Design rules for defect-tolerant photovoltaics
Lead Research Organisation:
Imperial College London
Department Name: Chemistry
Abstract
There is increasing demand for renewable energy, as highlighted by the UK government's aim of reducing carbon emissions by 80% before 2050. Solar power is the most promising renewable technology due to the enormous amount of energy the sun can provide. Most commercially available solar panels - based on crystalline silicon - are relatively efficient but expensive to manufacture. Accordingly, there is significant interest in alternative photovoltaic absorbers that are just as efficient but have lower materials and processing costs.
One route to finding novel solar absorbers is using quantum-mechanical computations. Indeed, many of the properties that determine photovoltaic performance - such as the strength of visible light absorption - can be calculated relatively easily. Many studies have taken advantage of this by searching for new solar absorbers based solely on electronic and optical properties. Unfortunately, this approach generally gives rise to many false positives where materials are predicted as efficient but perform poorly in practice. These shortcomings often result when the behaviour of crystal imperfections is not considered. These imperfections, called point-defects, play a crucial role in photovoltaic devices by limiting the maximum obtainable voltage and current. However, predicting the effects of defects on photovoltaic performance has so far proved tricky and has only been achieved for a select few systems.
By gaining an understanding of the fundamental factors that control defect formation we can design new materials that are resistant to their effects. Materials in which defects do not significantly affect photovoltaic performance are called "defect tolerant". Due to the difficulty of calculating the impact of defects, the structural and chemical properties that give rise to defect tolerance are not well understood. However, recent advances in computational workflow software means it is now possible to automate the calculation of complex properties. This project will develop an automatic computational workflow to determine whether a material is defect tolerant. By applying the workflow to many hundreds of materials and analysing the trends, we can extract the structure-property relationships that give rise to defect tolerance. We can also use this information to develop machine learning models for predicting the impact of defects without needing to perform any calculations. As many other applications also rely on the formation of point-defects - such as thermoelectrics and quantum computers - our calculated data will be of broad interest to the scientific community. We will therefore make the results available as an online database of computed defect properties.
An advanced understanding of the factors that govern defect tolerance will enable the rational design of the next generation of photovoltaic materials. Photovoltaics with reduced cost will facilitate the adoption of solar power and pave the way for a revolution in clean energy.
One route to finding novel solar absorbers is using quantum-mechanical computations. Indeed, many of the properties that determine photovoltaic performance - such as the strength of visible light absorption - can be calculated relatively easily. Many studies have taken advantage of this by searching for new solar absorbers based solely on electronic and optical properties. Unfortunately, this approach generally gives rise to many false positives where materials are predicted as efficient but perform poorly in practice. These shortcomings often result when the behaviour of crystal imperfections is not considered. These imperfections, called point-defects, play a crucial role in photovoltaic devices by limiting the maximum obtainable voltage and current. However, predicting the effects of defects on photovoltaic performance has so far proved tricky and has only been achieved for a select few systems.
By gaining an understanding of the fundamental factors that control defect formation we can design new materials that are resistant to their effects. Materials in which defects do not significantly affect photovoltaic performance are called "defect tolerant". Due to the difficulty of calculating the impact of defects, the structural and chemical properties that give rise to defect tolerance are not well understood. However, recent advances in computational workflow software means it is now possible to automate the calculation of complex properties. This project will develop an automatic computational workflow to determine whether a material is defect tolerant. By applying the workflow to many hundreds of materials and analysing the trends, we can extract the structure-property relationships that give rise to defect tolerance. We can also use this information to develop machine learning models for predicting the impact of defects without needing to perform any calculations. As many other applications also rely on the formation of point-defects - such as thermoelectrics and quantum computers - our calculated data will be of broad interest to the scientific community. We will therefore make the results available as an online database of computed defect properties.
An advanced understanding of the factors that govern defect tolerance will enable the rational design of the next generation of photovoltaic materials. Photovoltaics with reduced cost will facilitate the adoption of solar power and pave the way for a revolution in clean energy.
Planned Impact
This project aims to uncover the design rules that enable highly efficient photovoltaic devices. In particular, the behaviour of defects at typical device operating conductions - i.e., under illumination - is severally understudied. An understanding of these fundamental factors may enable the next generation of breakthrough materials that are both cheaper and more efficient. This work will benefit photovoltaics researchers by directing the focus of future research towards more optimal materials for solar applications. Advances in this area may also benefit researchers of more established solar technologies, such as crystalline silicon devices. These benefits will be felt both in the UK (through the SUPERGEN Supersolar and Superfuel networks) and abroad, due to the international nature and global impact of photovoltaics research. In addition, defect properties are fundamentally important for many other emerging applications, including thermoelectrics, batteries, and quantum computing. A deeper understanding of the factors that control defect formation will therefore enormously benefit researchers across numerous disciplines and may lead to advances outside the field of photovoltaics.
According to a recent study by the Energy Watch Group, solar power could provide 70% of the world's total energy by 2050. In the UK alone, the installed capacity of photovoltaics is expected to almost triple in the next ten years, as predicted by the 2019 Solar Commission. Accordingly, there are increasing scientific and industrial efforts to achieve the cost-competitiveness needed for utility scale solar power generation. Greater use of renewable technologies will minimise the environmental impact of energy use and alleviate the UK's reliance on energy imports, thereby benefiting many consumers across the UK.
Solar power is an enormous and rapidly expanding industry - worth £40 billion in 2018 and expected to rise to over £200 billion by 2026. Silicon based solar panels currently dominate the market despite their relatively high processing costs. The UK is home to several world-leading companies attempting to find alternative photovoltaic materials with increased cost-competitiveness, including Oxford PV the largest global developer of commercial perovskite devices. As part of this project, I will release open-source machine learning models to predict defect tolerance that can be employed by industry for rapid prototyping of novel materials. Furthermore, my results may enable the optimisation of the synthesis conditions of existing materials. Contributing to a vibrant research and development process will allow the UK to maintain a competitive advantage over its international competitors.
According to a recent study by the Energy Watch Group, solar power could provide 70% of the world's total energy by 2050. In the UK alone, the installed capacity of photovoltaics is expected to almost triple in the next ten years, as predicted by the 2019 Solar Commission. Accordingly, there are increasing scientific and industrial efforts to achieve the cost-competitiveness needed for utility scale solar power generation. Greater use of renewable technologies will minimise the environmental impact of energy use and alleviate the UK's reliance on energy imports, thereby benefiting many consumers across the UK.
Solar power is an enormous and rapidly expanding industry - worth £40 billion in 2018 and expected to rise to over £200 billion by 2026. Silicon based solar panels currently dominate the market despite their relatively high processing costs. The UK is home to several world-leading companies attempting to find alternative photovoltaic materials with increased cost-competitiveness, including Oxford PV the largest global developer of commercial perovskite devices. As part of this project, I will release open-source machine learning models to predict defect tolerance that can be employed by industry for rapid prototyping of novel materials. Furthermore, my results may enable the optimisation of the synthesis conditions of existing materials. Contributing to a vibrant research and development process will allow the UK to maintain a competitive advantage over its international competitors.
People |
ORCID iD |
| Alexander Ganose (Principal Investigator / Fellow) |
Publications
Blakesley J
(2024)
Roadmap on established and emerging photovoltaics for sustainable energy conversion
in Journal of Physics: Energy
Ganose AM
(2022)
The defect challenge of wide-bandgap semiconductors for photovoltaics and beyond.
in Nature communications
Huang J
(2023)
Room-temperature stacking disorder in layered covalent-organic frameworks from machine-learning force fields.
in Materials horizons
Huang J
(2022)
Band gap opening from displacive instabilities in layered covalent-organic frameworks
in Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Lin Z
(2024)
Insights from experiment and machine learning for enhanced TiO 2 coated glazing for photocatalytic NO x remediation
in Journal of Materials Chemistry A
Lou Y
(2025)
Discovery of highly anisotropic dielectric crystals with equivariant graph neural networks.
in Faraday discussions
Lu Y
(2024)
Hydrogenated V2O5 with Improved Optical and Electrochemical Activities for Photo-Accelerated Lithium-Ion Batteries.
in Small (Weinheim an der Bergstrasse, Germany)
Mosquera-Lois I
(2024)
Machine-learning structural reconstructions for accelerated point defect calculations
in npj Computational Materials
| Description | We have developed a new approach for understanding defect properties using machine learning. This approach enables the rapid screening of defects in photovoltaic materials at low computational cost. In this way, this tool can be used to accelerate the search for photovoltaic absorbers with high efficiency, and to diagnose performance limitations of existing materials. |
| Exploitation Route | We have developed a new approach that can be used by others beyond the field of photovoltaics. Defects are important for many technological applications and therefore this approach will be useful for the broad field of materials discovery and optimisation. |
| Sectors | Electronics Energy |
| Description | The software developed in this work, atomate2 and jobflow, has been adopted by industrial partners including Microsoft Research, Matgenix, BASF, Umicore. |
| First Year Of Impact | 2024 |
| Sector | Chemicals,Electronics,Energy |
| Impact Types | Economic |
| Title | Forbidden Transitions |
| Description | High-throughput computed optical and electronic properties across a set of ~18,000 semiconductors. |
| Type Of Material | Database/Collection of data |
| Year Produced | 2023 |
| Provided To Others? | Yes |
| URL | https://www.osti.gov/servlets/purl/1996545/ |
| Title | atomate2 |
| Description | Atomate2 is a free, open-source software for performing complex materials science workflows using simple Python functions. Features of atomate2 include - It is built on open-source libraries: pymatgen, custodian, jobflow, and FireWorks. - A library of "standard" workflows to compute a wide variety of desired materials properties. - The ability scale from a single material, to 100 materials, or 100,000 materials. - Easy routes to modifying and chaining workflows together. - It can build large databases of output properties that you can query, analyze, and share in a systematic way. - It automatically keeps meticulous records of jobs, their directories, runtime parameters, and more. |
| Type Of Technology | Software |
| Year Produced | 2022 |
| Open Source License? | Yes |
| Impact | This software has been used to automate the calculation of over 8,000 materials properties. These include a database calculations of finite temperature properties of 50 solar absorbers which will be released in a publication and dataset. Atomate2 is now being used to power the Materials Project website (https://materialsproject.org) and is being used across academia (Berkeley, Princeton, UC Louvain, Imperial, UCL, Bundesamt für Migration und Flüchtlinge) and industry. |
| URL | https://materialsproject.github.io/atomate2/ |
| Title | jobflow |
| Description | Jobflow is a free, open-source library for writing and executing workflows on computing resources. Complex workflows can be defined using simple python functions and executed locally or on arbitrary computing resources using the FireWorks workflow manager. Some features that distinguish jobflow are dynamic workflows, easy compositing and connecting of workflows, and the ability to store workflow outputs across multiple databases. Jobflow has been used to automate first-principles calculations of materials properties. |
| Type Of Technology | Software |
| Year Produced | 2022 |
| Open Source License? | Yes |
| Impact | Jobflow is now used to power the following open-source python libraries for computational materials science workflows: - atomate2: https://github.com/materialsproject/atomate2 - reaction-network: https://github.com/GENESIS-EFRC/reaction-network - NanoParticleTools: https://github.com/BlauGroup/NanoParticleTools - quacc: https://github.com/arosen93/quacc |
| URL | https://github.com/materialsproject/jobflow |
| Description | ML Autumn School |
| Form Of Engagement Activity | Participation in an activity, workshop or similar |
| Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
| Geographic Reach | National |
| Primary Audience | Postgraduate students |
| Results and Impact | The machine learning for materials workshop was run by the Physical Sciences Data Infrastructure (PSDI) initiative in collaboration with PSDS, AI4SD, STFC-SCD and CCP5.This training was targeted towards PhD students, in particular those in the Materials and Molecular Simulations field. The aim of this training was to introduce attendees to the latest methods of machine learning applied to atomistic simulation of materials. This training will encompassed a number of talks and practical sessions, focusing on the basics of machine learning, machine learning interatomic potentials and graph neural networks. There was also be the opportunity for attendees to present a poster on their work. |
| Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2023 |
| URL | https://www.psdi.ac.uk/event/machine-learning-autumn-school-2023/ |