Freeform Composites: Breaking Free from the Mould.

Lead Research Organisation: University of Sheffield
Department Name: Mechanical Engineering

Abstract

When making a carbon or glass fibre composite part, a mould is required. The mould supports the flexible composite fabric and adhesive while the adhesive sets. Once the adhesive sets the mould is no longer required. These moulds are expensive to make and wear out over time. As they are expensive, designs tend to change slowly, as the cost of the mould needs to be recovered by repeated use of the mould. But, what if, you only supported a small piece of the part while it cured and then moved on to other parts. Ultimately you could draw the part in 3 dimensional space, just as a pencil draws on flat paper.

The benefit of this would be the ability to create lightweight strong parts. Unencumbered by the restrictions of a mould, with fewer joints and therefore more resilient structures. Is this not already done with 3D printing? In essence yes and no, in 3D printing of composites, either short fibre in resin matrix are used (FDM type) or layers are cut to shape and placed on a flat bed, with successive layers added. Here the joins between the layers are weak and the flat layers are not oriented to give the strongest structures. This new system will produce optimal structures, emphasising the directional properties of carbon and glass fibre to create strong lightweight structures for bespoke engineering applications. These could find uses in new lightweight bridges, car parts, prosthetic limbs, even aircraft wings. The importance of this mould free process, is the fact that it can be easily scaled by building a larger robot. A large robot could therefore build a wing or a canoe whatever the customer required at that time. This new system would create truly flexible composite manufacturing.
Overview of Proposed Research.

The research will create low friction surfaces that will not foul with resin by using fluorinated polymer brushes lubricated by a fluorinated oil. The oil and resin are chemically incompatible and do not wet each other. This surface will be pressed into the composite fabric, deforming it into the required shape, in the same way that Two point incremental forming (TPIF) operatives on aluminium. As the fabric is deformed, the resin will be applied and the composite will be cured. In the first stage of the work by UV, for glass fibre (SMC) and thin carbon fibre panels, in the later stages by microwave curing. To create larger parts, wide carbon fibre tape (1-2cm) will be woven into mats. The ends of the tape will be fed into the system, (with new tape woven into it, as the tapes extend) creating new surface that can be subsequently cured. In this way a continuous weaving, pressing, curing process is created. This would allow for the first time the creation of freeform composite parts. In the early stages this will be limited to panel structures but the long term goal is to integrate this with 3D weaving technology.

Planned Impact

Who would benefit from this research?
Composite manufacturers, including those who would still use moulds as the technology for understanding the tool-composite interaction could be used to develop automated adhesive and consolidation systems. Leading to greater automation and more reproducible composite parts.
Robotic and automation industries; due to increased market opportunities.
Schools, Universities and Colleges: The ability to create bespoke parts with minimal waste, would create the opportunity for schools to make composite parts. This would introduce composites to a much younger audience, and help develop their thinking around anisotropic material manufacturing.
Prosthetic limb and medical applications: A scan of a patients limb could be rapidly turned into a bespoke composite socket. Limbs for children could be produce rapidly from lightweight materials. As such the project could have impacts on quality of life, health and well being.
Manufacturing industry: Marine: Marine manufacturing particularly of yachts, tends to be on a relatively small scale. Novel designs such as those of Glider Yachts would become more readily available. Automotive: While most automotive manufacturing would still concentrate on moulds due to the volume, small scale performance vehicles could benefit from this technology, particularly as it would allow for rapid turn-around in the design -testing cycle. Aviation: Longer term this technology will find applications in large scale manufacturing of composite wings and fuselages. Allowing the creation of larger continuous structures, reducing the need for joining technology.
Energy: Wind power: The creation of large structures, such as entire blades in a single process would be facilitated by this system. This would reduce the costs of wind power, both in reduced production time (in particular "finishing time") and in assembly and material costs.

Secondary benefits: Due to the bespoke nature, the proposed research creates opportunities for artists, architects and designers to use composite materials in novel ways. The lightweight, strong and stiff nature of carbon composites is surprising to all the first time it is encountered. The new possibilities for installations based around composites would bring composites to a new audience.

Who would lose out?
Potentially this could be disruptive to mould manufacturers, particularly those specialising in the machining of epoxy block. As this tends to be used in the more niche small volume sectors.
 
Description The idea seems to work for simple designs. Flat samples are easy to form, samples with simple one direction curvature are also relatively easy, (unless sharp bends are required) more complex two dimensional systems will require specialist weaving. I am in contact with weaving specialists at the AMRC to understand this better.

We have extended the work to include thermoplastic and thermoset materials in flat and curved geometries. The limitation on using simple 3 axis machines, due to the limited expenditure on the grant, means that we have not been able to extend the work to highly curved surfaces or a surface that is curved in two dimensions. We are about to undertake further trials on 6 axis robotic machines, as part of a collaboration with a group in the Netherlands. This hopefully will lead to some new understanding of how this could be achieved on a larger scale.
We are still working on improving the clamping mechanism as the project focused essentially on the curing methodology and improving the rate of production. The clamping methodology proved to be a difficult task to automate and to predictively understand and this will be the subject of a grant application in the future. We are currently in discussions with other composite groups in the UK on extending the work. The aim is to produce a consortium to build on this work to exploit the technology and deliver a fully automated system.
Exploitation Route We are in discussions with other composite groups on developing this technology. These discussions came out of the NEC event that we attended. This attracted a great deal of interest and several industrial leads, who are willing to assist us in further progressing the technology. The project was very well received at the NEC and we are looking to build on this to take this idea forward.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Construction,Energy,Leisure Activities, including Sports, Recreation and Tourism,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Retail,Transport

URL https://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/S2212827119312806
 
Title Double Point Composite forming tool 
Description New system developed to cure composite materials without the use of a mold. The system comprised two 3 axis cartesian frames that allow two tools to impinge on the composite fabric and cure the composite in an incremental manner. 
Type Of Technology Systems, Materials & Instrumental Engineering 
Year Produced 2019 
Impact The equipment is now being modified by a self-funded PhD student to imporve the curing rate whilst at the same time reducing the energy input to the system. 
 
Description NEC Advanced Engineering show 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact We attended the advanced engineering show at the NEC. We took a stall near the entrance and took the two 3 axis machines to demonstrate the project. We received a great deal of interest from a number of industrial companies, polymer suppliers, fabric and pre preg suppliers and a number of the UK composite groups, their postgraduate students, a few undergraduate students and students from Technical College. We saw more than 150 people in the two day event, who were very interested in the project and most discussed possible involvement in the project in the longer term.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019