LATENT: RESIDENTIAL HEAT AS AN ENERGY SYSTEM SERVICE

Lead Research Organisation: University of Southampton
Department Name: Sch of Engineering

Abstract

The UK's carbon targets, as defined by the Climate Change Act of 2008, specify an emissions reduction of 80% by 2050, which the government has recently revised down to 'net zero' for the same year. In 2017, 17% of the UK's carbon emissions were associated with non-electric use in the residential sector (64.1 Mt CO2), the majority of which were associated with natural gas space heating, cooking and domestic hot water. The UK must therefore decarbonise residential heat to be able to meet its climate change targets, but, in combination with electric vehicles (EVs), this could lead to a 200-300% increase in the UK's annual electricity demand.

In terms of deployment at scale, Air Source Heat Pumps (ASHP) operating either in isolation or as a hybrid gas system appear a key technology as they are not site specific and are applicable to both new build housing and retrofit. The UK's low voltage (LV) electricity network will not however, be able to operate with unconstrained electrical heating or EV charging loads. Both loads must be deferrable or scheduled in a manner to support the electricity network and maintain substations and feeders within limits.

Household electric heating has the potential to operate as a significant deferrable load which LATENT is seeking to understand and harness. This can provide benefits across scales, namely to the UK (energy security and carbon targets), DNO (Distributed Network Operator as grid support), heat pump suppliers (by demonstrating added grid value), householders (in terms of bill reduction and avoidance of peaking dynamic tariffs) and electricity suppliers by applying aggregation techniques to minimise energy service costs.

The key aim of LATENT therefore, is to be able to predict the impact of customers with electrical heating (predominantly ASHP) operating with 3rd party deferrable heating control on the LV network at the feeder / substation level. 3rd party control in this context would be through the energy service supplier, with whom, unlike the DNO, a household has an existing financial contract relationship. LATENT will inform industry of the potential of 3rd party control of deferrable heat through a rigorous field experiment, and, in doing so, accelerate the transition to decarbonised household heating.

LATENT will determine the influence of householder personality trait (OCEAN traits: either positive / negative as Openness, Conscientiousness, Extraversion, Agreeableness, Neuroticism) alongside more traditional Census metrics such as educational attainment, house type etc to deliver a multi-variate regression model to describe deferrable heat reduction at the household level. A substation or feeder can then be analysed in terms of its household type mix (10% C+ detached, 30% E- flat etc) to produce a composite substation level, deferrable heat reduction estimate.

This model will be realised through field trials with LATENT's industrial partner, Igloo Energy. Igloo have a customer base with smart heating systems and ASHP which support remote 3rd party control. LATENT will test (i) householder's stated acceptance to deferral of heating (in terms of temperature drop and duration) through focus groups and surveys, (ii) actual acceptance of heat deferral through heating season field trials, and (iii) operation of a commercial deferrable heat tariff with a sample of Igloo's customer base.

Planned Impact

LATENT will create impact across multiple scales (from the citizen to the country) and across multiple sectors (policy, manufacturing, electricity supply, energy retail). These are as follows:

HOUSEHOLD IMPACT (HI)
HI 1. Increased availability of heat as a service energy contracts which incorporate deferral of heat and so lead to a reduction in household bills.
HI 2. Subsidised ASHP system offers start to appear on the market for new customers via energy service companies (such as Igloo) who are able to part finance their packages against the additional value that aggregated heat deferral brings to the LV network. This effect was seen with photovoltaics and Feed-in-Tariff through 'rent your roof' schemes.

SOCIETAL IMPACT (SI)
SI 1. LATENT will support the transition to decarbonised household heating enhancing local air quality and reducing carbon emissions.
SI 2. LATENT will provide a pathway for off gas network households to fuel switch from high cost / high carbon fossil fuels.

NATIONAL IMPACT (NI)
NI 1. LATENT as an enabler of ASHP (or other electrical heating type) at scale in LV networks.
NI 2. Demand Side Management (DSM) becoming embedded within heat as a service provision by energy suppliers.
NI 3. Contribution to decarbonisation of residential heat and delivery of national carbon targets.

POLICY IMPACT (PI)
PI 1. Briefing of Government Scientific Advisors on the decarbonisation of heat challenge and the policy implications of LATENT findings. LATENT will provide valuable evidence of a pathway to decarbonisation of residential heat without compromising the LV network or requiring significant DNO (Distributed Network Operator) investment.
PI 2. LATENT End of Project conference to policymakers and stakeholders.

ACADEMIC IMPACT (AI)
AI 1. 4 High impact journal papers within timefame of LATENT programme
AI 2. Presentation of work at UK meetings, European and International conferences
AI 3. Open access archive of LATENT datasets for future research use via UKDS.
AI 4. LATENT provides academic benefit across four core areas of (i) Understanding of Energy Performance Gap, (ii) Study design and delivery incorporating household traits (iii) household heating behaviour datasets, and (iv) thermal comfort response.

INDUSTRY IMPACT (II)
II 1. Industry awareness (DNOs, technology manufacturers, energy service companies) of the impact of household deferral heat by a 3rd party as an approach to LV support. LATENT addresses one of the key barriers to ASHP (or electrical heating in general) at scale - that winter peak stress on some LV networks will become so severe that a moratorium on heat pump deployment will have to be put in place.
II 2. LATENT will enable the acceleration of heat as a service into the marketplace by building understanding and therefore industry confidence and trust in the approach.
II 3. Development and field testing of a costing framework to deliver deferrable heat in a home.
III 4. Understanding of how household personality trait (OCEAN positive / negative) impacts on 3rd party intervention in the home, wider implications to the energy industry.
 
Description Deferral of heating in homes by a third party provider has successfully been trialled within LATENT. This makes the case for the viability of the approach at scale.
Exploitation Route provision of tariffs which support deferral of heat in homes.
Sectors Energy

 
Description The work is already feeding into the development of deferrable heat tariffs.
First Year Of Impact 2023
Sector Energy
Impact Types Economic

 
Description Addressing Carbon Emissions through Sustainable Energy Technologies at Different Scales 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact The presentation created interest among the participants which was ended up in many Q & As'.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://climatelinkup.com/launch-event/
 
Description Business Innovation South Expo 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The Energy and Climate Change Division attended the Business Innovation South Expo held at Hilton Hotel, Ageas Bowl, Southampton on the 15th September 2021.
The event was the South's first large-scale expo where established companies from within the science, technology, engineering and innovation sectors could showcase the latest products/services available to businesses across the region.
At the in-person expo the Energy and Climate Change Division exhibited engineering solutions related to renewable energy and energy efficiency. This included reliable, affordable and sustainable energy, including marine, wind and solar photovoltaics as well as optimised and user sensitive energy efficiency solutions.
Our exhibition also showcased a variety of research in collaboration with businesses, local authorities and international partners to evaluate and develop evidence for robust sustainable pathways.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.businessinnovationsouth.com/
 
Description Conference Presentation EvolvingCities 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact INTRODUCTION TO PhD STUDY WHICH USES LATENT PARTICIPANTS
Investigating inter-generational factors on behaviour and human building interaction

G. Sewell, S. Gauthier, P. James

Residential buildings in the UK represent twice the energy consumption when compared to all industry and services. Moreover, this is consistently increasing despite national and international policies. Within the home, space heating is responsible for over 60% of this total, thus representing the greatest potential for change. Many factors influence the occupant's behaviour towards heating usage; some outside the occupier's control such as weather, building fabric and energy cost, but occupier thermal comfort is the obvious driver towards heating usage. However, a user's energy literacy and personality type may also influence occupants' heating behaviour. These traits, along with perceived thermal comfort, can significantly vary with differing cultures and demographics. Demographics such as age (both younger and older than the main occupant) have seen little research into their respective influences on the main occupant's behaviour, but may be considerable factors in the overall use of domestic heating usage. These factors could include sub-conscious health concerns for older relatives or pressure from the ever-increasing environmental awareness of children. It raises the question; do other generations affect occupants' heating behaviour, in particular the frequency and type of interaction with the heating system in the home? To address this question, a survey engaged a pool of 26,000 dwellings in the UK. The survey also gathered information on the occupier's energy literacy levels, personal traits, social demographics and general dwelling information. Analysis initially divided the participants' homes between those with a younger generation, older generation or those with both. A second contrast was drawn between those homes that saw an increase or a decrease in heating usage within these groups. The survey results were analysed with reference to these contrasting groups. Then the analysis provided evidence describing if and how inter-generational factors influence occupants' heating behaviour and human building interactions. These results helped to identify potential pathways for future research; leveraging these inter-generational influences to reduce household energy consumption. Moreover, these results could be used to improve the future engagement of public health and national energy reduction policies to aid sustainable development.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://evolvingcities.org/presentations-abstracts/
 
Description Conference Presentation EvolvingCities 2021 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact PRESENTATION OF LATENT AND THE WORK UNDERTAKEN TO DATE RELATING TO PERSONALITY TRAITS

The influence of personality and energy literacy on households' stated acceptance of heat deferral
P. A. B. James, P. Turner, T. Rushby, S. Gauthier, A. S. Bahaj
The UK's carbon targets, as defined by the Climate Change Act of 2008, specify an emissions reduction of 80% by 2050, which in 2019 the government has revised down to 'net zero' carbon by 2050. In 2017, 17% (64.1 Mt CO2), of the UK's carbon emissions were associated with non-electric use in the residential sector. The majority of these emissions are associated with natural gas space heating, cooking and domestic hot water. In order to meet UK 'net zero' objectives the UK will aim to decarbonise residential heat (currently through electricity and energy efficiency measures), which in combination with electric vehicles could lead to a 200-300% increase in the UK's annual electricity demand introducing serious capacity issues for the electricity system. In the future residential electrical heating or EV charging loads may need to be remotely adjusted to better suit the capacity of the electricity network and maintain substations and feeders within their technical and regulatory limits. Here we present the findings from a survey with a UK energy provider's household customers (N=4,100) which asks whether household would approve of such a scheme and what levels of heat deferral they would be willing to accept at various times of day. The survey also gathers information on the occupiers energy literacy levels personality traits, trust in energy companies, social demographics, thermal comfort and general dwelling information. The survey results were analysed with reference to these topics providing evidence describing if and how these factors influence stated acceptance of heat deferral. These results helped to identify potential pathways for future research, guiding follow-up online focus group interactions to further understand the influencing factors whilst identifying ways to enhance household acceptance. Moreover, these results could be used to inform national energy reduction policies to aid sustainable development.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://evolvingcities.org/presentations-abstracts/
 
Description Degrees to Save the World - Exploring STEM! 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an open day or visit at my research institution
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Schools
Results and Impact Degrees to Save the World - Exploring STEM! 30 June 2022

LATENT Co-Investigator Dr Stephanie Gauthier presented at the University of Southampton's Degrees to Save the World - Exploring STEM! event held at Highfield Campus on 30 June 2022. Stephanie presented to year 12 students about the LATENT project in relation to completing an engineering degree, showing the range of disciplines within Engineering and how research can have an impact on everyday life and behaviour.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://energy.soton.ac.uk/latent-outreach-and-engagement/
 
Description EPSRC Engineeering Net Zero Week 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact LATENT researcher Dr Tom Rushby attended and exhibited at the EPSRC Engineering Net Zero Week held in person at the Advanced Research Centre, University Glasgow from 21-23 June 2022. Tom exhibited the initial project findings at the event which also included panels, workshops and keynote sessions with discussions on the project aims and outputs taking place with researchers, industry leaders and policy makers.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://energy.soton.ac.uk/latent-outreach-and-engagement/
 
Description ERBE Conference - Striking the Balance: Demand Reduction Vs Supply Decarbonisation 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact ERBE Conference - Striking the Balance: Demand Reduction Vs Supply Decarbonisation 25 May 2022

LATENT researcher Dr Philip Turner presented virtually at the 9th Annual ERBE Conference - Striking the Balance: Demand reduction vs supply decarbonisation taking place in Galway, Ireland on 25 May 2022. Philip presented initial findings form the LATENT online focus groups, fielding questions from attendees on the range of perspectives conveyed during the focus groups.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://energy.soton.ac.uk/latent-outreach-and-engagement/
 
Description Network Heating and Cooling Webinars - DURHAM UNIVERSITY 
Form Of Engagement Activity A talk or presentation
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact A Network for Heating and Cooling Research to Enable a Net-Zero Carbon Future (H+C Zero Network) has been established by UK Research and Innovation (UKRI) to maximise the impact of UK-funded research and innovation. These monthly webinars explore the challenges of decarbonising heating and cooling.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2023
URL https://www.durham.ac.uk/research/institutes-and-centres/durham-energy-institute/about-us/events/net...
 
Description Pint of Science - People, Homes and Drones 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Local
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact Pint of Science - People, Homes and Drones 11 May 2022

Latent Co-Investigator Dr Stephanie Gauthier presented the LATENT project "Would you give-up control of your home heating" at the Southampton Pint of Science taking place on 11 May 2022 at Harbour Lights Cinema, Southampton. The People, Homes and Drones event Stephanie explained how homes can be connected to reduce our carbon footprint and engaged in a engaging Q&A with the in-person audience.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://pintofscience.co.uk/event/walking-with-drones
 
Description The Big Sustainability Expo 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach Regional
Primary Audience Industry/Business
Results and Impact The Energy and Climate Change Division attended The Big Sustainability Expo (Southampton) 2022 held at St Mary's Stadium, Southampton on Thursday 22 September.
The 2022 Expo, organised by the Southern Sustainability Network, had over 100 exhibitors and followed on from the previous event last October. It marked the 6th Anniversary of the only dedicated Expo on the South Coast facilitating communication between leading experts and exhibitors to help organisations implement environmental impact reduction strategies.
At the in-person Expo, ECCD exhibited engineering solutions related to renewable energy, behaviour, cities/infrastructure and energy access, including reliable, affordable and sustainable energy solutions including marine, wind and solar photovoltaics as well as optimised and user sensitive energy efficiency solutions such as the LATENT project. Our exhibition also showcased a variety of research in collaboration with businesses, local authorities and international partners to evaluate and develop evidence for robust sustainable pathways.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021,2022
URL https://southernsustainability.co.uk/
 
Description Unlocking Flexibility: A research, policy and practice workshop 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach National
Primary Audience Professional Practitioners
Results and Impact LATENT researchers Dr Tom Rushby and Dr Philip Turner attended and presented at the Unlocking Flexibility workshop at Newcastle University on 16-17 May 2022. The aim of the workshop was to create a forum for open discussion and collective questioning on demand side flexibility with contributions from academics, policy, industry and NGO stakeholders. Tom detailed the project aims and objectives and debated the project plan requesting feedback on the method of engagement and study.
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2022
URL https://energy.soton.ac.uk/latent-outreach-and-engagement/