MORPHINE: Re-designing the coast: The Morphodynamics of Large Bodies of Sediment in a Macro-tidal Environment

Lead Research Organisation: University of Nottingham
Department Name: Faculty of Engineering

Abstract

We propose developing the mathematical theory of morphodynamics as it pertains to a macro-tidal environment (coastal region with large tidal range, like that in the UK), so as to understand the movement of large deposits of sand on our beaches and shorefaces (shorefaces are, loosely, the regions in between the beach and the continental shelf floor). This theory will allow us to formulate a new mathematical modelling approach. New models stemming from this will allow us to develop a new approach to designing sea defences, in which large quantities of sand ("nourishments") are deposited at strategic locations at and / or near to the coastline. These nourishments will provide a source of sediment for beaches that are eroding, but, importantly, they will also alter local wave and current conditions, which will transform previously eroding beaches into more stable configurations, and so form naturalistic coastal defences.
The theory and the models, coupled with a new, realistic statistical model of sea conditions, will make it possible for us to predict the behaviour of these nourishments to a high degree of accuracy under different conditions. Because the models are highly efficient we will be able to do this for long times (say, 20 years or more), and to investigate the likely variations in wave conditions that might occur during this time. This will support the design of this new approach to designing sea defences, and will mean that we do not have to rely on invasive, expensive and reactive traditional sea defences. It will have the additional benefit of providing the means to predict how a major proportion of our existing coast will behave in the future. The proposal addresses UK conditions in particular, in which a very large tidal range combines with a wide variety of wave conditions to produce a particularly challenging environment. We are therefore proposing to undertake fundamental work on coastal morphodynamics so as to develop tools that will let us re-think our coastal defence strategy.

Planned Impact

+ Between 2005 and 2015 the UK government spent about £6 billion on flood and coastal erosion risk management, with the annual figure (most recently £795 million) having risen sharply over the last two years (about 62% of this is coastal flooding or erosion, according to previous estimates). The work proposed will result in a better understanding of coastal morphodynamics, around the UK coast in particular, and so the UK government will benefit in terms of better designed, more predictable, less invasive coastal defences. This will also save money in the future.
+ District councils, and all other bodies who manage the coastal environment will similarly benefit.
+ Coastal engineering consultants and contractors will benefit from more reliable numerical models, and a better understanding of these dynamics, so that traditional model output can also be assessed from a more knowledgeable perspective. Modelling may also be carried out faster using the amplitude equation approach.
+ The improved statistical model will also mean that coastal change can be assigned more reliable error estimates, thus reducing uncertainty. This will again help coastal managers, but also the insurance industry in producing better estimates of risk for homes / businesses at risk of flooding, thus reducing costs across the board.
+ In the future, tourists will benefit from fewer beaches being rendered unusable or unsightly, because the proposed coastal defence strategies involve longer-term solutions without recourse to hard engineering structures. This will similarly benefit local economies.
 
Description Proof of concept for description of aspects of natural morphodynamics using an amplitude equation. We have shown that a one mathematical equation can be used to describe some characteristics (e.g. lengthscale) and behaviour (long-term evolution) associated with natural beach morphologies.

Feb. 2019: The concept of a nourishment as a morphodynamic perturbation has been implemented in a mathematical model. In the first instance the cross-shore dynamics of a single shoreface nourishment has been examined. The resulting dynamics agree with the general observation that mild wave conditions promote onshore migration of the nourishment, whereas energetic waves promote offshore movement. The primary impact of tides in the cross-shore study is to alter water depth, thus making the nourishment more or less active. The concept therefore appears viable.

Feb. 2020. The concept of the nourishment as a perturbation has now been validated against the Terschelling shoreface nourishment on the Dutch coast. The model is at present being extended to 2D.

Feb. 2021: The nourishment-as-a-perturbation (NaaP) model concept has now been successfully validated (Chen and Dodd, 2021; Cont. Shelf Res., 214, 104317) (in other words, it has been shown to reproduce real-world observations). The application reveals that the migration rate of the nourishment (speed of movement shoreward) is calculable even without the nourishment in place, which therefore means that for design purposes we do not necessarily require a time-intensive full computational study. That prediction capability remains very faithful to actual (with nourishment in place) migration rate in non-storm periods, gradually diverging as the effects of storms accumulate. The new, more accurate 1D model developed in Chen and Dodd (2021) (building on Chen and Dodd (2019)--see earlier submission), captures nourishment response to shoaling and breaking behaviour more accurately. The NaaP method is particularly attractive and powerful because in principle it is amenable to application of any morphodynamical model, with and without the nourishment in place.

Feb. 2022: The expertise gained has been used to investigate "green nourishments" (Chen et al, 2022, Front. Mar. Sci.--see new publication). In this technique a nourishment is also seeded with marine grass (or an area adjacent to the nourishment). This acts to further reduce wave energy and further stabilise the coast. It was found that it was particularly effective to position the sea grass meadow in the sheltered region landward of a shoreface nourishment, such that the nourishment dissipates much of the wave energy, and the sea grass meadow stabilises the shoreline region without being buried due to sediment transport.
Exploitation Route The concept could be applied to artificial features, given the appropriate theoretical underpinning.

Feb. 2019: The modelling concept may allow design of nourishment location, size based on local beach profile and prevailing wave and tide conditions.

Feb. 2020: Extension to beach as opposed to shoreface nourishments. Use as a design tool. Consideration of different sediment mixes.

Feb. 2021: The verification of the NaaP approach in 2D would be the top priority. Thereafter the extension of the approach to beach (as opposed to shoreface) nourishments would be desirable. In principle this could be done with existing models, although one building on the present 1D model would be preferable because of the faster solution times that could be achieved, as well as providing a clearer picture of the importance of various physical processes. The validation at a UK site (especially because of the larger tidal range) would be desirable. The development of the approach to accommodate mixed sediments would also be very desirable, as these are typical of many UK conditions.

March 2022: The green nourishment concept is one that looks very promising. This needs to be put on a sounder theoretical footing, with a better representation / parameterisation of the interaction between fluid, sand and sea grass. In addition, the effects of tide will be crucial, because it will repeatedly alter the environment for the sea grass. This will be particularly important for UK conditions of course. Extension of the evaluation of the effect of sea grass planting to 2d (i.e., area) would also be highly desirable.
Sectors Energy,Other

 
Description Professors Dodd and Reeve provided brief technical advice to the Royal HaskoningDHV team responsible for the Bacton sandscaping project regarding the sediment composition of proposed sand nourishment and the limitations of current modelling tools. + As mentioned in an earlier submission, Prof Dodd co-organised, attended and spoke at the Coastal Engineering Conference at Da Nang University of Science and Technology in 2019. There the Nourishment-as-a-Perturbation (NaaP) model was explained, and possible applications discussed with an audience including local and national government officials. Later discussions focused on the coastal erosion problems being experienced at Da Nang, with a view to developing a solution strategy (see below). + The Nourishment-as-a-Perturbation (NaaP) model was applied to the Terschelling shoreface nourishment in The Netherlands. The Terschelling nourishment is an ideal case against which to test the concept in 1D (on/offshore), and the data-set was obtained from Dutch researchers advising on Dutch coastal protection policy. The model concept proved successful in reproducing observed nourishment behaviour, which therefore opens the door to a wider application. In addition, the post-doctoral researcher (Dr W. Chen) attended the RCEM2020 (Rivers, Coasts and Estuarine Morphodynamics) conference in New Zealand, in November 2020. There he presented the NaaP model to a worldwide audience of practitioners / managers as well as academics. + In 2020 Prof Dodd submitted a Royal Society proposal in the International Collaboration Award scheme to The Royal Society to further develop and apply the NaaP model to the beaches in the vicinity of Da Nang, Vietnam. This proposed work, involving two Vietnamese universities, and their contacts in government and industry in the Da Nang area, aimed to address the coastal erosion problems observed at Da Nang in 2019 (see above). These problems are signficiant in that they impact on livelihoods (loss of beaches for tourism) and safety of local people. The work programme provided sustainable solutions that mitigate economic and societal impacts. Unfortunately it was not funded. Further opportunities are being sought.
First Year Of Impact 2017
Sector Construction,Energy,Environment
Impact Types Societal,Economic

 
Description Beach Nourishment using the "Nourishment as a Perturbation" approach
Amount ¥432,000 (CNY)
Organisation University of Nottingham Ningbo China 
Sector Academic/University
Country China
Start 10/2021 
End 09/2024
 
Description Collaboration with Texas A & M University 
Organisation Texas A&M University
Country United States 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Project post-doc Dr Valsamidis visited Prof Jens Figlus at Texas A&M University Galveston to discuss the major beach renourishment scheme there. Dr Valsamidis is extending an existing beach model to try to replicate the observed changes in beach morphology at Galveston.
Collaborator Contribution Prof Figlus made several beach surveys available to the project to assist in model chekcing and validation. One of his PhD students visited Swansea in November 2017 to discuss and update the surveys.
Impact None yet as it is early in th ecollaboration.
Start Year 2017
 
Description Discussions with Royal HaskoningDHV 
Organisation Royal HaskoningDHV
Country Netherlands 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution Discussions between Prof N. Dodd (University of Nottingham) and Prof. D.E. Reeve (Swansea University) with two senior employees of Royal HaskoningDHV on their experiences / ideas regarding 'sandscaping'. Sandscaping is the commonly used terminology in coastal engineering for the deposition of large amounts of sediment at or near to the coast, so as to counteract / mitigate the effects of flooding and / or erosion. Reeve visited Nottingham, and Dodd and Reeve discussed this topic with the representatives of Royal HaskoningDHV about 60 minutes on 17.02.17. Originally, the meeting had been provisionally scheduled for Oct 2016, but Dodd's teaching timetable made that very difficult, so a later meeting was planned. A face-to-face meeting had then been scheduled, but there were problems communicating between the Royal HaskoningDHV representatives, hence the eventual skype meeting with one on speaker phone. It was decided that the next project meeting at Nottingham would be immediately followed by an in-person meeting with, if possible, both representatives from Royal HaskoningDHV. On 02.02.18 Royal HaskoningDHV were also present at the Bacton sandscaping meeting (see Key Findings) and further discussion were had with them. On Aug 21st, 2018 Prof Dodd and Prof Reeve met with a senior representative of Royal HaskongDHV at the University of Nottingham to discuss possible implementations of sandscaping solutions at various representative locations (i.e. scenarios). Discussions included the kinds of possible implementations, and the stability concept.
Collaborator Contribution Discussions between Prof N. Dodd (University of Nottingham) and Prof. D.E. Reeve (Swansea University) with two representatives from Royal HaskoningDHV on their experiences / ideas regarding 'sandscaping'. Sandscaping is the commonly used terminology in coastal engineering for the deposition of large amounts of sediment at or near to the coast, so as to counteract / mitigate the effects of flooding and / or erosion. One representatives (speaker phone) and the second (Skype) discussed this topic with Dodd and Reeve for about 60-90 minutes on 17.02.17. On 02.02.18 Royal HaskoningDHV were also present at the Bacton sandscaping meeting (see Key Findings) and further discussion were had with them. Royal HaskoningDHV were involved in setting up and running the meeting. On Aug 21st, 2018 Prof Dodd and Prof Reeve met with a senior representative of Royal HaskongDHV at the University of Nottingham to discuss possible implementations of sandscaping solutions at various representative locations (i.e. scenarios). Discussions included the kinds of possible implementations, and the stability concept.
Impact N/A
Start Year 2017
 
Description ITB - ICMSE Lecture 
Organisation Bandung Institute of Technology
Country Indonesia 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution In October 2018 I visited Dr Magdalena (Department of Mathematics, Institut Teknologi Bandung, Indonesia), to give an invited lecture on 'Applying mathematics to the problem of coastal protection', as part of the 5th International Conference on Mathematics, Science and Education (ICMSE), Universitas Negeri Semarang, Bali, Indonesia. The work we are undertaking as part of the MORPHINE project formed an integral part of the talk.
Collaborator Contribution The extended an Speaker invitation to me and hosted my visit.
Impact One student from ITB had a 2 week visit to Swansea to undertake some experiments in our wave tank. Two papers, coauthored with Dr Magdalena and her students, are now in preparation.
Start Year 2018
 
Description Nourishment-as-a-Perturbation (NaaP) modelling using traditional numerical models 
Organisation University of Nottingham Ningbo China
Country China 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution The PhD student is now 1.5 years into the PhD, and has learned how to apply the Delft3D + waves model.
Collaborator Contribution The PhD student is now 1.5 years into the PhD, and has learned how to apply the Delft3D + waves model.
Impact None yet.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Nourishment-as-a-Perturbation (NaaP) modelling using traditional numerical models 
Organisation University of Nottingham Ningbo China
Country China 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution PhD supervision of student now 6 months into PhD.
Collaborator Contribution PhD supervision of student now 6 months into PhD. And the actual running of the numerical model (Delft-3D) by the PhD student.
Impact None yet.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Research on "green nourishments" 
Organisation Cranfield University
Country United Kingdom 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution Collaboration on research to investigate the efficacy of so-called green nourishments (beach nourishments on which, or in lee of which, sea grass meadows are deployed / seeded). My work was to guide / advise on the numerical modelling.
Collaborator Contribution Collaboration on research to investigate the efficacy of so-called green nourishments (beach nourishments on which, or in lee of which, sea grass meadows are deployed / seeded). Cranfield's work was to advise on and carry out the numerical modelling.
Impact Yes, there is a publication. Please see publications list. + Chen et al (2022) "Green nourishment: an innovative nature-based solution for coastal erosion," Front. Mar. Sci.
Start Year 2021
 
Description Royal HaskoningDHV - beach sandscaping 
Organisation Royal HaskoningDHV
Country Netherlands 
Sector Private 
PI Contribution On Aug 21st, 2018 Prof Dodd and Prof Reeve met with a senior representative of Royal Haskong DHV at the University of Nottingham to discuss possible implementations of sandscaping solutions at various representative locations (i.e. scenarios). Discussions included the kinds of possible implementations, and the stability concept.
Collaborator Contribution We provided technical advice relating to sandscaping at Bacton.
Impact none to date
Start Year 2017
 
Description Visit to Universitat Politecnica de Catalunya, Dept of Applied Physics 
Organisation Polytechnic University of Catalonia
Department Department of Physics
Country Spain 
Sector Academic/University 
PI Contribution In a month-long visit to UPC, Barcelona, Dr Chen (Nottingham PDRA) studied the approach to linearization of the dynamical equations in a linear stability model (in particular, MORFO60). Dr Chen obtained the MORFO60 code from UPC, and learned how to compile and run the model. He became familiar with the input and output files of the model. For the purposes of verification Dr Chen then reproduced the results of the by Calvete et al (2005) [J. Geophys. Res., vol.110, C10006, doi:10.1029/2004JC002803] with the MORFO60 code. Dr Chen also subsequently discussed strategies with the members of the research group at UPC (associate professor, and full professor) and Prof Dodd and, for the implementation of the effect of tides into MORFO60. Both Dr Chen and Prof Dodd joined the field observation trip, organised by the research group, including a second associate professor, to Punta de la Banya to look at the development of nearshore seabed patterns. Prof Dodd also visited UPC for 1 week (funded by UPC) toward the end of Dr Chen's stay to participate in discussions, also with the group on related morphodynamics.
Collaborator Contribution The UPC research group provided the MORFO60 code. One member (associate professor) supervised Dr Chen during his studies on linear stability theory and on the implementation and use of the computational model MORFO60. The same asscociate professor also discussed with Dr Chen and Prof Dodd how to implement the effect of tides in the model. Another group member (professor) entered into discussions on this topic. The research group then organized the field observation trip to Punta de la Banya (see above). A second associate professor in the research group further discussed related topics of morphodynamics with Prof Dodd. The UPC research group also provided the funding for Prof Dodd to visit UPC for one week, toward the end of Dr Chen's stay, to participate in discussions (air fare and accommodation).
Impact Dr Chen has become as expert user of the MORFO60 model. He has begun to implement strategies for the inclusion of tides.
Start Year 2016
 
Description A presentation on the new method for assessing shoreface nourishments was given at Da Nang University of Science and Technology on April 22, 2019. 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The talk was given as part of a workshop on The impact of typhoons on the Da Nang Bay area, funded by the University of Nottingham. The audience was a mixture of other engineers and scientists, some undergraduates, some representatives of regional authorities who have responsibility for typhoon prediction, and some with wider responsibilities. As part of the workshop we visited a number of locations where erosion is being experienced in Da Nang. This is particularly important for this area as tourism is one of the most important areas of the economy. Prof Dodd was further invited to a trip to Dinosaur Island, which is a small and rapidly evolving island near the outfall of the Thu Bon River. The visit was also reported in the newspaper.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL https://phapluat.tuoitrethudo.com.vn/cat-boi-lap-dao-khung-long-o-bien-cua-dai-tu-dau-toi-20204.html...
 
Description Attendance at sand-scaping meeting in London 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The PIs of the MORPHINE project were invited to attend a meeting of scientist, engineers, and governmental representatives re the Bacton (Norfolk) sand-scaping project, which is planned to go ahead. This is a smaller-scale nourishment (compared to the Sand Engine on the Dutch coast). Dodd attended on behalf of the team. Results of observations and simulations of the Sand-Engine project were shown by a rep from Deltares. Discussions were had about how best to make scientific / engineering use of the Bacton intervention such that we can learn from it. A document was to be circulated to all attendees (including those invited but who couldn't attend) so as to summarise the meeting and plan possible actions. The meeting was held on 02.02.18 at UCL.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2018
 
Description Invitation to give presentation on MORPHINE research at workshop at University of Da Nang, Vietnam 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact Funding was obtained from the University of Nottingham, under the auspices of the Research Priority Area of Life in Changing Environments for a workshop to be held at the University of Da Nang - University of Science and Technology, Vietnam, on typhoon impacts on the Da Nang Bay region and the central Vietnam coast.
The aim was to combine coastal engineering and hydrodynamics, and sustainable flood risk management and assessment expertise, with local hydrology / fluvial flooding knowledge, to understand flood event dynamics; and to share experience from the Philippines and SE Asia region on disaster prevention and management. These synergies have potential to improve regional resilience to typhoons. As part of this Prof Dodd was invited by the local contact, Prof Vo Ngoc Duong, of the Facult of Water Resource Engineering, to present work on the MORPHINE project. The workshop is to be held on April 25-26, 2019.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2019
URL http://wred.dut.udn.vn/icwrce/?fbclid=IwAR1anAJZVux57Qsn3PAnBYmOsGgvd0C2AUsw22ImCDlHwz8RaEpRgyuo5ao