Geometry of Artin Group Actions

Lead Research Organisation: Heriot-Watt University
Department Name: S of Mathematical and Computer Sciences

Abstract

Groups are a structure that encode the mathematical idea of symmetry. While one may think of symmetry as a geometric notion, such as in the symmetries of a snowflake or of a wall-paper, mathematicians investigate a more abstract notion of symmetry, namely the possible transformations that leave features of an object unchanged. This larger class of symmetries ranges from shuffling a deck of cards to the manipulation of strings of hair when making a braid. The study of this generalised idea of symmetry, known as group theory, plays a key role in modern mathematics, as understanding the symmetries of an object is a stepping stone towards a deeper understanding of that object.

Geometric group theory is the field of mathematics that aims to understand these more abstract symmetry groups by realising them as symmetries of new geometric objects. Doing so allows one to use geometric methods to investigate the structure of these groups, and the resulting dialogue between algebra and geometry has proved particularly fruitful in recent years, both within and outside mathematics.

This project focuses on a class of groups known as Artin groups, a vast generalisation of the groups involved in making braids, which have ramifications in many areas of mathematics and beyond. While the structure of braid groups is relatively well understood, the situation is much more mysterious for general Artin groups, and many important and natural questions remain open.

This project will introduce a new geometric framework to study general Artin groups. In recent years, large classes of groups from various horizons have been studied with great success from a geometric viewpoint, and particularly from the point of view of actions on spaces satisfying some form of non-positive curvature. This is such an approach that will be carried out in this project. More precisely, this project will study large classes of Artin groups through their actions on hyperbolic spaces, and will use the dynamics of such actions to understand the structure of these groups in great generality. This project will also highlight structural similarities with other important classes of groups.

This work represents an exciting project at the crossroads between algebra, combinatorial geometry, and dynamics in negative curvature. It will involve collaborations with researchers from Canada and France. A workshop will be organised halfway through, in order to bring together experts studying Artin groups from various perspectives: algorithmic group theory, combinatorics, etc.

Planned Impact

The goal of this project is to bring new insights in the study of Artin groups, and to highlight similarities with other important classes of groups, such as mapping class groups and cubical groups. The main impact of this work will thus be on academics working in geometric group theory and in its neighbouring fields: algorithmic group theory, combinatorics, etc. Researchers will be able to use this new point of view to study Artin groups, leading to further research on this topic. Moreover, as the class of groups studied from the point of view of actions on hyperbolic spaces is an ever-growing on, we expect this work to have significant impact in geometric group theory, as researchers will be able to import the techniques introduced in this project to study other classes of groups.

A central part of this project is the organisation of a workshop in Spring 2020 that will bring together experts from various horizons. Indeed, Artin groups are a topic of active research at the intersection of several fields (hyperbolic geometry, Garside structures, etc. ), but where communication barriers may impede the cross-fertilisation of these fields. By bringing together leading experts working on these groups from various perspectives, we expect a significant transfer of knowledge between these various subfields. This workshop will also spark new collaborations, leading to new and exciting approaches to study Artin groups and related groups.

Concepts and tools at the heart of this project have already found applications outside of mathematics: CAT(0) cube complexes have been used to model configuration spaces relevant to robotics, while small cancellation techniques have strong connections with communication networks. Artin groups represent a topic that is particularly easy to introduce, and the PI will thus propose the (co-)organisation of specialised courses, both at Heriot-Watt University and through the Scottish Mathematical Sciences Training Centre, thus allowing large cohorts of students across Scotland to learn about cutting-edge research in geometric group theory. We expect a long-term economic impact since, as often with pure mathematical research, providing students with today's abstract mathematical frameworks will enable them to model and solve tomorrow's applied problems.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Aroca J (2022) A new family of infinitely braided Thompson's groups in Journal of Algebra

publication icon
Calvez M (2021) Curve graphs for Artin-Tits groups of type B, A~ and C~ are hyperbolic in Transactions of the London Mathematical Society

publication icon
CUMPLIDO M (2022) Parabolic subgroups of large-type Artin groups in Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society

publication icon
Cumplido M (2019) The Root Extraction Problem for Generic Braids in Symmetry

publication icon
Genevois A (2019) Automorphisms of graph products of groups from a geometric perspective in Proceedings of the London Mathematical Society

publication icon
Hagen M (2022) Extra-large type Artin groups are hierarchically hyperbolic in Mathematische Annalen

publication icon
Martin A (2020) Tits alternative for Artin groups of type FC in Journal of Group Theory

publication icon
MARTIN A (2020) A combination theorem for combinatorially non-positively curved complexes of hyperbolic groups in Mathematical Proceedings of the Cambridge Philosophical Society

publication icon
Martin A (2022) Acylindrical Actions for Two-Dimensional Artin Groups of Hyperbolic Type in International Mathematics Research Notices

publication icon
Martin A (2021) Acylindrical actions on CAT(0) square complexes in Groups, Geometry, and Dynamics

 
Description Artin groups are an important class of groups generalizing braid groups, and whose structure is still very elusive.

A key insight of this research so far has been to successfully exploit the fact that certain of these groups (namely Artin groups of dimension 2 and of type FC) can be realised as geometric symmetries of well-behaved spaces to reveal important and previously unknown aspects of their structure.

The research supported by this grant has shown that:
- many such groups admit an analogue of a "curve complex", i.e. a particularly nice hyperbolic complex on which they act.
- most of these groups satisfy an important dichotomy known as the Tits Alternative: Their subgroups are either very big or very small. (This conjecture is believed to be true for all Artin groups, but was known for very few classes until now.)
- many of these groups are hierarchically hyperbolic, and very strong form of non-positive curvature that has many consequences.
- for many such groups, some "building blocks" called parabolic subgroups form a very nice combinatorial structure called a "lattice", revealing further connections with Coxeter groups.
- for a large class of large-type Artin groups, it is possible to solve the isomorphism problem, i.e. to show that these groups are uniquely determined by their presentation graphs.
- for may Artin groups, even though the subgroups generated by two elements can be wild (this is well-known), the subgroups generated by suitably large powers become much better behaved: free or free abelian.
Exploitation Route The outcomes highlight how the action of Artin groups on their Deligne complex (or their variants) can be used to reveal new properties of general Artin groups. This approach should be extremely fruitful in studying new classes of Artin groups, as well as studying open problems for the class of two-dimensional Artin groups.
The detour we have taken for Objective 4 has led to a new powerful criterion to show that certain groups are hierarchically hyperbolic. This will prove useful for other researchers, will help cement the notion of hierarchical hyperbolicity as a natural, general, and powerful concept, and has already led to new results in the field.
Sectors Education,Other

 
Description ICMS Research in Groups (H-M-S)
Amount £2,575 (GBP)
Organisation International Centre for Mathematical Sciences (ICMS) 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 02/2020 
End 02/2020
 
Description Collaboration on hierarchical hyperbolicity and Artin groups 
Organisation City University of New York (CUNY)
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I started a project to reformulate hierarchical hyperbolicity with Sisto back in 2017 using a more combinatorial and tractable approach. I also brought my understanding of the geometry of Artin groups, which was necessary to apply our combinatorial criterion.
Collaborator Contribution My collaborators are the people who introduced the notion of hierarchical hyperbolicity, and as such their expertise was invaluable to overcome many technical obstacles.
Impact This collaboration resulted in two papers, both currently submitted for publication, and currently feely accessible on the arXiv: - A combinatorial take on hierarchical hyperbolicity and applications to quotients of mapping class groups, (with Behrstock, Hagen, Sisto), available at https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.00567 - Extra-large type Artin groups are hierarchically hyperbolic, (with Hagen, Sisto) available at https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.04387
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration on hierarchical hyperbolicity and Artin groups 
Organisation ETH Zurich
Country Switzerland 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I started a project to reformulate hierarchical hyperbolicity with Sisto back in 2017 using a more combinatorial and tractable approach. I also brought my understanding of the geometry of Artin groups, which was necessary to apply our combinatorial criterion.
Collaborator Contribution My collaborators are the people who introduced the notion of hierarchical hyperbolicity, and as such their expertise was invaluable to overcome many technical obstacles.
Impact This collaboration resulted in two papers, both currently submitted for publication, and currently feely accessible on the arXiv: - A combinatorial take on hierarchical hyperbolicity and applications to quotients of mapping class groups, (with Behrstock, Hagen, Sisto), available at https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.00567 - Extra-large type Artin groups are hierarchically hyperbolic, (with Hagen, Sisto) available at https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.04387
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration on hierarchical hyperbolicity and Artin groups 
Organisation University of Bristol
Department School of Mathematics
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I started a project to reformulate hierarchical hyperbolicity with Sisto back in 2017 using a more combinatorial and tractable approach. I also brought my understanding of the geometry of Artin groups, which was necessary to apply our combinatorial criterion.
Collaborator Contribution My collaborators are the people who introduced the notion of hierarchical hyperbolicity, and as such their expertise was invaluable to overcome many technical obstacles.
Impact This collaboration resulted in two papers, both currently submitted for publication, and currently feely accessible on the arXiv: - A combinatorial take on hierarchical hyperbolicity and applications to quotients of mapping class groups, (with Behrstock, Hagen, Sisto), available at https://arxiv.org/abs/2005.00567 - Extra-large type Artin groups are hierarchically hyperbolic, (with Hagen, Sisto) available at https://arxiv.org/abs/2109.04387
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration with Dr Maria Cumplido and Nicolas Vaskou on parabolic subgroups of Artin groups of large type 
Organisation University of Seville
Country Spain 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The understanding of parabolic subgroups of Artin groups had so far been studied from a rather algebraic perspective. I explained to my PhD student Nicolas Vaskou and collaborator Maria Cumplido (postdoc) how we could understand the intersection of parabolic subgroups from the point of view of the geometry of a well-chosen complex. I explained to them the relevant systolic geometry to study this complex for Artin groups of large type.
Collaborator Contribution Maria's understanding of the conjugation stability problem for Artin groups of finite allowed us to generalise this result to all Artin groups of large type. More generally, her understanding of parabolic subgroups in the finite type case was very useful and complemented my own expertise.
Impact one article currently submitted for publication (freely available on the arXiv: https://arxiv.org/abs/2012.02693 )
Start Year 2019
 
Description Collaboration with Dr Piotr Przytycki on the Tits alternative for Artin groups 
Organisation McGill University
Country Canada 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The grant funding allowed the PI to visit Dr Przytycki in McGill (Canada) to establish a scientific collaboration, based on our prior work and understanding of the geometry of Artin groups.
Collaborator Contribution Expertise on the combinatorial geometry of complexes
Impact Three papers published on the geometry of Artin groups in collaboration with P. Przytycki, full details available in the "outcomes" section: - Tits Alternative for Artin groups of type FC (Journal of Group Theory) - Abelian subgroups of two-dimensional Artin groups (Bulletin of the LMS) - Acylindrical actions for two-dimensional Artin groups of hyperbolic type (IMRN) A fourth paper was released recently as a preprint. Although not a joint article, it certainly benefitted from discussions with P. Przytycki: - The Tits Alternative for two-dimensional Artin groups and Wise's Power Alternative
Start Year 2019
 
Description Organisation of a 4-day online international workshop "Perspectives on Artin Groups" in May 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact About 30 academics and postgraduate students / researchers took part in a four-day online international workshop on Artin groups hosted by the ICMS (Edinburgh), whose goal was to bring together experts on Artin groups to make a state of the art on the topic, share perspectives, and foster new collaborations. The workshop was made of 9 talks by experts from all over the world (USA, Poland, Spain, France, UK), as well as 3 longer discussion sessions to address open problems in the field and share ideas.
The workshop was attended by a mix of experts and younger researchers (postdocs, PhD students), for which it was an ideal opportunity to learn more about this growing field.
Videos of most talks are available at this address: https://media.ed.ac.uk/playlist/dedicated/51612401/1_mdkfkzpn/1_at7bm1cy
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.icms.org.uk/workshops/2021/perspectives-artin-groups