Plasma-actuator controlled turbulent jets

Lead Research Organisation: Imperial College London
Department Name: Aeronautics

Abstract

Aeronautics and air transport is a vital sector of our society and economy. Aviation currently accounts for about 2% of human-induced CO2 emissions with more than 3.12 billion passengers and 48 million tons of freight worldwide last year with an average of more than 100,000 flights every day. Worldwide traffic is predicted to grow at a rate of 4% to 5% per year for the next 30 years. It simply means that more than 16 billion passengers and 25 million flights are expected in 2050. Aviation will have to find ways to meet the growing demand for air transport whilst reducing its environmental impact, specifically the level of noise and of carbon emissions. Innovative solutions are also needed to deal with fuel consumption so that aviation does not become increasingly dependent on more and more expensive energy sources. It is clear that it requires a significant step change in the technologies of future aircraft.

In recent years, the development of devices known as plasma actuators has advanced the promise of controlling flows in new ways that increase lift, reduce drag and improve aerodynamic efficiencies, advances that may lead to safer, more efficient and quieter aircraft. Dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) plasma actuators consist of two electrodes, one exposed to the ambient fluid and the other covered by a dielectric material. When an A.C. voltage is applied between the two electrodes the ambient fluid over the covered electrode ionizes. This ionized fluid is called the plasma and results
in a body force vector which exchanges momentum with the ambient, neutrally charged, fluid.

For this project, high-resolution simulations will be carried out on the most powerful supercomputers in Europe in order to demonstrate the potential of DBD plasma actuators for the control of turbulent jets. The problem of jet noise pollution has become more severe in the past few decades due to the ever increasing number of flights, the tightening of environmental impact regulations, and the development of urban/residential areas in close proximity to airports. The scientific objective of the present project is to advance our understanding of aeroacoustic mechanisms up to the point where we can
propose targeted plasma control strategies for free shear flows to tackle the problem of jet noise pollution. This research project is a first step in the development of new technologies based on plasma actuators in the aeronautic sector not only for noise reduction purposes but also potentially for mixing enhancement and for a better efficiency of jet engines.

As of today, active flow control technologies have not been implemented in commercial aircraft. The large number of parameters (location of the actuator, orientation, size, relative placement of the embedded and exposed electrodes, applied voltage, frequency) affecting the performance of plasma actuators makes their development, testing and optimisation a very complicated task. Experimental approaches require numerous high-cost and time consuming trial-and-error iterations. Computational Fluid Dynamics (CFD) can complement ideally experiments with the potential to investigate in
detail plasma-actuator controlled turbulent flows.

Planned Impact

By 2032 it estimated that worldwide more than 29,000 new large civil airliners, 24,000 business jets, 5,800 regional aircraft and 40,000 helicopters will be required to deal with the constant increase of the worldwide traffic. For instance, more than 16 billion passengers per year worldwide are expected in 2050. Aviation will have to find ways to meet this growing demand whilst reducing its environmental impact, specifically the level of noise and of carbon emission. It is clear that it requires a significant step change in the technologies of future aircraft. The UK is directly concerned by this challenge as it the second national aerospace industry in the world, with a 17% global market share for a turnover of more than £20 billion every year, sustaining directly and indirectly more than 200,000 jobs.

This application proposes to investigate the potential for noise reduction of a very promising active flow control strategy based on plasma actuators.
Plasma actuators can be used in a wide range of engineering applications such as viscous drag reduction and boundary layer separation control in low-speed flows, shock wave modification and wave drag reduction in supersonic and transonic flows, and supersonic boundary layer transition control. The idea here is to use them to manipulate a turbulent round jet in order to either reduce the acoustic sources or to minimise their propagation.
The number of active flow control devices that have successfully transitioned from a laboratory prototype to a real-world aeronautical application is still relatively small and the proposed Computational Fluid Dynamics project is offering a great opportunity to explore active control strategies as a complement to experiments. Another important aspect of this project is related to the identification of acoustic noise in a turbulent flow. To develop efficient noise reduction strategy, it is necessary to understand where the noise is coming from. The main problem in identifying the acoustic sources is that they often get eclipsed by the much larger turbulent fluctuations and become inaccessible if evaluated directly. This project is aiming to propose a general framework for the identification of acoustic sources in turbulent flows based on indirect evaluation of the acoustic sources and their propagations.

The Department of Aeronautics at Imperial College has agreed to provide a DTA student to work on this project. This student and the PDRA funded by this grant will become experienced scientists in High Performance Computing and in the manipulation of turbulent flows. They will both attend High Performance Computing training sessions organised by the UK supercomputing service ARCHER. They will both collaborate with the team of Professor Choi from the University of Nottingham as it is the UK experimental leading research group for active flow control strategies using plasma actuators. Finally, they will also interact with the PhD students from the Centre for Doctoral Training in Fluid Mechanics across the Scales at Imperial College to develop their lecture skills.

Plasma actuators are one of the most promising technologies to manipulate a turbulent jet with strong potential benefits in mixing efficiency for combustion, propulsion efficiency and noise reduction. However, a thorough scientific understanding of this new active control solution is required before it can be implemented at an industrial scale. Only very few research groups in the UK are working on active plasma control solutions. This research project will hopefully encourage other research groups to start using plasma actuator in their research as it can be applied to a wide range of flow configurations. It will also hopefully arouse curiosity and interest from the many aerospace industries in the UK looking for innovative active flow control solutions.
 
Description In recent years, the development of devices known as plasma actuators has advanced the promise of controlling flows in new ways that increase lift, reduce drag and improve aerodynamic efficiency,advances that may lead to safer, more efficient and quieter aircraft. Dielectric barrier discharge (DBD) plasma actuators consist of two electrodes, one exposed to the ambient fluid and the other covered by a dielectric material. When an A.C. voltage is applied between the two electrodes the ambient fluid over the covered electrode ionizes. This ionized fluid is called the plasma and results in a body force vector which exchanges momentum with the ambient, neutrally charged, fluid.

Modern airliner engines are jet Turbofan engines. They are extremely efficient but terribly noisy. One way of reducing noise is to simply cuts the trailing edge of the engine's exit nozzle in a repeated saw-tooth pattern. These are called chevron nozzles. They can reduce noise levels during landing and take off by few decibels. However, they are associated with a trust penalty during flight.

The research funded on this grant demonstrated that it is possible to use plasma actuators to mimic chevrons at the engine's exit nozzle. The plasma actuators can be turned off during flight (no trust penalty) and are only activated at landing and take off when noise levels need to be reduced. We managed to demonstrate that the use of eight plasma actuators located just at the exit of the nozzle are introducing strong modifications of the vortex structures downstream of the nozzle exit, with a substantial reduction of the potential core, an increase of the jet radial expansion and an improvement of the mixing properties of the flow. Further work is needed in order fully understand the underlying physics and to optimise the various parameters of this innovative active flow control solution (location of the actuator, orientation, size, relative placement of the embedded and exposed electrodes, applied voltage, frequency).
Exploitation Route All the numerical tools developed during this research project are freely available on demand. They can be used to study other flow configurations.
See http://www.incompact3d.com/impact.html for list of published papers based on the numerical methods used in the project and developed by the PI.
Sectors Aerospace, Defence and Marine,Energy,Transport

 
Description Turbulent jets are used in a variety of industrial applications, such as jet engines and combustion chambers. Greenhouse gases, toxic pollutants, heat ejection and sound radiation emitted from such devices are often detrimental to the environment. Enhancing specific properties of a jet is therefore vital. For instance, improving its mixing property would result in higher thrust for a jet engine and more energy extraction due to a more complete combustion in the combustion chamber. Most of the research related to the control of turbulent jets is nowadays focusing on active control solutions for which the control is only active when needed (as opposed to passive control which is always on, even when no needed). In this project, high-fidelity simulations of turbulent jets at high speed have been performed with dielectric barrier discharges (DBD) plasma actuators located inside the nozzle to actively control the large scale structures of a round jet. It was one of the very first time that plasma actuators were used to control an incompressible turbulent jet with the aim to enhance its mixing properties. The main results is that plasma actuators can strongly modify the flow field downstream of the nozzle with the promotion of elongated structures, a thinner potential core and an early breakdown of turbulence, and as a results, an improved mixing activities. Following this project, several research groups worldwide have started looking at the potential of DBD plasma actuators to improve the performance of jets in various industrial applications.
First Year Of Impact 2019
Sector Aerospace, Defence and Marine
Impact Types Economic

 
Description High End Computing Consortia Call 2017
Amount £860,000 (GBP)
Funding ID EP/R029326/1 
Organisation Engineering and Physical Sciences Research Council (EPSRC) 
Sector Public
Country United Kingdom
Start 07/2018 
End 06/2021
 
Description Acoustic prediction for turbulent free shear flows 
Organisation University of Poitiers
Country France 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Contribution from Imperial: Numerical data and expertise in high-fidelity simulations
Collaborator Contribution Contribution from Poitiers: design of the acoustic prediction tool
Impact 1 paper is currently under review (A diagnostic tool for jet noise using a line-source approach and Implicit Large-Eddy Simulation data)
Start Year 2017
 
Description Modelling of Dielectric Barrier Discharge Plasma Actuators for Direct Numerical Simulations 
Organisation University of Poitiers
Country France 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Contribution from Imperial: Numerical data and expertise in high-fidelity simulations
Collaborator Contribution Contribution from Poitiers: Experimental data and expertise in active flow control using plasma actuators
Impact 1 conference paper for 8th AIAA Flow Control Conference, AIAA Aviation and Aeronautics Forum and Exposition 2016, Washington DC, USA Title: Modelling of Dielectric Barrier Discharge Plasma Actuators for Direct Numerical Simulations Authors: Timothy Brauner; Sylvain Laizet; Nicolas Benard; Eric Moreau 1 conference paper for 55th AIAA Aerospace Sciences Meeting, Grapevine, Texas, 09 Jan 2017 - 13 Jan 2017. Title: PIV-based dynamic model of EHD volume force produced by a surface dielectric barrier discharge Authors: Nicolas Benard; Sylvain Laizet; Eric Moreau
Start Year 2015
 
Title Xcompact3d 
Description Xcompact3d is a Fortran-based framework of high-order finite-difference flow solvers dedicated to the study of turbulent flows. Dedicated to Direct and Large Eddy Simulations (DNS/LES) for which the largest turbulent scales are simulated, it can combine the versatility of industrial codes with the accuracy of spectral codes. Its user-friendliness, simplicity, versatility, accuracy, scalability, portability and efficiency makes it an attractive tool for the Computational Fluid Dynamics community. XCompact3d is currently able to solve the incompressible and low-Mach number variable density Navier-Stokes equations using sixth-order compact finite-difference schemes with a spectral-like accuracy on a monobloc Cartesian mesh. It was initially designed in France in the mid-90's for serial processors and later converted to HPC systems. It can now be used efficiently on hundreds of thousands CPU cores to investigate turbulence and heat transfer problems thanks to the open-source library 2DECOMP&FFT (a Fortran-based 2D pencil decomposition framework to support building large-scale parallel applications on distributed memory systems using MPI; the library has a Fast Fourier Transform module). When dealing with incompressible flows, the fractional step method used to advance the simulation in time requires to solve a Poisson equation. This equation is fully solved in spectral space via the use of relevant 3D Fast Fourier transforms (FFTs), allowing the use of any kind of boundary conditions for the velocity field. Using the concept of the modified wavenumber (to allow for operations in the spectral space to have the same accuracy as if they were performed in the physical space), the divergence free condition is ensured up to machine accuracy. The pressure field is staggered from the velocity field by half a mesh to avoid spurious oscillations created by the implicit finite-difference schemes. The modelling of a fixed or moving solid body inside the computational domain is performed with a customised Immersed Boundary Method. It is based on a direct forcing term in the Navier-Stokes equations to ensure a no-slip boundary condition at the wall of the solid body while imposing non-zero velocities inside the solid body to avoid discontinuities on the velocity field. This customised IBM, fully compatible with the 2D domain decomposition and with a possible mesh refinement at the wall, is based on a 1D expansion of the velocity field from fluid regions into solid regions using Lagrange polynomials or spline reconstructions. In order to reach high velocities in a context of LES, it is possible to customise the coefficients of the second derivative schemes (used for the viscous term) to add extra numerical dissipation in the simulation as a substitute of the missing dissipation from the small turbulent scales that are not resolved. Xcompact3d is currently being used by many research groups worldwide to study gravity currents, wall-bounded turbulence, wake and jet flows, wind farms and active flow control solutions to mitigate turbulence. 
Type Of Technology Software 
Year Produced 2019 
Open Source License? Yes  
Impact see list of publications 
URL http://www.incompact3d.com
 
Description Participation at Imperial Festival 2019 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Demonstration of the Shadowgraph experiments (how to see invisible air using advance optical techniques) during Imperial Festival 2017/2018/2019. Imperial Festival is a free public event which is held each year on Imperial's South Kensington Campus. The weekend-long event features activities and attractions for all ages, including: Hands-on demonstrations; Workshops; Talks and Tours. More than 400 pupils attended for a school visit on the Friday, which sparked questions and discussion afterwards. More than 10,000 members of the public attended on Saturday and Sunday. As a result of a very successful event, we are now receiving request to reproduce this experiments at other outreach events.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2017,2018,2019
URL http://www.imperial.ac.uk/festival/