understand the Cu2+ active site for SCR. The operando EPR facility that will be developed in this research program will be one of few around world and unique in the UK. It directly probes the active sites and can quantitatively measure the status/changes of the oxidation state and coordination environment, while recording the reaction kinetics simultaneously. In this way, a structure-activity relationship of the catalysts will be established. Such facility will not only be important for catalysis, but also crucial for materials discovery in the UK. Together with operando X-ray absorption spectroscopy (XAS) and IR, the success of this program will provide fundamental understanding of the reaction and help develop more selective SCR catalysts. It is expected that operando EPR, together with other operando spectroscopies, will provide deep understanding of catalysis mechanisms in many industrially important reactions, and thus optimize the design and development of future catalysts.

Planned Impact

The research program aims at developing operando EPR technique for optimizing SCR catalysts and reducing NOx gas emission. The potential stakeholders that can benefit from this research are: academics in catalysis/EPR/materials around world, the catalysts industry/ car industry, the transportation sector, and also the general public. This program provides deep understanding in reaction mechanisms and materials property/structure relationship for the academics in catalysis and materials. It will stimulate new characterization methodology in the EPR field.
The study of SCR reactions will provide guidance in optimizing and developing new SCR catalysts with high selectivity and stability. In particular, it helps develop SCR catalysts that work at low temperatures, which is one of the main problems with the state of art SCR technique. This will help industry to upgrade their products and gain bigger market share. By designing efficient catalysts, the use of noble metals such as Cu will also be reduced. It is an effective way to reduce the price of the SCR technique, and make it affordable to all diesel cars. Potentially, events such as the Volkswagen's emission scandal will never happen again.
JM, a UK based company, is one of the biggest company supplying SCR catalysts. JM is also the industrial collaborator of this program. It is expected that the success of this program will help their performance in the future, and therefore provide more jobs in the UK.
Efficient SCR catalysts also have huge impact in the transportation sector. Diesel has more power per volume than that of petrol, so in general the use of diesel is a more economic than the use of petrol. However, for historical reasons, emission standards for diesel are much stricter than that of petrol, e.g. USA, EU, China and Japan. By applying efficient and low cost SCR catalysts, the diesel cars in future can meet those strict standards and can compete with petrol cars in the market. This will help increase the energy utilization efficiency in the transportation sectors.
The success of this research program will also benefit the general public in the terms of better environment and improved transportation experience. The emission control catalysis aims at reducing the harmful gases, such as CO and NOx in the exhaust gas. The NOx gas not only has negative health effects but also attacks the ozone layer in the atmosphere. The low cost SCR technique will provide better transportation experience and lower charges and fees on the car emission. In the long term, this research program can also stimulate new technique that not only deal with car exhaust control, but also be applied in stationary exhaust control, such as technique for flue gas in the power plants.
In summary, the impact of this research program lies in both the economic benefits to the UK and the well-being of the people living in the country and around world.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description The aim of our research is to study the catalytic behaviours of Cu2+ site for NOx gas removal. The project has been completed and key results are summarized for publications:
1. In the Cu-SAPO system, we are able to identify two types of Cu2+ sites for NOx removal by using electron paramagnetic resonance spectroscopy (EPR), X-ray absorption fine structure (XAFS), Near-edge X-ray absorption fine structure (NEXAFS). The combination of those techniques enable tracing the evolution of Cu species and surface nitrogen species during the NO2 removal reaction. Both sites are in +2 oxidation state and disperse uniformly in the zeolites framework. High time resolution in our measurement reveals the dynamics of the Cu sites at different gas atmospheres. The NO+O2 mixture provides the most oxidative atmosphere, where Cu show 2+ oxidation state. NH3, NH3+O2 and NH3+NO+O2 all provide a semi-reductive atmosphere, with reducibility in NH3 > NH3+NO+O2 > NH3+O2 order. NH3 + NO provides the most reductive atmosphere, suggesting the interactions between Cu and NH3. The study provides fundamental understanding into the catalyst active sites and reaction mechanism in the NOx removal chemistry. The results are shared with Johnson Matthey, gaining insights into their catalyst systems. In the past year, we have also used operando X-ray technique to study the 1AlCu and 2AlCu site in SCR reaction. We have idenitied a Cu(I)(NH3)O species in the framework that prevents the oxidation half cycle. We use this to explain the low activity of the 2AlCu site in the SCR reaction.


2. In the Cu/CeO2 system, we find a Cu(I/II) single-site on CeO2 surface for oxygen activation. The oxidative nature of Ce4+ helps stabilize the Cu(I/II) site and reduces the energy of the frontier orbitals. These single-sites are 10 times more active than CuO clusters in CO oxidation, showing a turnover frequency of 0.028 ± 0.003 s-1 at 373 K and 0.01 bar PCO. Operando EPR and XAFS study and density functional theory simulations reveal the dynamic transition between [Cu(I)O2]3- and a possible peroxide species [Cu(II)O2(n2-O2)]4- in CO rich and lean conditions, indicating the redox mechanism during the reaction. The Cu(I/II) single-site shows superior styrene epoxidation activity with molecular O2, giving styrene oxide with 57% selectivity at 373 K. The results are submitted to Nat. Commun. and is current under revision.

In addition to those scientific findings, we have also achieved:

3. A quantification method for Cu2+ single-site with EPR technique.
4. A combined operando EPR and XAFS technique. We aim to apply for a future EPSRC grant support on this.
5. We wrote a book chapter on in situ EPR for catalysis.
Exploitation Route Our understanding of the Cu/SAPO-34 and Cu/CeO2 catalytic systems is of crucial importance for the understanding of current de-NOx systems and for developing next generation catalysts.
1. Our results are summarized into 4 manuscripts, two under revision and two will be submitted soon.
2. Our research provides evidence to show why Cu/SAPO-34 is among the best catalysts for de-NOx reaction so far. This information will be shared with the public via academic journals, conference presentations, and thus benefits both the academic and industry.
3. We are develop next generation catalysts with high efficiency and stability. Thus new technology will be invented to remove the NOx gas emission from diesel engines. This will be developed with our industrial partner Johnson Matthey, Plc. They current own 30% of the car exhaust control market around the world.
4. Our ultimate target is to have NOx free emission and thus provide clean air in the UK. This target will be achieved by applying more efficient catalysts to remove NOx gas, as showed above. We will collaborate with both Johnson Matthey and Toyota on this.
Sectors Chemicals,Energy,Environment

 
Description Based on our research, a key non-academic impact is that we build our partnership with Johnson Matthey, plc.(JM). JM is the world leading company in de-NOx technique. Through this partnership, JM supports us with one PhD student, who started in September 2017. JM also provides their de-NOx catalyst for this research. 1. The identification of the active site structure is one of the key steps to understand why their catalysts outperform other commercial catalysts. 2. Our discovery of Cu/CeO2 system immediately attracts their interests. The system not only can serve as the next general de-NOx catalyst for diesel engines but also can potentially replace the Pt Rh catalysts for the car exhaust in the gasoline engines. 3. We have identified that Cu single site over Fe2O3 system to be a potential SCR catalyst. It has very high activity and selectivity towards N2. We further secure a partnership with Toyota, the world largest car maker. Toyota is interested in our Cu/CeO2 base materials for oyxgen storage in the three way catalysts. One of the Toyota Employee is current visiting our lab for one year. Toyota also supports us with 22,000 GBP funding on the consumables.
First Year Of Impact 2020
Sector Chemicals,Energy,Environment,Transport
 
Title Single Cu2+ site quantification with EPR 
Description We have developed a quantification method that can accurately determine the Cu2+ single-site loading. Comparing the Cu2+ single-site loading with the total Cu loading will reveal the true single-site composition. 
Type Of Material Technology assay or reagent 
Year Produced 2018 
Provided To Others? No  
Impact Such new method quantify the amount of Cu2+ single-site in heterogeneous catalysts for the first time. This will enable the understanding of single-site behaviors under reaction conditions. 
 
Description Cu-CHA for NOx removal reaction 
Organisation Johnson Matthey
Department Johnson Matthey Technology Centre
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution JM: We charaterize the Cu-CHA system at in situ conditions and identify the key role of the Al during the reaction
Collaborator Contribution JM: provide catalysts and catalysts evaluation platforms for this research, fund a PhD student.
Impact Identifying two Cu2+ sites and their dynamics during the NOx removal reactions. This insight helps to develop new and efficient catalysts for this reaction.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Cu-CHA for NOx removal reaction 
Organisation Toyota Motor Corporation
Country Japan 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution JM: We charaterize the Cu-CHA system at in situ conditions and identify the key role of the Al during the reaction
Collaborator Contribution JM: provide catalysts and catalysts evaluation platforms for this research, fund a PhD student.
Impact Identifying two Cu2+ sites and their dynamics during the NOx removal reactions. This insight helps to develop new and efficient catalysts for this reaction.
Start Year 2017
 
Description N2O emission control in nitric acide production 
Organisation Johnson Matthey
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution We are developing a reactor for NH3 oxidation reaction. We will measure the reaction kinetics and understand the N2O emission during the reaction.
Collaborator Contribution The partner provide 1 million GBP to this project. The funding is provided to develop the reactor, support 4 year PDRA and one 4 year PhD studentship.
Impact We just start the project, so there is no output so far.
Start Year 2022
 
Description Promoting storage capacity of oxygen storage materials 
Organisation Toyota Motor Corporation
Country Japan 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Toyota: We improve the oxygen storage capacity of three-way catalysts by introducing new isolated site that accelerating the oxygen uptake.
Collaborator Contribution Toyota: Send a visitor to my group for one year to carry out the research. They also provide the basic chemical formular of oxygen storage materials using machine learning techniques.
Impact The colloboration just started one month ago, so the outputs are yet to be summarized.
Start Year 2020