Improved face-worn PPE designs for use by the public and professionals to reduce audio-visual communication difficulties

Lead Research Organisation: University of Manchester
Department Name: School of Health Sciences

Abstract

To reduce the transmission of COVID-19, personal protective equipment (PPE) is
required. PPE to protect the eyes, nose and mouth comprises face masks and transparent
visors. These range from a simple covering made from domestic fabrics for use by the
public, to FFP3/N99 rated air filters and wrap-around face visors in care settings. All these
PPE styles make spoken and signed communication harder. Everyone, not just the
hearing impaired, will struggle to understand in real-world conditions and background
sounds. This will result in increased listening effort, stress, communication errors and
potentially social withdrawal. Articles published in May 2020 by the PI and his group
leader in a professional journal
(https://www.entandaudiologynews.com/features/audiology-features/post/the-challenges-
of-facemasks-for-people-with-hearing-loss) produced over 100 responses from anxious
adults, parents, public and professionals.
Both acoustic and visual cues are reduced by face coverings: (i) acoustic : the high frequencies of
the sound are attenuated, leading to a "muffled" perception (ii) visual : sight of the talker's mouth
movements that can be used by all listeners to supplement the muffling of speech and (iii) visual :
full-facial expressions that convey emotions, supplement lip-reading and are essential
components of (the non-acoustic) British Sign Language (BSL).
Employing user surveys, fabrication, and testing, this project will produce validated examples of
facemask and visor designs that preserve acoustic and visual cues thereby offering less effortful
communication in a variety of usage scenarios. It brings together acousticians, audiologists,
material scientists, and users to tackle an urgent problem that affects everyone now, and will also
outlast the current pandemic.

Publications

10 25 50
publication icon
Cox TJ (2022) Improving the measurement and acoustic performance of transparent face masks and shields. in The Journal of the Acoustical Society of America

publication icon
Jackson I (2024) The impact of face coverings on audio-visual contributions to communication with conversational speech in Cognitive Research: Principles and Implications

 
Description The first aim of the project was to develop a facemask for the general public that was both acoustically and optically "near-transparent". This means that, as well as not muffling the sound of the talker, a clear view of the mouth and surrounding area of the face is provided. During communication, both spoken and emotional, this area of the face is important to enable more relaxed communication for both talker and listener.
We developed a mask with acoustic performance better than the routinely used surgical mask, but was also transparent.
We have produced a video as well as "how to assemble" documents to enable a "make-at-home" approach.
We incoporated the core feature of the mask into a face shield (visor) in order to improve acoustic transmission.
We produced a demonstrator mask of how this acousti-optic feature could also be combined with a novel filtration material developed in Manchester, in order to produce a mask capable of a very high standard of filtration.
We sought feedback from Deaf and hearing-impaired users on the effectiveness of the general-public mask design, and used this to refine the final version.
Exploitation Route We have produced a "proof-of-concept" and hope to engage with industry to look at upscaling the manufacture from the "make-at-home" concept.
The general design will have a use far beyond that of COVID since we have identified multiple use cases where the features enable better communication, eg in operating theatres, dental surgeries, health & safety.
Sectors Healthcare

 
Description Apart from previously approaching potential manufacturers in UK, we have approached a partner in Singapore for potential manufacture, a process that is underway, although very slow. We have also contacted Department of Health and Social Care to inform them of the outputs so that they can create contact with any interested manufacturers. given that this was a COVID grant, all outputs had to be open source. We published a "how-to-make" guide at https://hub.salford.ac.uk/sirc-acoustics/facemask-with-improved-communication/ Hence there may be usages of which we are not aware.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Healthcare
 
Title Improving the measurement and acoustic performance of transparent face masks and shields 
Description This is the raw measured data that is analysed and presented in: T. J. Cox , G. Dodgson, L. Harris, E. Perugia, M. A. Stone, M. Walsh, Improving the measurement and acoustic performance of transparent face masks and shields, Journal of the Acoustical Society of America, 2022.Included:* Impulse responses for a head and torso with mouth simulator measured at a microphone 1m away, with and without a variety of face masks and shields.* Recordings of four talkers reciting prose with and without various face masks to a microphone 1m away.* Laser Doppler vibrometer measurements of various face masks.The "descriptions of files.docx" describes the contents of the zip archives.The file mask_construction_instructions_templates.pdf includes templates and instructions for making the final mask design. 
Type Of Material Database/Collection of data 
Year Produced 2022 
Provided To Others? Yes  
Impact Too early to quantify. 
URL https://salford.figshare.com/articles/dataset/Improving_the_measurement_and_acoustic_performance_of_...
 
Title Facemask with improved communication 
Description This product is in the form of a "how-to-make" web page incorporating a demonstration video as well as templates in pdf format. 
Type Of Technology New/Improved Technique/Technology 
Year Produced 2022 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact None observed so far. Being an open source output, it is quite likely to have been used without our being contacted. , 
URL https://hub.salford.ac.uk/sirc-acoustics/facemask-with-improved-communication/
 
Description Press release to national and international news outlets 
Form Of Engagement Activity A press release, press conference or response to a media enquiry/interview
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Media (as a channel to the public)
Results and Impact At the end of June 2022, University of Manchester/Manchester Biomedical Research Centre sourced a press release on the grant output, including a link to an open-source design package.
Press release picked up by at least :
(a) national : GBNews, BBC Radio 4 science program (interview of a senior Co-Investigator on this grant).
(b) international : myscience.org website
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://www.manchesterbrc.nihr.ac.uk/news-and-events/speech-friendly-face-mask-could-end-frustration...