Performing Violence, Engendering Change: Developing Arts-Based Approaches to Peacebuilding

Lead Research Organisation: Brunel University London
Department Name: Arts and Humanities

Abstract

'Performing Violence, Engendering Change: Developing Arts-Based Approaches to Peacebuilding' connects artists and researchers from ODA recipient countries across Africa, the Middle East and South Asia working with peacebuilding practices rooted in the arts. It does so by bringing together GCRF and British Academy projects on the impact of the Lebanese civil war on infrastructure; gender and resistance to violent extremism in Kenya; the relationship between transitional justice and development in conflict-affected societies; and gender justice and gendered insecurities. The Cluster will enhance participants' roles as stakeholders in peacebuilding by providing opportunities for research collaboration and knowledge exchange during three week-long workshops held in Kenya, Lebanon and Sri Lanka.

In recent years, scholars, policy makers and practitioners have begun to acknowledge the benefits of using arts-based methods for violence prevention and peacebuilding. Evidence suggests that arts-based methods hold significant potential for improving human security and relations between groups in areas affected by violence and conflict. Arts-based methods, especially when combined with community-centred participatory methodologies, can act at once as analytical tools and dissemination media, whilst creating spaces for practical interventions in difficult contexts.

Despite the growing awareness of the positive impact of arts-based methods, there are scarce opportunities for communities of practice and research to learn from each other, co-create research and establish networks. Spatial and existential isolation can result from living with extremist violence and conflict, with debilitating but different consequences for women, men, youth and other social groups. The silence and seclusion, secrecy and loneliness that conflict zones engender have been linked with the presence of PTSD and other mental health conditions.

Whilst violence and conflict disrupt and often devastate communities, the shared experiences they generate can also be used to connect people. The Cluster aims to break isolation and achieve impact by connecting communities in Kenya, Lebanon and Sri Lanka affected by conflict and extreme violence, who are working to build positive peace. The grant will be invested almost exclusively in bringing together community activists, practitioners, artists, academics (including early career researchers and PhD students) and policy makers in three workshops that will focus on network- and capacity building through intensive research production, knowledge exchange and training sessions on the use of filmmaking, theatre, performance and visual arts as tools to confront violence and promote positive peace. Workshops will include substantial focus on the ways that arts-based approaches can enhance gender approaches to conflict research and peacebuilding.

The Cluster is designed to accelerate the impact of the contributor projects by building deep and lasting links between researchers, partners, policy makers, civil society actors and communities affected by violence, with a view to the network expanding to include other participants and cases in future research. In addition to traditional academic outputs, the Cluster will produce short documentary films on arts-based peacebuilding practices and an open-ended interactive Online Archive providing wide access to the Cluster's research via a dedicated website. The website will be the main portal for public engagement, featuring videos, podcasts and case studies, as well as serving as a resource beyond the end of the award. These activities and outputs are geared towards achieving three specific and measurable impacts on the practices of violence prevention, the prevention of violent extremism and peacebuilding: the creation and transfer of knowledge on arts-based approaches to these challenges; context-driven learning and capacity building; and fostering gender and social inclusion.

Planned Impact

The Cluster will create impact through workshops and the production of a series of documentary films as well as accelerating the impact from the contributor projects. The Cluster will benefit academics, policymakers, international NGOs, civil society organisations, and members of local communities. As academic beneficiaries are discussed separately, this section deals solely with non-academic stakeholders.

Workshop participants: one of the main challenges identified by the Cluster is the lack of opportunities for practitioners working with arts-based methods in violence prevention and peacebuilding to do collaborative work across different cases. This lack of opportunities undermines the creation of best practices and the sharing of effective solutions, thus limiting the impact that arts-based methods can have and limiting their integration into policy and programming. Spatial and existential isolation also limits the capacity of local organisations to respond to new challenges by tapping into solutions that have proven effective elsewhere. The Cluster will enable organisations within contributor projects, such as Art2Be (Nairobi), ICES (Colombo), Laban (Beirut), Amani (Gulu) and All-Stories (Islamabad), to work together. Through the workshops, researchers and practitioners will learn about using arts-based methods as research tools and share their experiences with others. The workshops will also enable members of NGOs to connect with other organisations and learn about different experiences from other contexts. By devising 3 workshops that bring together practitioners and researchers who wouldn't otherwise have this opportunity, the Cluster will create unique opportunities for knowledge sharing, networking and mutual learning. The participants will benefit from the ability to share their experiences, be trained in different methods, and compare solutions adopted by communities similarly affected by violence. They will be able to utilise this learning in their work which will lead to benefit to broader communities.

Policymakers: the Cluster will target policymakers in Lebanon, Kenya, Sri Lanka and internationally. In the Cluster's contributor projects, we have engaged with policymakers at specially organised events, by inviting them to advisory boards and through personal contact and policy focused publications. We already have a strong network of policymakers in each of the three focus countries. These relationships will be strengthened further through the activities of the Cluster. We will invite policymakers to take part in the workshops activities and the networking dinner. For instance, in Kenya, we will invite representatives from the National Commission on Community Cohesion and the Centre for CounterTerrorism. We will also invite representatives from DFID local offices and USAID and to attend the conference days of the workshops. In addition we will invite representatives of international agencies present in each country for instance UNDP, UN Women, UN Economic and Social Commission for Western Asia, and the UN Peacebuilding Commission. Our project policy report and films will provide national and international level policymakers with policy recommendations and information on best practices.

International NGOs: We will also target International NGOs: such as the Rift Valley Institute, the Life and Peace Institute, ForumZFD, the International Centre for Transitional Justice and The Sexual Violence Research Initiative. International NGOs have the ability to transfer art-based practices across contexts through their projects on the ground. The workshops will enable members of local and international NGOs to network with policymakers, donors and other NGOs in a way that is conducive to developing future collaboration. International NGOs will be able to use the research and its outputs to understand the effectiveness of arts-based methods in preventing violence and to use these methods in their own initiatives.

Publications

10 25 50
 
Title Bodymapping and The Art of Change 
Description This video, produced by Art2Be and the Performing Violence team discusses the impact of Body Mapping as a research and intervention tool in Kenya and Somalia. Peace-builders, artists, workshop facilitators and participants offer insights into how body mapping can help produce change in societies affected by conflict. 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact This video brought together a number of key body mapping practitioners and members of communities affected by violence for the first time. It also offers a unique discussion of the impacts of body mapping by integrating a variety of diverse points of view. 
URL https://www.performingviolence.com/resourcecentre/projects
 
Title The Criminal Gang Syndicate, Gendered Nuances & Violence. Body Maps as tool for research and intervention 
Description This project, led by Dr Fathima Azmyia Badurdeen, used visual arts as a way to research and communicate individual involvements in organized criminal gangs in Mombasa. The interview emerge from a three day residential workshop conducted in August 2021 at the Technical University of Mombasa (TUM). 
Type Of Art Film/Video/Animation 
Year Produced 2021 
Impact Mombasa has been grappling with the gang syndicate for many years. Simultaneously, the increase in the number of gangs in Mombasa and the intense police crackdowns has heightened attention on this phenomenon in relation to political violence, mainly with regard to the upcoming elections in 2022 and other gang-crime-terror nexuses. The workshop brought together reformed gang members, gang members who were in the process of reforming, local artists from Mombasa and university students from the BA in Conflict and Security Studies programme from TUM, in an exploratory journey into the lives of gang members using body maps as a visual art technique. The research provided opportunities for local artists engaged in community development initiatives in marginalized localities to gain experience on the use of body maps as a tool for research and intervention among hard-to-reach individual samples. Similarly, two early-career postgraduate students participated in the workshop, where they learned the skills of body maps. The research also benefited from the expertise of NGOs and practitioners working on reforming gang members such as Mr. Nicholas Songora from Manyatta Youth Entertainment and Ms. Shamsa Abubakar, Chair - Peace Committee, Mombasa among other local area chiefs who attended the workshop. The workshop aimed to use body maps to understand individual pathways into gangs; identify meaning making of their life events in individual pathways into gangs; understand gendered nuances in gang formation and organization; develop skills in the use of body maps as a research and intervention tool. 
URL https://www.performingviolence.com/gang-syndycate-mombasa
 
Description One of the key finding of this project to date is that the research landscape of arts-based approaches to conflict and gender-based-violence encompasses 3 broadly separate agendas, namely a) using art as a perspective on conflict and art-based methods to illuminate conflict dynamics, b) using art for therapeutic purposes in conflict settings to achieve 'aesthetic distance, and transformation at the level of the individual, c) using art as a pathway for collective understanding and societal transformation, as well as for tackling violence, particularly during peace and transitional justice processes.
We have also found that our cluster's work encompasses the use of 'art as a tool', as well as 'art as intervention'. While the two are intimately connected, we have found that it is worth highlighting this distinction for analytical and practical purposes., e.g. to create and measure impact.
Meanwhile, gender is rarely explicitly addressed in the existing research at the nexus of arts and conflict. At the same time, a lot of research on gender is not presented as formally 'arts-based', even if it employs creative, and visual methods. We have identified a need to examine this dynamic more closely.
Another key finding of the project has been that the creation of virtual spaces for networking and learning amongst partners is possible and desirable, as evidenced by our impact below. However, challenges remain. While spaces for artists and researchers to engage in global exchange and collaboration have always been rare, especially in conflict settings (as premised by this cluster), the pandemic has further exacerbated this, as it has mounted additional (economic and social) pressures on artists, researchers, and practitioners working at the nexus of arts, peacebuilding and gender.
Exploitation Route Through conducting a broad scoping study, we have identified key opportunities and challenges for work that takes place at the nexus of arts, peacebuilding and gender. We have found that global stakeholders are increasingly paying attention to the role that art can play in achieving the SDGs, as a route for whole of society transformations. Within this global landscape, the UK is a particularly prolific funder of projects that engage the arts for development, social change, and conflict resolution. The global and UK-based funding landscape also reveal an increase in engagement with the creative economy, a fast-growing sector in global South countries.
Sectors Creative Economy,Government, Democracy and Justice,Culture, Heritage, Museums and Collections,Security and Diplomacy

URL https://www.performingviolence.com/webinars
 
Description We have used our key findings to bolster the impact of this project, and to ensure future work addresses existing needs and challenges encountered within the cluster. Specifically, we have achieved impact by creating virtual spaces and opportunities for knowledge exchange, both within the cluster, but also with a broader group of stakeholders and publics. As a result, we have begun to develop trust and build a community of practice, and to foster learning and collaboration among global South partners. This has led to candid and meaningful discussions even on sensitive and contentious topics, which is central to this cluster's work. Because we have exploited the advantages of working with visual and creative media that are impactful even/especially in the digital realm, we quickly adapted our original project plan to pandemic circumstances. We have thus been able to turn the challenges generated for our project implementation into an opportunity for thinking about alternative pathways for impact, which will be of broader interest. We have sought feedback and identified needs and interests of partners, as well as our broader community, and subsequently designed online output/content in line with these needs. This has included changing the format of webinars, inviting particular speakers, and offering online training on specific tools and methods. Crucially, it has also involved supporting our partners in Kenya, Sri Lanka and Lebanon in designing and implementing arts-based peacebuilding projects on the ground, by facilitating knowledge exchanges, as well as offering planning and organisational resources at-a-distance. These local-led projects, from bodymapping workshops to Playback theatre sessions, coupled with our broader outreach and communications activities, will enhance local community engagement and thus ensure sustainable impact in the long term. We have expanded our network, qualitatively, by engaging a (geographically and disciplinarily) broader range of artists and practitioners, as well as quantitatively by increasing webinar attendance, social media and website engagement, and newsletter subscriptions. We have built an online infrastructure, i.e. website, blog, newsletter and social media channels. And we have generated original material and have gathered broader resources on art-based-methods, which are made widely accessible via our online infrastructure. We have completed a scoping and analysis of stakeholders, that will allow us to generate further collaborations with researchers and practitioners in partner countries, and generate long lasting and sustainable impact channels.
First Year Of Impact 2021
Sector Government, Democracy and Justice
Impact Types Cultural,Societal

 
Description PERFORMING VIOLENCE, ENGENDERING CHANGE A Conference on Gender and the use of Arts-Based Methods to Understand Conflict, Prevent Violence and Build Peace 
Form Of Engagement Activity Participation in an activity, workshop or similar
Part Of Official Scheme? No
Geographic Reach International
Primary Audience Public/other audiences
Results and Impact This 3 days conference took place in November 2021 and offered panels, roundtables and screenings on the interaction between arts-based methods and gendered experiences of conflict.

In recent years, scholars, policy makers and practitioners have begun to acknowledge the benefits of using arts-based methods for violence prevention, peacebuilding and understanding the impacts of conflict.

However, the ability of arts-based methods to explore gendered experiences of violence and conflict and to prevent and respond to gender harms remain under explored. The Conference addressed this gap by bringing together artists, academics, activists and representatives from civil society and governments.

The Conference focused on linking participants across disciplines and backgrounds to highlight the potential of the arts and art-based methods in addressing gender issues in conflict situations and peacebuilding. The Conference also had a substantial international reach with speakers from the UK, Australia, France, Iraq, Lebanon, Germany, Uganda, Sri Lanka, Kenya, DR Congo, Somalia.

All videos from the conference are now recorded and available here:
https://www.performingviolence.com/conference-videos
Year(s) Of Engagement Activity 2021
URL https://www.performingviolence.com/conference-videos