It's soil, Jim, but not as we know it: unlocking the hydromechanical behaviour of hydrophobic sands

Lead Research Organisation: University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Engineering

Abstract

Climate change means that many geotechnical structures will face harsher conditions in the future than their designers previously considered. Specifically, droughts, heat waves, flooding or heavy rain will all compromise soil covers used to protect mining or municipal waste storage sites, as material either cracks or becomes waterlogged. The environmental and economic consequences of such failures are and will be disastrous. Water repellent (hydrophobic) sands may be able to resist such changes and so be a novel and timely substitute for current cover layer materials. However, these materials are new and we do not yet know how water passes through them or acts to stick particles together. Understanding this will greatly help the engineering of structures they support.
We know that soil behaviour is governed by the amount of water trapped within its pores. In normal soils, water trapped between soil particles forms concave 'bridges' which act to stick the particles together via a phenomenon known as "suction". A classic example of this is a beach sandcastle: if the sand is fully wet or dry it collapses but, if moist, it stands. On the other hand, a hydrophobic material is one where water will form beads on its surfaces, rather than spreading out. Hydrophobic soils naturally form in arid regions when particles are coated with plant oils or if exposed to very high temperatures, for example during forest fires. Soils can also become hydrophobic if treated with contaminated water or chemicals in the laboratory. Water trapped between hydrophobic surfaces forms very different structures to those in normal soils; instead of the usual concave shape, the water forms convex 'balls' between the particles. This shape suggests that the water acts to force the particles apart: the opposite of suction. Some work has been done to examine this possibility but, as yet, Engineers do not have a method to predict how the soil will behave if the water is in this condition.
This project will reset our understanding of how water interacts with hydrophobic soils. Firstly, we will use state-of-the-art microscopy techniques to observe water as it condenses and grows, to understand how it interacts with the individual soil particles and those around them. This knowledge will tell us what pressures exist in the water structures and whether the particles are being drawn together or forced apart. Using this knowledge, we will develop tests to cycle the water content to relate the soil's water content to pressures during drying and wetting; a critical phenomenon when predicting how water will pass through the material during, for example, heavy rainfall. 3D reconstructions, generated using X-ray tomography, will tell us whether these changes in pressure change the particle arrangements, which may change how water passes through the material. Lastly, we will develop methods to test how the soil's strength is affected by and how it varies with changes in those water pressures. Understanding how strength varies is key to permitting Engineers to design structures using these new materials.

Planned Impact

This project will develop a new, climate change-resilient material for municipal and mining waste containment: hydrophobic soil. There are many beneficiaries to this research; it will directly benefit academic and industrial researchers working in the fields of unsaturated soil mechanics and, more broadly, the wider field of resilient infrastructure and engineers working in the waste storage industry.
Unsaturated soil mechanics researchers will benefit from new research opportunities and characterisation methodologies (testing and a descriptive framework) for hydrophobic granular media, for example novel solutions for water sequestration. They will also benefit from improved publicity and industry appreciation of the potential applications of unsaturated soils research. Impact will be delivered through face-to-face meetings, to introduce innovations directly into laboratory practice, conference attendance and journal articles. Hydrophobised soils manufactured at Edinburgh will be made available to other institutions to encourage research and collaboration (avoiding the potentially hazardous preparation processes). These routes will also impact researchers in wider engineering fields concerned with resilient infrastructure, for example geotechnical and environmental engineers, by providing greater design and modelling flexibility. Hydrophobicity is also an emerging issue in areas outside of the traditional engineering sector, for example in the minerals (repellence of mineral fracture surfaces), carbon sequestration (repellence due to introduced organic matter), pharmaceutical (repellence in highly dry media), food and agricultural sectors (water repellent soils as an irrigation constraint). The project's findings will be introduced to these broader fields through targeted seminars (e.g. through the University of Edinburgh Global Academy of Agriculture and Food Security) and a project website.
Academic dissemination routes are unlikely to impact industry. Members of the UoE Civil and Environmental Advisory Board (and their colleagues) will be contacted and invited to observe testing and discuss results. The project's researchers will also regularly meet with representatives from the Scottish Environmental Protection Agency, responsible for regulating all landfills in Scotland, to communicate research findings, promote the new material and permit future field trials. Members of the public will be engaged through popular scientific events, for example the annual Midlothian Science Festival, to showcase the material, demonstrate quirks of its behaviour, highlight issues surrounding waste storage systems and show how the new material can provide needed innovations in the area.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Description This award had to key objectives: to examine the hydromechanical behaviour of hydrophobic granular soils; and to provide a foundation from which additional funding applications could be submitted. We have succeeded in both objectives.

We have discovered that the presence of sharp edges on particle surfaces affects the sessile drop (or "apparent") contact angle. This is in addition to the traditional Cassie-Baxter and Wenzel wetting mechanisms. In our work, we have shown that a droplet will encounter a greater number of edges with preferential orientation to the triple line as the droplet volume increases. The result is an increasing contact angle from the perspective of the average surface with increasing droplet volume for particles that are i) smaller than the capillary radius and ii) comprise surfaces with sharp edges. Particles that are smooth (e.g. spherical beads) do not demonstrate this effect. As a consequence, drop shape analysis on angular particles must account for changes in droplet volume when determining contact angles; this is significant for industrial processes reliant upon droplet formation and contact forces, e.g. granular transport. How this effect affects droplet contact angle hysteresis is a subject of ongoing research.

We have discovered that our original hypothesis, being that water trapped between water repellent soil particles must adopt convex shapes with positive Laplace pressures, is only applicable under the specific circumstances of menisci caught between clean, spherical particles that are in contact. We have identified mechanisms by which water droplets and menisci are able to bridge between hydrophobic particles, by which the material gains stability (negative Laplace pressures). In hydrophobic soils, we have revealed that this mechanism can produce either repulsive (classically assumed theory) or attractive forces (identified through our work) depending on the volume of the coalescing droplets or menisci. We assume, but have not yet been able to show, that dependence on the droplet or meniscus volume has significant implications for the material's geotechnical stability; this is being explored through an ongoing PhD project and current and future funding applications.

We have submitted several funding applications based on our findings and new partnerships developed during the project. Submissions to the NERC Discovery Science, NERC Global Partnership Seedcorn Fund, EPSRC Future Leadership Fellowship scheme, and the EPSRC SOFI DTP were unsuccessful at the internal or external review stage. Submissions to the Royal Society and the EXCITE Network are under review. Submissions to the EPSRC Standard Grant scheme and The University of Edinburgh's NERC E4 DTP are planned for the coming months.
Exploitation Route We are examining the use of these materials as filter and barrier layers for embankments (flood defences). The Environment Agency has recently identified the need for research and investment in UK flood defence technology and we believe that our work aligns well with this need. Our partners are exploring the use of hydrophobic granular soils as subgrades for roads in Hong Kong, provided that the materials can be demonstrated to remain inert when placed in the environment. We are pursuing both avenues as targets for future funding.
Sectors Agriculture, Food and Drink,Construction,Environment,Transport

URL https://www.eng.ed.ac.uk/about/news/20210308/stem-britain-competition-success-dr-zeynep-karatza
 
Description EXCITE Network HY-VIS: Visualising water distribution and flow through hydrophobic particles
Amount € 10,000 (EUR)
Funding ID TNA C1 2022 47 
Organisation European Commission H2020 
Sector Public
Country Belgium
Start 06/2023 
End 08/2023
 
Description UKRI COVID-19 extension
Amount £10,049 (GBP)
Organisation University of Edinburgh 
Sector Academic/University
Country United Kingdom
Start 06/2021 
End 07/2021
 
Title Method to assess the contact angle of sessile drops on rough particle surfaces 
Description The sessile drop method (goniometry) is regularly used in surface chemistry to measure the contact angle of a fluid with a substrate. This method has been extended to measure the contact angle of droplets on surfaces comprised of multiple small particles (e.g. <10% of the size of the drople). Our research showed that if the particle surfaces are geometrically smooth, the contact angle is not affected by the volume of the droplet. However, if the particle surfaces comprise sharp edges, the measured contact angle increases with the droplet volume as the effect of the edges on the contact angle accumulates. Our method is to record the volume of the droplet as well as the contact angle and to determine the volume above which the contact angle becomes constant. 
Type Of Material Improvements to research infrastructure 
Year Produced 2021 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact The method has been adopted by our laboratory. The paper presenting the finding has already been cited by several authors investigating the contact angle of particulate materials, e.g. for calculations for fluid flow. 
 
Description Edinburgh City Council 
Organisation City of Edinburgh Council
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution We intend to establish testing sites in Scotland to examine the performance of geotechnical water sequestration structures constructed from hydrophobic soils. Our group approached the City of Edinburgh Council (Mr Stephen Knox) to explain the concept and secure testing sites. Sites will either be modified with the new material or instrumented without modification, to secure in situ data.
Collaborator Contribution The City of Edinburgh Council have agreed to provide access for up to four testing sites concerning water sequestration within their boundaries. The sites will be instrumented using grant funding but will be monitored and maintained by City of Edinburgh personnel, as part of their regular maintenance schemes. City of Edinburgh personnel (Mr Stephen Knox) dedicated time to review our proposals and to identify suitable testing sites. The estimated in-kind cost was calculated based on the value of the site, the time commitment of the monitoring personnel (for over several years) and Mr Knox's time in reviewing our proposals.
Impact NERC Discovery Science Grant application NE/W000962/1 to explore the use of satellite data imagery and in situ soil information to predict flooding. The project will make use of City of Edinburgh sites for in situ and remote monitoring.
Start Year 2020
 
Description HKUST 
Organisation The Hong Kong University of Science and Technology
Department HKUST Institute for Emerging Market Studies
Country Hong Kong 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution I have worked with Dr Anthony Leung on topics relating to hydrophobic soil research
Collaborator Contribution Dr Leung has contributed to research funding proposals and has provided comments on written work.
Impact NERC Discovery Science application (2020, unsuccessful) NERC Global Partnerships Seedcron Fund application (2021, unsuccessful) Multidisciplinary: granular mechanics, civil engineering
Start Year 2019
 
Description USDA 
Organisation U.S. Department of Agriculture USDA
Country United States 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Our research into hydrophobic soils allowed me to approach researchers at the USDA examining mechanisms behind the formation of debris flows after wildfires. We have worked with Dr Peter Robichaud to explore opportunities to forecast debris flow formation after wildfires
Collaborator Contribution Dr Robichaud has contributed to funding proposals
Impact NERC Discovery Science application (2020, unsuccessful) NERC Global Partnership Seedcord Fund application (2021, unsuccessful) Multidisciplinary: civil engineering, soil science
Start Year 2019
 
Description University of Hong Kong 
Organisation University of Hong Kong
Country Hong Kong 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Dr Sergio Lourenco was an international partner and mentor for this project. A PhD student visited HLU in 2018 for three weeks to learn their laboratory processes. I have reviewed work arising from the HKU group.
Collaborator Contribution The HKU group hosted my PhD student for three weeks, to familiarise her with their laboratory processes. The HKU group have recently asked me to be involved with an upcoming project to use hydrophobic granular soils in construction in Hong Kong.
Impact NERC Discovery Science application (2020, unsuccessful) NERC Global Partnerships Seedcron Fund application (2021, unsuccessful) Multidisciplinary: granular mechanics, civil engineering, soil science
Start Year 2019
 
Description University of Sheffield 
Organisation University of Sheffield
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution We approached Dr Elisabeth Bowman at The University of Sheffield to join us in the next iteration of this project. We treated spherical borosilicate glass beads with dichlorodimethylsilane to render them hydrophobic. The beads are roughly 3 mm in diameter to permit filtration testing (this is larger than the 0.1 mm diameter beads used in our hydromechanical testing programme). Owing to the change in diameter, we have adopted a new method to characterise the degree of hydrophobicity and its distribution over the bead's surface, based on drop shape analyses for curved surfaces. This work will contribute to an ongoing PhD project.
Collaborator Contribution Dr Bowman agreed to perform some pilot tests for us, to find an optically matched fluid for 3 mm borosilicate glass beads treated with dichlorodimethylsilane, to be able to perform filtration tests. This will support an upcoming EPSRC application.
Impact Submission to the NERC Discovery Science scheme (2020, unsuccessful) Submission to the NERC Global Partnerships Seedcorn Fund (2021, unsuccessful)
Start Year 2020
 
Description E-UNSAT 2020 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Dr Karatza presented at the European Unsaturated Soils Conference (E-UNSAT) 2020 (online due to COVID-19). Dr Karatza presented our findings on hydrophobic soils, which resulted in considerable interest from other geotechnical groups in the UK, specifically researchers at The University of Glasgow (Simon Wheeler) and Strathclyde University (Alessandro Tarantino).
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
URL https://eunsat2020.tecnico.ulisboa.pt/
 
Description GM3 Conference 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Dr Beckett presented to the GM3 From Micro to Macro conference in Dundee, December 2021. The accompanying paper was shortlisted for the best paper award and received second place.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description GM3 Workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Other audiences
Results and Impact Dr Karatza presented at the 17th GM3 Workshop: Geomechanics from Micro to Macro Workshop, New Castle, UK, 2020
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2020
 
Description Invited presentation - The University of Glasgow 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Dr Beckett was invited to present to the geomechanics research group at The University of Glasgow (UG) regarding the project's findings surrounding hydrophobic soils. The presentation sparked new interest in these materials and Dr Beckett will seek further collaborations with UG as the project matures
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
 
Description STEM for Britain 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Policymakers/politicians
Results and Impact Dr Karatza participated in the 2021 STEM for Britain competition. She has reached the top 10 finalists for Engineering and we are awaiting the outcome of the final round.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://stemforbritain.org.uk/engineering-exhibition/