Benchmarking Quantum Advantage
Lead Research Organisation:
University of Edinburgh
Department Name: Sch of Informatics
Abstract
Quantum computing promises to revolutionise our capability to solve hard problems which could incur great economic and societal impact. Expected applications of quantum algorithms range from deciphering cryptographic protocols, to solving complex optimization problems in logistics and finance, and the simulation of quantum systems with direct applications to materials science and drug discovery, among many others.
To fulfil this potential, we need to understand for which problems quantum computation provides a significant advantage over currently existing computing technologies and what are the requirement to achieve the potential of quantum computing, a question of paramount importance for the future of quantum computation. It is therefore not surprising that one of the core missions of the recently created National Quantum Computing Center (NQCC) is to understand the technology readiness and systems performance on the pathway to delivering fully fault tolerant error corrected quantum computing.
The mission of our "Benchmarking quantum advantage" project is to provide our stakeholders with easy to deploy quantum advantage benchmarking techniques that will allow them to rigorously assess the performance and readiness of the technology. To achieve our goal, we will build upon recent results and ongoing research by the principal investigator, developing a unified theoretical framework that allows the design of rigorous quantum advantage benchmarking tools for large families of problems in classical optimization, with applications in logistic and finance, together with quantum optimization problems, with applications in chemistry and material science. Our framework will not only allow for benchmarking existing devices and algorithms but will also allow for reliable predictions of the performance of future quantum computing architectures, applicable from todays' noisy intermediate-scale quantum NISQ hardware all the way to fault-tolerance quantum computers.
Our quantum advantage benchmarking approach has two key advantages. Firstly, as opposed to currently existing approaches, it does not need the direct simulation of the quantum circuits but relies on fundamental trade-offs between the quality of the solution and the errors accumulated along the computation. Secondly, the effects of error are crucially considered and are central to the framework. By the end of the project, we aim to have built a unified framework that would allow for the design of problem-tailored benchmarking tests that are easy to implement, scalable, and require little quantum computing expertise for their use, making them ideal for its adoption among end-user with little quantum-awareness.
We believe that our "Benchmarking quantum advantage" project will allow the NQCC to succeed on its mission towards providing guidance on technological readiness and system performance on solving real-world problems. Our project, combined with the partnership between NQCC and the "Quantum Software Lab" at the School of Informatics in the University of Edinburgh and the alignment of our project objectives with the NQCC's readiness program, SparQ, is the ideal setting to deliver reliable and rigorous quantum advantage benchmarking tools to all our stakeholders within the quantum computing ecosystem.
To fulfil this potential, we need to understand for which problems quantum computation provides a significant advantage over currently existing computing technologies and what are the requirement to achieve the potential of quantum computing, a question of paramount importance for the future of quantum computation. It is therefore not surprising that one of the core missions of the recently created National Quantum Computing Center (NQCC) is to understand the technology readiness and systems performance on the pathway to delivering fully fault tolerant error corrected quantum computing.
The mission of our "Benchmarking quantum advantage" project is to provide our stakeholders with easy to deploy quantum advantage benchmarking techniques that will allow them to rigorously assess the performance and readiness of the technology. To achieve our goal, we will build upon recent results and ongoing research by the principal investigator, developing a unified theoretical framework that allows the design of rigorous quantum advantage benchmarking tools for large families of problems in classical optimization, with applications in logistic and finance, together with quantum optimization problems, with applications in chemistry and material science. Our framework will not only allow for benchmarking existing devices and algorithms but will also allow for reliable predictions of the performance of future quantum computing architectures, applicable from todays' noisy intermediate-scale quantum NISQ hardware all the way to fault-tolerance quantum computers.
Our quantum advantage benchmarking approach has two key advantages. Firstly, as opposed to currently existing approaches, it does not need the direct simulation of the quantum circuits but relies on fundamental trade-offs between the quality of the solution and the errors accumulated along the computation. Secondly, the effects of error are crucially considered and are central to the framework. By the end of the project, we aim to have built a unified framework that would allow for the design of problem-tailored benchmarking tests that are easy to implement, scalable, and require little quantum computing expertise for their use, making them ideal for its adoption among end-user with little quantum-awareness.
We believe that our "Benchmarking quantum advantage" project will allow the NQCC to succeed on its mission towards providing guidance on technological readiness and system performance on solving real-world problems. Our project, combined with the partnership between NQCC and the "Quantum Software Lab" at the School of Informatics in the University of Edinburgh and the alignment of our project objectives with the NQCC's readiness program, SparQ, is the ideal setting to deliver reliable and rigorous quantum advantage benchmarking tools to all our stakeholders within the quantum computing ecosystem.
Organisations
Publications

Morstyn T
(2024)
Opportunities for quantum computing within net-zero power system optimization
in Joule
Description | We have developed a framework to benchmark the potential of a quantum processing unit to provide quantum advantage for optimisation problems, crucial in logistic and finance, but that also expand to their quantum analogue problem of finding the groundstate of an Hamiltonian, a key problem in chemistry and material science. We do so by connecting two concepts: firstly, developing techniques to experimentally estimate how the accumulation of errors increases the entropy of the system and building heuristic predictive models based on those results; Secondly, we have developed theoretical tools to connect how the entropy accumulation relates to the degradation of the quality of solution of our problem of interest. |
Exploitation Route | The technique could be used by end-user or quantum hardware practitioner or vendors to characterise the quality of a quantum device and asses its capability to solve a given problem. From the end-user side it does not need to have a deep understanding of quantum computation but rather adapt a mathematical framework to their problem of interest. It could become a standard to predict the capability of current and future quantum hardware platforms. |
Sectors | Aerospace Defence and Marine Chemicals Digital/Communication/Information Technologies (including Software) Energy Financial Services and Management Consultancy Government Democracy and Justice Manufacturing including Industrial Biotechology Pharmaceuticals and Medical Biotechnology Transport |
URL | https://github.com/quantumsoftwarelab/Entropy_Benchmarking |
Description | Kenza Hamman, postdoc working in this project has secured funding to do a secondment at the National Quantum Computing Center (NQCC), to transfer the know-how acquired during this project on benchmarking quantum advantage. This will result in opportunities to implement our benchmarking techniques in the NQCC Testbeds but also with their support disseminate them among end-user and members of the quantum computing ecosystem. |
First Year Of Impact | 2025 |
Sector | Other |
Impact Types | Policy & public services |
Description | PV241 Standardized Benchmarking for UK Quantum Computing Testbeds |
Amount | £50,000 (GBP) |
Funding ID | University of Edinburgh Project ID: 14278069 |
Organisation | Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) |
Sector | Public |
Country | United Kingdom |
Start | 03/2025 |
End | 12/2025 |
Description | Workshop at National Quantum Computing Cewnter |
Form Of Engagement Activity | A formal working group, expert panel or dialogue |
Part Of Official Scheme? | No |
Geographic Reach | National |
Primary Audience | Professional Practitioners |
Results and Impact | This was a workshop organised between the quantum Software Lab (QSL) we belong to and the National Quantum Computing Center with how QSL has an MoU. different topics of collaboration were discussed among them the work done in the Benchmarking Quantum Advantage project. |
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity | 2024 |