Towards In-Combustion-Event Feedback (ICEF) Control by Laser Ignition

Lead Research Organisation: University of Liverpool
Department Name: Centre for Materials and Structures

Abstract

The project seeks to explore the science of laser ignition (LI) based control & sensing of combustion, leading towards In-Combustion-Event Feedback (ICEF) control in future internal combustion (IC) engines. The main objectives are to pursue optimisation of LI & sensing for next generation engine configurations, to provide knowledge to extend the stratified GDI combustion envelope by cycle-to-cycle variation reduction, to enhance fuel efficiency by up to 20% & progress towards large-scale engine NOX & HC emissions reduction. The work will explore dynamically varying temporal & spatial multi-point LI, rapid real-time optical sensing of combustion signatures and robust feedback control strategies for multi-point ICEF. It is widely accepted that the IC engine will continue to be the main vehicle power plant over the next 10-15 years, before significant displacement by other technologies (such as fuel cell based plant) takes place. To meet environmental legislation requirements, automotive manufactures continue to address two critical aspects of engine performance: fuel economy & exhaust gas emissions. New engines are becoming increasingly complex, with advanced combustion mechanisms that burn an increasing range of fuels to meet future goals on performance, fuel economy and emissions. In the spark-ignition (SI) engine, the spark plug has remained largely unchanged since its invention and limits the potential for improving efficiency due to its poor ability to ignite highly dilute air-fuel mixtures. Also vital to optimising engine performance is the sensing & diagnostics for high speed feedback control, but accurate real-time in-cylinder sensing is currently prohibitively expensive. LI offers several potential solutions, including the ability to ignite highly dilute air-fuel mixtures. Due to recent laser technology advances, the range of combustion control parameters can now be widened to include laser wavelength, pulse duration, spatial & temporal optical energy distribution, single & multiple ignition events. The opportunity now exists to explore how the dynamic selection of these variables can be optimised for more efficient and cleaner combustion over the widest range of engine operating conditions. The holistic systems approach will include making use of a self-cleaned optical pathway for both LI & feedback sensing purposes, to allow information-rich monitoring and control of combustion to be explored. An extensive programme is needed to establish basic engineering science for highly optimised combustion control by LI to suit specific engine configurations, operating conditions and fuel types. The key research hypothesis is that LI is a viable route to active feedback control of combustion, both cycle-by-cycle & ultimately within the combustion event, by multi-point / event actuation & delay-free self-cleaning laser optic virtual sensing. As well as progress towards the goal of full ICEF control, it will provide shorter term exploitation potential for in cycle-by-cycle combustion feedback control. The research methods to be adopted comprise novel work in: a/ the study of LI mechanisms for combustion control by high-speed ICEF, derived from laser wavelength tuning & spatially & temporally varied energy delivery in multiple foci to suit injection mode, absorption & combustion properties of fuel mixtures; b/ simultaneous use of a self-cleaned optical pathway for real-time in-event light signature capture from LI; c/ the use of sensor data & LI mechanisms for robust optimised ICEF control; d/the use of SLMs as a means to multipoint LI; e/ the optimisation of combustion control using Direct Numerical Simulation (DNS) studies. Use of the team's existing engine control facilities & liaison with FMC will allow study of rapid feedback control & its associated computer control issues, conducted through instrumented powertrain control experiments, with control strategies optimised via computational combustion research.

Planned Impact

The principal beneficiaries of the research will be the academic and industrial partners of the project. The Laser Group and Powertrain Engineering Group in the School of Engineering at the University of Liverpool (UoL) are currently partnered on laser ignition (LI) research together with Ford Motor Company (FMC). FMC is a global developer and manufacturer of automotive vehicles and has leading internal combustion (IC) engine and associated powertrain technology development at its sites in the UK (Dunton), Germany and the United States. External industry beneficiaries will include, in powertrain engineering, a number of existing UK and Europe based developers of IC engines and related components, sub-systems and test equipment. In photonics, several UK and international laser manufacturers are currently developing solid state pulsed lasers as part of their product range. UK laser systems integrators have expertise in combining laser and optics technology with high precision machinery and computer control. Many leading developers of laser optics for delivery, modulation and sensing are currently collaborating with the Laser Group on materials processing applications. Further potential beneficiaries exist in the powertrain technology value chain. External academic beneficiaries will include UK research groups currently researching IC engine combustion and fuel systems including those at Loughborough University (led by Prof R Stobart), University of Nottingham (led by Prof P Shayler) and University College London (Prof N Ladommatos et al). Many international groups will benefit from dissemination of the research into the wider academic community, including the MIT Sloan Automotive Laboratory (led by Prof J Heywood) in the US, which is supported by FMC.How they will benefit from this research:The LI research team at the UoL will benefit from the opportunity to pursue new research in combustion control, enabled by the proposed project funds to enhance and make full use of the experimental facilities currently established with the support of FMC, together with the research staff and student resource. LI is an interesting research area with potential for interdisciplinary study and will lead to several high quality academic publications. The project will establish new research in laser applications, through the use of specially modulated pulsed lasers to explore laser ignition mechanisms and optical sensing for combustion control. FMC will benefit from access to a new pool of knowledge aimed at controlled combustion by LI, for competitive advantage by improved engine performance and emissions. Both parties would benefit from any successful joint patent applications, to be exploited through future licensing and industrial scaling projects. The successful outcome of the project will result in a significant global market for R&D and production level LI systems in the future, together with associated laser device and optics. Externally, the project will benefit the powertrain engineering sector by informing their work on future design of engines and associated components and sub-systems, including feedback control through sensor development and computer control strategies. Laser source and system developers will benefit from the application of high energy pulsed lasers in a new engineering research area and gain knowledge of the future capabilities required for their products. Laser system integrators will be well-placed to leverage knowledge gained from the research and translate this into prototype LI system development in the future. The UK will then have capability to build LI systems, through industrial scaling and device miniaturization. The project, if successful, will have significant socio-economic impact for the wider community, including: lower fuel consumption and reduced noxious emissions in IC engines; helping UK government to reduce/meet UK carbon footprint targets; job creation in a range of UK engineering sectors.

Publications

10 25 50

publication icon
Patel D (2015) Effects of Energy Deposition Characteristics on Localised Forced Ignition of Homogeneous Mixtures in International Journal of Spray and Combustion Dynamics

publication icon
Page V (2015) Calibration of Ignition Location and Pulse Energy in the Laser Ignited Engine in International Journal of Powertrains (IJPT)

 
Description We have discovered that it is possible to influence and control the combustion of fuel-air mixture in an automobile engine by methods for flexible delivery of laser light in terms of spatial (3D) position and multiple event timing. The most significant achievements from the award have been the advances in knowledge of the effect of single and multiple laser ignition events on engine combustion performance, from both experimental and simulation perspectives. These have enabled initial approaches to advanced control and optimisation of automobile engine ignition to be explored through laser ignition and in-combustion event feedback principles. This includes a dual pulse predictive 'fire/no fire' approach to minimising variations in cycle to cycle cylinder pressure. Novel optical techniques for 3D spatial distribution of multiple spark events, based on spatial light modulator technology, have been studied and successfully demonstrated. The results from the work show not only that superior flexibility of energy deposition achieved by the laser ignition techniques can improve combustion control; they also point to where the potential benefits in engine performance can be realised and verified practically in the future using laser ignition technology.
Exploitation Route Engine design teams in industry partner Ford Motor Company are currently being appraised of the findings and potential benefits and considering how to take them forward. Jaguar Land Rover have also expressed interest in the technology and reported findings. A pan-European R&D consortium has been formed to work collaboratively on the complementary aspects of laser source, system components and packaging for future laser ignition systems in a range of industry applications. We anticipate that the new knowledge gained from the project work will benefit the powertrain engineering sector by informing their work on future design of engines and associated components and sub-systems, including feedback control through sensor development and computer control strategies. Laser source and system developers will benefit from the successes of applying high energy pulsed lasers in a new engineering research area and knowledge gained of the future capabilities required for their products. Laser system integrators will be well-placed to leverage knowledge gained from the research and translate this into prototype LI system development in the future. The UK will then have capability to build LI systems, through industrial scaling and device miniaturization. We thus envisage economic and social benefits from these developments, as well as much needed environmental benefits of improved engine performance from in-event feedback controlled laser ignition. The insight gained into optical techniques for multi-point, multi-event delivery of laser energy can be taken forward by academia and industry in a number of disciplines including laser based diagnostics, materials processing and high throughput manufacture, and electro-optic communications. The University of Lincoln, working with Siemens UK, have followed the research of the TICEF award team and are now carrying out R&D in laser ignition and diagnostics for application in co-generation gas turbines. Other UK organisations now working with Liverpool through the EU LASIG-TWIN project include the ORC, University of Southampton (on optical fibres for high power laser beam delivery for laser ignition) and Niro Engineering (large-scale co-generation and marine engine design), while in Germany DLR (working with the ESA) are developing laser ignition devices for rocket engine applications. These emerging application areas will provide a platform for taking forward our findings.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Transport

 
Description The findings from the research are being evaluated by partners and contacts the private sector, in particular by supporters Ford Motor Company, to inform their design teams of the potential opportunities and benefits of laser ignition in future engine developments. In comparison to other advanced engine technologies that FMC have been assessing, laser ignition is seen as far simpler to implement in order to target urgently required improvements in engine efficiency and reduced noxious emissions to address forthcoming strict legislated requirements of motor manufacturers. Jaguar Land Rover (UK) contacts have also been appraised of the key reported findings of the project and have expressed an initial interest in supporting future activity to take this work forward through engine system developments. One of the Liverpool team PDRAs has now been appointed by JLR following completion of the project, hence takes forward key expertise and knowledge of the laser ignition research directly into industry. The research and its findings have encouraged new research activity in other sectors, a key example being research on laser ignition for land based turbines now being undertaken by a former PhD of the Liverpool team at University of Lincoln with the support of Siemens. A pan-European consortium has been established within a EU H2020 project 'LASIG-TWIN', awarded to Professor Dearden at the University of Liverpool plus 4 other partners, to pursue miniaturisation of laser ignition systems for a range of future applications. From this follow-on project, it has emerged that the strongest interest and short term potential for laser ignition systems is in the space sector, for ignition / re-ignition of rocket engines. Here, such laser ignition systems based on compact and energy efficient solid-state technology also enable multiple engine ignition operation for future re-usable launcher concepts. The optical techniques researched in the project, on spatial light modulation, are being pursued in continuing research and followed up by other academic institutions. PhD completion of Dr Elliott Lyon (Title: Optical Techniques for Multi-point and Variable Wavelength Laser Ignition). PhD completion of Dr Dipal Patel (Title: Fundamental investigation of localised forced ignition in turbulent homogeneous and stratified mixtures: A Direct Numerical Simulation analysis). Dr Patel has since been appointed as an assistant professor at the University of Ontario. PhD completion of Dr Vincent Page (Title: The Laser Ignition and the In Combustion Event Feedback of Internal Combustion Engines). Dr Page has since been appointed as PDRA at the University of Liverpool (working on autonomous systems control). A follow on grant has been awarded to Professor Chakraborty in 2017: UK-Gulf Institutional Links 2016 grant: A combined experimental and numerical investigation of ignition probability of turbulent inhomogeneous biogas-air mixtures. Dr Hua Cheng (PDRA on the grant) is now employed by Jaguar Land Rover in the UK (working on engine / powertrain development). Dr Zheng Kuang worked at Advanced Laser Technology Ltd (working on laser systems and applications development), before then taking up an academic post in China (working on laser technology) due to family circumstances.
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Manufacturing, including Industrial Biotechology,Transport,Other
 
Description H2020-TWINN-2015
Amount £125,566 (GBP)
Funding ID 691688 
Organisation European Commission 
Sector Public
Country European Union (EU)
Start 01/2016 
End 12/2018
 
Description UK-Gulf Institutional Links 2016 grant: A combined experimental and numerical investigation of ignition probability of turbulent inhomogeneous biogas-air mixtures
Amount £400,000 (GBP)
Organisation Department for Business, Energy & Industrial Strategy 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 03/2017 
End 02/2019
 
Description Laser Ignition - A Twinning Collaboration for Frontier Research in Eco-Friendly Fuel-Saving Combustion (LASIG-TWIN) 
Organisation Fraunhofer Society
Department Fraunhofer Institute for Applied Optics and Precision Engineering
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Expertise and facilities for research in laser ignition of automobile engines
Collaborator Contribution Expertise and facilities for research on laser / plasma source; laser ignition and diagnostics in aero engines; engine diagnostics; precision engineering in optics, miniaturisation and packaging.
Impact Multi-disciplinary collaboration on frontier research and training on system and component developments for future laser ignition applications.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Laser Ignition - A Twinning Collaboration for Frontier Research in Eco-Friendly Fuel-Saving Combustion (LASIG-TWIN) 
Organisation National Center for Scientific Research (Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique CNRS)
Country France 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Expertise and facilities for research in laser ignition of automobile engines
Collaborator Contribution Expertise and facilities for research on laser / plasma source; laser ignition and diagnostics in aero engines; engine diagnostics; precision engineering in optics, miniaturisation and packaging.
Impact Multi-disciplinary collaboration on frontier research and training on system and component developments for future laser ignition applications.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Laser Ignition - A Twinning Collaboration for Frontier Research in Eco-Friendly Fuel-Saving Combustion (LASIG-TWIN) 
Organisation National Institute for Laser Plasma and Radiation Physics, Bucharest
Country Hungary 
Sector Public 
PI Contribution Expertise and facilities for research in laser ignition of automobile engines
Collaborator Contribution Expertise and facilities for research on laser / plasma source; laser ignition and diagnostics in aero engines; engine diagnostics; precision engineering in optics, miniaturisation and packaging.
Impact Multi-disciplinary collaboration on frontier research and training on system and component developments for future laser ignition applications.
Start Year 2015
 
Description Laser Ignition - A Twinning Collaboration for Frontier Research in Eco-Friendly Fuel-Saving Combustion (LASIG-TWIN) 
Organisation University of Bayreuth
Country Germany 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Expertise and facilities for research in laser ignition of automobile engines
Collaborator Contribution Expertise and facilities for research on laser / plasma source; laser ignition and diagnostics in aero engines; engine diagnostics; precision engineering in optics, miniaturisation and packaging.
Impact Multi-disciplinary collaboration on frontier research and training on system and component developments for future laser ignition applications.
Start Year 2015